Favorite Charmed Plot Twists?

[cyma]

So what is everybody's favorite plot twists? Things you never saw coming? Mine in no particular order are:

1) The identity of Prue's stalker. While I suspected she had a stalker and not a demon after her, I fully expected it to be either Shawn or some other male. So Abbey the bartender was a total surprise.

2) Prue and Piper's past lives actually being responsible for killing Past Phoebe. Not to mention cursing all her future lives.

3) Paige orbing in panic after Shax attacks her for the first time. I had no idea about behind the scenes drama, so I was kind of stunned by an innocent having whitelighter powers. Then the said innocent turning out to be their half-sister.

4) The darklighter crossbow in whitelighter Natalie's hands actually being Eames the warlock.

5) Phoebe and Piper having this heart-to-heart about vanquishing Cole who was the Source and then in the next moment, Phoebe morphs into Cole and kills the innocent Leo naively orbed down with.

6) Zankuo killing Kyra  I really expected Kyra to become like a recurring character helping the sisters and what not from time to time and becoming besties with Phoebe and helping her with her powers as well.

[Elle Em]

When Prue kills Piper to de-possess her in Coyote Piper. It was so violent and sudden.

In All Hell Breaks Loos when they go back in time to save Piper and make the world forget about their secret, and then their lives are in more jeopardy than before.

[cyma]

Oct 4, 2016 7:24:36 GMT -5 Elle Em said:

When Prue kills Piper to de-possess her in Coyote Piper. It was so violent and sudden.

Can't believe I forgot about that one. The table dancing by possessed Piper was also unexpected. I just expected some dancing with another guy which also happened later, but that's all.

There were some very good, funny and tense plot twists in The Day the Magic Died episode. With everyone losing their powers, Doris being a demon mid-wife, Victor being stabbed then later saving Piper while still so injured.

[unakite]

3) Paige orbing in panic after Shax attacks her for the first time. I had no idea about behind the scenes drama, so I was kind of stunned by an innocent having whitelighter powers. Then the said innocent turning out to be their half-sister.

Me too
It was very emotional, I hoped she was Prue returned to fight with her sisters in the body of an innocent

[Melinda Halliwell]

These aren't really my favourites persay but did shock me the first time I saw them.

Chris sending Leo to Valhalla and Gideon wanting to kill Wyatt then actually killing Chris even though he was an Elder who were meant to be beings of good.

[Elle Em]

Oct 4, 2016 8:51:31 GMT -5 cyma said:

Oct 4, 2016 7:24:36 GMT -5 Elle Em said:

When Prue kills Piper to de-possess her in Coyote Piper. It was so violent and sudden.

Can't believe I forgot about that one. The table dancing by possessed Piper was also unexpected. I just expected some dancing with another guy which also happened later, but that's all.

There were some very good, funny and tense plot twists in The Day the Magic Died episode. With everyone losing their powers, Doris being a demon mid-wife, Victor being stabbed then later saving Piper while still so injured.

Yes, I was shocked and horrified when they had the knife to Piper's neck and she told her sisters to let them kill her to save the baby. That went way beyond normal demon fighting stuff that was typically in Charmed. 

[cyma]

Oct 4, 2016 13:35:07 GMT -5 Elle Em said:

Oct 4, 2016 8:51:31 GMT -5 cyma said:

Can't believe I forgot about that one. The table dancing by possessed Piper was also unexpected. I just expected some dancing with another guy which also happened later, but that's all.

There were some very good, funny and tense plot twists in The Day the Magic Died episode. With everyone losing their powers, Doris being a demon mid-wife, Victor being stabbed then later saving Piper while still so injured.

Yes, I was shocked and horrified when they had the knife to Piper's neck and she told her sisters to let them kill her to save the baby. That went way beyond normal demon fighting stuff that was typically in Charmed. 

Indeed. Now I'm reminded of Phoebe beating Paige an inch of her life and stabbing her in the chest under the influence of Barbas. And also the part where Piper believed she lost her baby.

And then there was the episode where Baccara incinerates Phoebe and Paige while a shocked Piper just looks on.

The episode with the Crone stealing the senses of Charmed Ones also had the twist of Wyatt being too powerful. Perhaps possibly evil. So the whole Chris-Crossed revelation and Chris' suspicious behavior didn't surprise me much.

[lordumbrex]

Cole's eyes turning black.

[Charmed by Piper]

- Zankou killing The Seer. Oh man was I fooled thinking it was Phoebe.

- Cole appearing as Phoebe in Long Live the Queen to the sisters. Again I got fooled. I also got fooled the second time watching and forgetting it was Cole.

- The darklighter crossbow in Natalie's hands actually being Eames the warlock.

Look's like I am getting fooled by these shape-shifting tricks.

[Melinda Halliwell]

The sisters being the Werewolves who attacked Whitelighters then Elders even though the episode was rubbish anyway.

And the witch who could levitate things being killed by her own familar who turned into a Warlock afterwards then.

[cyma]

Oct 4, 2016 13:12:50 GMT -5 Melinda Halliwell said:

These aren't really my favourites persay but did shock me the first time I saw them.

Chris sending Leo to Valhalla and Gideon wanting to kill Wyatt then actually killing Chris even though he was an Elder who were meant to be beings of good.

While the execution wasn't good, an Elder responsible for turning Wyatt and ruining the future was a very good plot twist. Along with Chris just suddenly fading away after getting stabbed.

Chris making out with someone who looked like his Aunt counts as a shocker too 

[cyma]

Oct 5, 2016 5:34:38 GMT -5 Charmed by Piper said:

- Zankou killing The Seer. Oh man was I fooled thinking it was Phoebe.

- Cole appearing as Phoebe in Long Live the Queen to the sisters. Again I got fooled. I also got fooled the second time watching and forgetting it was Cole.

- The darklighter crossbow in Natalie's hands actually being Eames the warlock.

Look's like I am getting fooled by these shape-shifting tricks.

Lol. Same here. That and when someone acts violently rather than just use their powers. An angry Cole backhanding Phoebe. A possessed Cole strangling Phoebe. Astral Prue clasping a hand around Phoebe's throat and picking her up. And then Piper literally pouncing on Billie, delivering a punch before trying to strangle her.

Lots of Phoebe strangling it seems Especially considering her past life also died this way.

[Elle Em]

Oh, I forgot when Cole slaps Phoebe in the alternate reality in Centennial Charmed. That was sickening to see, and I never thought Cole would do it. Even if he was angry before, he and Phoebe were always on the same side.

And I too always, always forget that it's Zankou posing as Phoebe. I've seen that episode multiple times and I still never remember.

Also, when Piper and Phoebe turn into warlocks, Piper literally freezes Leo, and Phoebe kicks him into bloody pieces. Also in that episode, not really a plot twist but just the shock factor of Piper and Phoebe smashing the woman's hand after freezing it too.

[cyma]

Oct 6, 2016 8:35:33 GMT -5 Elle Em said:

And I too always, always forget that it's Zankou posing as Phoebe. I've seen that episode multiple times and I still never remember.

Yup. He also posed as Piper, giving Phoebe a pep talk after her friend was killed by his minion right in front of her. Always forgot it was Zankuo whenever I rewatched and always was surprised I forgot, lol.

[Charmed by Piper]

Oct 6, 2016 12:37:49 GMT -5 cyma said:

Oct 6, 2016 8:35:33 GMT -5 Elle Em said:

And I too always, always forget that it's Zankou posing as Phoebe. I've seen that episode multiple times and I still never remember.

Yup. He also posed as Piper, giving Phoebe a pep talk after her friend was killed by his minion right in front of her. Always forgot it was Zankuo whenever I rewatched and always was surprised I forgot, lol.

I feel the same way sometimes and with Cole as Phoebe in Long Live the Queen. I have to say those twists always keep me on the edge of my seat. They really do a good job of fooling the audience or me. lol

[cyma]

Season 4 had a lot of good twists: Cole turning into Seer after he got caught by the Charmed Ones and successfully formulating a whole lie to get him off the hook. Cole turning Seer into a man so he's not caught by the sisters.

Then there's Cole driving an infected Paige crazy which ended up with Paige attacking him on his honeymoon o.0 There's also Piper suddenly eating the evil baby conceiving chocolate.

In season 6, the bloodthirsty demonic-looking Manticore mated with human Derek o.0 Good twist especially with Derek turning himself into Beast to get his son back.

[Deleted]

When Christina Larson in 'Pardon My Past' turned out to be Anton in disguise.

[Melinda Halliwell]

The Seer plotting against Phoebe and Cole/The Source all along so she could get the baby and become Queen Of The Underworld.

[cyma]

Oct 8, 2016 12:35:43 GMT -5 @deano said:

When Christina Larson in 'Pardon My Past' turned out to be Anton in disguise.

Lol. Yet another shape-shifting moment which surprised me but I completely forgot.

Another plot twist moment, in Brain Drain episode, Piper being hit by a car she tried to freeze. Then later literally crumbling into pieces after being handed a baby who wasn't even real.

[sol]

Dark Leo and Chris in Bad Bad World