Favorite Parts of Every Season of Charmed?

[Miranda Turner]

Clearly what most here agree was the best parts of the series.

1st
Season 1: (end part) That '70's Episode to Deja Vu All Over Again

2nd
Season 3: (first half) The Honeymoon's Over to Sleuthing with the Enemy

3rd
Season 2: (middle part) Ms. Hellfire to Murphy's Luck


4th
Season 2: (first half) Witch Trial to P3 H2O

So people love the end part of S3 through the first part of S3, apart from the end part of S2.

I didn't mind the last part of S2, I guess if I could trade the season finale and maybe How to Make a Quilt Out of Americans. I could vote for it. I wished the season ended with Apocalypse Not. Well, that Charmed rewritten project may get me that wish.

[Esmeralda]

Nov 2, 2018 5:42:43 GMT -5 pheebs said:

Curious what other new members name as their best parts from certain seasons?


I had fun ranking every season of Charmed in three parts. Although for some, I simply couldn't do it, since I equally hated them all. LOL

Season 1

1. Season 1: (end part) That '70's Episode to Deja Vu All Over Again
2. Season 1: (middle part) Feats of Clay to Which Prue Is It, Anyway?
3. Season 1: (first part) Something Wicca This Way Comes to Wicca Envy


Season 2

1. Season 2: (first half) Witch Trial to P3 H2O
2. Season 2: (middle part) Ms. Hellfire to Murphy's Luck
3. Season 2: (end part) How to Make a Quilt Out of Americans to Be Careful What You Witch For


Season 3

1. Season 3: (first half) The Honeymoon's Over to Sleuthing with the Enemy (Sleuthing ending this part ruins it and I really loathe the episode.  Otherwise it would be a great first arc)
2. Season 3: (end part) Death Takes a Halliwell to All Hell Breaks Loose
3. Season 3: (middle part) Coyote Piper to Just Harried


Season 4

1. Season 4: (first part) Charmed Again to Brain Drain
2. Season 4: (middle part) Black as Cole to Charmed and Dangerous
3. Season 4: (end part) The Three Faces of Phoebe to Witch Way Now?



Season 5

1. Season 5: (end part) Cat House to Oh My Goddess (if only I could remove Oh My Goddess)
2. Season 5: (middle part) House Call to Lucky Charmed
3. Season 5: (first part) A Witch's Tail to Centennial Charmed


Season 6
Cannot do it.

Season 7

1. Season 7: (end part) Carpe Demon to Something Wicca This Way Goes
2. Season 7: (middle part) Charmed Noir to Charmageddon
3. Season 7: (first part) A Call to Arms to Someone to Witch Over Me


Season 8
Cannot do it.

I was going to do my own version of this and realized I didn't have to - you already did, especially wanting to throw 'Oh, My Goddess!' to Season Six and then forgetting about that season.

I'm having fun imagining a rewritten version of Charmed that only includes the favorite part of each season. Going from the last part of Season 1 to the first part of Season 2 is obviously easy (it's part of my favorite part of Charmed, which is from 'The Truth is Out There...And it Hurts' to 'Muprhy's Luck', even if it includes some episodes I don't like/hate), but going from 'P3 H2O' to 'The Honeymoon is Over' and then from 'Sleuthing with the Enemy' to 'Charmed Again' and from 'Brain Drain' to 'Cat House' and from 'Necromancing the Stone' (skipping 'Oh, My Goddess!') to 'Carpe Demon' would be very interesting - you would need a connecting episode or two between each!

Any idea how you would do it?

[Esmeralda]

Something for everyone to try. As you read each title, highlight the title and use the "B" tag for ones you love and the "S" tag for ones you hate, leaving ones you have no strong feelings towards.

Here's mine:

KEY: LOVE
HATE
No strong feelings towards

SEASON ONE:

"Something Wicca This Way Comes"
"I've Got You Under My Skin"
"Thank You for Not Morphing"
"Dead Man Dating"
"Dream Sorcerer"
"The Wedding from Hell"
"The Fourth Sister"
"The Truth Is Out There… and It Hurts"
"The Witch Is Back"
"Wicca Envy"
"Feats of Clay"
"The Wendigo"
"From Fear to Eternity"
"Secrets and Guys"
"Is There a Woogy in the House?"
"Which Prue Is It, Anyway?"
"That '70s Episode"
"When Bad Warlocks Turn Good"
"Out of Sight"
"The Power of Two"
"Love Hurts"
"Déjà Vu All Over Again"

SEASON TWO

"Witch Trial"
"Morality Bites"
"The Painted World"
"The Devil's Music"
"She's a Man, Baby, a Man!"
"That Old Black Magic"
"They're Everywhere"
"P3 H2O"
"Ms. Hellfire"
"Heartbreak City"
"Reckless Abandon"
"Awakened"
"Animal Pragmatism"
"Pardon My Past"
"Give Me A Sign"
"Murphy's Luck"
"How to Make a Quilt Out of Americans"
"Chick Flick"
"Ex Libris"
"Astral Monkey"
"Apocalypse, Not"
"Be Careful What You Witch For"

SEASON THREE:

"The Honeymoon's Over"
"Magic Hour"
"Once Upon a Time"
"All Halliwell's Eve"
"Sight Unseen"
"Primrose Empath"
"Power Outage"
"Sleuthing with the Enemy"
"Coyote Piper"
"We All Scream for Ice Cream"
"Blinded by the Whitelighter"
"Wrestling with Demons"
"Bride and Gloom"
"The Good, the Bad and the Cursed"
"Just Harried"
"Death Takes a Halliwell"
"Pre-Witched"
"Sin Francisco"
"The Demon Who Came in from the Cold"
"Exit Strategy"
"Look Who's Barking"
"All Hell Breaks Loose"

SEASON FOUR

Charmed Again Part 1
Charmed Again Part 2
"Hell Hath No Fury"
"Enter the Demon"
"Size Matters"
"A Knight to Remember"
"Brain Drain"
"Black as Cole"
"Muse to My Ears"
"A Paige from the Past"
"Trial by Magic"
"Lost and Bound"
"Charmed and Dangerous"
"The Three Faces of Phoebe"
"Marry-Go-Round"
"The Fifth Halliwheel"
"Saving Private Leo"
"Bite Me"
"We're Off to See the Wizard"
"Long Live the Queen"
"Womb Raider"
"Witch Way Now?"

SEASON FIVE

A Witch's Tale Part One
A Witch's Tail Part Two
"Happily Ever After"
"Siren's Song"
"Witches in Tights"
"The Eyes Have It"
"Sympathy for the Demon"
"A Witch in Time"
"Sam, I Am"
"Y Tu Mummy Tambien"
"The Importance of Being Phoebe"
"Centennial Charmed"
"House Call"
"Sand Francisco Dreamin'"
"The Day the Magic Died"
"Baby's First Demon"
"Lucky Charmed"
"Cat House"
"Nymphs Just Wanna Have Fun"
"Sense and Sense Ability"
"Necromancing the Stone"
Oh My Goddess Part One
Oh My Goddess Part Two

SEASON SIX

Valhalley of the Dolls
Valhalley of the Dolls
"Forget Me... Not"
"The Power of Three Blondes"
"Love's a Witch"
"My Three Witches"
"Soul Survivor"
"Sword and the City"
"Little Monsters"
"Chris-Crossed"
"Witchstock"
"Prince Charmed"
"Used Karma"
"The Legend of Sleepy Halliwell"
"I Dream of Phoebe"
"The Courtship of Wyatt's Father"
"Hyde School Reunion"
"Spin City"
"Crimes and Witch Demeanors"
"A Wrong Day's Journey into Right"
"Witch Wars"
It's a Bad, Bad, Bad, Bad World
It's a Bad, Bad, Bad, Bad World

SEASON SEVEN

"A Call to Arms"
"The Bare Witch Project"
"Cheaper by the Coven"
"Charrrmed!"
"Styx Feet Under"
"Once in a Blue Moon"
"Someone to Witch Over Me"
"Charmed Noir"
"There's Something About Leo"
"Witchness Protection"
"Ordinary Witches"
"Extreme Makeover: World Edition"
"Charmageddon"
"Carpe Demon"
"Show Ghouls"
"The Seven Year Witch"
"Scry Hard"
"Little Box of Horrors"
"Freaky Phoebe"
"Imaginary Fiends"
"Death Becomes Them"
"Something Wicca This Way Goes...?"

SEASON EIGHT

"Still Charmed & Kicking"
"Malice in Wonderland"
"Run Piper, Run"
"Desperate Housewitches"
"Rewitched"
"Kill Billie Vol. 1"
"The Lost Picture Show"
"Battle of the Hexes"
"Hulkus Pocus"
"Vaya Con Leos"
"Mr. & Mrs. Witch"
"Payback's a Witch"
"Repo Manor"
"12 Angry Zen"
"The Last Temptation of Christy"
"Engaged and Confused"
"Generation Hex"
"The Torn Identity"
"The Jung and the Restless"
"Gone with the Witches"
"Kill Billie Vol. 2"
"Forever Charmed"

If anyone else wants to do this, I used this thread: thecharmedcafe.proboards.com/thread/12364/favourite-worst-string-22-episodes Thanks, Rebooted!

[pheebs]

Nov 22, 2018 8:41:35 GMT -5 Esmeralda said:

Nov 2, 2018 5:42:43 GMT -5 pheebs said:

Curious what other new members name as their best parts from certain seasons?


I had fun ranking every season of Charmed in three parts. Although for some, I simply couldn't do it, since I equally hated them all. LOL

Season 1

1. Season 1: (end part) That '70's Episode to Deja Vu All Over Again
2. Season 1: (middle part) Feats of Clay to Which Prue Is It, Anyway?
3. Season 1: (first part) Something Wicca This Way Comes to Wicca Envy


Season 2

1. Season 2: (first half) Witch Trial to P3 H2O
2. Season 2: (middle part) Ms. Hellfire to Murphy's Luck
3. Season 2: (end part) How to Make a Quilt Out of Americans to Be Careful What You Witch For


Season 3

1. Season 3: (first half) The Honeymoon's Over to Sleuthing with the Enemy (Sleuthing ending this part ruins it and I really loathe the episode.  Otherwise it would be a great first arc)
2. Season 3: (end part) Death Takes a Halliwell to All Hell Breaks Loose
3. Season 3: (middle part) Coyote Piper to Just Harried


Season 4

1. Season 4: (first part) Charmed Again to Brain Drain
2. Season 4: (middle part) Black as Cole to Charmed and Dangerous
3. Season 4: (end part) The Three Faces of Phoebe to Witch Way Now?



Season 5

1. Season 5: (end part) Cat House to Oh My Goddess (if only I could remove Oh My Goddess)
2. Season 5: (middle part) House Call to Lucky Charmed
3. Season 5: (first part) A Witch's Tail to Centennial Charmed


Season 6
Cannot do it.

Season 7

1. Season 7: (end part) Carpe Demon to Something Wicca This Way Goes
2. Season 7: (middle part) Charmed Noir to Charmageddon
3. Season 7: (first part) A Call to Arms to Someone to Witch Over Me


Season 8
Cannot do it.

I was going to do my own version of this and realized I didn't have to - you already did, especially wanting to throw 'Oh, My Goddess!' to Season Six and then forgetting about that season.

I'm having fun imagining a rewritten version of Charmed that only includes the favorite part of each season. Going from the last part of Season 1 to the first part of Season 2 is obviously easy (it's part of my favorite part of Charmed, which is from 'The Truth is Out There...And it Hurts' to 'Muprhy's Luck', even if it includes some episodes I don't like/hate), but going from 'P3 H2O' to 'The Honeymoon is Over' and then from 'Sleuthing with the Enemy' to 'Charmed Again' and from 'Brain Drain' to 'Cat House' and from 'Necromancing the Stone' (skipping 'Oh, My Goddess!') to 'Carpe Demon' would be very interesting - you would need a connecting episode or two between each!

Any idea how you would do it?

I really love that idea Es. How much fun. 

I think you would need a connecting episode or two between each. Which is hard to do, I know between  'Necromancing the Stone' (skipping 'Oh, My Goddess!') to 'Carpe Demon', I would want any connecting episodes from S6, perhaps in S7 maybe Styx Feet Under. 

Between Brain Drain to Cat House, the connecting episodes I'd pick maybe The Eyes Have it (deals with Piper's pregnancy, has no Cole and is a good way to lead to The Day the Magic Died and Baby's First Demon. 

This is such a good question, I'll need to think more about what else I'd do. 

EDIT: My bad, I saw you said a fun imagining a rewritten version of Charmed, not a re-watch that includes only episodes with this set-up and a few connecting episodes. 

[Esmeralda]

Nov 24, 2018 7:36:04 GMT -5 pheebs said:

Nov 22, 2018 8:41:35 GMT -5 Esmeralda said:

I was going to do my own version of this and realized I didn't have to - you already did, especially wanting to throw 'Oh, My Goddess!' to Season Six and then forgetting about that season.

I'm having fun imagining a rewritten version of Charmed that only includes the favorite part of each season. Going from the last part of Season 1 to the first part of Season 2 is obviously easy (it's part of my favorite part of Charmed, which is from 'The Truth is Out There...And it Hurts' to 'Muprhy's Luck', even if it includes some episodes I don't like/hate), but going from 'P3 H2O' to 'The Honeymoon is Over' and then from 'Sleuthing with the Enemy' to 'Charmed Again' and from 'Brain Drain' to 'Cat House' and from 'Necromancing the Stone' (skipping 'Oh, My Goddess!') to 'Carpe Demon' would be very interesting - you would need a connecting episode or two between each!

Any idea how you would do it?

I really love that idea Es. How much fun. 

I think you would need a connecting episode or two between each. Which is hard to do, I know between  'Necromancing the Stone' (skipping 'Oh, My Goddess!') to 'Carpe Demon', I would want any connecting episodes from S6, perhaps in S7 maybe Styx Feet Under. 

Between Brain Drain to Cat House, the connecting episodes I'd pick maybe The Eyes Have it (deals with Piper's pregnancy, has no Cole and is a good way to lead to The Day the Magic Died and Baby's First Demon. 

This is such a good question, I'll need to think more about what else I'd do. 

EDIT: My bad, I saw you said a fun imagining a rewritten version of Charmed, not a re-watch that includes only episodes with this set-up and a few connecting episodes. 

OH! Doing a re-watch that way would be interesting, too! And because you already know what happens in the other parts, you really wouldn't need a connecting episode - although it would be fun to try to find one that works!

[Ruth Marie]

Curious to see what our new members think and old members who haven't done so yet.

[Deleted]

Season 1 (beginning, middle and and end) I can personally appreciate this as a whole. Season 2 (end) for three reasons: Ex Libris for me is a balanced/equal storyline between all of the Charmed Ones, Astral Monkey was the last time Piper showed any sincerity and pathos, Be Careful What You Witch For will always be my bias fan favorite episode. Season 3 (middle) simple there's briefly NO Cole we try to refocus on the sisters. Season 3 (end) Doherty acted her butt off until the very end. Season 4 (beginning) Love everything except Size Matters and A Knight to Remember- both weak episodes. Season 4 (end) No more Phoebe and Cole... Or so I thought. Season 7 (middle) I dug Agent Brody and the Avatar story arc. It gave the season focus and Leo much needed purpose.

[Jean]

*Bump* for our newbies.

[Aaeiyn]

The 9 I chose (in no particular order):

Season 1: (first part) Something Wicca This Way Comes to Wicca Envy
Season 1: (middle part) Feats of Clay to Which Prue is it, Anyway?
Season 1: (end part) That 70's Episode to Deja Vu, All Over Again
Season 3: (first half) The Honeymoon's Over to Sleuthing with the Enemy
Season 3: (middle part) Coyote Piper to Just Harried
Season 6: (first part) Valhalley of the Dolls to Chris-Chrossed
Season 7: (first part) A Call to Arms to Someone to Witch Over Me
Season 7: (middle part) Charmed Noir to Charmageddon
Season 8: (first part) Still Charmed & Kicking to Vaya Con Leos

[Sasha]

Nov 24, 2018 10:15:59 GMT -5 Esmeralda said:

Nov 24, 2018 7:36:04 GMT -5 pheebs said:

I really love that idea Es. How much fun. 

I think you would need a connecting episode or two between each. Which is hard to do, I know between  'Necromancing the Stone' (skipping 'Oh, My Goddess!') to 'Carpe Demon', I would want any connecting episodes from S6, perhaps in S7 maybe Styx Feet Under. 

Between Brain Drain to Cat House, the connecting episodes I'd pick maybe The Eyes Have it (deals with Piper's pregnancy, has no Cole and is a good way to lead to The Day the Magic Died and Baby's First Demon. 

This is such a good question, I'll need to think more about what else I'd do. 

EDIT: My bad, I saw you said a fun imagining a rewritten version of Charmed, not a re-watch that includes only episodes with this set-up and a few connecting episodes. 

OH! Doing a re-watch that way would be interesting, too! And because you already know what happens in the other parts, you really wouldn't need a connecting episode - although it would be fun to try to find one that works!

That would make quite a fun re-watch Es.

[Emmett]

Season 1: (middle part) Feats of Clay to Which Prue Is It, Anyway?

Season 1: (end part) That '70's Episode to Deja Vu All Over Again

Season 2: (first half) Witch Trial to P3 H2O

Season 2: (middle part) Ms. Hellfire to Murphy's Luck

Season 3: (first half) The Honeymoon's Over to Sleuthing with the Enemy

Season 7: (end part) Carpe Demon to Something Wicca This Way Goes

[Olga Halliwell]

1. Season 1: (end part) That '70's Episode to Deja Vu All Over Again
2. Season 2: (first half) Witch Trial to P3 H2O
3. Season 2: (middle part) Ms. Hellfire to Murphy's Luck
4. Season 1: (middle part) Feats of Clay to Which Prue Is It, Anyway?
5. Season 7: (end part) Carpe Demon to Something Wicca This Way Goes

[prudencehalliwell]

May 25, 2018 19:34:58 GMT -5 Granny Charmed said:

Season 1 end part - Season 2 middle part, season 7 end part.

May 26, 2018 12:59:51 GMT -5 Esmeralda said:

Agreed totally!!! Although I'd also include Season Three (first part) if it had ended BEFORE 'Sleuthing with the Enemy' but couldn't due to that.

May 26, 2018 19:21:06 GMT -5 prudencehalliwell said:

I'd have included some parts of S5, but I can't because I don't like the end of S5. So I didn't vote for that, and instead similar to Es and Granny Charmed and voted S1 (end part) through S2, and Season 7 (end part).

I saw this thread, wondering if after our S1-4 re-watches, if I'd change my votes. I have, I've taken out the end of S2 from my votes.

Curious if you two still feel the same way. Or might alter the results. Knowing Es, how you feel about S3 and S4. You vmight not change anything.

[Esmeralda]

Jun 7, 2022 21:46:26 GMT -5 prudencehalliwell said:

May 25, 2018 19:34:58 GMT -5 Granny Charmed said:

Season 1 end part - Season 2 middle part, season 7 end part.

May 26, 2018 12:59:51 GMT -5 Esmeralda said:

Agreed totally!!! Although I'd also include Season Three (first part) if it had ended BEFORE 'Sleuthing with the Enemy' but couldn't due to that.

May 26, 2018 19:21:06 GMT -5 prudencehalliwell said:

I'd have included some parts of S5, but I can't because I don't like the end of S5. So I didn't vote for that, and instead similar to Es and Granny Charmed and voted S1 (end part) through S2, and Season 7 (end part).

I saw this thread, wondering if after our S1-4 re-watches, if I'd change my votes. I have, I've taken out the end of S2 from my votes.

Curious if you two still feel the same way. Or might alter the results. Knowing Es, how you feel about S3 and S4. You might not change anything.

Nope, typical Es - I wouldn't change anything.

[Sandra]

Season 1: (middle part) Feats of Clay to Which Prue Is It, Anyway?
Season 1: (end part) That '70's Episode to Deja Vu All Over Again
Season 2: (first half) Witch Trial to P3 H2O
Season 2: (middle part) Ms. Hellfire to Murphy's Luck
Season 3: (first half) The Honeymoon's Over to Sleuthing with the Enemy
Season 3: (middle part) Coyote Piper to Just Harried
Season 4: (middle part) Black as Cole to Charmed and Dangerous
Season 5: (middle part) House Call to Lucky Charmed

Season 7: (end part) Carpe Demon to Something Wicca This Way Goes

These could change the more re-watches I get in.

[Aaeiyn]

I re-vamped my answer. 9 I chose, in no particular order...

S1 First Part S1E1 - S1E10
S1 End Part S1E17 - S1E22
S2 First Part S2E1 - S2E8
S3 First Part S3E1 - S3E8
S4 First Part S4E1 - S4E7
S6 First Part S6E1 - S6E10
S6 Mid Part S6E11 - S6E16
S7 Mid Part S7E8 - S7E13
S8 Mid Part S8E11 - S8E16

[lunchking]

My 9 choices are in no particular order:

Season 1: (first part) Something Wicca This Way Comes to Wicca Envy
Season 1: (middle part) Feats of Clay to Which Prue Is It, Anyway?
Season 1: (end part) That '70's Episode to Deja Vu All Over Again
Season 2: (first half) Witch Trial to P3 H2O
Season 2: (middle part) Ms. Hellfire to Murphy's Luck
Season 3: (first half) The Honeymoon's Over to Sleuthing with the Enemy
Season 4: (first part) Charmed Again to Brain Drain
Season 6: (first part) Valhalley of the Dolls to Chris Crossed
Season 6: (middle part) Witchstock to The Courtship of Wyatt's Father
Season 7: (end part) Carpe Demon to Something Wicca This Way Goes

[zack]

I chose, in no particular order...

S1 Middle Part S1E11 - S1E16
S1 End Part S1E17 - S1E22
S2 First Part S2E1 - S2E8
S2 End Part S2E17 - S2E22
S3 First Part S3E1 - S3E8
S4 First Part S4E1 - S4E7
S4 End Part S4E14 - S4E22
S6 Mid Part S6E11 - S6E16
S7 Mid Part S7E8 - S7E13

[lunchking]

May 10, 2023 23:06:11 GMT -5 lunchking said:

My 9 choices are in no particular order:

Season 1: (first part) Something Wicca This Way Comes to Wicca Envy
Season 1: (middle part) Feats of Clay to Which Prue Is It, Anyway?
Season 1: (end part) That '70's Episode to Deja Vu All Over Again
Season 2: (first half) Witch Trial to P3 H2O
Season 3: (first half) The Honeymoon's Over to Sleuthing with the Enemy
Season 4: (first part) Charmed Again to Brain Drain
Season 6: (first part) Valhalley of the Dolls to Chris Crossed
Season 6: (middle part) Witchstock to The Courtship of Wyatt's Father
Season 7: (end part) Carpe Demon to Something Wicca This Way Goes

I was checking to see if I had S3's first half listed, after the board re-watch has made it past that. And it is.

But I've taken out S2's middle part.

[missjessica]

Season 1: (first part) Something Wicca This Way Comes to Wicca Envy
Season 1: (middle part) Feats of Clay to Which Prue Is It, Anyway?
Season 1: (end part) That '70's Episode to Deja Vu All Over Again
Season 2: (first half) Witch Trial to P3 H2O
Season 2: (end part) How to Make a Quilt Out of Americans to Be Careful What You Witch For
Season 3: (first half) The Honeymoon's Over to Sleuthing with the Enemy
Season 4: (first part) Charmed Again to Brain Drain
Season 4: (end part) The Three Faces of Phoebe to Witch Way Now?
Season 6: (first part) Valhalley of the Dolls to Chris Crossed
Season 6: (middle part) Witchstock to The Courtship of Wyatt's Father
Season 7: (middle part) Charmed Noir to Charmageddon
Season 7: (end part) Carpe Demon to Something Wicca This Way Goes