Prue: The Beloved Older Sister

[xoFeliciaFinleyxo]

I totally agree. I miss Prue very much. She was the best big sister to both Phoebe and Piper. They should've brought her back for the very last episode 'Forever Charmed' They brought back basically all the other family member and they didn't bring her back. there's something wrong with this picture.

[xoFeliciaFinleyxo]

We really should've seen Prue in some more episode but it didn't really happen.

[Cara Halliwell]

here is a vid i made while we r on the subject. comments would be appreciated.

www.youtube.com/watch?v=iNG3kzbUxlU

[micki98]

Great Video!

Thanks so much for sharing, Cara! ;D

[foreverprue]

I never asked for the responsibility of taking care of my sisters but by me being the oldest, i had to step up to the plate. And im very glad i did, i love my sisters with all my heart and i protected them with my very life. I fought off evil and bad boyfriends. LOL. im the oldest its my job. ( not actually shannon doherty, just her number one prue halliwell fan)

[Cara Halliwell]

thanks, micki! yeah i'm also the oldest in my family. i have a younger brother, and you do have to be the responsible one sometimes. it's actually more like that with my friends, but i understand what the oldest of the family has to go through.

[xoFeliciaFinleyxo]

I enjoyed it. It was really good. I cried becasue seeing Prue in videos just makes me so sad becasue she died. But other than that I love it!!!

[Cara Halliwell]

thanks!

i hope i can put up another vid about prue very sooon!

[xoFeliciaFinleyxo]

me too!

[Esmeralda]

Guys, would you mind making your signatures a bit thinner?

They break the margin of every thread where you post and make it hard to read the threads--very irritating.

Thanks much.

[Cara Halliwell]

uh, look who's talking. you have two HUGE banners, Es.

[pipercharmedphreak]

As completely off topic to the thread as this is, Es's banners fit under the banner size requirements.

[crazy4charmed]

Jul 1, 2008 13:25:49 GMT -5 xoFeliciaFinleyxo said:

I totally agree. I miss Prue very much. She was the best big sister to both Phoebe and Piper. They should've brought her back for the very last episode 'Forever Charmed' They brought back basically all the other family member and they didn't bring her back. there's something wrong with this picture.

;D ;D :)HEY I'M RYAN,14, I AGREE PRUE GAVE CHARMED THAT EXTRA KICK DIDN'T SHE, WEN THEY TOOK HER OFF I CRIED LIKE HELL , AND I AGREE THAT THEY SHOULDVE BROUGHT HER BACK 4 'FOREVER CHARMED!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Esmeralda]

First, apologies for going off-topic before and now again, but I have to reply.

Aug 6, 2008 11:17:41 GMT -5 Cara Halliwell said:

uh, look who's talking. you have two HUGE banners, Es.

Both of mine are small compared to both of yours and they fit in the site's requirements for signatures (which yours don't--the requirements are 500 long x 200 high, mine are 500 x 165, well within the limits, while yours are 846 x 195--MUCH HUGER than mine and especially much wider than mine.) and they don't break the margins (like yours do--even if you have a wide-screen monitor, not all members do).

I'm considerate of my fellow posters. Please be the same.

[Cara Halliwell]

I'm considerate of my fellow posters. Please be the same.

I AM considerate of others. this thread is not hard to read at all. and since you are the only one who has ever complained about my banners, i think they are perfectly resonable. and since you have two banners, your sig is filled with empty space that it taking up room on this thread.

[Primrose_Empath]

*blows whistle* Time out here! I'd like to throw in my two cents, if I may -- and then we really should get this thread back on topic where it belongs.

Both of mine are small compared to both of yours and they fit in the site's requirements for signatures (which yours don't--the requirements are 500 long x 200 high, mine are 500 x 165, well within the limits, while yours are 846 x 195--MUCH HUGER than mine and especially much wider than mine.) and they don't break the margins (like yours do--even if you have a wide-screen monitor, not all members do).

I'm considerate of my fellow posters. Please be the same.

*smiles* That you are. Thank you for accepting my advice and taking out the second banner, since technically the two of them together did break the size requirement for banner height.

I AM considerate of others. this thread is not hard to read at all. and since you are the only one who has ever complained about my banners, i think they are perfectly resonable. and since you have two banners, your sig is filled with empty space that it taking up room on this thread.

I beg to differ on two counts:

1) The broken margin makes this thread extremely hard to read -- and I'm sure I'm not the only one who feels this way.

2) While you feel that the size of your banners is perfectly reasonable, the fact remains that they are not fitting the size requirement -- especially in banner length. The length requirement is 500; the length of yours is 849. It makes a huge difference, trust me.

I know for a fact that Es' banner (which measures 500 x 165) more than fits the requirements.

How do I know that, you ask? Simple. Because I made the banner for her and made sure that it fit within the size requirements as set forth by the rules of this site.

---

Now back on topic...

Ryan, I couldn't agree with you more. Prue's character gave this show that extra "something" that was most definitely missed once she was gone. It just didn't feel like the same show to me. I also wished that we could have had the opportunity to see her again in the finale -- but since that didn't happen -- well, that's what fan fics are for!

[xoFeliciaFinleyxo]

Yeah I know right lol. (the fan fic thing)

[carly]

I have to agree Pru was fantastic I wonder what it would have been like if she had stayed.But saying that I think paige is a great charater to.

[Esmeralda]

Agree totally. Since the only way we could have Paige was to lose one of the originals, I would've prefered Phoebe dying so that Piper could remain the middle sister and we'd still have Paige. And then I'd remember Phoebe as Phoebs, not as Freebie/PhoeMe. And Piper would remain our snarky heart of the family, not Miss Whinealot.

Best of all, the only way that would've happened is if BOTH Kern and Alyssa had left! Maybe then we'd still have three sisters who happen to be witches rather than three demon hunters, I mean witches, who happen to live in the same Manor.

[CharmedFaith]

I think if the writers were smart enough, they would have brought in Paige even if none of them dieing. It would shake the sisters up along with putting their destiny in serious question.