Who was the funniest Sister?

[forbuss]

Another master thread. Who was the funniest sister of all? Who made you laugh the most? Did any scene make your stomach hurt with laughter?

Discuss!!

[latincoffee]

I think Phoebe was the funniest sister without a doubt. Even her facial expressions at times. 😊

[forbuss]

Sept 21, 2020 10:20:01 GMT -5 latincoffee said:

I think Phoebe was the funniest sister without a doubt. Even her facial expressions at times. 😊

I agree! But they did all have some really funny moments throughout the show.

Welcome to the board

[Katie Warren]

Having re-watched S1 and S2 so far with the board re-watches, All three had their moments, but Piper was always the best one with her one-liners.

But, it's very hard to vote for just one. It's a tie between Season 1 Piper and Season 1 and 2 Phoebe. So I might hold off voting until I can figure out my answers.

[xhalliwellx]

I am going to say Paige! She was very witty and light-hearted. A few scenes comes to mind: The Seven Year Witch: "Okay, hi. I'm wearing lip-gloss. Do I look homeless?" (Even if it was Rose who came up with this!).

The scenes in Black as Cole where she set Leo & Piper up to look after the robotic baby, shows this side of her, as well.

"I did the rhyme. I will do the time. Good night".

[Esmeralda]

Alyssa's a fantastic comedic actress, but I had to vote for Piper, especially early-season Piper when she was based on one of Connie's sisters and not on Holly. During the early seasons, she always had the funniest line at the most tense moment, something the show did so well. Unfortunately that wonderful humor turned mean and bitter in the latter seasons, the reason I hate that version of Piper while loving the earlier version.

[prudencehalliwell]

Sept 25, 2020 23:31:16 GMT -5 Esmeralda said:

Alyssa's a fantastic comedic actress, but I had to vote for Piper, especially early-season Piper when she was based on one of Connie's sisters and not on Holly. During the early seasons, she always had the funniest line at the most tense moment, something the show did so well. Unfortunately that wonderful human turned mean and bitter in the latter seasons, the reason I hate that version of Piper while loving the earlier version.

Oh yes, Holly has great comedic timing herself, even if she has never been in anything comedic. And 'Is There a Woogy in the House' comes to mind when how well funny Piper is at the most tense moments. 

I love early season Piper so very much, and that is what I voted for.

[forbuss]

Sept 25, 2020 23:43:27 GMT -5 prudencehalliwell said:

Sept 25, 2020 23:31:16 GMT -5 Esmeralda said:

Alyssa's a fantastic comedic actress, but I had to vote for Piper, especially early-season Piper when she was based on one of Connie's sisters and not on Holly. During the early seasons, she always had the funniest line at the most tense moment, something the show did so well. Unfortunately that wonderful human turned mean and bitter in the latter seasons, the reason I hate that version of Piper while loving the earlier version.

Oh yes, Holly has great comedic timing herself, even if she has never been in anything comedic. And 'Is There a Woogy in the House' comes to mind when how well funny Piper is at the most tense moments. 

I love early season Piper so very much, and that is what I voted for.

I think one of the reasons the show was so great is because really, all four sisters were funny (in my eyes). I know Prue seemed more "intense" but she had a lot of great funny moments too. So did Paige!

[prudencehalliwell]

Sept 27, 2020 19:06:29 GMT -5 forbuss said:

Sept 25, 2020 23:43:27 GMT -5 prudencehalliwell said:

Oh yes, Holly has great comedic timing herself, even if she has never been in anything comedic. And 'Is There a Woogy in the House' comes to mind when how well funny Piper is at the most tense moments. 

I love early season Piper so very much, and that is what I voted for.

I think one of the reasons the show was so great is because really, all four sisters were funny (in my eyes). I know Prue seemed more "intense" but she had a lot of great funny moments too. So did Paige!

They sure did, and the many sisterly moments brings out the fun in all of then when together as a collective.

[Julian]

Phoebe, she always made me laugh and some of the facial expressions she does. Alyssa is such a good comedic actress. 

But all the sisters had their moments.

[Aaeiyn]

Even though, Phoebe sucks, I do have to give her credit for being funny.

[latincoffee]

Sept 22, 2020 18:31:09 GMT -5 Katie Warren said:

Having re-watched S1 and S2 so far with the board re-watches, All three had their moments, but Piper was always the best one with her one-liners.

But, it's very hard to vote for just one. It's a tie between Season 1 Piper and Season 1 and 2 Phoebe. So I might hold off voting until I can figure out my answers.

Thanks much. Sorry for being late with my response.

How are you?

[Katie Warren]

Dec 29, 2021 21:58:29 GMT -5 latincoffee said:

Sept 22, 2020 18:31:09 GMT -5 Katie Warren said:

Having re-watched S1 and S2 so far with the board re-watches, All three had their moments, but Piper was always the best one with her one-liners.

But, it's very hard to vote for just one. It's a tie between Season 1 Piper and Season 1 and 2 Phoebe. So I might hold off voting until I can figure out my answers.

Thanks much. Sorry for being late with my response.

How are you?

My pleasure. That's alright. Sometimes real life gets in the way or your online life and Charmed life. It's nice to hear from you again.

I'm good thanks. Hope you had a great Christmas.

[forbuss]

I think the comedy was super dependent on the different sisters. Piper was super funny in the early seasons but got a lot less funny into season three, and less after she was the oldest (living) sister.

I think Phoebe was always funny, but was definitely the funniest of all the sisters in the later seasons.

I do think that the actors brought a lot of comedy to the scripts when it wasn't inherently there in writing. This is a credit to the cast, in particular the main cast.

[Elle Em]

I feel like Holly early on got more of the funnier lines, which she was good with delivering, but Alyssa was better being funny when she wasn't written exactly that way. So I think Piper was written to be funnier but Alyssa was better at acting in that way. 

[squint]

All I can say is that Phoebe made me smile the most while Piper made me laugh the most. I'm only judging the first few seasons tough, because I am neither familiar with nor care for the later seasons.

[latincoffee]

Dec 31, 2021 7:21:58 GMT -5 Katie Warren said:

Dec 29, 2021 21:58:29 GMT -5 latincoffee said:

Thanks much. Sorry for being late with my response.

How are you?

My pleasure. That's alright. Sometimes real life gets in the way or your online life and Charmed life. It's nice to hear from you again.

I'm good thanks. Hope you had a great Christmas.

Hey Katie Warren ! I'm well. Thanks. I also hope you had an awesome Christmas.

[Katie Warren]

Apr 11, 2022 10:33:31 GMT -5 latincoffee said:

Dec 31, 2021 7:21:58 GMT -5 Katie Warren said:

My pleasure. That's alright. Sometimes real life gets in the way or your online life and Charmed life. It's nice to hear from you again.

I'm good thanks. Hope you had a great Christmas.

Hey Katie Warren ! I'm well. Thanks. I also hope you had an awesome Christmas.

Good to hear. I had a great Christmas thank you. It was nice to have a proper Christmas last year for the first time since pre pandemic.

Nice to see you again on the boards.

[latincoffee]

Hey Katie. Hope you are well. I have not been on here in such a while. Do you visit often?

-Angel

[Katie Warren]

Feb 29, 2024 21:46:50 GMT -5 latincoffee said:

Hey Katie. Hope you are well. I have not been on here in such a while. Do you visit often?

-Angel

Welcome back! I'm well thank you. Hope your doing well.

Yes I visit here at least once or twice a week. Sometimes more.