Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Aug 8, 2015 5:34:11 GMT -5
Unfortunately, that flash forward, like it or hate it, is canon. So unless you want to build a series around fringe characters, like Rex and Hannah, who were not affected by said flash forward, you have to acknowledge it.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Aug 8, 2015 8:35:38 GMT -5
Yes it would be a good reason to explain Paige's absence and her alive again. Yeah impossible to do in 1998-2001 sadly. Yeah I can see some complaining. It wouldn't bother me one bit at all. Seeing as I'm one of the fans who loved the Prue years more than Paige. But seeing as both Holly and Shannen are the only main actors to attend charmed events and conventions in recent years and seem to love the show, they probably would be the ones who would be most open to return. You cant do it without at least three. Still my dream would be for them to get all four sisters back, and a reunion with Prue. But an alternate timeline with Prue alive sounds even better. No offence to Paige, but the original is what started the series, and if it wasn't for them there would be no show. So I'd prefer that to an original movie with Paige which brings Prue back and is forced to keep the series canon of Forever Crap. Yeah, some people might complain about the absence of Paige, but if Rose doesn't want to do it and the original three do, what else could you do? Besides, I'd prefer an alternate timeline, myself. It'd be great to see the original P3 again, and it'd be easier to jettison the crap from the later seasons that most fans hate. More significantly, it'd wipe out that awful flash-forward, along with Stupid Cupid and Brad's Brood of Brats, so the movie wouldn't be saddled with any of that baggage. (It'd also provide an easy solution to the Wyatt and Chris issue, since Wes and Drew are probably even less interested in returning to Charmed than Rose. It's a new timeline, so their characters don't have to exist. The movie could safely avoid any possible fan backlash over them being played by different actors or them having a younger sister.)
|
|
Esmeralda
Charmed
S2 "What If...?" Fan Fic Winner
Twenty Years Gone....But Never Forgotten.
Posts: 21,903
|
Post by Esmeralda on Aug 8, 2015 12:34:56 GMT -5
Yes it would be a good reason to explain Paige's absence and her alive again. Yeah impossible to do in 1998-2001 sadly. Yeah I can see some complaining. It wouldn't bother me one bit at all. Seeing as I'm one of the fans who loved the Prue years more than Paige. But seeing as both Holly and Shannen are the only main actors to attend charmed events and conventions in recent years and seem to love the show, they probably would be the ones who would be most open to return. You cant do it without at least three. Still my dream would be for them to get all four sisters back, and a reunion with Prue. But an alternate timeline with Prue alive sounds even better. No offence to Paige, but the original is what started the series, and if it wasn't for them there would be no show. So I'd prefer that to an original movie with Paige which brings Prue back and is forced to keep the series canon of Forever Crap. Yeah, some people might complain about the absence of Paige, but if Rose doesn't want to do it and the original three do, what else could you do? Besides, I'd prefer an alternate timeline, myself. It'd be great to see the original P3 again, and it'd be easier to jettison the crap from the later seasons that most fans hate. More significantly, it'd wipe out that awful flash-forward, along with Stupid Cupid and Brad's Brood of Brats, so the movie wouldn't be saddled with any of that baggage. (It'd also provide an easy solution to the Wyatt and Chris issue, since Wes and Drew are probably even less interested in returning to Charmed than Rose. It's a new timeline, so their characters don't have to exist. The movie could safely avoid any possible fan backlash over them being played by different actors or them having a younger sister.) I'll agree with most of this, although I don't mind the Charmed Ones having kids IF it's after the Ultimate Battle when there's no longer as much danger. And I'd definitely prefer at least one of them to remain unmarried. I'd prefer Piper to never marry and never have kids - she'd do so much better if she was just taking care of her catering business which she does out of the Manor (I prefer that to either nightclub or restaurant, but since most fans would want Piper and Leo to be together, I'd at least prefer them childless so you don't have any half-whitelighters roaming around) She was a dreadful wife and a dreadful mother, so she'd be so much better off with neither husband or child. Phoebe, I wouldn't mind her having Ladybug just to shut her up, but I can't see her staying with Coop once she has the baby she wants so much. Prue, if she lived, I'd want to see married to Bane with kids once the danger is over. She's the one who would make the best mother. I also don't mind the magical community if they're used properly - more like "Happily Ever After" and less like "Oh, My Goddess!", where the only ones who can see them are the young and the young at heart. Just that would've fixed a lot of the problems since Paige was the only one who was young at heart after S3. What I'd want to see is an alternate timeline with Prue living so S4-8 never happens and Paige, Wyatt and Chris never exist, and with the TV-movie showing what happens 20 years after "All Hell Breaks Loose".
|
|
Esmeralda
Charmed
S2 "What If...?" Fan Fic Winner
Twenty Years Gone....But Never Forgotten.
Posts: 21,903
|
Post by Esmeralda on Aug 8, 2015 12:36:19 GMT -5
I'd so watch a movie with the original power of three, and Piper has Melinda. An alternate timeline, where Prue lived after season 3. Doesn't Star Trek do movies that are alternate to the series or something. I'm not a fan, but I heard they do this. Yup, the new Star Trek movies are set in an alternate universe from the Original Series and its Next Generation/Deep Space Nine/Voyager spinoffs. (The prequel series, Enterprise, exists in both timelines.) In fact, they actually came up with an in-universe explanation for the new timeline, which is something that Charmed could easily do as well, if needed. Tim did something like this for his Charmed reboot idea, which I would love to see.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Aug 8, 2015 12:48:36 GMT -5
I'll agree with most of this, although I don't mind the Charmed Ones having kids IF it's after the Ultimate Battle when there's no longer as much danger. And I'd definitely prefer at least one of them to remain unmarried. I'd prefer Piper to never marry and never have kids - she'd do so much better if she was just taking care of her catering business which she does out of the Manor (I prefer that to either nightclub or restaurant, but since most fans would want Piper and Leo to be together, I'd at least prefer them childless so you don't have any half-whitelighters roaming around) She was a dreadful wife and a dreadful mother, so she'd be so much better off with neither husband or child. Phoebe, I wouldn't mind her having Ladybug just to shut her up, but I can't see her staying with Coop once she has the baby she wants so much. Prue, if she lived, I'd want to see married to Bane with kids once the danger is over. She's the one who would make the best mother. Doing it your way, Prue and Phoebe could each have one daughter, which is fine with me. Phoebe could be a single mom, while Prue/Bane and Piper/Leo are together. I also don't mind the magical community if they're used properly - more like "Happily Ever After" and less like "Oh, My Goddess!", where the only ones who can see them are the young and the young at heart. Just that would've fixed a lot of the problems since Paige was the only one who was young at heart after S3. You mean "Once Upon a Time," right? ("Happily Ever After" was the Season 5 fairytale episode.) Yeah, I didn't mind the Season 3 depiction of fairies and trolls, which was almost more horror than Disney. Seriously, those trolls were scarier than many of the later season bad guys! What I'd want to see is an alternate timeline with Prue living so S4-8 never happens and Paige, Wyatt and Chris never exist, and with the TV-movie showing what happens 20 years after "All Hell Breaks Loose". Maybe, it could follow up from an alternate "All Hell Breaks Loose" where magic was never exposed and time was never rewound?
|
|
Esmeralda
Charmed
S2 "What If...?" Fan Fic Winner
Twenty Years Gone....But Never Forgotten.
Posts: 21,903
|
Post by Esmeralda on Aug 8, 2015 13:37:12 GMT -5
I'll agree with most of this, although I don't mind the Charmed Ones having kids IF it's after the Ultimate Battle when there's no longer as much danger. And I'd definitely prefer at least one of them to remain unmarried. I'd prefer Piper to never marry and never have kids - she'd do so much better if she was just taking care of her catering business which she does out of the Manor (I prefer that to either nightclub or restaurant, but since most fans would want Piper and Leo to be together, I'd at least prefer them childless so you don't have any half-whitelighters roaming around) She was a dreadful wife and a dreadful mother, so she'd be so much better off with neither husband or child. Phoebe, I wouldn't mind her having Ladybug just to shut her up, but I can't see her staying with Coop once she has the baby she wants so much. Prue, if she lived, I'd want to see married to Bane with kids once the danger is over. She's the one who would make the best mother. Doing it your way, Prue and Phoebe could each have one daughter, which is fine with me. Phoebe could be a single mom, while Prue/Bane and Piper/Leo are together. Well, I'd want Prue with more than just one, since as I said, I think she'd make the best mother while either still working for 415 Magazine. There's a fanfic that I absolutely adore, "Unspeakable Consequences" where Piper and Leo are separated for 16 full years after "The Magic Hour". You wouldn't like it because they're all married and have children - Prue who's married to Bane after he was released from jail has a young son named AJ (of course the A stands for Andrew) Piper who was pregnant when the Elders separate them has Melinda; Phoebe, who's married to an unevil still-demonic Cole has twins, Chris (this was written during the summer between S3 & S4 and has absolutely nothing to do with S6 Chris) and Kristen. So none of them have three and none of the kids will ever become Charmed - that will end with the Charmed Ones. Here's part of that story: The rest of dinner was long, filled with only small talk. Piper had told everyone where she had been all of those years, and how she couldn’t get a hold of anyone, and how she’d tried. Phoebe and Prue told her about not being able to take care of P3, and how it was shut down months after she ‘left’. Piper had expected that to happen; she tried to reassure them that it was fine. She could tell that they were feeling guilty. It was no big deal to her anymore.
Current careers was also a major topic.
“I’m a psychiatrist, but I’ve also got a very popular advice column on the Internet,” Phoebe was saying.
“You’re a shrink?” Piper asked jokingly.
“Yes, I am.” Phoebe smirked. “What have you been doing all these years?”
“Well, I actually manage and co-own an inn. Yeah, you may say how ‘Gilmore Girls’ is that, but I wanted to own a restaurant, but inns make a lot more money.”
“‘Gilmore Girls’?” Melinda asked.
“TV show when you were younger,” she murmured back.
“Oh…”
“What about you, Prue? Bane? Cole?” Piper asked. “What do you all do for a living?”
Prue smiled. “Bane and I bought 415 magazine, and I’m the main editor for it.”
“Wow,” Leo smiled. “That’s pretty impressive.”
“Thank you,” Prue said, smiling proudly.
“And I’m a lawyer,” Cole added. “I’m the District Attorney.” . Piper couldn’t help laughing. “So you’re both a demon and a lawyer? Insert joke here!”
“Yeah,” Cole said, laughing a little too. That's how I would've loved to find them 20 years after "All Hell Breaks Loose" but with Piper running her catering business out of the Manor (in this one, Phoebe lives in the Manor while Prue and Bane live in Bane's dream house - Piper still lives in her own little apartment many, many states away) and no kids and no husband. Unfortunately the site where I got that story is no longer around and although it *is* in the "Old Cafe Fanfics" it's very hard to read like most of the stories that were transferred from the original ezBoard site. But if anyone wants to try, here's the link: thecharmedcafe.proboards.com/thread/3307/unspeakable-consequencesOops! My bad! For some reason I always get those two titles mixed up, but I absolutely meant "Once Upon a Time". Definitely. I just hated them being called trolls - trolls are huge and ugly! If I use them in fanfics, I always change them to gremlins. No, because then Piper would be dead and since Holly wants to do it and Rose doesn't, I'd want all three original sisters to be alive. I'd want it exactly like "All Hell Breaks Loose", just have it be just like the beginning where Leo gets there in time to save both Prue and Piper. Or better, as someone else suggested, do like what happened in "Forever Charmed" but have it be Phoebe and Leo who go on a time-travel trip to save both Prue and Piper (I'd let *both* of them be dead...) by Phoebe deciding to stay aboveground and talking her sisters out of chasing Shax into the street. Then when Shax shows up, they can say the spell together and he goes bye-bye without an everlasting time loop.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Aug 8, 2015 17:14:52 GMT -5
No, because then Piper would be dead and since Holly wants to do it and Rose doesn't, I'd want all three original sisters to be alive. I'd want it exactly like "All Hell Breaks Loose", just have it be just like the beginning where Leo gets there in time to save both Prue and Piper. Or better, as someone else suggested, do like what happened in "Forever Charmed" but have it be Phoebe and Leo who go on a time-travel trip to save both Prue and Piper (I'd let *both* of them be dead...) by Phoebe deciding to stay aboveground and talking her sisters out of chasing Shax into the street. Then when Shax shows up, they can say the spell together and he goes bye-bye without an everlasting time loop. I said "where magic was never exposed and time was never rewound." Piper wouldn't have died if magic wasn't exposed in the first place. We both pretty much have the same idea on how "All Hell Breaks Loose" would be redone.
|
|
Esmeralda
Charmed
S2 "What If...?" Fan Fic Winner
Twenty Years Gone....But Never Forgotten.
Posts: 21,903
|
Post by Esmeralda on Aug 8, 2015 17:18:30 GMT -5
No, because then Piper would be dead and since Holly wants to do it and Rose doesn't, I'd want all three original sisters to be alive. I'd want it exactly like "All Hell Breaks Loose", just have it be just like the beginning where Leo gets there in time to save both Prue and Piper. Or better, as someone else suggested, do like what happened in "Forever Charmed" but have it be Phoebe and Leo who go on a time-travel trip to save both Prue and Piper (I'd let *both* of them be dead...) by Phoebe deciding to stay aboveground and talking her sisters out of chasing Shax into the street. Then when Shax shows up, they can say the spell together and he goes bye-bye without an everlasting time loop. I said "where magic was never exposed and time was never rewound." Piper wouldn't have died if magic wasn't exposed in the first place. We both pretty much have the same idea on how "All Hell Breaks Loose" would be redone. Ah, gotcha. Somehow it didn't read as if you meant it quite that way, so I wanted to be sure. But I think you're right that we do.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Aug 8, 2015 17:23:36 GMT -5
The problem with all these scenarios is that the actors are nearly twenty years older. They can't look like they did in 1999 anymore.
|
|
Esmeralda
Charmed
S2 "What If...?" Fan Fic Winner
Twenty Years Gone....But Never Forgotten.
Posts: 21,903
|
Post by Esmeralda on Aug 8, 2015 17:44:55 GMT -5
The problem with all these scenarios is that the actors are nearly twenty years older. They can't look like they did in 1999 anymore. And that's exactly why I said I'd want it to take place 20 years after "All Hell Breaks Loose"... *rolls eyes at Tim*. They can either reshoot the episode or use computer-generated images for flashbacks or just talk about it.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Aug 8, 2015 17:48:27 GMT -5
Well, since the likelihood of this actually happening is the same as Putin dressing up in drag, talk is all there is.
|
|
juls
Innocent
Posts: 42
|
Post by juls on Jan 10, 2016 12:28:47 GMT -5
It's nice that Shannen, Holly, and Brian did Comic Con, but Alyssa, Rose, and Julian were such a huge part of the show, that I really think there should be another Comic Con with Holly Marie Combs, Alyssa Milano, Rose McGowan, and Julian McMahon. If Holly is still mad at Alyssa, then they can just do Alyssa, Rose, and Julian as another trio for Comic Con.
|
|
juls
Innocent
Posts: 42
|
Post by juls on Jan 10, 2016 21:01:06 GMT -5
|
|
|
Post by Astral Vision on Jan 13, 2016 14:24:56 GMT -5
Doing it your way, Prue and Phoebe could each have one daughter, which is fine with me. Phoebe could be a single mom, while Prue/Bane and Piper/Leo are together. Well, I'd want Prue with more than just one, since as I said, I think she'd make the best mother while either still working for 415 Magazine. There's a fanfic that I absolutely adore, "Unspeakable Consequences" where Piper and Leo are separated for 16 full years after "The Magic Hour". You wouldn't like it because they're all married and have children - Prue who's married to Bane after he was released from jail has a young son named AJ (of course the A stands for Andrew) Piper who was pregnant when the Elders separate them has Melinda; Phoebe, who's married to an unevil still-demonic Cole has twins, Chris (this was written during the summer between S3 & S4 and has absolutely nothing to do with S6 Chris) and Kristen. So none of them have three and none of the kids will ever become Charmed - that will end with the Charmed Ones. Here's part of that story: The rest of dinner was long, filled with only small talk. Piper had told everyone where she had been all of those years, and how she couldn’t get a hold of anyone, and how she’d tried. Phoebe and Prue told her about not being able to take care of P3, and how it was shut down months after she ‘left’. Piper had expected that to happen; she tried to reassure them that it was fine. She could tell that they were feeling guilty. It was no big deal to her anymore.
Current careers was also a major topic.
“I’m a psychiatrist, but I’ve also got a very popular advice column on the Internet,” Phoebe was saying.
“You’re a shrink?” Piper asked jokingly.
“Yes, I am.” Phoebe smirked. “What have you been doing all these years?”
“Well, I actually manage and co-own an inn. Yeah, you may say how ‘Gilmore Girls’ is that, but I wanted to own a restaurant, but inns make a lot more money.”
“‘Gilmore Girls’?” Melinda asked.
“TV show when you were younger,” she murmured back.
“Oh…”
“What about you, Prue? Bane? Cole?” Piper asked. “What do you all do for a living?”
Prue smiled. “Bane and I bought 415 magazine, and I’m the main editor for it.”
“Wow,” Leo smiled. “That’s pretty impressive.”
“Thank you,” Prue said, smiling proudly.
“And I’m a lawyer,” Cole added. “I’m the District Attorney.” . Piper couldn’t help laughing. “So you’re both a demon and a lawyer? Insert joke here!”
“Yeah,” Cole said, laughing a little too. That's how I would've loved to find them 20 years after "All Hell Breaks Loose" but with Piper running her catering business out of the Manor (in this one, Phoebe lives in the Manor while Prue and Bane live in Bane's dream house - Piper still lives in her own little apartment many, many states away) and no kids and no husband. Unfortunately the site where I got that story is no longer around and although it *is* in the "Old Cafe Fanfics" it's very hard to read like most of the stories that were transferred from the original ezBoard site. But if anyone wants to try, here's the link: thecharmedcafe.proboards.com/thread/3307/unspeakable-consequences:/ That's annoying. I'd probably want to give it a read if it weren't so annoyingly formatted.
|
|
|
Post by Chrisaholic on Jan 15, 2016 12:18:23 GMT -5
I would like to see a cast reunion show. Where the actors share their memories of the show, favourite episodes, and such. I would watch that. Just like they did with Army Wives. I so love that!! It's always interesting how actors watch their own show and how they acted behind the scenes.
|
|
|
Post by Melinda Halliwell on Jan 15, 2016 13:43:41 GMT -5
Well there doing a friends cast reunion show without Matthew Perry who's in theatre then but he's goanna film something on video though.
|
|
juls
Innocent
Posts: 42
|
Post by juls on Jan 22, 2016 21:56:06 GMT -5
Which Comic Con does Holly say that she sees Alyssa jogging and being all healthy? I haven't seen that one.
|
|