Favorite sister-centric ending from Season One?

[Esmeralda]

What was your favorite sister-centric ending from Season One? I know how tough that is, so that's why I've given you 10 choices. I know...still tough! But even if you can't vote, go ahead and enjoy the memories of these sisters who happen to be witches. Are you like me - glad this season wasn't episodic since otherwise we'd never have endings like these!

Many thanks to Ruth Marie for doing the research. Here's her summary:

Episodes featuring endings with sisters: 18
Episodes featuring endings with all three: 12
Episodes featuring endings with Phoebe and Prue: 2
Episodes featuring endings with Prue and Andy: 1 ('The Fourth Sister')
Episodes featuring endings with Andy: 1 ('Which Prue is It Anyway?')

[Elle Em]

I picked 10, but my favorites are the very first and last episodes of them walking up the stairs to the house, when they're watching the Christmas video, Prue and Phoebe bringing Cabo to them, and Piper and Phoebe joking at the end of Wedding From Hell. Some nice ones, some silly ones, but I love them all.

[pheebs]

Great job Es and Ruth Marie (the research). This was so very hard for me to pick even 10. But I made my choices.

I'm like you Es, very glad this season wasn't episodic since we'd never have gotten these amazing endings. I'd like to mention that even though Prue and Andy were the couple story of Season 1, they didn't constantly end episodes, also not being episodic helped.

I think you accidentally forgot to put The Seventies Episode as a choice.

[Esmeralda]

OMG, you're right! And it WAS on Ruth Marie's list and I absolutely love it! I'm going to see if I can edit my poll to include it.

[Esmeralda]

DARN IT! I can't edit my poll. I'm tempted to delete this thread and redo it, making sure to include it. But since 5 other members have already voted, I'm not sure if I should.

Let me know what you guys think...

[pheebs]

Jul 4, 2018 19:32:38 GMT -5 Esmeralda said:

DARN IT! I can't edit my poll. I'm tempted to delete this thread and redo it, making sure to include it. But since 5 other members have already voted, I'm not sure if I should.

Let me know what you guys think...

Is it possible to just remove the poll and re-do it, while not needing to delete this thread? Is that an option?

I vote for yes, but only if other's agrees. Up to you Es?

EDIT: I just did a quick test for a poll (already deleted the thread). I see you can remove a poll from a thread, which just leaves the rest of the thread intact, and you can re-do the poll again, with the add poll choice again. So not needing to start a whole thread again. I wish you were able to edit a poll and add an additional choice or edit spelling mistakes. 

[Esmeralda]

How did you do that? When I edited my post, I didn't have the option to delete the poll and if I delete my post, the whole thread will go away.

[pheebs]

When you hit the edit button on your first post in the thread, an option for remove poll should be present on the top right-hand side. When you click, it should just remove the poll and not anything else.

[Ruth Marie]

Great job Es with this thread.

If you can't get the poll fixed, maybe we could just save that one for a series favorite sister centric ending. It depends if we can have up to 50, and so far I've tallied up S1-3 with some interesting results.

[cyma]

Jul 4, 2018 19:32:38 GMT -5 Esmeralda said:

DARN IT! I can't edit my poll. I'm tempted to delete this thread and redo it, making sure to include it. But since 5 other members have already voted, I'm not sure if I should.

Let me know what you guys think...

There’s another episode ending missing. From Fear to Eternity. Prue tells Piper she loves her and discussion about seeing Mom in pool.

I think only this and the 70s show ending is missing from the poll.

[Esmeralda]

Jul 4, 2018 22:19:02 GMT -5 Ruth Marie said:

Great job Es with this thread.

If you can't get the poll fixed, maybe we could just save that one for a series favorite sister centric ending. It depends if we can have up to 50, and so far I've tallied up S1-3 with some interesting results.

You definitely have my curiosity piqued, Ruth Marie. Are you going to do the latter seasons, too? I'm very curious about them.

Yes, you can have up to 50 choices in polls, but I think I"d prefer doing one for each season and then using the "winners" for a series one.

Jul 5, 2018 3:15:34 GMT -5 cyma said:

Jul 4, 2018 19:32:38 GMT -5 Esmeralda said:

DARN IT! I can't edit my poll. I'm tempted to delete this thread and redo it, making sure to include it. But since 5 other members have already voted, I'm not sure if I should.

Let me know what you guys think...

There’s another episode ending missing. From Fear to Eternity. Prue tells Piper she loves her and discussion about seeing Mom in pool.

I think only this and the 70s show ending is missing from the poll.

But that's TWO of them! Oh, I'm so embarrassed!

I did figure out how to remove it - thanks, everyone! - but if I do that, all of the votes will go away and already 7 people have voted.

I think what I'm going to do is go ahead and just leave it for the rest of the week, and then on Sunday do a new one with all of the choices, but in a new thread so this one stays put. Then it will be up to you guys if you want to vote in the corrected one or not. You'll still only get 10 votes, so start thinking of which one(s) you wouldn't include if you decide to include one or both of these two.

[Miranda Turner]

Jul 5, 2018 7:34:01 GMT -5 Esmeralda said:

Jul 4, 2018 22:19:02 GMT -5 Ruth Marie said:

Great job Es with this thread.

If you can't get the poll fixed, maybe we could just save that one for a series favorite sister centric ending. It depends if we can have up to 50, and so far I've tallied up S1-3 with some interesting results.

You definitely have my curiosity piqued, Ruth Marie. Are you going to do the latter seasons, too? I'm very curious about them.

Yes, you can have up to 50 choices in polls, but I think I"d prefer doing one for each season and then using the "winners" for a series one.

Jul 5, 2018 3:15:34 GMT -5 cyma said:

There’s another episode ending missing. From Fear to Eternity. Prue tells Piper she loves her and discussion about seeing Mom in pool.

I think only this and the 70s show ending is missing from the poll.

But that's TWO of them! Oh, I'm so embarrassed!

I did figure out how to remove it - thanks, everyone! - but if I do that, all of the votes will go away and already 7 people have voted.

I think what I'm going to do is go ahead and just leave it for the rest of the week, and then on Sunday do a new one with all of the choices, but in a new thread so this one stays put. Then it will be up to you guys if you want to vote in the corrected one or not. You'll still only get 10 votes, so start thinking of which one(s) you wouldn't include if you decide to include one or both of these two.

Didn't From Fear To Eternity end with Prue in the attic and saying she misses Patty alone? Unless I'm mistaken. 

But Es this is a good idea moving forward. I still can't make my mind up to vote. So I might just wait a week and vote in the new one.

[Esmeralda]

I just spot Ruth Marie's listing and observations for Season Two and Three here: thecharmedcafe.proboards.com/thread/12214/name-favorite-moments-scenes-season?page=2 Please check them out and if she's missing any, please post them so when I do those polls I won't miss any.

[Ruth Marie]

Jul 5, 2018 7:34:01 GMT -5 Esmeralda said:

Jul 4, 2018 22:19:02 GMT -5 Ruth Marie said:

Great job Es with this thread.

If you can't get the poll fixed, maybe we could just save that one for a series favorite sister centric ending. It depends if we can have up to 50, and so far I've tallied up S1-3 with some interesting results.

You definitely have my curiosity piqued, Ruth Marie. Are you going to do the latter seasons, too? I'm very curious about them.

Yes, you can have up to 50 choices in polls, but I think I"d prefer doing one for each season and then using the "winners" for a series one.

Great idea Es.

Jul 5, 2018 7:34:01 GMT -5 Esmeralda said:

Jul 5, 2018 3:15:34 GMT -5 cyma said:

There’s another episode ending missing. From Fear to Eternity. Prue tells Piper she loves her and discussion about seeing Mom in pool.

I think only this and the 70s show ending is missing from the poll.

But that's TWO of them! Oh, I'm so embarrassed!

I did figure out how to remove it - thanks, everyone! - but if I do that, all of the votes will go away and already 7 people have voted.

I think what I'm going to do is go ahead and just leave it for the rest of the week, and then on Sunday do a new one with all of the choices, but in a new thread so this one stays put. Then it will be up to you guys if you want to vote in the corrected one or not. You'll still only get 10 votes, so start thinking of which one(s) you wouldn't include if you decide to include one or both of these two.

I didn't include FFTE as I counted the Prue scene as the ending in the attic. But I think we should include it now. I guess we need to consider if endings with one sister counts if it was leading in from a sisterly moment. 

If I have left anymore out post them in the thread.

[Esmeralda]

Jul 5, 2018 23:53:19 GMT -5 Ruth Marie said:

Jul 5, 2018 7:34:01 GMT -5 Esmeralda said:

You definitely have my curiosity piqued, Ruth Marie. Are you going to do the latter seasons, too? I'm very curious about them.

Yes, you can have up to 50 choices in polls, but I think I"d prefer doing one for each season and then using the "winners" for a series one.

Great idea Es.

Jul 5, 2018 7:34:01 GMT -5 Esmeralda said:

But that's TWO of them! Oh, I'm so embarrassed!

I did figure out how to remove it - thanks, everyone! - but if I do that, all of the votes will go away and already 7 people have voted.

I think what I'm going to do is go ahead and just leave it for the rest of the week, and then on Sunday do a new one with all of the choices, but in a new thread so this one stays put. Then it will be up to you guys if you want to vote in the corrected one or not. You'll still only get 10 votes, so start thinking of which one(s) you wouldn't include if you decide to include one or both of these two.

I didn't include FFTE as I counted the Prue scene as the ending in the attic. But I think we should include it now. I guess we need to consider if endings with one sister counts if it was leading in from a sisterly moment. 

If I have left anymore out post them in the thread.

For me, personally, I wanted sisterS-centric ending, and I was only counting the actual final scene, so if it's just Prue at the very end, I wouldn't count it.

It's like my second all-time-favorite ending is Phoebe watching 'Kill It Before It Dies', but I wouldn't include it in a poll I started. As I've stated numerous times, my all-time favorite ending is the sisters dancing to the Cranberries.

If someone else wants to do it differently, of course, they can.

What I'm considering doing is actually posting all of the final scenes in my first post (from transcripts.foreverdreaming.org/viewtopic.php?t=6051) and also numbering my choices both in the poll and the post to make sure I don't skip anyone.

[Esmeralda]

Jul 5, 2018 7:39:58 GMT -5 Miranda Turner said:

Jul 5, 2018 7:34:01 GMT -5 Esmeralda said:

You definitely have my curiosity piqued, Ruth Marie. Are you going to do the latter seasons, too? I'm very curious about them.

Yes, you can have up to 50 choices in polls, but I think I"d prefer doing one for each season and then using the "winners" for a series one.


But that's TWO of them! Oh, I'm so embarrassed!

I did figure out how to remove it - thanks, everyone! - but if I do that, all of the votes will go away and already 7 people have voted.

I think what I'm going to do is go ahead and just leave it for the rest of the week, and then on Sunday do a new one with all of the choices, but in a new thread so this one stays put. Then it will be up to you guys if you want to vote in the corrected one or not. You'll still only get 10 votes, so start thinking of which one(s) you wouldn't include if you decide to include one or both of these two.

Didn't From Fear To Eternity end with Prue in the attic and saying she misses Patty alone? Unless I'm mistaken. 

But Es this is a good idea moving forward. I still can't make my mind up to vote. So I might just wait a week and vote in the new one.

That sounds like a good idea, Miranda. Others might also want to wait until I put up the corrected one.

[Ruth Marie]

Jul 6, 2018 0:05:27 GMT -5 Esmeralda said:

Jul 5, 2018 23:53:19 GMT -5 Ruth Marie said:

Great idea Es.


I didn't include FFTE as I counted the Prue scene as the ending in the attic. But I think we should include it now. I guess we need to consider if endings with one sister counts if it was leading in from a sisterly moment. 

If I have left anymore out post them in the thread.

For me, personally, I wanted sisterS-centric ending, and I was only counting the actual final scene, so if it's just Prue at the very end, I wouldn't count it.

It's like my second all-time-favorite ending is Phoebe watching 'Kill It Before It Dies', but I wouldn't include it in a poll I started. As I've stated numerous times, my all-time favorite ending is the sisters dancing to the Cranberries.

If someone else wants to do it differently, of course, they can.

What I'm considering doing is actually posting all of the final scenes in my first post (from transcripts.foreverdreaming.org/viewtopic.php?t=6051) and also numbering my choices both in the poll and the post to make sure I don't skip anyone.

Good idea Es. You do as you feel necessary. 

That's a great idea posting the scenes. That makes sure nothing is left off. 

I haven't had a chance to do S4 or beyond yet with my observations and tally counts. Will when I get time. But had fun doing a grand total for S1-3 so far.

[Esmeralda]

Jul 6, 2018 0:13:48 GMT -5 Ruth Marie said:

Jul 6, 2018 0:05:27 GMT -5 Esmeralda said:

For me, personally, I wanted sisterS-centric ending, and I was only counting the actual final scene, so if it's just Prue at the very end, I wouldn't count it.

It's like my second all-time-favorite ending is Phoebe watching 'Kill It Before It Dies', but I wouldn't include it in a poll I started. As I've stated numerous times, my all-time favorite ending is the sisters dancing to the Cranberries.

If someone else wants to do it differently, of course, they can.

What I'm considering doing is actually posting all of the final scenes in my first post (from transcripts.foreverdreaming.org/viewtopic.php?t=6051) and also numbering my choices both in the poll and the post to make sure I don't skip anyone.

Good idea Es. You do as you feel necessary. 

That's a great idea posting the scenes. That makes sure nothing is left off. 

I haven't had a chance to do S4 or beyond yet with my observations and tally counts. Will when I get time. But had fun doing a grand total for S1-3 so far.

SOOO glad you're enjoying doing that! I know I've found your observations and tally counts EXTREMELY interesting and very curious about "The Perils of Poor, Poor Pitiful Piper" aka "PhoeME and Her Fantasy Men" aka "Two Witches Plus One Living Whitelighter Equals The Power of Three???" aka S4-8.

[Granny Charmed]

Jul 6, 2018 0:06:30 GMT -5 Esmeralda said:

Jul 5, 2018 7:39:58 GMT -5 Miranda Turner said:

Didn't From Fear To Eternity end with Prue in the attic and saying she misses Patty alone? Unless I'm mistaken. 

But Es this is a good idea moving forward. I still can't make my mind up to vote. So I might just wait a week and vote in the new one.

That sounds like a good idea, Miranda. Others might also want to wait until I put up the corrected one.

I think I'll wait for the new poll dears to vote too. Since That Seventies Episode is one of my favorites, obviously I can't wait to make that my pick. 

I can't wait for Ruth to do the other seasons when she can. This is so fascinating to see the observations. 

[cyma]

Jul 5, 2018 23:53:19 GMT -5 Ruth Marie said:

Jul 5, 2018 7:34:01 GMT -5 Esmeralda said:

But that's TWO of them! Oh, I'm so embarrassed!

I did figure out how to remove it - thanks, everyone! - but if I do that, all of the votes will go away and already 7 people have voted.

I think what I'm going to do is go ahead and just leave it for the rest of the week, and then on Sunday do a new one with all of the choices, but in a new thread so this one stays put. Then it will be up to you guys if you want to vote in the corrected one or not. You'll still only get 10 votes, so start thinking of which one(s) you wouldn't include if you decide to include one or both of these two.

I didn't include FFTE as I counted the Prue scene as the ending in the attic. But I think we should include it now. I guess we need to consider if endings with one sister counts if it was leading in from a sisterly moment. 

If I have left anymore out post them in the thread.

Feats of Clay is also missing. Phoebe is trying to put on a brave face after Clay leaves which both her sisters can see and she receives a comforting hug from them. That's the very last scene if only the last scenes are being counted.