If you were stuck in an elevator with one charmed one?

[West]

Like my Stranded on an Island thread Charmed style. I thought of another fun one.

If you could be stuck in an elevator with just one charmed one for 15-20 minutes.

And you could ask them anything. What would it be?

Would you knock sense into them over things they did you didnt like?
Get juicy details out of them?
Flirt with them, (lol why not)

Im curious what everyone picks?

[Deleted]

Paige all the way. She was the most fun and consistently likeable.

[lilchi7212]

Phoebe

[Deleted]

Depends on which era we're talking about here.

If we're talking early seasons, I'd say Phoebe.  However, if we're talking later seasons, then I'd say Paige. 

[adzpower]

I'd say Prue. It'd be nice to have some intelligent conversation.

[Astral Vision]

Let's think this through, sister by sister:

Prue: I don't think we'd have much to talk about and I can only imagine her telekinetically pressing all the buttons, trying to get the lift moving again (I have the second episode's lift scene in mind here).

Piper: Early season Piper, yes. I think I could get stuck in a lift with her and we'd get along. After we bond over our combined panic over why the lift just stopped. Later season Piper, no. I think I'd be fearing for my life due to her temperament and her power.

Phoebe: I'd be worried for Phoebe. According to season one, she has a fear of lifts. This never comes up when she uses the lifts at the Bay Mirror or Cole's place, so I'll assume that her main fear is if they break down with her inside. Therefore she might not be so fun in such a predicament.

Paige: And then there's Paige. The one sister who we have seen to be claustrophobic, subsequently get over this and then actually spend an afternoon stuck in a lift. In that particular lift scene, she did have the dentist drill in her head, but in another scenario without that, she would actually probably be fun to chat with.

Overall, I think I'd go with early season Piper though.

If I get more time later, I might go into the annoying habits part.

[Chrisaholic]

I'd go for Prue and Paige. Need some challenge when talking with a Charmed One, beside their inherited power.

[Elle Em]

I'd choose Prue and try to convince her to not be so reckless in the hopes that it would help her survive Shax's attack.

Although early seasons Phoebe seemed like a lot of fun, so maybe I'd choose her. And early seasons Piper was so sweet, and we'd probably have a nice conversation. Or perhaps I'd go with Paige and try to convince her to stay a social worker.

[craig]

*Bumping for newbies* Also for our newbie Nini who wanted some positivity about Charmed, and this looks like a good thread for some fun.

[rebooted]

Prue in Season 1
Piper in Season 4
Phoebe in Season 1 and 2
Paige in Season 4 and 8

But overall Phoebe. I would love to hear her story and feel like she'd be fun all the time. I would love to give her advice as a friend

[angelap]

Phoebe just to get to know her. She'd be fun.

Piper. Knock some sense into her so she can be less mean. But I doubt she'd care what I'd have to say and just proceed to blow me up. LOL

[prueislove]

I'd want to get stuck with Piper. I love cooking and food so we'd bond over that. Especially s1 Piper. S2 onwards I didn't see her love for food as much. Glad they brought it back in the epilogue.

[lunchking]

Questions:

Phoebe - What made you want to have that late S4 haircut?
Piper - Why are you so mean to Leo at times?
Paige - Don't listen to them if you are not ready to move into the manor.
Prue - Stop being so reckless.