Name your top 10 most favorite moments or scenes of season 2

[Granny Charmed]

I've loved dears the thread on naming your top 10 most favorite moments or scenes of the series. Now I think it would be wonderful to get a top 10 for each season.


Pick your all time top 10 favorite season 2 moments or scenes but only moments you really liked. You can also note down honourable mentions to one or two moments *not* in the top 10, but worth mentioning.



This is going to be so much fun!!!

[Granny Charmed]

Top 10

#1 Phoebe telling her sisters why they have to let her burn in 'Morality Bites'

#2 The sisters answer Five strangers in 'Apocalypse, Not'

#3 Prue telling Sam to tell Patty hi for them at the end of 'P3 H20"

#4 Sisters dancing to the Cranberries at the end of 'She's a Man, Baby, a Man".

#5 Piper tells her sisters why they have to let her die in 'Awakened'


#6 Prue breaks down in front of Piper and Phoebe when Phoebe had confronted her about not wanting to use her powers  in 'Witch Trials'
#7 The sisters teasing Piper about Dan at the end of 'The Painted World' 
#8 Grams appears to the sisters and writes Happy Anniversary in the book at the end of 'Witch Trials'
#9 The ending of Piper has made her choice 'Give Me a Sign'
#10 Phoebe's excitement of getting the video of of "Kill It Before It Dies" 'Chick Flick'

Honourable Mentions

#1 Piper trying to cope with Dr Williamson death at the end of "Astral Monkey" 
#2 Piper and Phoebe trying to convince Prue that they are not impostors in 'Miss. Hellfire'

[Charmed by Piper]

Top 10

#1 Piper trying to cope with Dr Williamson death and seeking comfort from Leo at the end of "Astral Monkey"
#2 Phoebe telling Prue and Piper why they have to let her burn in 'Morality Bites'
#3 Piper talks to Leo and contemplates binding Melinda's powers in 'Morality Bites'
#4 The sisters answer Five strangers in 'Apocalypse, Not' 
#5 Piper dreams of running out to kiss Leo, after finding the card Leo gave her in 'Animal Pragmatism'
#6 Piper tells her sisters why they have to let her die in 'Awakened'
#7 Piper hides in the shower in 'Chick Flick'
#8 Piper's sign lead her to her love Leo in the ending of 'Give Me a Sign'
#9 Sam dies and crosses over to the other side with Patty's ghost in 'P3 H20"
#10 Prue breaks down over the death of Andy to her sisters in 'Witch Trials'


Honourable Mentions

#1 Sisters dancing to the Cranberries at the end of 'She's a Man, Baby, a Man'
#2 Are you scum, I knew you weren't exchange between Piper and Prue in 'Heartbreak City'

[Ruth Marie]

Top 10



#1 Phoebe explains to Prue and Piper why they have to let her burn in 'Morality Bites'

#2 One Sibling or Five strangers in 'Apocalypse, Not'

#3 Prue breaks down over Andy's death in 'Witch Trials'

#4 Prue, Piper, their dates and Phoebe enjoying the night out at the beginning of 'Heartbreak City'

#5 Phoebe and Cupid get close making potions in 'Heartbreak City'

#6 Piper tells her sisters why they have to let her die in 'Awakened'

#7 Piper cries over Dr Williamson's death in Leo's arms in 'Astral Monkey

#8 Prue, Piper and Phoebe bathing baby Matthew in 'Reckless Abandoned'

#9 Sam's death in 'P3 H20'

#10 Sisters dancing to the Cranberries at the end of 'She's a Man, Baby, a Man'



Honourable Mentions



#1 Piper considers binding Melinda's powers in 'Morality Bites'

#2 Piper hides in the shower in 'Chick Flick'

[craig]

This was really hard. I had many more moments I wanted to add. I found so many great moments even if they were funny or a sisterly moments. I really don't get the hate of season 2 in general, this season is when the sisters were all at their best and so many nice funny or humours moments between the sisters this season.


Top 10

#1 Phoebe convinces Prue and Piper to let her burn in in 'Morality Bites'
#2 The sisters answer the question on saving one sibling or five strangers and answer with five strangers in 'Apocalypse, Not'
#3 Prue breaks down to Piper and Phoebe over Andy's death in 'Witch Trials'
#4 Piper tells her sisters why they have to let her die in 'Awakened'
#5 Piper hides in the shower in 'Chick Flick'
#6 Prue tries to convince Phoebe she need's glasses in 'How to Make a Quilt out of Americans'
#7 Phoebe see's Patty's final moments in 'P3 H20'
#8 Phoebe asks the monkey's what they think of evil in 'Astral Monkey'
#9 Piper and Prue ask each other if they are scum in 'Heartbreak City'
#10 Piper cries over Dr Williamson's death in 'Astral Monkey'

Honourable Mentions

#1 Prue, Piper and Phoebe dancing in P3 after Piper recovers the first time in 'Awakened'
#2 Prue and Phoebe having a sisterly moment when Phoebe uses Jack's phone to call Tokyo in 'They're Everywhere'

[Sasha]

I love that most here like that moment in 'Apocalypse, Not'. Hence my Display pic on my profile.

I really wished Apocalypse, Not was the S2 finale instead. A much stronger episode to end S2.

[Esmeralda]

Mar 9, 2018 23:23:20 GMT -5 Sasha said:

I love that most here like that moment in 'Apocalypse, Not'. Hence my Display pic on my profile.

I really wished Apocalypse, Not was the S2 finale instead. A much stronger episode to end S2.

*nods* Exactly so.

[Esmeralda]

Aug 23, 2017 5:45:09 GMT -5 Charmed by Piper said:

Top 10

#1 Piper trying to cope with Dr Williamson death and seeking comfort from Leo at the end of "Astral Monkey"
#2 Phoebe telling Prue and Piper why they have to let her burn in 'Morality Bites'
#3 Piper talks to Leo and contemplates binding Melinda's powers in 'Morality Bites'
#4 The sisters answer Five strangers in 'Apocalypse, Not' 
#5 Piper dreams of running out to kiss Leo, after finding the card Leo gave her in 'Animal Pragmatism'
#6 Piper tells her sisters why they have to let her die in 'Awakened'
#7 Piper hides in the shower in 'Chick Flick'
#8 Piper's sign lead her to her love Leo in the ending of 'Give Me a Sign'
#9 Sam dies and crosses over to the other side with Patty's ghost in 'P3 H20"
#10 Prue breaks down over the death of Andy to her sisters in 'Witch Trials'


Honourable Mentions

#1 Sisters dancing to the Cranberries at the end of 'She's a Man, Baby, a Man'
#2 Are you scum, I knew you weren't exchange between Piper and Prue in 'Heartbreak City'

I can't believe I've never answered this! Probably because there are so many fantastically wonderful moments in this season that I couldn't come up with 10. But I think yours comes closest for me - just in a different order and slightly different explanations as to why:

#1 Sisters dancing to the Cranberries at the end of 'She's a Man, Baby, a Man' (my all-time favorite scene of Charmed)
#2 The entire conversation between Piper and Prue as they wait to get into the restroom in 'Heartbreak City' that includes
"Yeah, unless they're transvestite, Nazi, war criminals with great face lifts, then I think we've got them beat." (Second-favorite)
#3 Piper hides in the shower in 'Chick Flick'
#4 Phoebe telling Prue and Piper why they have to let her burn in 'Morality Bites'
#5 As Sam dies, Prue tells him to say hi to Patty for them (I used this as my good-bye to my own mom...telling her to say hi to Grandma and Grandpa for us.) in 'P3 H20'
#6 Phoebe's spell for her sister (thinking Piper) instead leads Prue to Bane in 'Give Me a Sign'
#7 Piper trying to cope with Dr Williamson's death and seeking comfort from Leo at the end of 'Astral Monkey'
#8 Piper tells her sisters why they have to let her die in 'Awakened'
#9 The sisters answer Five strangers in 'Apocalypse, Not'
#10. Prue breaks down over the death of Andy to her sisters in 'Witch Trials'

I won't do Honorable Mentions because there are so many of them and I don't want to leave any of them out. All why, despite that horrible triangle which the series could've done without, Season Two is part of my all-time favorite season - last half of Season One through first half of Season Two.

Our differences, CharmedbyPiper, probably comes from you being a huge Piper/Leo fan and I'm not, not once Season One is over.

[gzv969]

Absolutely really love almost every episode of season 2 except maybe 3 episodes. I rewatch season 2 the most.

The 3 I really don’t care too much for are

That Old Black Magic

How to make an American quilt out of Americans - seemed more like a really bad dream that the girls got stuck in.

Animal Pragmatism- just didn’t like it.

But overall season 2 is one of the best charmed seasons

[Esmeralda]

Mar 10, 2018 13:57:15 GMT -5 gzv969 said:

Absolutely really love almost every episode of season 2 except maybe 3 episodes. I rewatch season 2 the most.

The 3 I really don’t care too much for are

That Old Black Magic

How to make an American quilt out of Americans - seemed more like a really bad dream that the girls got stuck in.

Animal Pragmatism- just didn’t like it.

But overall season 2 is one of the best charmed seasons

Yup, those are three I can easily do without also - even if I love the dream-scene between Piper and Leo at the end of 'Animal Pragmatism' and Phoebe telling Prue she has to do it, because she's the oldest and Darryl coming to the rescue. The other two, just no.

[pheebs]

Top 10

1.  Phoebe telling Prue and Piper why they have to let her burn - 'Morality Bites'
2.  The sisters answer Five strangers - 'Apocalypse, Not'
3.  Sisters dancing to the Cranberries at the end of the episode - 'She's a Man, Baby, a Man'
4.  Phoebe and Prue's talk at the end of the episode - 'Pardon My Past'
5.  I didn't need a sign to know where my heart lies - 'Give Me a Sign'
6. Phoebe and Eric at the end of the episode - 'They’re Everywhere'
7. Sam dies, and Prue tells him to say hi to Patty for them - 'P3 H20'
8. Piper trying to cope with Dr. Williamson's death and seeking comfort from Leo at the end - 'Astral Monkey'
9. Piper considers binding Melinda's powers in 'Morality Bites'
10. Piper tells her sisters why they have to let her die - 'Awakened'

Honorable Mentions

1. Prue breaks down over the death of Andy to her sisters in 'Witch Trials'
2. Piper hides in the shower in 'Chick Flick'

[Jean]

Top 10

1. Phoebe shakes her head. Prue: I don't think so. - 'They're Everywhere'
2. A very smart girl once told me that we were supposed to protect the innocent, not punish the guilty. - 'Morality Bites'
3. Prue, we were sent here for a reason. Maybe not to stop this like we thought. But maybe to understand why this has to happen. Why you have to let this happen. I don't want to die. But I don't want you to die because of me. (They hug.) I love you. - 'Morality Bites'
4. Sisters dancing to the Cranberries at the end of the episode - 'She's a Man, Baby, a Man'
5. The sisters answer Five strangers - 'Apocalypse, Not'
6. Sam dies, and Prue tells him to say hi to Patty for them - 'P3 H20'
7. Piper tells her sisters why they have to let her die - 'Awakened'
8. "Okay, you in the water. I know that you've been waiting for this. For me. Well, here I am, so come and get me. You took what matters most to me and as long as I live, you will never kill again." - 'P3 H20'
9. Piper crying on her bed as Leo orbs in and sits down next to her. He puts his arm around her and pulls her close to him - 'Astral Monkey'
10. Phoebe refuses to let an innocent die. - 'They're Everywhere'


Honorable Mentions (All made up of my favorite moments from our re-watches)

*I don't wanna lose Piper. Not at the expense of losing one of her sisters. This is my calling. You have to let me help. You have to give me my wings back. - 'Murphy's Luck'
*You bastard. How dare you hurt people this way. - 'Murphy's Luck'
*Prue saves Maggie with her powers from falling. - 'Murphy's Luck'
*Are you scum? No, I'm not scum. I knew you weren't. - 'Heartbreak City'
*Phoebe helping Cindy with Cupid - 'Heartbreak City'
*Water bad...land good...water bad...land good. - 'P3 H20'
*I am being stalked by psycho killers and I hide in the shower. - 'Chick Flick'
*Phoebe's excitement over the video tape - 'Chick Flick'
*Still, it's okay to be bad every once in a while, isn't it? - Pardon My Past
*Yeah, well, get used to it. Until we figure out what happened, we're your bodyguards. - Pardon My Past
*Getting to look out of Phoebe's eyes as she enters the manor in the 20s for the first time.  - Pardon My Past
*Hey, everyone has their limits. Anything in Dr. Spock? - 'Reckless Abandon'
*Looks like we all finally fell for the same guy.
- 'Reckless Abandon'
*Sisters taking care of Matthew before giving him back to his mother. - 'Reckless Abandon'
*Happy Anniversary, My Darlings - 'Witch Trial'
*Prue and Piper in the car about what they'll do when they return to 1999. - 'Morality Bites'
*Phoebe realizes that the Power of Three is the Power of One - 'Witch Trial'
*Prue and Phoebe reveal they took out a loan for Piper. - 'Witch Trial'
*Sisters all standing together when Gibbs is arrested and justice is served for Cleavant - 'Ex Libris'
*Phoebe, I see this man on the bus bench every single day and he's just waiting there hoping. Why was I drawn to him if I can't help him nail his daughter's killer? - 'Ex Libris'
*Prue catches Leo Naked. - 'Ex Libris'
*Okay, but how do I get the words inside without getting trapped inside the painting myself? (Phoebe sees Kit runs past, and figures out how) - 'The Painted World'
*Prue: You picked his pocket. Phoebe: I picked his pocket. - 'The Painted World'
*Piper watches Dan's tape and smiles. - 'She's A Man, Baby, A Man!'
*Don't kill anyone...don't ask. -  'She's A Man, Baby, A Man!'

[Esmeralda]

Jul 5, 2020 2:57:47 GMT -5 Jean said:

Top 10

1. Phoebe shakes her head. Prue: I don't think so. - 'They're Everywhere'
2. A very smart girl once told me that we were supposed to protect the innocent, not punish the guilty. - 'Morality Bites'
3. Prue, we were sent here for a reason. Maybe not to stop this like we thought. But maybe to understand why this has to happen. Why you have to let this happen. I don't want to die. But I don't want you to die because of me. (They hug.) I love you. - 'Morality Bites'
4. Sisters dancing to the Cranberries at the end of the episode - 'She's a Man, Baby, a Man'
5. The sisters answer Five strangers - 'Apocalypse, Not'
6. Sam dies, and Prue tells him to say hi to Patty for them - 'P3 H20'
7. Piper tells her sisters why they have to let her die - 'Awakened'
8. "Okay, you in the water. I know that you've been waiting for this. For me. Well, here I am, so come and get me. You took what matters most to me and as long as I live, you will never kill again." - 'P3 H20'
9. Piper crying on her bed as Leo orbs in and sits down next to her. He puts his arm around her and pulls her close to him - 'Astral Monkey'
10. Phoebe refuses to let an innocent die. - 'They're Everywhere'


Honorable Mentions (All made up of my favorite moments from our re-watches)

*I don't wanna lose Piper. Not at the expense of losing one of her sisters. This is my calling. You have to let me help. You have to give me my wings back. - 'Murphy's Luck'
*You bastard. How dare you hurt people this way. - 'Murphy's Luck'
*Prue saves Maggie with her powers from falling. - 'Murphy's Luck'
*Are you scum? No, I'm not scum. I knew you weren't. - 'Heartbreak City'
*Phoebe helping Cindy with Cupid - 'Heartbreak City'
*Water bad...land good...water bad...land good. - 'P3 H20'
*I am being stalked by psycho killers and I hide in the shower. - 'Chick Flick'
*Phoebe's excitement over the video tape - 'Chick Flick'
*Still, it's okay to be bad every once in a while, isn't it? - Pardon My Past
*Yeah, well, get used to it. Until we figure out what happened, we're your bodyguards. - Pardon My Past
*Getting to look out of Phoebe's eyes as she enters the manor in the 20s for the first time.  - Pardon My Past
*Hey, everyone has their limits. Anything in Dr. Spock? - 'Reckless Abandon'
*Looks like we all finally fell for the same guy.
- 'Reckless Abandon'
*Sisters taking care of Matthew before giving him back to his mother. - 'Reckless Abandon'
*Happy Anniversary, My Darlings - 'Witch Trial'
*Prue and Piper in the car about what they'll do when they return to 1999. - 'Morality Bites'
*Phoebe realizes that the Power of Three is the Power of One - 'Witch Trial'
*Prue and Phoebe reveal they took out a loan for Piper. - 'Witch Trial'
*Sisters all standing together when Gibbs is arrested and justice is served for Cleavant - 'Ex Libris'
*Phoebe, I see this man on the bus bench every single day and he's just waiting there hoping. Why was I drawn to him if I can't help him nail his daughter's killer? - 'Ex Libris'
*Prue catches Leo Naked. - 'Ex Libris'
*Okay, but how do I get the words inside without getting trapped inside the painting myself? (Phoebe sees Kit runs past, and figures out how) - 'The Painted World'
*Prue: You picked his pocket. Phoebe: I picked his pocket. - 'The Painted World'
*Piper watches Dan's tape and smiles. - 'She's A Man, Baby, A Man!'
*Don't kill anyone...don't ask. -  'She's A Man, Baby, A Man!'

Oh, Jean! What a great idea! First, here a repeat of my Top 10 S2 Moments:

#1 Sisters dancing to the Cranberries at the end of 'She's a Man, Baby, a Man' (my all-time favorite scene of Charmed)
#2 The entire conversation between Piper and Prue as they wait to get into the restroom in 'Heartbreak City' that includes "Yeah, unless they're transvestite, Nazi, war criminals with great face lifts, then I think we've got them beat." (Second-favorite)
#3 Piper hides in the shower in 'Chick Flick'
#4 Phoebe telling Prue and Piper why they have to let her burn in 'Morality Bites'
#5 As Sam dies, Prue tells him to say hi to Patty for them (I used this as my good-bye to my own mom...telling her to say hi to Grandma and Grandpa for us.) in 'P3 H20'
#6 Phoebe's spell for her sister (thinking Piper) instead leads Prue to Bane in 'Give Me a Sign'
#7 Piper trying to cope with Dr Williamson's death and seeking comfort from Leo at the end of 'Astral Monkey'
#8 Piper tells her sisters why they have to let her die in 'Awakened'
#9 The sisters answer Five strangers in 'Apocalypse, Not'
#10. Prue breaks down over the death of Andy to her sisters in 'Witch Trials'

And for my Honorable Mentions, my favorite moments from each S2 episode after re-watching that episode that didn't make this list:

Phoebe realizes that the Power of Three is the Power of One - Piper's expression when they're naked and Phoebe says "GRAMS! - AND WE DIDN"T EVEN HAVE TO GET NAKED!- 'Witch Trial'

Phoebe looking at Kit. "I wouldn't...yes, I would" - "Just don't lose that common sense. We may need it to save the day again." - 'The Painted World'

Phoebe realizing that THEY hadn't learned their lesson yet, and this may be where it started. - Piper and Leo talking as they watch little Melinda with her tea set. - 'Morality Bites'

"I'd rather just freeze him and kick him in the" DING DONG! (Only time I laughed during the whole episode) - We've gotta get them out of there...With what? Demonic Ipecac? - "Prue, what's going on here? Someone wanna clue me in?" "You're arresting a kidnapper" "And rescuing his victims. Good job" "Trust me. That's all what you wanna know" "I guess that's all I need to know." - 'The Devil's Music'

"Piper figures out Phoebe can use her connection to save Prue." "You think I'm sort of man-killing demon and you want me to go to Man Central?" - 'She's a Man, Baby, a Man'

"Phoebe once told me that if it matters to you it matters. If they think you're something Kyle, than you probably are." - "Prue, the courage potion." "What? There is no courage potion." "No? Now look who's teaching who. Kyle, get the wand, you can do it." - "How'd you do that?" "Magic. Wanna know more?"

"Water bad, land good...water bad, land good" "Okay, you in the water. I know that you've been waiting for this. For me. Well, here I am, so come and get me. You took what matters most to me and as long as I live, you will never kill again." - 'P3 H2O'

"Did we do something good?" "You did something incredible." - Phoebe shakes her head. "I don't think so." - "You know, they really shouldn't have given us the finger." - 'They’re Everywhere'

"I never get tired of kicking his butt." - "You broke your ankle when you were seven. Come on, Prue. We went to Duran Duran together. You stretched out my leg warmers." - "And then you gave them to me." - "Just a little something to think about in jail." "It won't be the only thing I think about, I promise." "Is that a threat?" "No. It's a compliment." - 'Ms. Hellfire'

The montage to "Baby, I Love You!" - 'Looks like all three of us finally fell for the same guy.' - The fact that Martha's not the innocent - Matthew is! - 'Reckless Abandon'

"Are you scum?" "No, I'm not scum." "I knew you weren't."- Phoebe helping Cindy - Phoebe helping her sisters.

Piper tells Prue and Phoebe they need to reverse the spell. - Phoebe crying that Piper is dying. - Prue refuses to pretend that the painting is authentic. - 'Awakened'

'Piper and Leo and the card' - Phoebe can't work well under pressure. - "Why do I have to carry the poisonous snake" "Because you're older and have lived longer" - 'Animal Pragmatism'

"Yeah, well, get used to it. Until we figure out what happened, we're your bodyguards." - "Relax-a-phobia" - Getting to look out of Phoebe's eyes as she enters the '20s Manor for the first time. - 'Pardon My Past'

"I'm sorry." "I'm not." - 2. "We're rescuing you...from the tall, dark and naked man." "Thank you for saving my life." "Thank you for changing mine." - 'Give Me a Sign'

"There's gotta be something in here. Damn it! I can't just sit back and do nothing. Think, think! (He looks up.) Give me my powers back. I want my powers back. I want my powers back, I want them back now! I can't keep being mortal if this is the cost. I don't wanna lose Piper. Not at the expense of losing one of her sisters. This is my calling. You have to let me help. You have to give me my wings back." - "Prue! Prue, this isn't you. The Darklighter is making you do this. He tried to kill Maggie and he's trying to kill you. He put a spell on you just like he did with Maggie. You're stronger than he is." - "I guess I just wasn't ready to relive that pain. But now I am. Especially since a demon tried to take advantage of it. But that was then... (she puts the photo in the fireplace and it burns ) and this... (she opens a magazine up to the article on Maggie.) this is now. Hi, it's me, I'm a professional photographer. Look." - Murphy's Luck

"Phoebe accepts wearing glasses" - "All the things the Trivia talked about...the callbacks." - "Alright, I'm only doing this for you guys and if I get killed, I'm gonna haunt the both of you forever."

Phoebe watching the video. - Phoebe telling Billy good-bye. - "Billy, it's the 20th century. It's the woman's job to save the day." - 'Chick Flick'

Piper talking to Lillian - Charlene spooking Gibbs - Prue talking to Mr. Wilson - "Ex Libris"

Leo comforting Piper - Dr. Williamson thinking he's doing good when he's not...just like the sisters later on - "Whatever you do, don't let that thing go!" - "Astral Monkey" -

Good having to work with Evil - Having to make a choice - your sister or the world - Wishing we could've seen what was going on with Prue and War - 'Apocalypse Not'

Power of Three Spell is used - A part seen from Shining Allure's "The Death of Prue". Phoebe's premonition saves the day - 'Be Careful What You Witch For'

[prudencehalliwell]

Jul 5, 2020 11:55:45 GMT -5 Esmeralda said:

Jul 5, 2020 2:57:47 GMT -5 Jean said:

Top 10

1. Phoebe shakes her head. Prue: I don't think so. - 'They're Everywhere'
2. A very smart girl once told me that we were supposed to protect the innocent, not punish the guilty. - 'Morality Bites'
3. Prue, we were sent here for a reason. Maybe not to stop this like we thought. But maybe to understand why this has to happen. Why you have to let this happen. I don't want to die. But I don't want you to die because of me. (They hug.) I love you. - 'Morality Bites'
4. Sisters dancing to the Cranberries at the end of the episode - 'She's a Man, Baby, a Man'
5. The sisters answer Five strangers - 'Apocalypse, Not'
6. Sam dies, and Prue tells him to say hi to Patty for them - 'P3 H20'
7. Piper tells her sisters why they have to let her die - 'Awakened'
8. "Okay, you in the water. I know that you've been waiting for this. For me. Well, here I am, so come and get me. You took what matters most to me and as long as I live, you will never kill again." - 'P3 H20'
9. Piper crying on her bed as Leo orbs in and sits down next to her. He puts his arm around her and pulls her close to him - 'Astral Monkey'
10. Phoebe refuses to let an innocent die. - 'They're Everywhere'


Honorable Mentions (All made up of my favorite moments from our re-watches)

*I don't wanna lose Piper. Not at the expense of losing one of her sisters. This is my calling. You have to let me help. You have to give me my wings back. - 'Murphy's Luck'
*You bastard. How dare you hurt people this way. - 'Murphy's Luck'
*Prue saves Maggie with her powers from falling. - 'Murphy's Luck'
*Are you scum? No, I'm not scum. I knew you weren't. - 'Heartbreak City'
*Phoebe helping Cindy with Cupid - 'Heartbreak City'
*Water bad...land good...water bad...land good. - 'P3 H20'
*I am being stalked by psycho killers and I hide in the shower. - 'Chick Flick'
*Phoebe's excitement over the video tape - 'Chick Flick'
*Still, it's okay to be bad every once in a while, isn't it? - Pardon My Past
*Yeah, well, get used to it. Until we figure out what happened, we're your bodyguards. - Pardon My Past
*Getting to look out of Phoebe's eyes as she enters the manor in the 20s for the first time.  - Pardon My Past
*Hey, everyone has their limits. Anything in Dr. Spock? - 'Reckless Abandon'
*Looks like we all finally fell for the same guy.
- 'Reckless Abandon'
*Sisters taking care of Matthew before giving him back to his mother. - 'Reckless Abandon'
*Happy Anniversary, My Darlings - 'Witch Trial'
*Prue and Piper in the car about what they'll do when they return to 1999. - 'Morality Bites'
*Phoebe realizes that the Power of Three is the Power of One - 'Witch Trial'
*Prue and Phoebe reveal they took out a loan for Piper. - 'Witch Trial'
*Sisters all standing together when Gibbs is arrested and justice is served for Cleavant - 'Ex Libris'
*Phoebe, I see this man on the bus bench every single day and he's just waiting there hoping. Why was I drawn to him if I can't help him nail his daughter's killer? - 'Ex Libris'
*Prue catches Leo Naked. - 'Ex Libris'
*Okay, but how do I get the words inside without getting trapped inside the painting myself? (Phoebe sees Kit runs past, and figures out how) - 'The Painted World'
*Prue: You picked his pocket. Phoebe: I picked his pocket. - 'The Painted World'
*Piper watches Dan's tape and smiles. - 'She's A Man, Baby, A Man!'
*Don't kill anyone...don't ask. -  'She's A Man, Baby, A Man!'

Oh, Jean! What a great idea! First, here a repeat of my Top 10 S2 Moments:

#1 Sisters dancing to the Cranberries at the end of 'She's a Man, Baby, a Man' (my all-time favorite scene of Charmed)
#2 The entire conversation between Piper and Prue as they wait to get into the restroom in 'Heartbreak City' that includes "Yeah, unless they're transvestite, Nazi, war criminals with great face lifts, then I think we've got them beat." (Second-favorite)
#3 Piper hides in the shower in 'Chick Flick'
#4 Phoebe telling Prue and Piper why they have to let her burn in 'Morality Bites'
#5 As Sam dies, Prue tells him to say hi to Patty for them (I used this as my good-bye to my own mom...telling her to say hi to Grandma and Grandpa for us.) in 'P3 H20'
#6 Phoebe's spell for her sister (thinking Piper) instead leads Prue to Bane in 'Give Me a Sign'
#7 Piper trying to cope with Dr Williamson's death and seeking comfort from Leo at the end of 'Astral Monkey'
#8 Piper tells her sisters why they have to let her die in 'Awakened'
#9 The sisters answer Five strangers in 'Apocalypse, Not'
#10. Prue breaks down over the death of Andy to her sisters in 'Witch Trials'

And for my Honorable Mentions, my favorite moments from each S2 episode after re-watching that episode that didn't make this list:

Phoebe realizes that the Power of Three is the Power of One - Piper's expression when they're naked and Phoebe says "GRAMS! - AND WE DIDN"T EVEN HAVE TO GET NAKED!- 'Witch Trial'

Phoebe looking at Kit. "I wouldn't...yes, I would" - "Just don't lose that common sense. We may need it to save the day again." - 'The Painted World'

Phoebe realizing that THEY hadn't learned their lesson yet, and this may be where it started. - Piper and Leo talking as they watch little Melinda with her tea set. - 'Morality Bites'

"I'd rather just freeze him and kick him in the" DING DONG! (Only time I laughed during the whole episode) - We've gotta get them out of there...With what? Demonic Ipecac? - "Prue, what's going on here? Someone wanna clue me in?" "You're arresting a kidnapper" "And rescuing his victims. Good job" "Trust me. That's all what you wanna know" "I guess that's all I need to know." - 'The Devil's Music'

"Piper figures out Phoebe can use her connection to save Prue." "You think I'm sort of man-killing demon and you want me to go to Man Central?" - 'She's a Man, Baby, a Man'

"Phoebe once told me that if it matters to you it matters. If they think you're something Kyle, than you probably are." - "Prue, the courage potion." "What? There is no courage potion." "No? Now look who's teaching who. Kyle, get the wand, you can do it." - "How'd you do that?" "Magic. Wanna know more?"

"Water bad, land good...water bad, land good" "Okay, you in the water. I know that you've been waiting for this. For me. Well, here I am, so come and get me. You took what matters most to me and as long as I live, you will never kill again." - 'P3 H2O'

"Did we do something good?" "You did something incredible." - Phoebe shakes her head. "I don't think so." - "You know, they really shouldn't have given us the finger." - 'They’re Everywhere'

"I never get tired of kicking his butt." - "You broke your ankle when you were seven. Come on, Prue. We went to Duran Duran together. You stretched out my leg warmers." - "And then you gave them to me." - "Just a little something to think about in jail." "It won't be the only thing I think about, I promise." "Is that a threat?" "No. It's a compliment." - 'Ms. Hellfire'

The montage to "Baby, I Love You!" - 'Looks like all three of us finally fell for the same guy.' - The fact that Martha's not the innocent - Matthew is! - 'Reckless Abandon'

"Are you scum?" "No, I'm not scum." "I knew you weren't."- Phoebe helping Cindy - Phoebe helping her sisters.

Piper tells Prue and Phoebe they need to reverse the spell. - Phoebe crying that Piper is dying. - Prue refuses to pretend that the painting is authentic. - 'Awakened'

'Piper and Leo and the card' - Phoebe can't work well under pressure. - "Why do I have to carry the poisonous snake" "Because you're older and have lived longer" - 'Animal Pragmatism'

"Yeah, well, get used to it. Until we figure out what happened, we're your bodyguards." - "Relax-a-phobia" - Getting to look out of Phoebe's eyes as she enters the '20s Manor for the first time. - 'Pardon My Past'

"I'm sorry." "I'm not." - 2. "We're rescuing you...from the tall, dark and naked man." "Thank you for saving my life." "Thank you for changing mine." - 'Give Me a Sign'

"There's gotta be something in here. Damn it! I can't just sit back and do nothing. Think, think! (He looks up.) Give me my powers back. I want my powers back. I want my powers back, I want them back now! I can't keep being mortal if this is the cost. I don't wanna lose Piper. Not at the expense of losing one of her sisters. This is my calling. You have to let me help. You have to give me my wings back." - "Prue! Prue, this isn't you. The Darklighter is making you do this. He tried to kill Maggie and he's trying to kill you. He put a spell on you just like he did with Maggie. You're stronger than he is." - "I guess I just wasn't ready to relive that pain. But now I am. Especially since a demon tried to take advantage of it. But that was then... (she puts the photo in the fireplace and it burns ) and this... (she opens a magazine up to the article on Maggie.) this is now. Hi, it's me, I'm a professional photographer. Look." - Murphy's Luck

"Phoebe accepts wearing glasses" - "All the things the Trivia talked about...the callbacks." - "Alright, I'm only doing this for you guys and if I get killed, I'm gonna haunt the both of you forever."

Phoebe watching the video. - Phoebe telling Billy good-bye. - "Billy, it's the 20th century. It's the woman's job to save the day." - 'Chick Flick'

Piper talking to Lillian - Charlene spooking Gibbs - Prue talking to Mr. Wilson - "Ex Libris"

Leo comforting Piper - Dr. Williamson thinking he's doing good when he's not...just like the sisters later on - "Whatever you do, don't let that thing go!" - "Astral Monkey" -

Good having to work with Evil - Having to make a choice - your sister or the world - Wishing we could've seen what was going on with Prue and War - 'Apocalypse Not'

Power of Three Spell is used - A part seen from Shining Allure's "The Death of Prue". Phoebe's premonition saves the day - 'Be Careful What You Witch For'

Like Es, fantastic job Jean! All of these made me smile.

And Es, fantastic job too!

I'll have to put mine together when I have time to look over the moments I gave, but I do remember well what some of my favorite ones are.

[Esmeralda]

Jul 5, 2020 17:27:07 GMT -5 prudencehalliwell said:

Jul 5, 2020 11:55:45 GMT -5 Esmeralda said:

Oh, Jean! What a great idea! First, here a repeat of my Top 10 S2 Moments:

#1 Sisters dancing to the Cranberries at the end of 'She's a Man, Baby, a Man' (my all-time favorite scene of Charmed)
#2 The entire conversation between Piper and Prue as they wait to get into the restroom in 'Heartbreak City' that includes "Yeah, unless they're transvestite, Nazi, war criminals with great face lifts, then I think we've got them beat." (Second-favorite)
#3 Piper hides in the shower in 'Chick Flick'
#4 Phoebe telling Prue and Piper why they have to let her burn in 'Morality Bites'
#5 As Sam dies, Prue tells him to say hi to Patty for them (I used this as my good-bye to my own mom...telling her to say hi to Grandma and Grandpa for us.) in 'P3 H20'
#6 Phoebe's spell for her sister (thinking Piper) instead leads Prue to Bane in 'Give Me a Sign'
#7 Piper trying to cope with Dr Williamson's death and seeking comfort from Leo at the end of 'Astral Monkey'
#8 Piper tells her sisters why they have to let her die in 'Awakened'
#9 The sisters answer Five strangers in 'Apocalypse, Not'
#10. Prue breaks down over the death of Andy to her sisters in 'Witch Trials'

And for my Honorable Mentions, my favorite moments from each S2 episode after re-watching that episode that didn't make this list:

Phoebe realizes that the Power of Three is the Power of One - Piper's expression when they're naked and Phoebe says "GRAMS! - AND WE DIDN"T EVEN HAVE TO GET NAKED!- 'Witch Trial'

Phoebe looking at Kit. "I wouldn't...yes, I would" - "Just don't lose that common sense. We may need it to save the day again." - 'The Painted World'

Phoebe realizing that THEY hadn't learned their lesson yet, and this may be where it started. - Piper and Leo talking as they watch little Melinda with her tea set. - 'Morality Bites'

"I'd rather just freeze him and kick him in the" DING DONG! (Only time I laughed during the whole episode) - We've gotta get them out of there...With what? Demonic Ipecac? - "Prue, what's going on here? Someone wanna clue me in?" "You're arresting a kidnapper" "And rescuing his victims. Good job" "Trust me. That's all what you wanna know" "I guess that's all I need to know." - 'The Devil's Music'

"Piper figures out Phoebe can use her connection to save Prue." "You think I'm sort of man-killing demon and you want me to go to Man Central?" - 'She's a Man, Baby, a Man'

"Phoebe once told me that if it matters to you it matters. If they think you're something Kyle, than you probably are." - "Prue, the courage potion." "What? There is no courage potion." "No? Now look who's teaching who. Kyle, get the wand, you can do it." - "How'd you do that?" "Magic. Wanna know more?"

"Water bad, land good...water bad, land good" "Okay, you in the water. I know that you've been waiting for this. For me. Well, here I am, so come and get me. You took what matters most to me and as long as I live, you will never kill again." - 'P3 H2O'

"Did we do something good?" "You did something incredible." - Phoebe shakes her head. "I don't think so." - "You know, they really shouldn't have given us the finger." - 'They’re Everywhere'

"I never get tired of kicking his butt." - "You broke your ankle when you were seven. Come on, Prue. We went to Duran Duran together. You stretched out my leg warmers." - "And then you gave them to me." - "Just a little something to think about in jail." "It won't be the only thing I think about, I promise." "Is that a threat?" "No. It's a compliment." - 'Ms. Hellfire'

The montage to "Baby, I Love You!" - 'Looks like all three of us finally fell for the same guy.' - The fact that Martha's not the innocent - Matthew is! - 'Reckless Abandon'

"Are you scum?" "No, I'm not scum." "I knew you weren't."- Phoebe helping Cindy - Phoebe helping her sisters.

Piper tells Prue and Phoebe they need to reverse the spell. - Phoebe crying that Piper is dying. - Prue refuses to pretend that the painting is authentic. - 'Awakened'

'Piper and Leo and the card' - Phoebe can't work well under pressure. - "Why do I have to carry the poisonous snake" "Because you're older and have lived longer" - 'Animal Pragmatism'

"Yeah, well, get used to it. Until we figure out what happened, we're your bodyguards." - "Relax-a-phobia" - Getting to look out of Phoebe's eyes as she enters the '20s Manor for the first time. - 'Pardon My Past'

"I'm sorry." "I'm not." - 2. "We're rescuing you...from the tall, dark and naked man." "Thank you for saving my life." "Thank you for changing mine." - 'Give Me a Sign'

"There's gotta be something in here. Damn it! I can't just sit back and do nothing. Think, think! (He looks up.) Give me my powers back. I want my powers back. I want my powers back, I want them back now! I can't keep being mortal if this is the cost. I don't wanna lose Piper. Not at the expense of losing one of her sisters. This is my calling. You have to let me help. You have to give me my wings back." - "Prue! Prue, this isn't you. The Darklighter is making you do this. He tried to kill Maggie and he's trying to kill you. He put a spell on you just like he did with Maggie. You're stronger than he is." - "I guess I just wasn't ready to relive that pain. But now I am. Especially since a demon tried to take advantage of it. But that was then... (she puts the photo in the fireplace and it burns ) and this... (she opens a magazine up to the article on Maggie.) this is now. Hi, it's me, I'm a professional photographer. Look." - Murphy's Luck

"Phoebe accepts wearing glasses" - "All the things the Trivia talked about...the callbacks." - "Alright, I'm only doing this for you guys and if I get killed, I'm gonna haunt the both of you forever."

Phoebe watching the video. - Phoebe telling Billy good-bye. - "Billy, it's the 20th century. It's the woman's job to save the day." - 'Chick Flick'

Piper talking to Lillian - Charlene spooking Gibbs - Prue talking to Mr. Wilson - "Ex Libris"

Leo comforting Piper - Dr. Williamson thinking he's doing good when he's not...just like the sisters later on - "Whatever you do, don't let that thing go!" - "Astral Monkey" -

Good having to work with Evil - Having to make a choice - your sister or the world - Wishing we could've seen what was going on with Prue and War - 'Apocalypse Not'

Power of Three Spell is used - A part seen from Shining Allure's "The Death of Prue". Phoebe's premonition saves the day - 'Be Careful What You Witch For'

Like Es, fantastic job Jean! All of these made me smile.

And Es, fantastic job too!

I'll have to put mine together when I have time to look over the moments I gave, but I do remember well what some of my favorite ones are.

It will be fun seeing which ones of yours will be your Top Ten, Prudence, and which will be honorable mentions.

[Aaeiyn]

I will do my best, to list 10 things ('cause I don't like S2) but no promises. This will (most likely) end up being a list of episodes of I like rather than scenes and/or moments LOL:

1. This is Phoebe's BEST season. I love her, in this season.
2. Prue & Bane are the BEST! I wish we had gotten more of them.
3. I like how both Piper & Prue were shown having fast reflexes against bullets, in Ms. Hellfire.
4. Morality Bites is my favorite episode, this season because of no Dan Gordon. IK the premiere didn't, either, but I like Morality Bites, better. I think it's the better episode.
5. The Painted World is not a bad episode, either.
6. That Old Black Magic is cool episode, as well.
7. They're Everywhere had an interesting concept.
8. Chick Flick is a nice fun episode.
9. Ex Libris is another good episode.
10. Be Careful What You Witch For is another good episode, as well.

Yeah, this isn't a very good list compared to my other "Top 10s", that I've done