|
|
Post by jdpm1991 on Aug 28, 2016 11:38:30 GMT -5
Would Prue go along with her sisters and attack Billie and Christy? Would she agree to killing them?
|
|
|
|
Post by Melinda Halliwell on Aug 28, 2016 13:33:45 GMT -5
Season 3 Prue would've tried saving Christy first and not kill Billie but with the way things were season 8 time then Prue probably would've done so had her character been butchered obviously.
|
|
|
|
Post by yinsoul on Aug 28, 2016 19:18:10 GMT -5
I don't think so.
She was willing to save that man in Wrestling With Demons from being a demon, she risked her life for it. And he was perfectly willing to fry some random guy to be full demon at the start; he wasn't even brainwashed. I don't think wayward witches would have caused her to lose that determination.
Christy was brainwashed; and not actually entirely wrong about the sisters, though of course she went to the extreme with wanting to kill them for the Triad. Billie loved her sister and was confused, and perfectly willing to try and talk it out with Phoebe until Piper ruined it. Prue never in a million years would have let her younger sisters rabid desire to level all opposition to seeing Leo as fast as possible get in the way of saving the Jenkins.
|
|
Granny Charmed
Whitelighter
S1 "What If...?"
Fan Fic Winner
Posts: 3,225 
|
Post by Granny Charmed on Aug 28, 2016 20:51:01 GMT -5
Season 3 Prue would've tried saving Christy first and not kill Billie but with the way things were season 8 time then Prue probably would've done so had her character been butchered obviously. I agree Melinda. And we should first consider how Prue would be written dear. I must add - I am curious how Prue being around would of gone down with the later seasons. But my views dear will not be anything like the writers. I would love a fanfic with Prue and handling this storyline dears. I have more faith in my Charmed community to write it well. |
|
|
|
Post by sol on Aug 29, 2016 1:31:26 GMT -5
Christy was killed by Billie in self-defense, Billie diverted the mass of fire launched by her big sister
Christy was raised by demons,but this cannot be an excuse: Billie love, her parents - of which she accepted the murder - love, the protection and the friendship of the sisters were wonderful opportunities to change lives, but she didn't
She, as Wyatt of the changed? future, loved power, so much to try to kill her own sister
As for Prue, she never would have trusted her, especially if she had to live the Cole / Source experience
|
|
cyma
Witch
Waiting
Posts: 1,447
|
Post by cyma on Aug 29, 2016 2:22:00 GMT -5
I don't think so. She was willing to save that man in Wrestling With Demons from being a demon, she risked her life for it. And he was perfectly willing to fry some random guy to be full demon at the start; he wasn't even brainwashed. I don't think wayward witches would have caused her to lose that determination. Christy was brainwashed; and not actually entirely wrong about the sisters, though of course she went to the extreme with wanting to kill them for the Triad. Billie loved her sister and was confused, and perfectly willing to try and talk it out with Phoebe until Piper ruined it. Prue never in a million years would have let her younger sisters rabid desire to level all opposition to seeing Leo as fast as possible get in the way of saving the Jenkins. This. Prue was also willing to save Bane, who actually sent a hitwoman to kill her and her sisters. Not to mention kidnapped Prue later. And let's not forget Brendan the priest. Both Piper and Phoebe trusted neither, but they trusted Prue so they went along with whatever plan she had to help those guys. Another reason Prue would try to save Billie and Christy is because she had a very stubborn personality. The reason Piper just accepted killing Billie and Christy was the only way was because the battle was destined. And previous experience had shown her that there was no way to fight against what was destined. Even if she tried to save them, if it was destined that they battle each other and one of them have to die, it would happen no matter what she did to prevent the battle from happening. That's why Piper just accepted it. When the Angel of Destiny herself tells you, how can you not accept it's inevitable? Prue however always had a hard time accepting things. She fought against the Angel of Death and tried to save inspector even if it was his time. Even after the episode, she learned something but it was obvious she never accepted death or the greater reason things happen. In the season 2 episode, 'That Old Black Magic,' it was Kyle's destiny to defeat the evil witch Tuatha, but Prue didn't accept that and went to confront the witch and destroy her so Kyle wouldn't need to face her. I'm pretty sure Prue would've take a similar approach when learning their Ultimate Battle was against a brainwashed witch and her sister. She would've tried to find loopholes. However, I imagine all bets would be off if Prue's sisters get hurt by Billie and Christy. She was ready to send Pratt flying to his death for trying to burn Phoebe to death had Phoebe not stopped her. Not to mention send reporters flying after Piper was brutually shot. Christy was ready to put a three year old Wyatt in harm's way to kill his mother and aunts. If Prue was a mother and Christy does something to harm her child or even nephew or nieces, plans to save Christy would be thrown out of the window right there. |
|
|
|
Post by unakite on Aug 31, 2016 23:42:08 GMT -5
You got it: Angel of Destiny and Elders have warned Piper to win a battle of which a negative outcome would be disastrous for humanity
The Angel of Destiny would not put herself out if Christy was only a poor confused girl, Christy was a powerful warlock, fueled by demonic powers during her growth, able to brainwash her powerful and younger sister
Prue would not accept blindly the words of the Angel of Destiny but she would unflinchingly accept any battle against those who attack her sisters and nephews
I remain convinced that never Prue'ld be able to trust in Christy, her sudden rescue was very suspicious
|
|
|
|
Post by vincehalliwell on Sept 8, 2016 10:31:35 GMT -5
For Prue personality, at first she *might* be trying to save Christy, but if she founds out the Triads getting involved, she would have kicking Christy's ass.
|
|
|
|
Post by imdb lives on on Oct 15, 2017 1:54:27 GMT -5
If it was Brad Kern's Prue yes she would.
The real Prue would vanquish the triad and bind their powers
|
|
Esmeralda
Charmed
S2 "What If...?"
Fan Fic Winner
Twenty Years Gone....But Never Forgotten.
Posts: 21,920
|
Post by Esmeralda on Oct 15, 2017 7:30:23 GMT -5
For Prue personality, at first she *might* be trying to save Christy, but if she founds out the Triads getting involved, she would have kicking Christy's ass. Yeah, she would've kicked Christy's ass, but she wouldn't have agreed with murdering her, just like she wouldn't have agreed with killing the Valkryie or soul-raping Darryl just to save Leo or setting up Rick to be murdered just to save Chris - unless Kern totally ruined her the way he ruined Piper and Phoebe. In that case, she'd probably be the one to suggest that they'd have to kill all of these people. After all, what Kern did to Piper shows what he thought the oldest should be like, so what he would've done to Prue. I'm SOOOOOOOOOOOOO glad she died when she did! If only all three had... If it was Brad Kern's Prue yes she would. The real Prue would vanquish the triad and bind their powers Exactly so - as what's should've happened no matter if Christy wanted her powers bound or not - just like the sisters binding Paige's past life, the Enchantress' powers. |
|
|
|
Post by universalcharmed on Jul 1, 2018 13:22:19 GMT -5
Prue would 100% have been on board with taking out Billie and Christy. If it came down to them or her sisters she would always chose her sisters unless something magical interfered. Billie and Christy were trying to kill the Charmed Ones. I don't see Prue being a Phoebe and trying to talk peace. I mean given she wanted Phoebe to vanquish Cole I don't see her having any different attitude towards Billie and Christy especially at that point.
The difference between Life and Death is that split level decision to decide to talk peace or to fight back. The charmed Ones weren't trying to vanquish Billie and Christy because they were "Evil" they were doing so because Billie and Christy were trying to kill them. Had Prue been alive she would have been more pro vanquishing Billie/Christy than against at that point.
|
|
|
|
Post by Polarity on Jul 31, 2018 21:20:11 GMT -5
Everyone has made some good points about what they think Prue would have done. I think she would've trusted her gut instinct, whatever that was, and gone with it. She definitely would have stood up for her sisters, like everyone's saying. I think she would've tried to help at first, then probably would have realized early on that Billie and Christy were the "Ultimate Battle" and tried to figure out ways to stop them.
|
|
ljones
Whitelighter
Posts: 4,123
|
Post by ljones on Oct 8, 2018 15:45:48 GMT -5
That is a very dangerous mindset for Piper to possess. Sometimes, someone's destiny is fulfilled. Sometimes, it's not. The idea that destiny will always happen smacks of a rigid form of thinking. And for me, that's dangerous.
|
|
|
|
Post by BriannaWarren2.0 on Oct 12, 2020 12:27:48 GMT -5
Yes, overall, she would.
Prue would have wanted to ultimately save Billie but wouldn't trust Christy. She would have figured out that Christy and Billie were the Ultimate Power but would have tried to work with Billie when that failed she would have come to the decision that they need to be vanquished.
That conclusion wouldn't be easy but it would have to be what they need to do, to not only save themselves but magic as a whole.
She also wouldn't have forgiven Billie that easy either especially after using Wyatt to summon the Hollow. She wouldn't have stopped trying to kill Billie at the end of "Kill Billie Vo.2".
|
|
|
|
Post by goldeneye049 on Oct 12, 2020 13:18:06 GMT -5
It's something I love about Prue. She is stubborn and does anything to save an innocent person, even risking the lives of her sisters. But she breaks the rules when she's desperate when Piper gets killed. She was going to do it before Phoebe burned down in the future. If Brad Kern ruins her character, he would want to kill her. Otherwise no. She would try to save Christie until the end and could stripping her powers.
|
|
forbuss
Witch
currently watching season seven
Posts: 1,748
|
Post by forbuss on Oct 12, 2020 14:31:04 GMT -5
Honestly, I am not sure about this. Prue is fiercely loyal to her family - in "All Hell Breaks Loose" she exposed magic in attempts to save Piper's life. I view this situation as different than most: Billie was the innocent and Christy was a warlock or evil witch (in the same vain as Tuatha). I had an issue with the sisters killing Billie but NOT Christy. Phoebe was against killing them.
I think Prue would have been willing to vanquish Christy although it would have been hard, much like the doctor in "Astral Monkey" - he needed to be stopped. I think Christy did too!
|
|
