Official Seer thread (both of them)

[Triad]

Even though Debbi Morgan's Seer the best, I tend to be favoring Charisma's Seer. I don't know, but in todays episode I couldn't watch her die

BTW this is also coming from a Angel fan....I miss Cordy

[Payton Phoenix Halliwell]

I liked Cordy, too, most especially after she went to work for Angel. There were a lot of changes she went through... which was probably good training for her becoming The Seer in Charmed.

[christopher_panic!!]

Charisma is my fave.

Krista Allen played The Oracle at the beginning of the season 4. Debbi Morgan replaced her in the role of The Seer and reffered to her to The Soruce in 4.13. Then in season 5, Grace Zabriskie played Crone who also had the power to see the future. Charisma Carpenter played The Seer during the season 7. She was so funny and I like her!

[angelcharmedest]

oh Cordelia from Angel whyd she HAVE TO DIE!!!!!
oh I liked her as a seer. Chrisma Carpenter was an Angel. She's beautiful

[foxfire]

Well let me say this, Charisma Carpenter's Seer was definitely better than the first. She had so much more charisma and spunk. I really wish they hadn't killed her because it might have been cool to have her as their season seven villain.

They should have had her kill Zankou and have her remain on the show until the finale.

[ljones]

I like Charisma Carpenter a lot, but I think that Debbi Morgan was a much better actress and had portrayed a better character. In fact, I think she was one of the best villains in the entire series.

[power321]

Kira! :love:

[ina]

I loved her much. It was so sad when she died...I almost cried!

[~B@MeLiSsA30@B~]

My favorite one was Kira. She was so pretty. So full of life although she was a demon. I could of pictured Kira and Phoebe becoming best friends. I wished they didn't kill her off. It was really sad.

[xoFeliciaFinleyxo]

I liked Chrisma Carpenter better as a Seer becasue she made her character funny The other Seer didn't really do anything. She wasn't really funny I found her sort of annoying.

[•|CharmedS678|•]

I cannot stand Debbi Morgan's seer. The bitch makes me so mad. Probably my least favorite demon of all.

She's creepy, has no personality in her voice, and has so many stupid excuses for what she wants, when we all know she's nothing but an evil bitch who wants to rule the underworld. And she comes up with all of these excuses. "I only want what's mine!" "I'm only doing what I was meant to do."

And plus, she is too nosy. A seer is not an important character at all. She's meant to see things to help out a demon, they did too much with this character, and I got sick of her fast.

As for Kira the seer. I absolutely love her. One of my most favorite characters. She's pretty much got the same personality as me and anyone who reminds me of myself I love.

I really didn't want her to die because I was very convinced that this girl did not want to be a demon and just wanted to be a person, as was the girls. She was a great character and didn't deserve to be vanquished.

[~Andrew~]

I really loved Kira the Seer. She was so awesome and funny. But of course that's obvious cause I loved Cordelia Chase while she was on Angel.

This is what happens when Kern is writing the story. Just when it gets good or something he has to go and ruin it!

[ljones]

I like Charisma Carpenter, but Debbie Morgan was superb. Her performance made me see why her "Seer" is considered one of the best villains from the show.


But I can see why most fans prefer Carpenter. She's a lot younger and closer in age to most of the fans.

[CharmedFaith]

Plus she had more personality.

But its funny that we have seen 4 different types of demonic seers throughout the show. Two young, two old. And all 4 of them used their abilities in different ways.

[~Andrew~]

Nov 26, 2008 20:22:54 GMT -5 ljones said:

I like Charisma Carpenter, but Debbie Morgan was superb. Her performance made me see why her "Seer" is considered one of the best villains from the show.


But I can see why most fans prefer Carpenter. She's a lot younger and closer in age to most of the fans.

That's not exactly why I like Kyra more than the first seer. I felt that she had personality and she would've made a great storyline. Debbie Morgan was cool at first and yes she had good acting but after a while she became really annoying and her storyline was meaningless.

[ljones]

Plus she had more personality.

For teenagers, twenty-somethings and those "who think young". Actually, Charisma seemed to have taken the character of Cordelia Chase and transfer it to another character.

[Elder]

The writers should have been like super clever and humorous.
They should have named one of the seers "Claire Voyant" (like the seer in my fan fic story) ;D

[matthew17]

I loved Kira! She was awesome, not to mention she was played by Charisma Carpenter! I wish she could have became a main character on the series, like in the main titles and everything, that would have rocked! As for the other seer I HATED her!!!! LOL!

[x0pruehalliwell0x]

[glow=violet,2,300]argh i hate seer shes mean and creepy [/glow]

[pixiesunbelle]

Debbi Morgan's seer was great and played the villain awesome. However, Charisma's seer played the opposite type who just wanted to be human. I think it would have been great if Kyra could have been made human instead of being killed off by a demon. I think she should have become a main character. I also think that she could have been the "fresh face" that productions needed instead of the Billie/Christy storyline.
Instead of being made human she could have been deemed "good" by the Elders officially and work as TCO's Seer to see what Phoebe may not see. This way she could be made a regular character. However, her character longed for human-ness so she would have needed to be made human and then perhaps could have returned later- say some other demons wanted their revenge even though she has no more powers. After all, she betrayed them.
Since she made her end of the deal; the Elders grant her defensive powers so she could protect herself and then she temporarily moves in with Phoebe at her new apartment.... sounds like a nice set-up to me. ;D