Is "Centennial Charmed" overrated?

[Kira Halliwell]

I actually really loved this episode, from beginning to end. While I wasn't a fan of the way they treated Cole during Season 5, I thought it was a great way to look deep into Cole's greatest motivation - his love for Phoebe, and his wish for them to be as they once were. It was interesting to see his desperation and the lengths he would go to to go back to the point where he believed he and Phoebe were at their best. His evident heartbreak at the realization that they were doomed from the start was great to see.

I think this episode would have possibly been best done as a two-episode arc. They maybe should have ended one episode with Paige realizing she is in an alternate reality, then using most of the next episode to examine a little deeper the way things "could have been" had Paige been killed by Shax.

[Aaeiyn]

I don't like this episode, at all. However, the ending with all three sisters in the elevator is nostalgic, for me because I recall that scene, as I flipped through channels, on my TV, when I was kid. I say, the ending (when they're in his penthouse) part is the only part I like because I recall it, from flipping through channels. Other than that, IDC too much for this episode.