I don't think she was that bad.

[moschizzzle]

Prue i mean. I know her and Alysaa didn't get along but i still thought she was a pretty good actress for the part. Don't get me wrong, Paige is great too =). Who do you prefer and why? I leaning more towards Paige because she brought alot more interest back to the series, and she's very cunning as well.

[The Original P3]

*runs away screaming*

[Hansemand]

I have nothing against Prue (Shannen) either.
But I'm also not a special fan of any of the characters on Charmed, I'm a fan of the whole package of Charmed and what it delivered to all the viewers at home and yes, Shannen was good as Prue and so was Rose as Paige.

[colehellsangel]

hansemand said:

I have nothing against Prue (Shannen) either.
But I'm also not a special fan of any of the characters on Charmed, I'm a fan of the whole package of Charmed and what it delivered to all the viewers at home and yes, Shannen was good as Prue and so was Rose as Paige.

I agree here, I am a fan of Shannon's acting as well I think she was a superb Prue and recently gave a great performance in this Christmas movie I recently saw called Christmas Caper. I think she has a lot of talent. I also agree here that I don't play favorites at least with the Charmed Ones alone(For the guys and couples its a slightly different story) I can't help but love them all as they all bring something completely different to the team the same goes for the question of Prue or Paige. They both brought something different to the team and I love both for their own special strengths.

[pipercharmedphreak]

colehellsangel said:

hansemand said:

I have nothing against Prue (Shannen) either.
But I'm also not a special fan of any of the characters on Charmed, I'm a fan of the whole package of Charmed and what it delivered to all the viewers at home and yes, Shannen was good as Prue and so was Rose as Paige.

I agree here, I am a fan of Shannon's acting as well I think she was a superb Prue and recently gave a great performance in this Christmas movie I recently saw called Christmas Caper. I think she has a lot of talent. I also agree here that I don't play favorites at least with the Charmed Ones alone(For the guys and couples its a slightly different story) I can't help but love them all as they all bring something completely different to the team the same goes for the question of Prue or Paige. They both brought something different to the team and I love both for their own special strengths.

WELL SAID!!

[marissa08]

At the moment, I prefer Paige over Prue. I just love her character and i think she really brought a lot to the show. Also i adore Rose McGowan as an actress. But to be fair, i have only seen one or two episodes from seasons 1-3, so i haven't really given Prue a chance yet. But i'm planning to use some of my christmas money to buy seasons 1-3 on dvd to complete my collection =] Once i watch those, then i'll be able to say for sure if i like Paige or Prue better.

Colehellsangel, i was wondering about that movie, Christmas Caper. My little sister was like, "I was watching this christmas movie, and Prue was in it!" I didn't know what movie she was talking about, but that must be it.

[colehellsangel]

Must be so far its the only Christmas movie I know her to be in. Its a good movie and her performance is great in it. I am glad to hear that you admit to having a poor Judgment of Prue since you have not given her much of a chance. I am glad you are willing to. Paige is awesome in her own special way but Prue is also a great character, I don't play favorites with them as I stated in my first post. They are both great.

[The Esbat of Ms.Sweeny]

I wasn't a very big fan of Prue, but she was there and she was good at what she did.
I love Paige a little more though, she is funny and sarcastic and I just love it about her.

[marissa08]

colehellsangel said:

Must be so far its the only Christmas movie I know her to be in. Its a good movie and her performance is great in it. I am glad to hear that you admit to having a poor Judgment of Prue since you have not given her much of a chance. I am glad you are willing to. Paige is awesome in her own special way but Prue is also a great character, I don't play favorites with them as I stated in my first post. They are both great.

Yeah, at first i didn't like Prue but then i realized that it would be wrong to judge her without even getting to know her character at all. Besides, she seems like she would be pretty cool. =]

[ArchAngel]

moschizzzle said:

Prue i mean. I know her and Alysaa didn't get along but i still thought she was a pretty good actress for the part. Don't get me wrong, Paige is great too =). Who do you prefer and why? I leaning more towards Paige because she brought alot more interest back to the series, and she's very cunning as well.

Actually, the real misunderstanding was that Alyssa was a little to into Shannen but Shannen don't "swing that way"...lol

If you really want to see something in the interactions on screen then look for Shannen trying to inch away or looking like she's about to bolt when Alyssa gets to close...lol.

Hey I Loved "Original Charmed" (season 1-3) despite the Oriental Style theme ending where all the heros die and "all fades to black"

I also liked the Spin Off "Charmed Again" (Season 4) and the fact that they "all lived happily after" with Piper Pregnant after defeating the Source in all it's incarnations (Also easy to assume that Phoebe would take Cole back in 3 months like she always did as he manage to escape the Wasteland on his own accord)

Wasn't to crazy about the "Loves and Life of Phoebe Halliwell" Drama crap or "As Halliwell Manor Turns" Soap Oprea Drama that made up the bulk of Season 1-7 but I did find the "Avatar Series" part of it interesting as well as individual eppisodes like "Chris Crossed Amazing". I could live with the "And they Lived happily ever after under assumed Identities" ending.

Season 8 was just there cause WB was like Wanna go 1 more year (as nobody wants to buy commercials on any other show in your spot) and the Writers though pooped, and cast though poop was like "what the hell"....lol

All in all this was a "Spin off" where the former Charmed Ones are in fact trainers of prodigy Witch hunter by the name of Billy and basically her sponser for the "ulitimate Battle' that has her pit against her own sister who has been coached and trained by the Triad. the Climatic "ultimate Battle" ended up taking 2 seconds and was basically Christy Trying to flame Billy and the girls and Bille reflecting and Christy ending up flaming herself....<the end> (yawn)

Bad side is that all hopes for another "Spin off" or Movie, or reunion eppisode was cancelled out by the ending of Season 8 as they made a truce with the last demon leader that he and his punk rocker, matrix, warriors,and MIb demon wannabes would not bother the girls of the family for at least 1 generation (when Wyatt and Chris and the kids are adults) and it shows the Girls and the family living rather peaceful lives (but since there are only rabble "demons left" that think dressing in all leather is "cool"...whatever)

[ljones]

Actually, the real misunderstanding was that Alyssa was a little to into Shannen but Shannen don't "swing that way"...lol

I know that I'm going to regret asking this, but from where did you get this idea?

[colehellsangel]

ljones said:

Actually, the real misunderstanding was that Alyssa was a little to into Shannen but Shannen don't "swing that way"...lol

I know that I'm going to regret asking this, but from where did you get this idea?

Yeah I agree. I don't think its known what really happened to Shannon. I mean yeah we have ideas, but I don't think the real, whole story is known.

However I did come across this just in case anyone is interested.
www.geocities.com/Hollywood/4616/tvg0825.html

[The Original P3]

ljones said:

Actually, the real misunderstanding was that Alyssa was a little to into Shannen but Shannen don't "swing that way"...lol

I know that I'm going to regret asking this, but from where did you get this idea?

Not the first time I've heard this. Alyssa and Shannen were drunk. Alyssa kissed Shannen while drunk. They were never the same.. *LOL*

[colehellsangel]

xcharmed1x said:

ljones said:

I know that I'm going to regret asking this, but from where did you get this idea?

Not the first time I've heard this. Alyssa and Shannen were drunk. Alyssa kissed Shannen while drunk. They were never the same.. *LOL*

Oooohk

[pipercharmedphreak]

WOW!! i have NEVER heard that story before!!!

[ArchAngel]

ljones said:

Actually, the real misunderstanding was that Alyssa was a little to into Shannen but Shannen don't "swing that way"...lol

I know that I'm going to regret asking this, but from where did you get this idea?

Well, it isn't a secret (nor really talked about) that Alyssa is Bi-sexual with a preference for girls over boys (It's nobody's business anyway) and one of her previous long term girlfriends was Jerry Ryan.

Shannen and Alyssa (and Holly) were really close and Alyssa felt really close to Shannen and one night when they were a little tipsy Alyssa made a pass at Shannen by kissing her cause she wanted to take the relationship to the next step, but Shannen, after much confusion and thinking decided she likes boys too much....lol

Howard Stern actually got Shannen to admit she made out with a girl before and while they are still friends and have reached an understanding and that she usually just stays away from the friend cause she is still uncomfy about the matter(Maybe even tempted "to switch')......Howard didn't put 2 and 2 together so I was just laughing during the interview that he didn't make the connection or press for the name of the friend that kissed her and confused her so...lol

[The Original P3]

archangel said:

Howard Stern actually got Shannen to admit she made out with a girl before and while they are still friends and have reached an understanding and that she usually just stays away from the friend cause she is still uncomfy about the matter(Maybe even tempted "to switch')......Howard didn't put 2 and 2 together so I was just laughing during the interview that he didn't make the connection or press for the name of the friend that kissed her and confused her so...lol

Haha I remember watching that thinking, "Yeah I know exactly who that was."

[charmedfan4evr]

archangel said:

ljones said:

I know that I'm going to regret asking this, but from where did you get this idea?

Well, it isn't a secret (nor really talked about) that Alyssa is Bi-sexual with a preference for girls over boys (It's nobody's business anyway) and one of her previous long term girlfriends was Jerry Ryan.

Shannen and Alyssa (and Holly) were really close and Alyssa felt really close to Shannen and one night when they were a little tipsy Alyssa made a pass at Shannen by kissing her cause she wanted to take the relationship to the next step, but Shannen, after much confusion and thinking decided she likes boys too much....lol

Howard Stern actually got Shannen to admit she made out with a girl before and while they are still friends and have reached an understanding and that she usually just stays away from the friend cause she is still uncomfy about the matter(Maybe even tempted "to switch')......Howard didn't put 2 and 2 together so I was just laughing during the interview that he didn't make the connection or press for the name of the friend that kissed her and confused her so...lol

What???

Alyssa Bi?

Alyssa and Shannen kiss kiss??

I never ever heard of this, is this true?

Or this some crazy joke?

[marissa08]

Are you sure Alyssa is bisexual? I find that a little hard to believe. What is your source?

[The Original P3]

I don't know where ArchAngel's information is coming from about Alyssa being bisexual. But the incident with Shannen and Alyssa is true...the drunken incident that is.

Watch the Howard Stern interview ArchAngel referred to. While Shannen doesn't obviously give up any name, that's who it is.

However, none of the actress' personal sexual preference is any of our business. There really shouldn't be any discussion about this.