Should TCO's have given up their powers in 422Witch Way now?

[rebooted]

What would have happened if the sisters gave up their powers in Witch Way Now to live normal lives like the angel of destiny proposed?

Imagine if we had 4 seasons about TCO's not being witches anymore but Paige living as a white-lighter and Piper's baby having magical powers through the womb and Phoebe not having magical powers at all. Although premonition was always one of those Powers that worked in a place where magic didn't work.

Anyway, should the sisters have given up their powers in 4x22 Witch Way Now? Not for us as viewers. Do you think they should have given up their powers to lead normal, demon free lives again. Even with Cole lurking around and Wyatt/Prudence Melinda giving Piper, powers through the womb.

[Esmeralda]

I wish I could say yes, but not with Cole and a twice-blessed brat no matter if her name is Prudence Melinda as it should've been or if his name was Wyatt Matthew as it was.

No, if you were going to set it up so that they could indeed give up their powers and live those normal lives, the Angel of Destiny would've set it up so that Piper's baby would've been a normal baby and Cole would become a normal lawyer who Phoebe could truly love and marry and be happy with while Paige would remain a social worker where hopefully she would've met Henry. Along the same lines, Leo would lose his wings and be just a normal doctor or normal taxicab driver since that's all he was at that point - his choice.

And had that damned Demon of Destiny (no way he was an angel) told them the truth about what keeping those powers would lead to, I'm sure they would've.

But since that's not part of your poll, I simply didn't vote.

[Aaeiyn]

Disagree.

I don't think they should do, anything, first off.  Secondly, had they done so, I (personally) wouldn't have gotten my "fluff" seasons like S6 and/or S7 ;P