|
|
Post by Melinda Halliwell on Jun 13, 2017 2:10:01 GMT -5
He did in late Season Six. And a lot of fans hated him for it. I didn't actually because I think Darryl had a valid reason to be angry after what happened to him earlier on and when the sisters soul raped him. |
|
Ruth Marie
Whitelighter
Prue Seasons
"What If...?"
Fan Fic Winner
Posts: 4,355 
|
Post by Ruth Marie on Jun 13, 2017 6:53:29 GMT -5
Andy and Prue for me. Even when they weren't dating or involved, they always have had a deep bond between them that transcends even romantic relationship. They were definitely soul mates; I wish it could have lasted longer. I liked the character of Andy in general dear too. He was a childhood friend of all three sisters, and his *purpose* on the show I liked. Even if he and Prue were not dating, I still feel he offered something. I really do wish he had stuck around longer. Even if Prue had died dears, I do feel he could have still played the role Darryl did, if not better because he had a personal connection to them since childhood. I liked the character of Andy in general dear too. He was a childhood friend of all three sisters, and his *purpose* on the show I liked. Even if he and Prue were not dating, I still feel he offered something. I really do wish he had stuck around longer. Even if Prue had died dears, I do feel he could have still played the role Darryl did, if not better because he had a personal connection to them since childhood. And that's one of the things I liked about him. He made sense even when he wasn't dating Prue. His connection to them went back to when they were little kids and he had their backs. Not that I didn't love Darryl, but sometimes I think Darryl could have used more of a backbone. I would have loved to see both Andy and Darryl be the sister's connection to the force. It would have been interesting to see how having Andy still around as his partner would have changed the course of Darryl's story on the show. I think the combination of Andy and Darryl would of added so much to the show. Especially getting a view point from non magical people. I think when Andy died, Darryl's role did increase, but without Andy. He didn't have anyone to play off. If Darryl did find out the secret in season 2 with Andy around, you have a great story for Andy having someone like Darryl to talk about it with. |
|
Granny Charmed
Whitelighter
S1 "What If...?"
Fan Fic Winner
Posts: 3,225
|
Post by Granny Charmed on Jun 13, 2017 7:05:50 GMT -5
I liked the character of Andy in general dear too. He was a childhood friend of all three sisters, and his *purpose* on the show I liked. Even if he and Prue were not dating, I still feel he offered something. I really do wish he had stuck around longer. Even if Prue had died dears, I do feel he could have still played the role Darryl did, if not better because he had a personal connection to them since childhood. And that's one of the things I liked about him. He made sense even when he wasn't dating Prue. His connection to them went back to when they were little kids and he had their backs. Not that I didn't love Darryl, but sometimes I think Darryl could have used more of a backbone. I would have loved to see both Andy and Darryl be the sister's connection to the force. It would have been interesting to see how having Andy still around as his partner would have changed the course of Darryl's story on the show. Oh this is so true dear. I truly would have *loved* to have seen how Darryl's role would change if he still had Andy as a partner. As Ruth Marie pointed out dear, we might have gotten more out of how non magical people like Andy and Darryl handle and react to the magic and demons. Because Darryl had nobody to talk too about how he truly felt. It wasn't like they showed Darryl and Sheila's home life. I liked the character of Andy in general dear too. He was a childhood friend of all three sisters, and his *purpose* on the show I liked. Even if he and Prue were not dating, I still feel he offered something. I really do wish he had stuck around longer. Even if Prue had died dears, I do feel he could have still played the role Darryl did, if not better because he had a personal connection to them since childhood. And that's one of the things I liked about him. He made sense even when he wasn't dating Prue. His connection to them went back to when they were little kids and he had their backs. Not that I didn't love Darryl, but sometimes I think Darryl could have used more of a backbone. I would have loved to see both Andy and Darryl be the sister's connection to the force. It would have been interesting to see how having Andy still around as his partner would have changed the course of Darryl's story on the show. I think the combination of Andy and Darryl would of added so much to the show. Especially getting a view point from non magical people. I think when Andy died, Darryl's role did increase, but without Andy. He didn't have anyone to play off. If Darryl did find out the secret in season 2 with Andy around, you have a great story for Andy having someone like Darryl to talk about it with. Now this is what I *so* wished had happened. If only Leo had stayed gone dear. Then Ted might have been pleased, since I heard that he left because he wasn't given enough content. Now he should of waited, because his role would of increased if we look at how much Leo got used later on dear. |
|
codebox
Familiar
Hey I'm a Charmed Veteran have been for a long time. Hope to share some insight and opinions.
Posts: 287 
|
Post by codebox on Jun 29, 2019 21:25:10 GMT -5
Piper & Mark- I feel these two had such great chemistry. They had more in common than even Piper and Leo. I also think Mark's inclusion could've included Asian culture and mythology into the show, one of the things I loved about Dead Man Dating was the china town setting, it was nice seeing a non San Francisco location. Plus later seasons Piper and Leo devolved to a sitcom housewife/doormat husband rather than originally being loves just fighting for their love.
Paige & Richard- Don't get me wrong I prefer Paige and Henry, and Henry was the best season 8 supporting character, but if they weren't endgame I would've love for Paige to stay with Richard simply because I felt they understood one another pretty well. He understood Paige's need for independence and stubbornness, while she helped his magical addition. It was by far one of the only things in Season 6 that was good. Also helping its case that its the Phoebe/Cole relationship done right!
Phoebe & Drake- While Phoebe and Cole are preferred I couldn't stand Phoebe's personality when she was around him. The only likable thing to come out of it was Cole's character himself. Enter Drake, while he was a means to teach Phoebe about love set by Cole, Drake made Phoebe less insufferable during his inclusion (minus that scene where she talks about not saving an innocent in favor of something else) and made every scene he was in enjoyable the only other romance Phoebe had besides Cole that had personality.
|
|
|
|
Post by Katie Warren on Jun 29, 2019 22:10:02 GMT -5
Piper & Mark- I feel these two had such great chemistry. They had more in common than even Piper and Leo. I also think Mark's inclusion could've included Asian culture and mythology into the show, one of the things I loved about Dead Man Dating was the china town setting, it was nice seeing a non San Francisco location. Plus later seasons Piper and Leo devolved to a sitcom housewife/doormat husband rather than originally being loves just fighting for their love. Paige & Richard- Don't get me wrong I prefer Paige and Henry, and Henry was the best season 8 supporting character, but if they weren't endgame I would've love for Paige to stay with Richard simply because I felt they understood one another pretty well. He understood Paige's need for independence and stubbornness, while she helped his magical addition. It was by far one of the only things in Season 6 that was good. Also helping its case that its the Phoebe/Cole relationship done right! Phoebe & Drake- While Phoebe and Cole are preferred I couldn't stand Phoebe's personality when she was around him. The only likable thing to come out of it was Cole's character himself. Enter Drake, while he was a means to teach Phoebe about love set by Cole, Drake made Phoebe less insufferable during his inclusion (minus that scene where she talks about not saving an innocent in favor of something else) and made every scene he was in enjoyable the only other romance Phoebe had besides Cole that had personality. We just finished a re-watch of 'Dead Man Dating' on the board tonight, and they are fantastic. So wished Mark was Piper's true love. They have outstanding chemistry in one episode. Agree with Phoebe and Drake too. |
|
Ruth Marie
Whitelighter
Prue Seasons
"What If...?"
Fan Fic Winner
Posts: 4,355
|
Post by Ruth Marie on Jun 30, 2019 16:36:14 GMT -5
Piper & Mark- I feel these two had such great chemistry. They had more in common than even Piper and Leo. I also think Mark's inclusion could've included Asian culture and mythology into the show, one of the things I loved about Dead Man Dating was the china town setting, it was nice seeing a non San Francisco location. Plus later seasons Piper and Leo devolved to a sitcom housewife/doormat husband rather than originally being loves just fighting for their love. Paige & Richard- Don't get me wrong I prefer Paige and Henry, and Henry was the best season 8 supporting character, but if they weren't endgame I would've love for Paige to stay with Richard simply because I felt they understood one another pretty well. He understood Paige's need for independence and stubbornness, while she helped his magical addition. It was by far one of the only things in Season 6 that was good. Also helping its case that its the Phoebe/Cole relationship done right! Phoebe & Drake- While Phoebe and Cole are preferred I couldn't stand Phoebe's personality when she was around him. The only likable thing to come out of it was Cole's character himself. Enter Drake, while he was a means to teach Phoebe about love set by Cole, Drake made Phoebe less insufferable during his inclusion (minus that scene where she talks about not saving an innocent in favor of something else) and made every scene he was in enjoyable the only other romance Phoebe had besides Cole that had personality. We just finished a re-watch of 'Dead Man Dating' on the board tonight, and they are fantastic. So wished Mark was Piper's true love. They have outstanding chemistry in one episode. Agree with Phoebe and Drake too. Now I can't wait to re-re-watch tonight. Mark did have good chemistry with Piper. |
|
Aaeiyn
Elder
✨The Amazing Phoebe✨
Posts: 5,565
|
Post by Aaeiyn on Aug 28, 2021 7:45:32 GMT -5
Both Andy & Brody. I always said Andy would make a great whitelighter especially after seeing how Brody became one, himself. There's no reason for Andy to not be one. Which whitelighter Brody had no reason to not make visits and marry Paige as a whitelighter.
|
|
