If you were stranded on a island somewhere..Charmed style

[West]

For a bit of fun. These sort of topics i remember in forums back in the day.

So, if you were stranded on a island somewhere, what season would you want with you?

In addition a collection of 7 snippets from other seasons is allowed. These are only single scene moments.

So what do you guys pick?

[West]

My picks

very tough pick but i went with season 2.

my snippet scene moments id want with me are;
1. the first vanquish in the first episode with jeremy.
2. the end to Something Wicca This Way Comes.
3. Sending Melinda back in The Witch is back.
4. The end to Long Live the Queen.
5. Grams and Patty sending back Phoebe, Prue and Piper to the present in That 70s Episode.
6. reunion with Patty in Just Harried.
7. Melindas birth in All Halliwells Eve.

[adzpower]

I think I'll go with season 4.

My snippets I'd pick are:
1. Piper tells Phoebe she thinks she's evil I've Got You Under my Skin
2. Phoebe sacrifices herself in Morality Bites
3. Cousins VS evil Phoebe Pardon my Past
4. Shax, "the end"
5. Phoebe attack Paige Sympathy for the Demon
6. Phoebe explains deafness to Paige Sense and Sense Ability
7. Piper takes Paige to the afterlife Styx Feet Under

[Deleted]

Just sit right back and you'll hear a tale...

Season One for me, of course.

[Esmeralda]

Mar 22, 2016 5:57:31 GMT -5 West said:

For a bit of fun. These sort of topics i remember in forums back in the day.

So, if you were stranded on a island somewhere, what season would you want with you?

In addition a collection of 7 snippets from other seasons is allowed. These are only single scene moments.

So what do you guys pick?

What a cool idea, West! I’d love to see more of these sort of topics.

Definitely Season Two. It's the one that has the best one-shots and the one least-dependent on the others.

For my 7 snippets (it's funny - I kept thinking of ones that I wanted - and they were all part of Season Two - the only reason why this was hard!)

1. Piper walking out to find Phoebe sitting on the steps and she tells her what she read (not out loud) in the Book of Shadows in ‘Something Wicca This Way Comes’.

2. The sisters watching the Christmas movie in 'Thank You for Not Morphing'

3. Phoebe telling Piper about Leo, and Piper not believing her in 'The Truth is Out There...and It Hurts'

4. The Charmed Ones meeting Little Piper and Little Prue in 'That Seventies Episode'

5. The birth of Melinda Warren, especially Phoebe flying across the moon in 'All Halliwell's Eve'

6. Patty first seeing her daughters in 'Just Harried'

7. Piper and Phoebe watch as Paige meets Patty in 'Charmed Again, Part Two'

[Deleted]

Oh, so difficult!

I think I will have to go for Season Three. And my snippets would be:

1. Prue tells her sisters she loves them (from 'From Fear to Eternity').
2. Prue breaks down over Andy's death/Grams' 'Power of Three' whisper (from 'Witch Trial').
3. Phoebe sacrifices herself for the greater good (from 'Morality Bites'). 
4. Piper and Leo reading each other Patty and Sam's love letters (from 'P3 H2O').
5. Piper breaks down at Prue's memorial plaque (from 'Hell Hath No Fury').
6. Paige witnesses her adoptive parents' deaths in her own past (from 'A Paige from the Past').
7. Piper and Paige comfort Phoebe (from 'Love Live the Queen').

[sol]

Really difficult


Maybe season 3

I don't go in order

1. The face off between Wyatt and Chris in the attic in Chris Crossed

2.Phoebe flying on a broom on All Halliwell's Eve

3.The sunlit kitchen, Prue and Phoebe at the beginning of a normal day in Deja Vu All Over Again

4.The final scene of the Exit Strategy, when they light candles for two fallen witches and for Cole, a lost love

5."I can't believe we're even having this conversation" Paige and Phoebe and Piper when are discussing how to use the Nexus's destruction to destroy Zankou in Something Wicca This Way Goes

6.At the end of Pre- Witched, Prue, Piepr and Phoebe on the coach

7.Cole's romantic proposal of marriage, while they are covered of green goo in Black as Cole

[West]

Mar 22, 2016 7:31:41 GMT -5 Esmeralda said:

Mar 22, 2016 5:57:31 GMT -5 West said:

For a bit of fun. These sort of topics i remember in forums back in the day.

So, if you were stranded on a island somewhere, what season would you want with you?

In addition a collection of 7 snippets from other seasons is allowed. These are only single scene moments.

So what do you guys pick?

What a cool idea, West! I’d love to see more of these sort of topics.

Definitely Season Two. It's the one that has the best one-shots and the one least-dependent on the others.

For my 7 snippets (it's funny - I kept thinking of ones that I wanted - and they were all part of Season Two - the only reason why this was hard!)

1. Piper walking out to find Phoebe sitting on the steps and she tells her what she read (not out loud) in the Book of Shadows in ‘Something Wicca This Way Comes’.

2. The sisters watching the Christmas movie in 'Thank You for Not Morphing'

3. Phoebe telling Piper about Leo, and Piper not believing her in 'The Truth is Out There...and It Hurts'

4. The Charmed Ones meeting Little Piper and Little Prue in 'That Seventies Episode'

5. The birth of Melinda Warren, especially Phoebe flying across the moon in 'All Halliwell's Eve'

6. Patty first seeing her daughters in 'Just Harried'

7. Piper and Phoebe watch as Paige meets Patty in 'Charmed Again, Part Two'

Thanks. Ill think of more. Once we get our new forum sorted. Ill have time to really get these into the appropriate boards.

[lilchi7212]

Mar 22, 2016 5:57:31 GMT -5 West said:

For a bit of fun. These sort of topics i remember in forums back in the day.

So, if you were stranded on a island somewhere, what season would you want with you?

In addition a collection of 7 snippets from other seasons is allowed. These are only single scene moments.

So what do you guys pick?

 If I was marooned on an island I would be thinking of surviving rather than Charmed. Besides no internet or tv why bother?

[Elle Em]

This was hard. I had to pick season 3 as the full season I'd have with me. As far as seven snippets from other seasons:

1. End of series premiere when Prue talks with Andy and the sisters are talking on the steps outside the house.
2. Prue, Piper, and Phoebe interacting with 1975 Grams and Patty in the manor
3. End of the season 2 episode where they're dancing to the Cranberries song. It seems like the actresses are genuinely having fun and not acting at all.
4. The scene in "Chick Flick" when Prue, Piper, Phoebe, and Billy are running through the house.
5. End of "Paige from the Past" where Piper, Phoebe, and Paige are having dinner together and Paige's parents come to see her.
6. Vanquish of the Source in season 4- the first time
7. Vanquish of Cole/the Source and the aftermath where Piper and Paige comfort Phoebe

[Chris]

The Season I would choose is Season 3

For my snippets...

1. When Chris proposes to Bianca
2. The Source's vanquish in Charmed and Dangerous
3. Phoebe and Cole's evil wedding
4. Piper mourning Prue in Hell Hath No Fury
5. The scene where Phoebe exclaims "Either this is some sick, twisted joke or somebodies making up a MASSIVE evil plan!"
6. The sisters on their "PMS" in Once in a Blue Moon
7. Zankou's death in Something Wicca This Way Goes...?

[Granny Charmed]

Season Two. I was struggling with putting Season One first based on it having one of my favorite episodes, but changed it to Season Two dears.

For my 7 snippets (A majority might consist of my favorite episode That 70's Episode. So let's see how this girl goes.)

1. Phoebe and Patty meet in 'That Seventies Episode'

2. The sisters watching the Christmas movie in 'Thank You for Not Morphing'

3. Patty and Grams helping the Charmed Ones return to the past in 'That Seventies Episode'

4. The Charmed Ones meeting Little Piper and Little Prue in 'That Seventies Episode'

5. The birth of Melinda Warren, and Phoebe flying across the moon in 'All Halliwell's Eve'

6. Patty first seeing her daughters in 'Just Harried'

7. The ending scene to 'Long Live the Queen'

[Miranda Turner]

Oh this is hard. 


Season Three. 



For my 7 snippets

1. Prue tells her sisters she loves them in from 'From Fear to Eternity'.



2. Piper tells Phoebe she thinks she's evil in 'I've Got You Under my Skin
'


3. Phoebe burns in 'Morality Bites'


4. The Charmed Ones meeting Little Piper and Little Prue in 'That Seventies Episode'



5. Prue breaks down over Andy's death in 'Witch Trial'.



6. The death of Cole/Source in 'Long Live the Queen'


7. Piper and Paige comfort Phoebe in 'Love Live the Queen'.

[craig]

Wow, this is such a fun thread. I like these sort of games.


Season Two for me.



For my 7 snippets


1. Patty first seeing her daughters in 'Just Harried' before Piper's wedding.


2. The sisters walking up the steps at the end of 'Something Wicca This Way Comes'


3. The sisters in the attic at the end of 'Secrets and Guys' 


4. Prue, Piper and Phoebe meeting Little Piper and Little Prue in the past during 'That Seventies Episode'



5. Patty and Paige meet in 'Charmed Again, Part Two'



6. Prue and Phoebe talking about switching powers and toasting their drinks at the end of 'Love Hurts'.


7. Phoebe reads the book of shadows for the first time in 'Something Wicca This Way Comes'

[Ruth Marie]

This looks like fun. But I am going to struggle to pick just one season.   


Toss up between season 1 and 2 for me, I went with 2 in the end.

My 7 snippets

1. The first episode's ending walking up the steps scene.
2. Prue, Piper, and Phoebe interacting with Grams and Patty in the manor in 1975.
3. Prue, Piper and Phoebe deliver baby Melinda Warren in the past.
4. Piper dies on the hospital bed with Prue beside her in All Hell Breaks Loose.
5. End of "Paige from the Past" where Paige see's her parents.
6. Sending Melinda back in The Witch is back.
7. Reunion with Patty in Just Harried.

[Too Much Coffee]

This is tough, but I have my snippets for other seasons to use.

Went with Season Two.


For my 7 snippets

1.  The sisters watching the Christmas movie in 'Thank You for Not Morphing'

2.  Patty saves Prue in the water in 'From Fear to Eternity'

3.  Phoebe and Patty meeting outside the Diner in 'That Seventies Episode'

4.  The Charmed Ones meeting Little Piper and Little Prue in 'That Seventies Episode

5. Prue and Andy's last talk before he fades away in 'Deja Vu All Over Again

6.  The Birth of Melinda and Phoebe flying across the moon in 'All Halliwell's Eve'

7.  Patty when she first appears at Piper's wedding to her daughters in 'Just Harried'

[lunchking]

Mar 22, 2016 5:57:31 GMT -5 West said:

For a bit of fun. These sort of topics i remember in forums back in the day.

So, if you were stranded on a island somewhere, what season would you want with you?

In addition a collection of 7 snippets from other seasons is allowed. These are only single scene moments.

So what do you guys pick?

S1 for sure!

My 7 snippets: (this was hard, so I'll have to think more on it, but added two so far)

1. The whole scene before Phoebe burns - Morality Bites

2. The Ending - Long Live the Queen

3. TO BE ADDED

4. TO BE ADDED

5. TO BE ADDED

6. TO BE ADDED

7. TO BE ADDED

[wyatt23]

I would chose season 4!

For my moments:
(No Order)

1. Phoebe giving herself for the greater good (Season 2; Morality Bites)
2. Prue giving her life for Dr. Griffin (just for him still to die 🙄)(Season 3; All Hell Breaks Loose)
3. Grandma Piper reading the entries the sisters wrote (Season 8; Forever Charmed)
4. Piper and Leo's Conversation in the Heavens (Season 5; OH My Goddess)
5. Prue and Piper convincing Phoebe to vanquish the Woogyman (Season 1; Is there a woogy in the house?)
6. Paige Heals Henry (Season 8; Paybacks A Witch
7. Phoebe grieves for Cole, with Piper and Paige right by her side.

What a great idea for a post!

[West]

Mar 22, 2016 6:01:50 GMT -5 West said:

My picks

very tough pick but i went with season 2.

my snippet scene moments id want with me are;
1. the first vanquish in the first episode with jeremy.
2. the end to Something Wicca This Way Comes.
3. Sending Melinda back in The Witch is back.
4. The end to Long Live the Queen.
5. Grams and Patty sending back Phoebe, Prue and Piper to the present in That 70s Episode.
6. reunion with Patty in Just Harried.
7. Melindas birth in All Halliwells Eve.

Seven Years Later. I think I might have changed my mind to wanting S1 overall now. So adjusting my picks:

Season 1.

7 Snippets/Moments:

1. Phoebe talking to her sisters before she burns. - Morality Bites
2. Prue's entrance - Ms. Hellfire
3. Melinda's birth  - All Halliwell's Eve.
4. Reunion with Patty - Just Harried.
5. Paige telling the story of her adopted parents death - A Paige From the Past
6. The ending - Long Live the Queen.
7. Paige Heals Henry - Paybacks a Witch

[greta]

S1 gets my vote!


My 7 snippets: 


1. Phoebe telling her sisters why she has to burn - Morality Bites

2. Sam's death and avenging Patty - P3 H20
3. Grams & Piper in the kitchen - Pre-Witched
4. Prue & Piper hospital scene, when Piper is dying - All Hell Breaks Loose
5. The Ending - Long Live the Queen
6. Paige telling her sisters how her adopted parents died - A Paige From the Past
7. Piper's pregnancy news - Witch Way Now