|
|
Post by jdpm1991 on Dec 5, 2015 6:14:56 GMT -5
Both were only a one season relationship (TV Wise) but who did you prefer the most?
Dan / Piper
Andy / Prue
or
Henry / Paige
|
|
Esmeralda
Charmed
S2 "What If...?"
Fan Fic Winner
Twenty Years Gone....But Never Forgotten.
Posts: 21,920 
|
Post by Esmeralda on Dec 5, 2015 10:08:36 GMT -5
Definitely Henry and Paige. I wish they were the ones who were married in the fast-forward so it wouldn't have been so rushed (I wish Phoebe had never been married- or even met Coop - at all), but I loved the fact that she was honest with him about their "secret" and that he could accept her as a witch. I could see Andy and Prue's relationship turning into something like that had he lived, but as is, I hate that both Halliwells didn't love or trust (love for Piper, trust for Prue) their guy enough to tell them the truth. I much prefer the Matthews approach.
|
|
|
|
Post by Melinda Halliwell on Dec 5, 2015 13:24:16 GMT -5
I don't know as I liked Prue and Andy and Paige and Henry the same really.
|
|
|
|
Post by adzpower on Dec 5, 2015 14:18:58 GMT -5
Paige and Henry definitely, their chesmistry felt real pretty much from the start what with her not having the same love issues that the other sisters had thanks to grams. She wanted to be honest from the beginning. We hadn't had the chance to see that in her other relationships beforehand because Richard was a witch and Brody knew she was a witch from the start. My only criticism of their relationship is that I wish they'd met before season 8 so the marriage hadn't felt as rushed.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 11, 2015 16:26:27 GMT -5
If it wasn't for the sisters hiding so much from them, all their relationships with mortals would've been just fine.
I would say Andy but I'm gonna go with Dan. He was the most normal and down to Earth.
|
|
|
|
Post by Darkhorse Christian on Dec 13, 2015 18:19:10 GMT -5
Neither Andy nor Dan could reconcile being in love with a witch. Maybe the girls constantly freezing Andy as a kid, Prue having to truth-spell him to tell him the secret, and Piper's inability to be honest enough with Dan to let him into the house until it was too late and he was turned into an old man had something to do with that.
Paige and Henry was the best handled relationship of the three. They were refreshingly honest with each other, kindred spirits, and both cared about the people they looked after. Prue and Andy falls short not because of Andy, but because of Prue. Dan was a good dude, but…no, he would not have stuck around well. Didn't seem to really fit the show to me.
|
|
|
|
Post by Melinda Halliwell on Dec 13, 2015 20:14:47 GMT -5
Well Dan was brought in as a love rival for Leo to spice up the show so once that was over they didn't need him afterwards really which always had me thinking what was the point originally.
|
|
|
|
Post by sol on Dec 14, 2015 11:21:18 GMT -5
Andy had a vision of the world that didn't include the relationship with a witch, it's a matter of choice, it's not important being more or less honest, it's better to remember that talking of the existence of the magic world can mean putting it in danger
Andy is a man with clear ideas about the life he wants, Henry, however, doesn't get in a sweat about the future: he's in love, ready to accept all of Paige, for any adventure or surprise has in store the life with her
Andy belongs to the third generation of policemen, he patterns his life after that of his family, Henry is an orphan raised in orphanage, he has no models to follow, only his instincts and his dreams to realize
I like Hemry and Paige
|
|
|
|
Post by erikamarie on Dec 18, 2015 16:39:50 GMT -5
Dan and Piper it'ld be a wrong couple:Dan seemed the classic husband who dreams of an accommodating wife with a lot of time for him: too jealous, too nosy, too looker
Andy and Prue: too friends to be a real couple. Andy, with great honesty, admitted he didn't wish a witch as wife, like Jason, like Dan, like Dex, like Victor
Henry is the exception: the revelation of the existence of magic intrigues him, thrills him, he is ready to accept all of Paige, like Leo, like Cole
Paige was lucky
|
|
Esmeralda
Charmed
S2 "What If...?"
Fan Fic Winner
Twenty Years Gone....But Never Forgotten.
Posts: 21,920
|
Post by Esmeralda on Dec 19, 2015 11:24:19 GMT -5
Dan and Piper it'ld be a wrong couple:Dan seemed the classic husband who dreams of an accommodating wife with a lot of time for him: too jealous, too nosy, too looker Andy and Prue: too friends to be a real couple. Andy, with great honesty, admitted he didn't wish a witch as wife, like Jason, like Dan, like Dex, like Victor Henry is the exception: the revelation of the existence of magic intrigues him, thrills him, he is ready to accept all of Paige, like Leo, like Cole Paige was lucky I agree with this, except for Dan. You're still basing him on someone who was never told the truth until after Piper had decided he wasn't the man for her. We don't know what he would've been like with Piper had he been told right away - if she actually loved him and wasn't just using him to try to have a normal life - she only started going after him when she got mad at Leo for DARING to use her club to save innocents. Had Piper truly loved Dan, had she been truthful, I believe he could've been just like Henry, and Piper would've been the one who was lucky rather than trying to have a normal life (which Dan could've given her at home) with a dead husband and a too-powerful brat of a son. Henry was the only one who was told by showing what good magic could do, not how horrible it could be. No wonder that he was the only one who wasn't immediately against it. Paige wasn't the lucky one - Henry was - lucky that Grams didn't raise Paige. |
|
ljones
Whitelighter
Posts: 4,123
|
Post by ljones on Dec 30, 2015 11:48:33 GMT -5
Actually, Andy was able to embrace the idea of Prue being a witch shortly before his death. So, I have to go with Prue and Andy.
|
|
Sasha
Whitelighter
Posts: 2,750
|
Post by Sasha on Mar 6, 2018 0:55:45 GMT -5
Paige/Henry because we got the most out of it. We saw how Henry responded to magic and he accepted her. Paige wasn't raised by Grams or the Halliwell's.
I can't say Andy/Prue, because Andy died so soon after learning the truth. I think if he survived into season 2, I'd be able to make a better answer. It's too bad Prue didn't tell Andy sooner, I felt they waited too long on that, but I don't think they would have worked in the long run.
Piper/Dan I can't answer because she told him after they broke up not before. So we don't truly know how it would turn out if we had more honesty in their relationship, especially from Piper's end.
|
|
|
|
Post by fallingsnow6136 on Mar 6, 2018 3:22:31 GMT -5
Paige/Henry for me too. I loved it loads  They were so cute. As for Andy I agree. I think if Leo never existed, Andy would have been better with Piper due to the whole normal life thing. Plus their moments (while not romantic) were kinda cute. |
|
Aaeiyn
Elder
✨The Amazing Phoebe✨
Posts: 5,616
|
Post by Aaeiyn on Sept 2, 2021 14:33:39 GMT -5
It's such a tough choice for me because I like both Andy and Henry, but I'mma go with Andy just because Andy makes S1 special, for me. So, my vote is Andy. Henry is a close second. Dan can just go away and never return, unless he's going to be with Phoebe then maybe but still. He can just go away and never come back LOL I like Josh, Jack, Justin Harper, Shane, Glenn, Jason, Nate, Greg the Fireman, Leslie and Dex more than Dan.
|
|
They were so cute. As for Andy I agree. I think if Leo never existed, Andy would have been better with Piper due to the whole normal life thing. Plus their moments (while not romantic) were kinda cute.
