Favorite Prue Episode

[Esmeralda]

Of all the episodes in the first three seasons, in which one did you like Prue best?

For me, it's "Murphy's Luck" hands down. "Deja vu All Over Again (Prue and Andy... *sigh*), "Morality Bites", "The Witch is Back", "P3 H2O", "Show Me a Sign" (Prue and Bane--*double sigh*!) "Primrose Empath" and "All Hell Breaks Loose" are all close seconds.

[Primrose_Empath]

Ohh. Now that's an interesting question you've posed there, Es.

Even though you can probably guess my absolute favorite via my screen name, I've still got top eps from each season too.

Here's my list, broken down by season:

Season 1

• Dream Sorcerer
  
  
• The Truth Is Out There...And It Hurts
  
  
• Which Prue Is It, Anyway?
  
  
• Blind Sided
  
  
• The Power Of Two
  
  
• Deja Vu All Over Again

Season 2

• Witch Trial (Her breakdown gets me every time.)
  
  
• P3 H₂O
  
  
• Ms. Hellfire (Ahh, hot Bane)
  
  
• Give Me Sign (And hot Bane again )
  
  
• Murphy's Luck (Just an all-around fantastic ep.)

Season 3

• Primrose Empath (My absolute favorite of all. Big surprise there, hmm?)
  
  
• We All Scream For Ice Cream (Even though a lot of people don't like this ep, I enjoy it for the Prue / Victor interactions, if nothing else)
  
  
• The Good, The Bad, And The Cursed (For the Prue / Cole banter -- and Shannen's directing.)
  
  
• Death Takes A Halliwell (This one actually originally aired a couple of days after my birthday, so I kind of have a special "connection" of sorts to it. And it's a powerful ep, even if I don't like how snarky Death is to her.)
  
  
• Sin Francisco (Prideful Prue is a total trip.)
  
  
• AHBL (Hands-down probably one of the best episodes ever, even if I don't like how it ends and can't bring myself to watch it on TNT or DVD since it's orginal airing.)

[Piper Halliwell]

I think Murphys Luck would have to be my favourite episode. There were allot of great moments for Prue in that episode but it's a hard choice to make. She was great in most episodes.

[StoryGirl83]

Favorite Prue episode. Hmm. Keep in mind this is for the Prue parts of the story, and not for the main plotline, 'cause one of them is "Blinded By the Whitelighter" (not the top and not for the story line, but it's up there in Prue eps.)

Top. Well, I did like her in "Miss Hellfire" and "The Good, the Bad, and the Cursed". Those were both excellent. Little Prue was adorable in "That's Seventies Episode" (as was little Andy). I liked "Which Prue is It Anyway".

I just feel like I'm going to get hit for not mentioning "Primrose Empath" and it was an amazing Prue ep. And yes, "Murphey's Luck," amazing.

Lots of amazing episodes. Prue in general, just amazing.

[Primrose_Empath]

Don't worry about it, Story Girl. I definitely wouldn't hit ya for not mentioning my namesake ep. After all, I'm not that vindictive!

Good mention on BBTW, though. It totally slipped my mind since the main plotline is definitely not one of my favorites. But for pure Prue-snarkiness, it's awesome.

[xoFeliciaFinleyxo]

Ok, this is very interesting. Let's take a look shall we.

Season 1
-Dream Sorcerer
-The Truth Is Out There And It Hurts
-Which Prue Is It Anyway
-Deja Vu All Over Again

Season 2
-Witch Trail
-The Painted World
-She's A Man Baby A Man
-Ms Hellfire
-Give Me Sign
-Murphy's Luck
-Be careful What You Witch For

Season3 just has way too many for me I think! So i'd say about all most all of them.

[katie92]

I love all episodes with Prue! But here is my list with my favorite ones.
Season 1:
- Dream Sorcerer
- The truth is out there...and it hurts
- From fear to eternity
- Which Prue is it, anyway?
- That 70´s episode
- The power of two
- Deja vu all over again

Season 2:
- Wich Trial
- Morality bites
- She´s a man, baby, a man
- P3 H2O
- Ms. Hellfire
- Murphy´s luck
- Be careful what you witch for

Season 3:
- Once upon a time
- All Halliwell´s eve
- Primrose path
- We all scream for icecream
- Blindet by the whitelighter
- Bride and gloom
- The good, the bad and the cursed
- Just harried
- Death takes a Halliwell
- Prewitched
- Sin Fransico
- All hell breaks lose

Yeah, I know, this is a lot, but these are my favourite ones.

[Esmeralda]

But which one is your FAVORITE Prue episode?? Here's what we've got so far:

Es: Murphy's Luck
Primrose: Primrose Empath
Georgia: Murphy's Luck
StoryGirl: Blinded by the Whitelighter (for Prue's parts in it)

Felicia??
Katie?? (and welcome to Prue' Fan Club, by the way!)
Anyone else?

And since some of you did it by season, here's for the other two seasons:

SEASON ONE: The Witch is Back
SEASON TWO: Murphy's Luck
SEASON THREE: Primrose Empath

[~B@MeLiSsA30@B~]

I figure I mention episodes I like by her:



Season 1:

- Dream Sorcerer
- Which Prue is it anyways
- That 70's Episode
- Deja Vu All Over Again

Season 2:

- The Painted World
- Ms Hellfire
- P3 H2O

Season 3:

- All Halliwell's Eve
- Primrose Empath
- All Hell Breaks Loose


I know I like some more episodes, but I can't recall the name of the episodes. When I find out, I'll add them. My favorite episode that I mentioned here has to be............Which Prue is it anyways!

[prueturner61]

Fave episode.The Good,The Bad,& the Cursed.Loved the chemistry between Cole & Prue