Esmeralda
Charmed
S2 "What If...?" Fan Fic Winner
Twenty Years Gone....But Never Forgotten.
Posts: 21,904
|
Post by Esmeralda on Sept 1, 2022 22:47:22 GMT -5
Yes, Victor being recast worked, but we only saw Victor Halliwell once in Season One and Victor Bennett didn't take over until S3. Prue was a lead character through three full seasons. To have her die at the end of S3 and then have her come back looking different in S4? Like you said, West, that would also be for me a BIG FAT NO! My actual response would be neither. I would've preferred if it was Piper & Leo and Phoebe & Cole with the Source leaving them alone and them going back to their true destiny of protecting innocents. That's what I like to think happened in the REAL Charmedverse, not the alternate-universe one. The series probably would've only gone four seasons, but that would've been perfectly okay with me! So much thanks to Assassin Witch for coming up with the two-couples idea! Now that's an interesting idea. No replacement for Shannen at all! Many thanks Assassin Witch for this idea. I never would've thought of that. Neither would I, but I'll bet if Connie was still around and Shannen was still fired, that's what she would've had happen.
|
|
|
Post by West on Sept 1, 2022 23:04:29 GMT -5
Now that's an interesting idea. No replacement for Shannen at all! Many thanks Assassin Witch for this idea. I never would've thought of that. Neither would I, but I'll bet if Connie was still around and Shannen was still fired, that's what she would've had happen. I don't see her introducing a new half-sister. I'll bet Connie would make sure Prue isn't forgotten and do a better job than Kern honoring her legacy. Which not introducing another sister would've done anyway. Phoebe's character would've benefited Connie being still around. It's too bad she and Kern couldn't compromise and have Cole's character match with Prue than Phoebe. I thought I heard she was against Phoebe being matched with Cole or was it Cole's character in general.
|
|