Esmeralda
Charmed
S2 "What If...?"
Fan Fic Winner
Twenty Years Gone....But Never Forgotten.
Posts: 21,920 
|
Post by Esmeralda on Feb 28, 2022 7:17:17 GMT -5
Having re-watched up to 'Saving Private Leo', my reactions have changed. My listing now looks like this: SEASON ONE: 1. Something Wicca This Way Comes 2. Dead Man Dating 3. The Witch is Back 4. Wicca Envy 5. Secrets and Guys 6. That Seventies Episode 7. Deja vu All Over Again SEASON TWO 8. Morality Bites 9. They’re Everywhere 10. P3 H20 11. Heartbreak City 12. Show Me a Sign 13. Murphy’s Luck 14. Chick Flick 15. Ex Libris 16. Apocalypse Not SEASON THREE: 17. Magic Hour 18. Once Upon a Time 19. All Halliwell’s Eve 20. Coyote Piper 21. The Good, The Bad and the Cursed 22. Just Harried 23. Pre-Witched 24. Sin Francisco SEASON FOUR 25. A Knight to Remember 26. Lost and Bound 27. Brain Drain 28. Muses to My Ears 29. A Paige from the Past SEASON FIVE 30. The Eyes Have It 31. The Day the Magic Died 32. Baby’s First Demon 33. Cat House 34. Sense and Sense-Ability SEASON SIX 35. Little Monsters 36. I Dream of Phoebe SEASON SEVEN 37. Show Ghoul 38. Something Wicca This Way Goes? SEASON EIGHT 39. Engaged and Confused 40. The Jung and The Restless TOTALS: Season One: 8 episodes Season Two: 9 episodes Season Three: 8 episodes Season Four: 5 episodes Season Five: 5 episodes Season Six: 2 episodes Season Seven: 2 episodes Season Eight: 2 episodes I'm surprised Es, Witch Trial wasn't included in your top 30 and SWTW still is. Also From Fear to Eternity as well. With how much you loved it in our re-watch, and didn't like SWTWC on the two previous re-watches we did with FFTE. Here's mine: GRADE: A 1. Phoebe realizes that the Power of Three is the Power of One 2. Piper's expression when they're naked and Phoebe says "GRAMS!" 3. AND WE DIDN"T EVEN HAVE TO GET NAKED! Funny, although I prefer the music, I actually liked this episode better than 'SWTWC'. Only Dan and Jenny bring it down - but otherwise... Grade: A+ Moments: 1. Phoebe hugs Prue after learning that the last thing Prue said to Patty was "I Love You" 2. Phoebe doesn't lie to her boss's husband 3. Patty saves Prue in the pool. So many others...but I think these are my favorites. Oops, Olga; you're right! I was concentrating on S4 and not the earlier ones. Oh, boy, now trying to just find 30 is going to be even harder - usually I do 50. summerreading, would you please send me a copy of my grades? I can use that to truly update this. |
|
Aaeiyn
Elder
✨The Amazing Phoebe✨
Posts: 5,487
|
Post by Aaeiyn on Feb 28, 2022 14:04:11 GMT -5
I'mma do this in an interesting way. I'mma have a S1-S2 list, a S3-S4 list, and a S5-S8 list. However, to get a full list of 30 episodes will include some "not so great" episodes, for me. Just episodes I'm willing to watch, for those sections. If it's not listed, I'm not interested LOL I'mma spoil-tag, so I'm not stretching pages. Also, in no particular order and fluctuating. S1-S2 List1. S1E1 Something Wicca This Way Comes
2. S1E2 I've Got You Under My Skin
3. S2E2 Morality Bites
4. S2E3 The Painted World
5. S1E4 Dead Man Dating
6. S2E4 The Devil's Music
7. S1E5 Dream Sorcerer
8. S2E5 She's a Man, Baby, a Man!
9. S2E6 That Old Black Magic
10. S1E7 The Fourth Sister
11. S2E7 They're Everywhere
12. S1E8 The Truth is Out There...and it Hurts
13. S1E9 The Witch is Back
14. S2E9 Ms. Hellfire
15. S1E10 Wicca Envy
16. S2E10 Heartbreak City
17. S1E11 Feats of Clay
18. S1E12 The Wendigo
19. S1E13 From Fear to Eternity
20. S2E13 Animal Pragmatism
21. S1E14 Secrets & Guys
22. S1E15 Is There a Woogy, in the House?
23. S2E15 Give Me a Sign
24. S1E16 Which Prue is it, Anyway?
25. S1E18 When Bad Warlocks Go Good
26. S2E18 Chick Flick
27. S1E19 Out of Sight
28. S2E19 Ex Libris
29. S1E20 The Power of Two
30. S1E22 Deja Vu all Over, Again
Total:
S1 - 18 episodes
S2 - 12 episodes S3-S4 List1. S3E1 The Honeymoon's Over
2. S4E1 Charmed Again, Pt 1
3. S3E2 Magic Hour
4. S4E2 Charmed Again, Pt 2
5. S3E3 Once Upon a Time
6. S4E3 Hell Hath No Fury
7. S3E4 All Halliwell's Eve
8. S4E4 Enter the Demon
9. S3E5 Sight Unseen
10. S4E5 Size Matters
11. S3E6 Primrose Empath
12. S4E6 A Knight to Remember
13. S3E7 Power Outage
14. S4E7 Brain Drain
15. S3E8 Sleuthing with the Enemy
16. S4E8 Black as Cole
17. S3E9 Coyote Piper
18. S4E9 Muse to My Ears
19. S3E10 We all Scream for Ice Cream
20. S4E10 A Paige from the Past
21. S3E11 Blinded by the Whitelighter
22. S4E11 Trial by Magic
23. S3E14 The Good, the Bad & the Cursed
24. S4E17 Saving Private Leo
25. S3E18 Sin Francisco
26. S3E19 The Demon Who Came in from the Cold
27. S4E20 Long Live the Queen
28. S3E21 Look Who's Barking
29. S4E21 Womb Raider
30. S4E22 Witch Way, Now?
Total:
S3 - 15 episodes
S4 - 15 episodes S5-S8 List1. S5E1 A Witch's Tail, Pt 1
2. S6E1 Valhalley of the Dolls, Pt 1
3. S7E2 The Bare Witch Project
4. S5E3 Happily Ever After
5. S8E3 Run, Piper, Run
6. S6E4 The Power of Three Blondes
7. S6E5 Love's a Witch
8. S5E6 The Eyes Have it
9. S6E7 Soul Survivor
10. S7E7 Someone to Witch Over Me
11. S8E7 The Lost Picture Show
12. S7E8 Charmed Noir
13. S6E9 Little Monsters
14. S7E10 Witchness Protection
15. S8E11 Mr. & Mrs. Witch
16. S8E12 Payback's a Witch
17. S7E13 Charmageddon
18. S6E14 Legend of Sleepy Halliwell
19. S5E15 The Day That Magic Died
20. S6E15 I Dream of Phoebe
21. S5E16 Baby's First Demon
22. S7E16 The Seven Year Witch
23. S6E17 Hyde School Reunion
24. S6E18 Spin City
25. S7E18 Little Box of Horrors
26. S5E20 Sense and Sense Ability
27. S7E21 Death Becomes Them
28. S7E22 Something Wicca This Way Goes
29. S8E22 Forever Charmed
30. S6E23 It's a Bad, Bad, Bad, Bad World, Pt 2
Total:
S5 - 6 episodes
S6 - 10 episodes
S7 - 9 episodes
S8 - 5 episodes |
|
Esmeralda
Charmed
S2 "What If...?"
Fan Fic Winner
Twenty Years Gone....But Never Forgotten.
Posts: 21,920
|
Post by Esmeralda on Feb 28, 2022 19:50:35 GMT -5
I'm surprised Es, Witch Trial wasn't included in your top 30 and SWTW still is. Also From Fear to Eternity as well. With how much you loved it in our re-watch, and didn't like SWTWC on the two previous re-watches we did with FFTE. Oops, Olga; you're right! I was concentrating on S4 and not the earlier ones. Oh, boy, now trying to just find 30 is going to be even harder - usually I do 50. summerreading , would you please send me a copy of my grades? I can use that to truly update this. Bless you, Summer! I just finished numbering all of the ones I gave an A++, an A. or an A- to and I came up with 31, just for S1-S4. Since we haven't re-watched the rest yet so I have no idea what my current grade for those (or the ones I haven't re-watched yet) will be, I'm going to just list those, along with their grades: Es' Season 1 Grades1. Dead Man Dating A 2. The Truth is Out There and It Hurts A 3. The Witch is Back A+ 4. Feats of Clay A 5. The Wendigo A-6. From Fear to Eternity A+ 7. Secrets and Guys A 8. Which Prue is It Anyway? A 9. That 70s Episode A++ 10. Out of Sight A- 11. Deja Vu All Over Again A+ ------------------------------------------------------------- Es' Season 2 Grades12. Witch Trial A 13. Morality Bites A++ 14. She’s a Man Baby, a Man A 15. They’re Everywhere A+16. P3 H20 A- 17. Ms. Hellfire A 18. Reckless Abandon A 19. Heartbreak City A+ 20. Give Me a Sign A+ 21. Murphy’s Luck A+ 22. Chick Flick A+ 23. Ex Libris A- 24. Astral Monkey A --------------------------------------------------- Es' Season 3 Grades25. All Halliwell's Eve A++
26. We All Scream for Ice Cream A-
27. The Good, The Bad, and The Cursed A+ 28. Just Harried A- 29. Sin Francisco A ------------------------------------- Es' Season 4 Grades30. Brain Drain A- 31. A Paige from the Past A+ SUMMARY:Season One: Eleven Episodes Season Two: Thirteen Episodes Season Three: Five Episodes Season Four: Two Episodes (so far) --------------------------- I'll update when I'm done doing all of more-watches, although I'll be surprised if I give any of them an A. Ditto for when we're done with S5, S6, S7 and S8. 'If I find I have some more As in those episodes (I may/I may not), I'll have to delete my A-'s and maybe my A's in order to be close to 30 episodes. We'll see... Unlike others, I only give one A++ per season. Once we're done with the re-watch, I'll give one of those my single A+++. Others give more than one A++ per season and even more than one A+++ per season. That's their choice. I just think those grades are too special to be overused. |
|
|
|
Post by Emmett on Mar 1, 2022 17:11:37 GMT -5
Oops, Olga; you're right! I was concentrating on S4 and not the earlier ones. Oh, boy, now trying to just find 30 is going to be even harder - usually I do 50. summerreading , would you please send me a copy of my grades? I can use that to truly update this.ES: Bless you, Summer! I just finished numbering all of the ones I gave an A++, an A. or an A- to and I came up with 31, just for S1-S4. Since we haven't re-watched the rest yet so I have no idea what my current grade for those (or the ones I haven't re-watched yet) will be, I'm going to just list those, along with their grades: Es' Season 1 Grades1. Dead Man Dating A 2. The Truth is Out There and It Hurts A 3. The Witch is Back A+ 4. Feats of Clay A 5. The Wendigo A-6. From Fear to Eternity A+ 7. Secrets and Guys A 8. Which Prue is It Anyway? A 9. That 70s Episode A++ 10. Out of Sight A- 11. Deja Vu All Over Again A+ ------------------------------------------------------------- Es' Season 2 Grades12. Witch Trial A 13. Morality Bites A++ 14. She’s a Man Baby, a Man A 15. They’re Everywhere A+16. P3 H20 A- 17. Ms. Hellfire A 18. Reckless Abandon A 19. Heartbreak City A+ 20. Give Me a Sign A+ 21. Murphy’s Luck A+ 22. Chick Flick A+ 23. Ex Libris A- 24. Astral Monkey A --------------------------------------------------- Es' Season 3 Grades25. All Halliwell's Eve A++
26. We All Scream for Ice Cream A-
27. The Good, The Bad, and The Cursed A+ 28. Just Harried A- 29. Sin Francisco A ------------------------------------- Es' Season 4 Grades30. Brain Drain A- 31. A Paige from the Past A+ SUMMARY:Season One: Eleven Episodes Season Two: Thirteen Episodes Season Three: Five Episodes Season Four: Two Episodes (so far) --------------------------- EMMETT: I enjoyed reading your results Es. --------------------------- ES: I'll update when I'm done doing all of more-watches, although I'll be surprised if I give any of them an A. Ditto for when we're done with S5, S6, S7 and S8. 'If I find I have some more As in those episodes (I may/I may not), I'll have to delete my A-'s and maybe my A's in order to be close to 30 episodes. We'll see... EMMETT: Sounds like a great way to do it Es. Knowing you, I won't be surprised you don't get too many more As. We'll see. --------------------------------- ES; Unlike others, I only give one A++ per season. Once we're done with the re-watch, I'll give one of those my single A+++. Others give more than one A++ per season and even more than one A+++ per season. That's their choice. I just think those grades are too special to be overused. EMMETT: That's very fair. No right or wrong way to grade. It's up to the grader. Looking forward to seeing this be updated as the seasons go on. |
|
rebooted
Witch
Started watching at 12
Posts: 1,803 
|
Post by rebooted on Sept 22, 2022 22:20:51 GMT -5
I redid this again, but got to 31 episodes. Both what I think are the best and favourites.
I have to make a decision to remove one of the 3 bolded episodes. So hard. But its nice to know that these are my new top 30.
Season 1
1. 1-1 07 Oct 98 Something Wicca This Way Comes
4. 1-4 28 Oct 98 Dead Man Dating
7. 1-7 18 Nov 98 The Fourth Sister
9. 1-9 16 Dec 98 The Witch Is Back
13. 1-13 10 Feb 99 From Fear to Eternity
15. 1-15 24 Feb 99 Is There a Woogy in the House?
17. 1-17 07 Apr 99 That '70s Episode
19. 1-19 05 May 99 Out of Sight
22. 1-22 26 May 99 Déjà Vu All Over Again
Season 2
24. 2-2 07 Oct 99 Morality Bites
29. 2-7 18 Nov 99 They're Everywhere
36. 2-14 17 Feb 00 Pardon My Past
38. 2-16 30 Mar 00 Murphy's Luck
40. 2-18 20 Apr 00 Chick Flick
41. 2-19 27 Apr 00 Ex Libris
42. 2-20 04 May 00 Astral Monkey
43. 2-21 11 May 00 Apocalypse Not
Season 3
46. 3-2 12 Oct 00 Magic Hour
48. 3-4 26 Oct 00 All Halliwell's Eve
49. 3-5 02 Nov 00 Sight Unseen
51. 3-7 16 Nov 00 Power Outage
58. 3-14 15 Feb 01 The Good, the Bad and the Cursed
59. 3-15 22 Feb 01 Just Harried
61. 3-17 22 Mar 01 Pre-Witched
Season 4
67. 4-1 04 Oct 01 Charmed Again (1)
69. 4-3 11 Oct 01 Hell Hath No Fury
73. 4-7 08 Nov 01 Brain Drain
75. 4-9 13 Dec 01 Muse to My Ears
76. 4-10 17 Jan 02 A Paige from the Past
79. 4-13 07 Feb 02 Charmed and Dangerous
86. 4-20 02 May 02 Long Live the Queen
|
|
|
|
Post by Sandra on Sept 23, 2022 18:54:16 GMT -5
Here's mine. It might change the more rewatches I do and adjust the list.
LATER: I couldn't cut my list down to 30. So mine is 40 episodes.
1. Dead Man Dating
2. The Truth is Out There and It Hurts 3. The Witch is Back 4. Feats of Clay 5. The Wendigo 6. From Fear to Eternity 7. Secrets and Guys 8. Is There a Woogy in the House
9. That 70s Episode 10. Out of Sight 11. Deja Vu All Over Again 12. Witch Trial 13. Morality Bites 14. They’re Everywhere 15. P3 H20 16. Heartbreak City 17. Give Me a Sign 18. Murphy’s Luck 19. Chick Flick 20. Ex Libris
21. Astral Monkey
22. All Halliwell's Eve 23. Power Outage 24. Coyote Piper
25. We All Scream for Ice Cream 26. The Good, The Bad, and The Cursed 27. Just Harried
28. Pre-Witched
29. Sin Francisco 30. Brain Drain 31. Muses to My Ears
32. A Paige from the Past 33. The Eyes Have It 34. Baby’s First Demon 35. Sense and Sense Ability 36. Little Monsters 37. I Dream of Phoebe
38. Show Ghoul 39. Something Wicca This Way Goes?
40. Paybacks a Witch SUMMARY: Season One: Eleven Episodes Season Two: Ten Episodes Season Three: Eight Episodes Season Four: Three Episodes Season Five: Three Episodes Season Six: Two Episodes Season Seven: Two Episodes Season Eight: One Episode
|
|
Esmeralda
Charmed
S2 "What If...?"
Fan Fic Winner
Twenty Years Gone....But Never Forgotten.
Posts: 21,920
|
Post by Esmeralda on Sept 24, 2022 16:47:43 GMT -5
Bless you, Summer! I just finished numbering all of the ones I gave an A++, an A. or an A- to and I came up with 31, just for S1-S4. Since we haven't re-watched the rest yet so I have no idea what my current grade for those (or the ones I haven't re-watched yet) will be, I'm going to just list those, along with their grades: Es' Season 1 Grades1. Dead Man Dating A 2. The Truth is Out There and It Hurts A 3. The Witch is Back A+ 4. Feats of Clay A 5. The Wendigo A-6. From Fear to Eternity A+ 7. Secrets and Guys A 8. Which Prue is It Anyway? A 9. That 70s Episode A++ 10. Out of Sight A- 11. Deja Vu All Over Again A+ ------------------------------------------------------------- Es' Season 2 Grades12. Witch Trial A 13. Morality Bites A++ 14. She’s a Man Baby, a Man A 15. They’re Everywhere A+16. P3 H20 A- 17. Ms. Hellfire A 18. Reckless Abandon A 19. Heartbreak City A+ 20. Give Me a Sign A+ 21. Murphy’s Luck A+ 22. Chick Flick A+ 23. Ex Libris A- 24. Astral Monkey A --------------------------------------------------- Es' Season 3 Grades25. All Halliwell's Eve A++
26. We All Scream for Ice Cream A-
27. The Good, The Bad, and The Cursed A+ 28. Just Harried A- 29. Sin Francisco A ------------------------------------- Es' Season 4 Grades30. Brain Drain A- 31. A Paige from the Past A+ SUMMARY:Season One: Eleven Episodes Season Two: Thirteen Episodes Season Three: Five Episodes Season Four: Two Episodes (so far) --------------------------- I'll update when I'm done doing all of more-watches, although I'll be surprised if I give any of them an A. Ditto for when we're done with S5, S6, S7 and S8. 'If I find I have some more As in those episodes (I may/I may not), I'll have to delete my A-'s and maybe my A's in order to be close to 30 episodes. We'll see... Unlike others, I only give one A++ per season. Once we're done with the re-watch, I'll give one of those my single A+++. Others give more than one A++ per season and even more than one A+++ per season. That's their choice. I just think those grades are too special to be overused. Nice job, Sandra! We finished re-watching S4 earlier this year, but I didn't give an A+, A or A- to any of the latter episodes, so this is still my listing - I can just remove the "(so far)". |
|
forbuss
Witch
currently watching season seven
Posts: 1,748
|
Post by forbuss on Sept 27, 2022 13:52:15 GMT -5
Here is my first crack at my top 30 episodes:
1. 1x01 Something Wicca This Way Comes
2. 1x04 Dead Man Dating
3. 1x15 Is There a Woogy In the House
4. 2x02 Morality Bites
5. 2x18 Chick Flick
6. 2x19 Ex Libris
7. 3x04 All Halliwell’s Eve
8. 3x19 The Demon Who Came in From the Cold
9. 3x20 Exit Strategy
10. 3x22 All Hell Breaks Loose
11. 4x01 Charmed Again Part 1
12. 4x02 Charmed Again Part 2
13. 4x03 Hell Hath No Fury
14. 4x10 A Paige from the Past
15. 4x20 Long Live the Queen
16. 4x21 Womb Raider
17. 5x06 The Eyes Have It
18. 5x10 Y Tu Mummy Tambien
19. 5x12 Centennial Charmed
20. 5x15 The Day That Magic Died
21. 5x20 Sense and Sense Ability
22. 6x09 Little Monsters
23. 7x04 Charrrmed
24. 7x10 Witchness Protection
25. 7x12 Extreme Makeover: World Edition
26. 7x16 The Seven Year Witch
27. 7x21 Death Becomes Them
28. 7x22 Something Wicca This Way Goes…?
29. 8x10 Vaya Con Leos
30. 8x22 Forever Charmed
Season One: 3 Episodes
Season Two: 3 Episodes
Season Three: 4 Episodes
Season Four: 6 Episodes
Season Five: 5 Episodes
Season Six: 1 Episode
Season Seven: 6 Episodes
Season Eight: 2 Episodes
|
|
rebooted
Witch
Started watching at 12
Posts: 1,803
|
Post by rebooted on Oct 24, 2022 22:58:58 GMT -5
My updated list - which I am sure will change again.
Season 1
1. 1-1 07 Oct 98 Something Wicca This Way Comes
4. 1-4 28 Oct 98 Dead Man Dating
9. 1-9 16 Dec 98 The Witch Is Back
13. 1-13 10 Feb 99 From Fear to Eternity
15. 1-15 24 Feb 99 Is There a Woogy in the House?
17. 1-17 07 Apr 99 That '70s Episode
22. 1-22 26 May 99 Déjà Vu All Over Again
Season 2
24. 2-2 07 Oct 99 Morality Bites
25. 2-3 14 Oct 99 The Painted World
29. 2-7 18 Nov 99 They're Everywhere
30. 2-8 09 Dec 99 P3 H2O
36. 2-14 17 Feb 00 Pardon My Past
38. 2-16 30 Mar 00 Murphy's Luck
40. 2-18 20 Apr 00 Chick Flick
41. 2-19 27 Apr 00 Ex Libris
42. 2-20 04 May 00 Astral Monkey
43. 2-21 11 May 00 Apocalypse Not
Season 3
46. 3-2 12 Oct 00 Magic Hour
48. 3-4 26 Oct 00 All Halliwell's Eve
49. 3-5 02 Nov 00 Sight Unseen
51. 3-7 16 Nov 00 Power Outage
52. 3-8 14 Dec 00 Sleuthing with the Enemy
58. 3-14 15 Feb 01 The Good, the Bad and the Cursed
61. 3-17 22 Mar 01 Pre-Witched
62. 3-18 19 Apr 01 Sin Francisco
Season 4
73. 4-7 08 Nov 01 Brain Drain
76. 4-10 17 Jan 02 A Paige from the Past
79. 4-13 07 Feb 02 Charmed and Dangerous
82. 4-16 21 Mar 02 The Fifth Halliwheel
86. 4-20 02 May 02 Long Live the Queen
|
|
