Granny Charmed
Whitelighter
S1 "What If...?" Fan Fic Winner
Posts: 3,225
|
Post by Granny Charmed on Aug 16, 2017 5:34:03 GMT -5
I've loved dears the thread on naming your top 10 most favorite moments or scenes of the series. Now I think it would be wonderful to get a top 10 for each season.
Pick your all time top 10 favorite season 3 moments or scenes but only moments you really liked. You can also note down honourable mentions to one or two moments *not* in the top 10, but worth mentioning.
This is going to be so much fun!!!
|
|
craig
Familiar
Posts: 255
|
Post by craig on Sept 3, 2017 19:42:26 GMT -5
Craig's Season 2 Top 10
#1 Piper dies in the hospital with Prue by her side in 'All Hell Breaks Loose' #2 Phoebe and Prue have a heart-to-heart conversation about Phoebe's betrayal in 'Wrestling With Demons'. #3 Patty hugs Prue, Piper and Phoebe in 'Just Harried' #4 Piper, Phoebe and Prue on the couch when Prue asked piper to move into her room. "Pre-Witched #5 Phoebe flying across the moon as her sisters watch in 'All Halliwell's Eve" #6 Grams takes the iconic picture of Prue, Piper and Phoebe in 'Pre-Witched' #7 Piper and Prue are left for dead, and Shax leaves the manor and the glass smashes on the door in 'All Hell Breaks Loose' #8 Prue's one on one talk with Piper in her club about away with Leo in 'The Honeymoon's Over' #9 Prue apologies to an unconscious Piper and then flings a knife into her chest releasing Terra in 'Coyote Piper' #10 Prue driven crazy by feeling everyone's emotions in the basement in 'Primrose Empath'
Honourable Mentions
#1 'Phoebe, it's just a carton' - 'Sin Francisco' #2 Phoebe building a sand castle at the beach with Prue in 'Death Takes a Halliwell'
|
|
|
Post by prudencehalliwell on Jul 2, 2020 1:09:38 GMT -5
Decided to bump this up, since lately so much discussion is always on what we hate about Charmed and the sisters.
|
|
|
Post by Melinda Halliwell on Jul 2, 2020 3:35:19 GMT -5
1. The courtroom fight scene in the first episode because the sisters worked together and were all on an equal footing.
No-one was powerful than the other.
2. Prue and Phoebe acting like kids after being dusted with Fairy powder. Very funny.
3. Phoebe flying over the moon on a broomstick in 'All Halliwell's Eve' which reminded me of season 1 and 2 Phoebe.
4. Prue apologising to Piper at the end of 'Coyote Piper' about what she's about to do.
5. Prue, Piper, and Phoebe talking at the end of 'Pre-Witched'.
6. Grams taking the picture of the sisters in the same episode.
7. Patty talking to her daughters in 'Just Harried' before the wedding ceremony.
8. Prue and Piper's acting when the younger sister dies in hospital after being shot which made me cry the first time because of the feels.
9. The end scene from 'All Hell Breaks Loose' where Prue and Piper are left for dead because of the gravity of the situation and the fact Shax actually killed a Charmed One then.
10. Prue and Victor finally getting along at the end of the Ice Cream Man episode.
|
|
Esmeralda
Charmed
S2 "What If...?" Fan Fic Winner
Twenty Years Gone....But Never Forgotten.
Posts: 21,903
|
Post by Esmeralda on Jul 2, 2020 20:48:32 GMT -5
I LOVE most of the ones in Craig's list: Craig's Season 2 Top 10
#1 Piper dies in the hospital with Prue by her side in 'All Hell Breaks Loose' #2 Phoebe and Prue have a heart-to-heart conversation about Phoebe's betrayal in 'Wrestling With Demons'. #3 Patty hugs Prue, Piper and Phoebe in 'Just Harried' #4 Piper, Phoebe and Prue on the couch when Prue asked piper to move into her room. "Pre-Witched #5 Phoebe flying across the moon as her sisters watch in 'All Halliwell's Eve" #6 Grams takes the iconic picture of Prue, Piper and Phoebe in 'Pre-Witched' #7 Piper and Prue are left for dead, and Shax leaves the manor and the glass smashes on the door in 'All Hell Breaks Loose'#8 Prue's one on one talk with Piper in her club about away with Leo in 'The Honeymoon's Over' #9 Prue apologies to an unconscious Piper and then flings a knife into her chest releasing Terra in 'Coyote Piper' #10 Prue driven crazy by feeling everyone's emotions in the basement in 'Primrose Empath' Honourable Mentions
#1 'Phoebe, it's just a carton' - 'Sin Francisco' #2 Phoebe building a sand castle at the beach with Prue in 'Death Takes a Halliwell' So from that (and a few of my own), here's my list: #1: Phoebe flying across the moon as her sisters watch in 'All Halliwell's Eve". #2: Phoebe building a sand castle at the beach with Prue in 'Death Takes a Halliwell'. #3: Patty hugs her daughters in 'Just Harried'. #4: Grams takes the iconic picture of Prue, Piper and Phoebe in 'Pre-Witched'. #5: The sisters sitting on the couch when Prue asked Piper to move into her room in"Pre-Witched '. #6: Leo proposes to Piper in the bathroom in 'The Honeymoon's Over'. #7: Christopher & Brooke are able to be together in 'Magic Hour'. #8: The sisters reveal their Halloween costumes in 'All Halliwell's Eve'. #9: Prue having to take Cole's hand in 'The Good, the Bad and the Cursed': "This part sucks." #10: Prue apologizes to an unconscious Piper before flinging a knife into her chest in 'Coyote Piper'.
|
|
|
Post by Jean on Jul 3, 2020 1:23:51 GMT -5
Wow! Such great picks guys.
Here are mine: (A mix of the majority here)
#1: Phoebe flying across the moon as her sisters watch in 'All Halliwell's Eve". #2: Patty hugs her daughters in 'Just Harried'. #3: The sisters sitting on the couch when Prue asked Piper to move into her room in"Pre-Witched '. #4: Phoebe building a sand castle at the beach with Prue in 'Death Takes a Halliwell'. #5: Piper dies in the hospital with Prue by her side in 'All Hell Breaks Loose' (gets me every time as the most emotional and well-acted death scene on Charmed) #6: Grams takes the iconic picture of Prue, Piper and Phoebe in 'Pre-Witched'. #7: Leo proposes to Piper in the bathroom in 'The Honeymoon's Over'. #8: Prue apologizes to an unconscious Piper before flinging a knife into her chest in 'Coyote Piper'. #9: Prue having to take Cole's hand in 'The Good, the Bad and the Cursed': "This part sucks." #10: Piper and Prue are left for dead, and Shax leaves the manor and the glass smashes on the door in 'All Hell Breaks Loose'
|
|
Esmeralda
Charmed
S2 "What If...?" Fan Fic Winner
Twenty Years Gone....But Never Forgotten.
Posts: 21,903
|
Post by Esmeralda on Jul 3, 2020 6:35:56 GMT -5
Wow! Such great picks guys. Here are mine: (A mix of the majority here) #1: Phoebe flying across the moon as her sisters watch in 'All Halliwell's Eve". #2: Patty hugs her daughters in 'Just Harried'. #3: The sisters sitting on the couch when Prue asked Piper to move into her room in"Pre-Witched '. #4: Phoebe building a sand castle at the beach with Prue in 'Death Takes a Halliwell'. #5: Piper dies in the hospital with Prue by her side in 'All Hell Breaks Loose' (gets me every time as the most emotional and well-acted death scene on Charmed) #6: Grams takes the iconic picture of Prue, Piper and Phoebe in 'Pre-Witched'. #7: Leo proposes to Piper in the bathroom in 'The Honeymoon's Over'. #8: Prue apologizes to an unconscious Piper before flinging a knife into her chest in 'Coyote Piper'. #9: Prue having to take Cole's hand in 'The Good, the Bad and the Cursed': "This part sucks." #10: Piper and Prue are left for dead, and Shax leaves the manor and the glass smashes on the door in 'All Hell Breaks Loose' Nice list, Jean! I'm a bit surprised that you didn't include the one that inspired your avatar - it would be in my Top 15 for sure.
|
|
|
Post by Jean on Jul 3, 2020 7:21:04 GMT -5
Wow! Such great picks guys. Here are mine: (A mix of the majority here) #1: Phoebe flying across the moon as her sisters watch in 'All Halliwell's Eve". #2: Patty hugs her daughters in 'Just Harried'. #3: The sisters sitting on the couch when Prue asked Piper to move into her room in"Pre-Witched '. #4: Phoebe building a sand castle at the beach with Prue in 'Death Takes a Halliwell'. #5: Piper dies in the hospital with Prue by her side in 'All Hell Breaks Loose' (gets me every time as the most emotional and well-acted death scene on Charmed) #6: Grams takes the iconic picture of Prue, Piper and Phoebe in 'Pre-Witched'. #7: Leo proposes to Piper in the bathroom in 'The Honeymoon's Over'. #8: Prue apologizes to an unconscious Piper before flinging a knife into her chest in 'Coyote Piper'. #9: Prue having to take Cole's hand in 'The Good, the Bad and the Cursed': "This part sucks." #10: Piper and Prue are left for dead, and Shax leaves the manor and the glass smashes on the door in 'All Hell Breaks Loose' Nice list, Jean! I'm a bit surprised that you didn't include the one that inspired your avatar - it would be in my Top 15 for sure. Thanks Es.
It will for sure be in my Top 15 for the series. But this thread is for our favorites in S3 and my avatar is from S2, so that will make the S2 cut for sure.
Still making my mind up for my overall top 10 in the general board.
|
|
Esmeralda
Charmed
S2 "What If...?" Fan Fic Winner
Twenty Years Gone....But Never Forgotten.
Posts: 21,903
|
Post by Esmeralda on Jul 3, 2020 14:25:04 GMT -5
Nice list, Jean! I'm a bit surprised that you didn't include the one that inspired your avatar - it would be in my Top 15 for sure. Thanks Es. It will for sure be in my Top 15 for the series. But this thread is for our favorites in S3 and my avatar is from S2, so that will make the S2 cut for sure.
Still making my mind up for my overall top 10 in the general board.
OOOPS!!! Oh, definitely my bad!!! Sorry, Jean - I forgot that this was just for Season 3. I thought it was the thread for the entire series.
|
|
Granny Charmed
Whitelighter
S1 "What If...?" Fan Fic Winner
Posts: 3,225
|
Post by Granny Charmed on Jul 4, 2020 2:30:31 GMT -5
Here's mine dears. #1: Phoebe flying across the moon as her sisters watch in 'All Halliwell's Eve". #2: Phoebe building a sandcastle at the beach with Prue in 'Death Takes a Halliwell'. #3: Patty hugs her daughters in 'Just Harried'. #4: Grams takes the iconic picture of Prue, Piper and Phoebe in 'Pre-Witched'. #5: The sisters sitting on the couch when Prue asked Piper to move into her room in"Pre-Witched '. #6: Grams and Piper in the kitchen in 'Pre-Witched' #7: Christopher & Brooke are able to be together in 'Magic Hour'. #8: Who is that masked man in 'All Halliwell's Eve'. #9: Prue having to take Cole's hand in 'The Good, the Bad and the Cursed': "This part sucks." #10: Prue apologizes to an unconscious Piper before flinging a knife into her chest in 'Coyote Piper'.
|
|
codebox
Familiar
Hey I'm a Charmed Veteran have been for a long time. Hope to share some insight and opinions.
Posts: 287
|
Post by codebox on Jul 5, 2020 0:06:35 GMT -5
This would be mine. -The courtroom fight scene in the first episode because the sisters worked together and were all on an equal footing. Not to mention how action involved it was. No-one was powerful than the other. -Phoebe flying over the moon on a broomstick in 'All Halliwell's Eve'it was a fun scene where we got to see Phoebe's more playful nature. It also helps its the very last time we see Phoebe as Phoebe before she becomes PhoeMe. -Prue apologizing to Piper at the end of 'Coyote Piper' about what she's about to do. -Prue, Piper, and Phoebe talking at the end of 'Pre-Witched'. -Grams taking the iconic picture of the sisters in the same episode -Patty talking to her daughters in 'Just Harried' before the wedding ceremony. -Prue and Piper's acting when the younger sister dies in hospital after being shot which made me cry the first time because of the feels. -The end scene from 'All Hell Breaks Loose' where Prue and Piper are left for dead because of the gravity of the situation and the fact Shax actually killed a Charmed One then. -Prue and Victor finally getting along at the end of the Ice Cream Man episode. -Piper's realization that her wanting Leo almost got Kate killed. To me this scene was very underrated and doesn't get noted much. I like it because its similar to the Dr Williamson situation, she felt bad for what her actions almost did to an innocent and her self awareness was great! www.youtube.com/watch?v=KmxyicDwgWA-Piper's message to Kate in the scene before her self awareness of her own selfishness. www.youtube.com/watch?v=mCUexAN5P48&t=1s-Grams and Piper in the kitchen in Pre-Witched. -Prue trying to help Piper through her power struggle in Exit Strategy by saying "The control will come" -The training scene against fake Belthazor in Power Outage -Prue and Piper making a potion in a kitchen in Sleuthing with the Enemy
|
|
Esmeralda
Charmed
S2 "What If...?" Fan Fic Winner
Twenty Years Gone....But Never Forgotten.
Posts: 21,903
|
Post by Esmeralda on Jul 5, 2020 12:42:57 GMT -5
This would be mine. -The courtroom fight scene in the first episode because the sisters worked together and were all on an equal footing. Not to mention how action involved it was. No-one was powerful than the other. -Phoebe flying over the moon on a broomstick in 'All Halliwell's Eve'it was a fun scene where we got to see Phoebe's more playful nature. It also helps its the very last time we see Phoebe as Phoebe before she becomes PhoeMe. -Prue apologizing to Piper at the end of 'Coyote Piper' about what she's about to do. -Prue, Piper, and Phoebe talking at the end of 'Pre-Witched'. -Grams taking the iconic picture of the sisters in the same episode -Patty talking to her daughters in 'Just Harried' before the wedding ceremony. -Prue and Piper's acting when the younger sister dies in hospital after being shot which made me cry the first time because of the feels. -The end scene from 'All Hell Breaks Loose' where Prue and Piper are left for dead because of the gravity of the situation and the fact Shax actually killed a Charmed One then. -Prue and Victor finally getting along at the end of the Ice Cream Man episode. -Piper's realization that her wanting Leo almost got Kate killed. To me this scene was very underrated and doesn't get noted much. I like it because its similar to the Dr Williamson situation, she felt bad for what her actions almost did to an innocent and her self awareness was great! www.youtube.com/watch?v=KmxyicDwgWA-Piper's message to Kate in the scene before her self awareness of her own selfishness. www.youtube.com/watch?v=mCUexAN5P48&t=1s-Grams and Piper in the kitchen in Pre-Witched. -Prue trying to help Piper through her power struggle in Exit Strategy by saying "The control will come" -The training scene against fake Belthazor in Power Outage -Prue and Piper making a potion in a kitchen in Sleuthing with the Enemy What a fantastic listing, Codebox! I love it! I'd love to see you do the same thing for S1 and S2. My question - is this the way you'd rank them? Which is your favorite moment from Season Three? I've decided against posting my own list. It's been a while since I've re-watched S3. I want to wait until Team Charmed Cafe re-watches S3 starting this fall and decide then.
|
|
|
Post by prudencehalliwell on Jul 5, 2020 17:25:12 GMT -5
This would be mine. -The courtroom fight scene in the first episode because the sisters worked together and were all on an equal footing. Not to mention how action involved it was. No-one was powerful than the other. -Phoebe flying over the moon on a broomstick in 'All Halliwell's Eve'it was a fun scene where we got to see Phoebe's more playful nature. It also helps its the very last time we see Phoebe as Phoebe before she becomes PhoeMe. -Prue apologizing to Piper at the end of 'Coyote Piper' about what she's about to do. -Prue, Piper, and Phoebe talking at the end of 'Pre-Witched'. -Grams taking the iconic picture of the sisters in the same episode -Patty talking to her daughters in 'Just Harried' before the wedding ceremony. -Prue and Piper's acting when the younger sister dies in hospital after being shot which made me cry the first time because of the feels. -The end scene from 'All Hell Breaks Loose' where Prue and Piper are left for dead because of the gravity of the situation and the fact Shax actually killed a Charmed One then. -Prue and Victor finally getting along at the end of the Ice Cream Man episode. -Piper's realization that her wanting Leo almost got Kate killed. To me this scene was very underrated and doesn't get noted much. I like it because its similar to the Dr Williamson situation, she felt bad for what her actions almost did to an innocent and her self awareness was great! www.youtube.com/watch?v=KmxyicDwgWA-Piper's message to Kate in the scene before her self awareness of her own selfishness. www.youtube.com/watch?v=mCUexAN5P48&t=1s-Grams and Piper in the kitchen in Pre-Witched. -Prue trying to help Piper through her power struggle in Exit Strategy by saying "The control will come" -The training scene against fake Belthazor in Power Outage -Prue and Piper making a potion in a kitchen in Sleuthing with the Enemy What a fantastic listing, Codebox! I love it! I'd love to see you do the same thing for S1 and S2. My question - is this the way you'd rank them? Which is your favorite moment from Season Three? I've decided against posting my own list. It's been a while since I've re-watched S3. I want to wait until Team Charmed Cafe re-watches S3 starting this fall and decide then. Ditto to everything here too. Codebox these are 15 moments, so I hope when you can, you'll rank these or at least list your top 10, followed by the rest as honorable mentions. I'll have to wait until we re-watch S3, then I'll know what I'll go with.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jul 7, 2020 11:29:39 GMT -5
In no particular order, and not exactly 10 because I'm lazy.
- All Hell's Breaks Loose when Prue just looses it and stars using her powers against the reporters outside the house to save Piper. I think this episode is where Charmed peaked tbh. I just have a lot of love for this episode. I could literally pick 10 scenes in just this episode alone.
- Phoebe flying her broom & when the sisters realize the baby is Melinda
- Astral Prue crashing Piper and Leo's wedding LMAO so Prue. Even re-watching I'm still shook.
- Cole killing the Triad. I felt that.
- Piper & Leo's wedding. Peak Piper/Leo. Cute. Also love everyone is there, Grams, Patty etc.
- Piper and Phoebe turning evil in Bride and Gloom. I think Holly and Alyssa were having a lot of fun in this episode. Also Prue's dark wedding dress <3
- Prue conquering the empath power and killing Vincenes with it.
- The sisters turning against each other in Power Outage. Shook.
May add more later.
|
|
|
Post by Elle Em on Jul 8, 2020 7:21:00 GMT -5
In no particular order:
-Prue, Piper, and Phoebe on the couch at the end of Pre-Witched. I love this scene already, but even more so after someone here pointed out what a nice series ending this scene could be.
-The sisters and Patty talking when she first appears to them before Piper's wedding. This is just without a doubt one of the most beautiful scenes of the entire show. It was well before Patty was around all the time, and the sisters were all looking so pretty.
-Phoebe flying across the moon on the broom. It's fun that the entire idea of witches as silly beings was created or at least helped along by Phoebe herself who would go on to be so annoyed with the idea. And it's just pure fun without being too silly. It's good this scene exists in a season that is mostly dark and serious so that it isn't overdone.
-Leo announcing at P3 that the elders are going to let him and Piper get married. It's great to see the two of them so happy, and Prue and Phoebe are so happy for them as well.
-The scenes with Prue/Piper and Phoebe/Leo when everyone slowly starts to realize who Cole really is. I love the dynamics here between the characters. Prue and Piper are such a great team, and Phoebe and Leo have such great chemistry. I love how Phoebe wants Leo to help her and has to keep the reason why a secret from her sisters, and also Leo's clear conflict over wanting to help Phoebe but knowing something is wrong and wanting to get back to her sisters.
-Phoebe telling Leo that she never actually killed Cole. Again, this is because of their chemistry together, and how close they are that Phoebe would tell him such a secret. The two of them having tension between them is also interesting as they mostly get along.
-Any scene with Natalie training the sisters and them being obnoxious and sarcastic to her. I so wish Natalie had stayed. I liked watching her and the sisters not get along, but still all be on the same team.
-The scene in Sight Unseen when Prue and Phoebe argue about Cole. There's such great tension here, and while we know that Prue is right, it's interesting to see her being the reckless one, the one who seems to be taking things too far.
-Patty and Victor talking to an upset Piper at P3. It just seems like such a normal moment between parents and their daughter that you'd never know Victor had only recently come back into their lives and that Patty had died a long time ago.
-Prue, Piper, Phoebe, and Leo eating breakfast together when Piper announces they're moving out. It's a nice family scene that I wish we could have seen more of.
|
|
Granny Charmed
Whitelighter
S1 "What If...?" Fan Fic Winner
Posts: 3,225
|
Post by Granny Charmed on Jul 8, 2020 8:46:54 GMT -5
In no particular order: -Prue, Piper, and Phoebe on the couch at the end of Pre-Witched. I love this scene already, but even more so after someone here pointed out what a nice series ending this scene could be. -The sisters and Patty talking when she first appears to them before Piper's wedding. This is just without a doubt one of the most beautiful scenes of the entire show. It was well before Patty was around all the time, and the sisters were all looking so pretty. -Phoebe flying across the moon on the broom. It's fun that the entire idea of witches as silly beings was created or at least helped along by Phoebe herself who would go on to be so annoyed with the idea. And it's just pure fun without being too silly. It's good this scene exists in a season that is mostly dark and serious so that it isn't overdone. -Leo announcing at P3 that the elders are going to let him and Piper get married. It's great to see the two of them so happy, and Prue and Phoebe are so happy for them as well. -The scenes with Prue/Piper and Phoebe/Leo when everyone slowly starts to realize who Cole really is. I love the dynamics here between the characters. Prue and Piper are such a great team, and Phoebe and Leo have such great chemistry. I love how Phoebe wants Leo to help her and has to keep the reason why a secret from her sisters, and also Leo's clear conflict over wanting to help Phoebe but knowing something is wrong and wanting to get back to her sisters. -Phoebe telling Leo that she never actually killed Cole. Again, this is because of their chemistry together, and how close they are that Phoebe would tell him such a secret. The two of them having tension between them is also interesting as they mostly get along. -Any scene with Natalie training the sisters and them being obnoxious and sarcastic to her. I so wish Natalie had stayed. I liked watching her and the sisters not get along, but still all be on the same team. -The scene in Sight Unseen when Prue and Phoebe argue about Cole. There's such great tension here, and while we know that Prue is right, it's interesting to see her being the reckless one, the one who seems to be taking things too far. -Patty and Victor talking to an upset Piper at P3. It just seems like such a normal moment between parents and their daughter that you'd never know Victor had only recently come back into their lives and that Patty had died a long time ago. -Prue, Piper, Phoebe, and Leo eating breakfast together when Piper announces they're moving out. It's a nice family scene that I wish we could have seen more of. I love all your moments dear. I especially love all of your top 3. And I also really like the two ones you picked from 'Just Harried'. Oh, the one with Patty and her daughters really gets to me each time. Phoebe and Leo had such an amazing brother/sister relationship didn't they. I feel like outside of of course Piper, Leo really only had a real a connection with Phoebe. I really don't think Leo/Prue or Leo/Paige had the sort of connection and brother/sister like relationship that Phoebe/Leo had. In fact, I can barely remember many of their scenes together when they are alone, outside of the one in Coyote Piper when Prue tells Leo about Piper's high school life or when Prue found Leo in the shower.
|
|
|
Post by Elle Em on Jul 8, 2020 9:58:00 GMT -5
Phoebe and Leo had such an amazing brother/sister relationship didn't they. I feel like outside of of course Piper, Leo really only had a real a connection with Phoebe. I really don't think Leo/Prue or Leo/Paige had the sort of connection and brother/sister like relationship that Phoebe/Leo had. In fact, I can barely remember many of their scenes together when they are alone, outside of the one in Coyote Piper when Prue tells Leo about Piper's high school life or when Prue found Leo in the shower. I agree. Prue and Cole almost seemed closer than Prue and Leo. There was no real chemistry of any kind between Prue and Leo, while Prue and Cole together was always interesting. I can't see them as a couple, but just as a team, be that a brother-sister team or two people who seemed to dislike each other but still had to work together. And with Paige and Leo, they seemed close at the beginning of the show, but that quickly faded as Paige grew more independent and moved out several times, and Piper and Leo became more focused on their own family. Phoebe and Leo were the longest-lasting non-sister sibling relationship of the entire show. They also lived together for a long time, starting back in season 2. They made a really nice team together.
|
|
Granny Charmed
Whitelighter
S1 "What If...?" Fan Fic Winner
Posts: 3,225
|
Post by Granny Charmed on Jul 15, 2020 22:23:20 GMT -5
Phoebe and Leo had such an amazing brother/sister relationship didn't they. I feel like outside of of course Piper, Leo really only had a real a connection with Phoebe. I really don't think Leo/Prue or Leo/Paige had the sort of connection and brother/sister like relationship that Phoebe/Leo had. In fact, I can barely remember many of their scenes together when they are alone, outside of the one in Coyote Piper when Prue tells Leo about Piper's high school life or when Prue found Leo in the shower. I agree. Prue and Cole almost seemed closer than Prue and Leo. There was no real chemistry of any kind between Prue and Leo, while Prue and Cole together was always interesting. I can't see them as a couple, but just as a team, be that a brother-sister team or two people who seemed to dislike each other but still had to work together. And with Paige and Leo, they seemed close at the beginning of the show, but that quickly faded as Paige grew more independent and moved out several times, and Piper and Leo became more focused on their own family. Phoebe and Leo were the longest-lasting non-sister sibling relationship of the entire show. They also lived together for a long time, starting back in season 2. They made a really nice team together. Couldn't agree more with this dear. It's too bad Paige and Leo didn't get more as the show progressed, as I really did like their scenes together. You bring up a great point dear, they were the longest-lasting non-sister sibling relationship. And it's too bad, because Leo was her strongest relationship outside of her sisters, even over any of her love interests. When we did our re-watch of S1, I thought Phoebe and Andy had a great sibling relationship but I've seen that outside of Prue/Andy, Piper and Andy had the closest and best sibling relationship than Phoebe/Andy. Especially when Andy was worried about Piper in 'The Wendigo', or when Piper and Andy shared scenes in 'Dead Man Dating'.
|
|
|
Post by Elle Em on Jul 16, 2020 8:26:01 GMT -5
It's too bad Paige and Leo didn't get more as the show progressed, as I really did like their scenes together. You bring up a great point dear, they were the longest-lasting non-sister sibling relationship. And it's too bad, because Leo was her strongest relationship outside of her sisters, even over any of her love interests. When we did our re-watch of S1, I thought Phoebe and Andy had a great sibling relationship but I've seen that outside of Prue/Andy, Piper and Andy had the closest and best sibling relationship than Phoebe/Andy. Especially when Andy was worried about Piper in 'The Wendigo', or when Piper and Andy shared scenes in 'Dead Man Dating'. Since this show is so based around family and especially sisterhood, I've always thought it was so important for each sister's love interest to get along well with the rest of the family. I agree about Andy. He and Phoebe had a great older brother/younger sister relationship, and Piper and Andy seemed to get along great and have a lot of potential for being good friends. Leo had a good amount of scenes with the other sisters, especially Phoebe. I would have liked, if Cole stuck around, to have more scenes of him bonding with Phoebe's sisters. He and Prue made an impressive team, and it would have been fun to see more of those types of bonds formed between him and the other sisters as well.
|
|
pheebs
Whitelighter
Posts: 3,802
|
Post by pheebs on Apr 15, 2021 6:42:31 GMT -5
Having finished S3 in our re-watch last month. Going to post all my three moments from each episode here. Enjoy!
3x01: The Honeymoon's Over 1. Leo talking to himself in the mirror. 2. Piper says yes to marriage. 3. Phoebe's new hair.
3x02: Magic Hour 1. Can only save one, and Piper chooses Brooke. 2. Phoebe and Prue acting sisterly making the eclipse glasses. 3. Christopher as an owl saves Brooke but gets hit by an arrow.
3x03: Once Upon a Time 1. Piper's speech to Kate. 2. Piper is willing to give up Leo, if it means she can save someone like Kate. 3. Piper: You need a diaper change? / Phoebe: Very funny. Look, we need you to come home right away by midnight or else... / Piper: The tooth fairy's gonna come and harass us all for not flossing?
3x04: All Halliwell's Eve 1. Phoebe flies over the witch hunters and cackles. (my ALL TIME FAVORITE moment on the series) 2. What? No funny hat? 3. I always get the messy jobs.
3x05: Sight Unseen 1. No, if she keeps this up we're gonna have to do a demon intervention. 2. It's okay. (Phoebe pokes her head back in the room.) I can't do it anyway. Phoebe: I am so sorry to hear that. 3. I hope you enjoyed the show.
3x06: Primrose Empath 1. I hate when she plays astral games. Marco. 2. Will you guys please stop being so negative? We didn't say anything. Yeah, but I can feel all of your- 3. Father Thomas tries to help Prue channel her Empathy powers.
3x07: Power Outage 1. Piper's witty remark about light meat or dark meat. 2. Cole trying to practice breaking up with Phoebe. 3. I don't think I'm the one who's been taken for granted around here. You know, who needs Oprah when we can do it ourselves?
3x08: Sleuthing with the Enemy 1. I don't know, Krell. Don't you think he would've picked a better human? Oh, no offence, honey. Oh, none taken. 2. You know, it's too bad that he's such a bad guy ‘cause he could really come in handy. Don't push it. 3. Such a slacker. Give me a second, lady. All right, ready?
3x09: Coyote Ugly 1. You want me to beat them up? ‘Cause I-I-'II beat them up one-by-one. 2. Hey! Bitch! Move the trays yourself 3. What I mean is I'm this super powerful witch who's engaged to a Whitelighter saving the world from evil on a daily freaking basis, and all these people are going to see is the same pitiful loser who still lives at home with her sisters and her unemployed boyfriend.
3x11: Blinded by the Whitelighter 1. Because one bad word from General Goody-Two-Shoes, and I'm not getting married. 2. 'Our challenge is to fight Eames. Our primary goal is...' 'To win!' 'No.' 'No'. 3. Okay, but then I have nothing to wear.
3x10: We All Scream for Ice Cream 1. Victor saves Prue the third time. 2. Well, don't you have orb-waiting? 3. So, he's a demonic dog catcher, and he uses ice cream as bait? Great news for the lactose intolerant demons.
3x12: Wrestling with Demons 1. Okay, oh god, oh god, come on, do something! Get angry! Focus! Get motivated! Prue, listen to me. She lied to you big time. Big time lied to you. Come on, get angry! Come on, or else we're in big deep. Phoebe, she thinks you're a weakling, like, big time sucker for love. Oh god! 2. You know, if I could freeze the two of you, I would, often. 3. My lost and found spell's a little too enthusiastic.
3x13: Bride and Gloom 1. Now there's a freezing power with kick. 2. Phoebe figures out which Prue is the real one, because she didn't say "I love you too". 3. Phoebe figures out how they can find Prue.
3x14: The Good, the Bad and the Cursed 1. Leo orbs out, leaving Victor in an unpleasant shock. 2. Prue: Hi. What am I? A potted plant? 3. Bartender: What'll it be? Prue: Hi. Moonshine. Bartender: A what? Cole: She means whiskey.
3x15: Just Harried 1. Phoebe: What did you see next? Patty: I held you. (They all hug.) 2. Piper and Leo kiss as everyone watches. 3. Piper: I'm not dreaming am I? Patty: No, sweetie, you're not.
3x16: Death Takes A Halliwell 1. I hereby proclaim this power of sand Kingdom Phoebeville! Yay! 2. Phoebe: Say no more. (yelling) Princess Prue has spoken! By the orders of the Queen, that's me… Prue: Ooh, I got that part. Phoebe: Phoebeville, and all of its glory will be abandoned for greater pastures and two lattes. Prue: Oh, all hail the Queen. Phoebe: Yay, I love to be hailed. 3. The lamp.
3x17: Pre-Witched 1. Sisters cuddling on the couch ending. 2. What, are we like in the Warlocks Guide of San Francisco? 3. Grams takes the iconic photo.
3x18: Sin Francisco 1. Oh, Phoebe, you do know that charming the pants off someone is just a figure of speech, don't you? 2. More like hold down the couch. 3. Prue: Hey, who sent the flowers? / Piper: I did, for myself.
3x19: The Demon Who Came in from the Cold 1. Eww, you kept that this long? That's disgusting! 2. I bet you wouldn't mind if we were voting with you. 3. Yeah, yeah, yeah, we're gonna go see the thrillers. As if we don't have enough scary bad guys in our real life.
3x20: Exit Strategy 1. The sisters blessing a soul. 2. Learning how to heal wounds with potions and herbs. 3. Leo: Well, I don't have news but I do have a passport. (He shows it to them. Piper gasps. Prue holds Piper's hands down.)
3x21: Look Who's Barking 1. Must have been ‘ruff'. No pun intended. 2. Phoebe: No, you can't. You have a club to run and a husband who can't stand to live without you. Prue: That's right, and-and two sisters who need you to cook for them and fight evil with them. Phoebe: Okay, do you want her to come up or do you want her to stay down there? Prue: Oh. 3. Wow, I'd forget about my love life if I were you, lately mine's been rated PG for pretty grim.
3x22: All Hell Breaks Loose 1. Prue: Piper, don't you dare die on me. / Piper: Prue, I'm cold. I-I-I can't feel my legs. / Doctor #1: Pulse is dropping. / Piper: Don't go. I love you. (The line on the heart monitor flattens out and Piper goes into full arrest.) 2. Shax: The end. (He throws an aerokinetic blast at Dr. Griffiths and he crashes through a window. Shax looks around. He looks at Prue and Piper unconscious on the floor. Pleased with what he's done, Shax turns back into the wind and flies out the front door. The glass on the door smashes as it slams shut.) Shax turns into the wind and flies out the front door. The glass on the manor door smashes as it slams shut. 3. Prue: Okay, Susie Johnson from tenth grade? They're interviewing her? / Piper: I always wondered why they broke up. (Prue lightly hits Piper's arm.) Prue: Not funny, not funny.
|
|