Post by Esmeralda on Jul 9, 2018 17:49:47 GMT -5
I'm going to try to do this again, but this time, I'm first going to state my own rules for this poll (and after reading the endings, I’ve changed them a little…), and then post ALL of the S1 endings, only numbering the ones that fit my rules and the choices. Hopefully that means I won't miss any.
RULES:
1) Only the very last scene counts...for this poll, as soon as they change scenery, it’s a different scene.
2) There must be two sisters (Prue, Piper and/or Phoebe) as part of the final scene. There can be more than two sisters and there can be other characters as part of the scene, but if at the end, there’s just one sister or no sister, the scene won't be part of this poll.
3) If the last scene starts with all three sisters together, but more than one leave before the end, leaving only one sister with another character as the ending, the scene does not count.
4) If anyone wants to redo this poll with different rules, GO FOR IT!
5) Even if the scene isn’t part of this poll, enjoy all of these memories!
DISCLAIMER: In all situations, these fan-written transcripts come from transcripts.foreverdreaming.org/viewtopic.php?t=6051 I’m bolding the name each time one of the sisters first appears in the scene or each time a sister leaves the scene so I can see if the scene counts.
1x01: Something Wicca This Way Comes
[Scene: Halliwell manor. It's morning. Prue walks outside and grabs the paper.]
Andy: Good morning! (He's holding a paper and a cup of coffee.)
Prue: Hey, this is a surprise.
Andy: I've been feeling really guilty about that bad cup of coffee. I just want to make it up to you.
Prue: So, you brought me a good cup of coffee?
Andy: Oh this? No, this is mine. I, uh, just wanted to ask you out to dinner. Unless of course you're afraid.
Prue: Afraid of what?
Andy: Oh, you know, having too good of time, stirring up old memories, rekindling and old flame.
Prue: Hmm, good point, better not.
Andy: Okay. Friday night, eight o'clock? You're hesitating.
Prue: Yeah, but it's not what you think. It's just that my life has gotten a bit complicated. Can I call you?
(He gives her his card.)
Andy: Take care, Prue.
Prue: Bye, Andy.
(He walks to his car. Phoebe and Piper come outside. Phoebe's holding the cat.)
Phoebe: It's Andy. I told you I heard a man's voice.
Piper: What did he want?
Prue: He asked me out.
Piper: And you said...?
Prue: I started to say yes and then I stopped. I wondered if I could date. I mean, do witches date?
Piper: Not only do they date but they usually get the best guys.
Prue: You two will not be laughing when this happens to you. Believe me, everything will be different now.
Phoebe: Well, at least our lives won't be boring.
Prue: But they'll never be the same.
Phoebe: And this is a bad thing?
Prue: No. But it could be a big problem.
Piper: Prue's right. What are we gonna do?
Phoebe: What can't we do?
Prue: We are gonna be careful, we're gonna be wise and we're gonna stick together.
Piper: This should be interesting.
(Prue stands inside the house, looks at the door and shuts it with her power.)
[Note from Es: Since both Piper and Phoebe leave the scene and we only see Prue, so much as I personally love this whole scene, it won’t be part of this poll.]
Choice #1: 1x02: I’ve Got You Under My Skin
[Scene: Quake. Phoebe walks in.]
Phoebe: Whoops, excuse me. (She walks up to a woman.) Hey, how are you? (The woman looks at her strangely. She goes over to Prue and Piper.)
Piper: Do you know that girl?
Phoebe: I almost was that girl. She was one of Stefan's victims. Obviously doesn't remember.
Prue: Lucky her.
Phoebe: No, lucky me. I learned my lesson. I have got to be more careful.
Prue: Excuse me, did I just hear it? Did she actually admit to doing something wrong?
Piper: That's what I heard.
Phoebe: Frame it. It won't happen again.
Piper: At least we helped those people. I mean, it's nice we know our powers really are good.
Prue: Yeah, good for everything but love lives unfortunately. Although I must admit they do come in handy once in a while.
Phoebe: Uh huh. Hypocrite. (Phoebe sees the lottery numbers come up on the TV screen.) The winning numbers. I've won. (Prue gives her a look.) Well, I did.
(She gets the ticket out of her purse and the numbers disappear.)
Prue: See, I told you. You can't intentionally use your powers for your own personal gain, remember?
Phoebe: It's a good thing I didn't take the tags off that dress. Oh, well. At least those old couples didn't lose their house.
Piper: A toast to the Power of Three. Whether we like it or not.
Choice #2: 1x03: Thank You for Not Morphing
[Time lapse. Prue, Piper and Phoebe are watching the video. On the video it's Christmas. Prue, Piper and Phoebe are there as kids. They are opening their presents. Victor kisses Prue on the cheek and then grabs Piper and lifts her in the air. He then asks what Phoebe got and she holds up a Barbie.]
Choice #3: 1x04: Dead Man Dating
[Scene: Manor. Prue, Piper and Phoebe walk inside.]
Prue: You know what? I've changed my mind. Maybe I should have a party after all.
Phoebe: Are you serious?
Prue: Yeah, why not? I mean, Mark is right.
Piper: Well, Prue, I'm glad you said that 'cause...
(They walk in the living room and there stands a room full of people.)
Everyone: Surprise!
Piper: Did I getcha? I gotcha.
Prue: Yeah, you got me.
Piper: Yeah.
Phoebe: And an actual present too. It's paid for. (She hands Prue a present.) I hope you like it.
Prue: I'm speechless.
(They hug. Prue sees Andy standing across the room. They smile at each other.)
1x05: Dream Sorcerer
[Scene: Hospital. Piper and Phoebe are carrying bunches and bunches of flowers into Prue's room.] Phoebe: Knock, knock.
Prue: Please, tell me you guys are here to pick me up.
Piper: Hi. No, Dr. Black said one more day. Just to be sure.
Phoebe: Yeah, and you know, it wouldn't kill you to get some rest. (She realizes what she just said and covers her mouth.)
Prue: Phoebe, it's okay. Thanks for the flowers.
Piper: Yeah.
(Phoebe laughs.)
Prue: What's going on?
Phoebe: Oh, long story, not very interesting.
Prue: Does this have anything to do with your lust spell?
Phoebe: Mmm hmm. But don't worry. Piper: We reversed the spell last night.
Phoebe: Piper called Jack.
Prue: The guy that you had dinner with?
Piper: And he didn't remember anything. And Phoebe called Hans...
Phoebe: And he didn't remember anything.
Piper: So, don't worry. Everything is back to normal.
Prue: Good.
(Andy walks in carrying a red rose and some take-away.)
Andy: Afternoon, ladies. Surprise.
Prue: Yes. It is. (Prue looks at Phoebe.)
Phoebe: What are you looking at me for? I didn't tell him.
(Prue then looks at Piper.)
Piper: Guilty. Come on, let's go.
Phoebe: Okay, bye.
Piper: Um, we'll see you later tonight.
Phoebe: After we raid your closet. (They leave.)
Andy: Brought your favourite.
(He hands Prue the take-away bag and she looks in it.)
Prue: Oh, cheeseburgers and fries.
Andy: Glad to see every bone in your body's not broken.
Prue: What?
Andy: The car accident. Never mind.
(Andy gives Prue the rose.)
[Note from Es: Since Piper and Phoebe left, this one doesn’t count.]
Choice #4: 1x06: The Wedding from Hell
[Scene: Outside the Spencer's house. Elliot and Allison are together hugging and kissing. Prue, Piper and Phoebe are nearby.]
Prue: We did that.
Phoebe: And they'll live happily ever after.
Piper: I wonder if we will.
Prue: Of course, we will. Why shouldn't we?
Piper: That's easy for you to say. You'll never greet your husband at the door with: "Honey, I think I froze the kids."
Prue: No, I've just accidentally moved them to another zip code.
Phoebe: But I will see them, find them, and bring them back safely. If I can ever learn to control my powers.
Piper: If any of us can.
Phoebe: Just think of the obstacles that Allison and Elliot have overcome. If they can do it, so can we.
Prue: I guess true love does conquer all.
Phoebe: Especially if you have separate bathrooms.
(They see Andy walking towards them.)
Piper: Speaking of true love...
Phoebe: Ooh. Andy: Fancy seeing you here.
Prue: Yeah, isn't it? (She holds up the poingnard.) Uh, I wanted to give this back to you. I'm finished with it.
Andy: How'd you know I'd be here? (He takes it off of her.)
Prue: I didn't. I was gonna drop it off after the wedding.
Andy: Aha, shall we talk about this in private, Prue?
(Andy puts his arm around Prue and they walk away.)
Phoebe: Do you believe in destiny?
(They giggle.)
Piper: He believes in destiny. Shh.
1x07: The Fourth Sister
[Scene: Outside Andy's house. Prue is in her car waiting for Andy. He pulls up in his car. Prue gets out and so Andy.]
Prue: Hey.
Andy: Hey.
(He walks towards his door and so does Prue.)
Prue: Uh, can we talk?
Andy: Is there really anything to talk about?
Prue: Andy? (He stops and turns around.) I'm sorry.
Andy: So am I!
Prue: What do you mean by that?
Andy: I mean, come on, Prue. Who we kidding? I mean, let's face it. One of us is obviously more interested in this relationship than the other.
Prue: That's not true.
Andy: Isn't it? Then how come I'm always the one left standing there looking like a jerk?
Prue: I can explain.
Andy: No, you can't. Or you won't. (He goes up the stairs and stops at the top. He throws the jacket on the ground.) Damn it Prue. I still love you. I'm not saying you have to explain it all to me, Prue. (Prue walks up to him.) That’s your prerogative. All I'm saying is it hurts that you don't trust me enough.
Prue: I do trust you, Andy. It has nothing to do with you. It's just…it's just something that I don't know if I can ever share with anybody.
Andy: Well I hope that's not true for your sake. All I know is there's nothing I can say or do to reassure you that I'm there for you. (He grabs his coat and walks up the stairs.)
Prue: Andy? (He stops half-way and turns around.) Are you saying that you don't want to see me anymore?
Andy: I don't know what I want anymore.
Choice #5: 1x08: The Truth is Out There and It Hurts
[Cut to Phoebe. Prue walks up to the table.]
Prue: Hey.
Phoebe: Hey. How'd it go?
Prue: Not well.
Phoebe: Oh, Prue, I'm so sorry.
Prue: Yeah, me too, but I cast the spell for an answer and I got it. Even if it wasn't the one I wanted. (They hug.)
Choice #6: 1x09: The Witch is Back
(Piper goes back upstairs in the attic.)
Phoebe: Who was it?
Piper: It was Leo.
Prue: Is he gone?
Piper: We're perfectly safe.
Melinda: Then let's begin.
(Piper joins the others around the table. Melinda is dressed in her normal clothes. She hands Phoebe's dress back to her.)
Phoebe: Oh, we can't take those back.
Melinda: Why not?
Phoebe: Because that means you're leaving.
Melinda: Well, I have to go.
Phoebe: Why? Why can't you stay here and have the life that you should've had?
Melinda: Because this isn't my time. It's your time, and Prue's and Piper's.
Piper: We don't mind sharing.
Melinda: You three give me great joy. I've seen the Charmed Ones. Good witches. Women of strength and grace.
(Phoebe takes Melinda's hand and holds it up to her heart.)
Phoebe: Tell me what you see. Melinda: I see the future. Many more generations of my beautiful daughters. I see my dreams fulfilled. Oh, thank you for that. (She puts on the locket and they all join hands.)
Prue: "Melinda Warren, blood of our blood, we release you."
Melinda: Blessed be, my daughters. I love you.
(Stardust surrounds her and she disappears.)
Phoebe: I'm gonna miss her.
Piper: Me too.
Prue: We can always bring her back.
Choice #7: 1x10: Wicca Envy
[Scene: Manor. Attic. Prue, Piper and Phoebe are looking through the Book Of Shadows.]
Piper: Spells, incantations, demons stuff. It's all here. Everything just like before.
Phoebe: Thank God.
Prue: But how? I mean, we certainly didn't reverse the spell.
Phoebe: Maybe we screwed it up. (Prue and Piper look at her.) What? It's not like it would be the first time.
Prue: No, we didn't screw it up. Something or someone must have done it. It couldn't happened on its own.
Piper: Why not? It's magic.
(Leo enters the attic.)
Leo: Knock, knock.
Piper: Leo.
Leo: The front door was open. I hope it's all right. I left my tool box.
Piper: That's funny. I don't remember that being there last night.
Leo: Yeah, well, you know what Freud always said about leaving things.
Piper: That you secretly wanted to come back for it.
Leo: Guilty.
Prue: Oh, don't use that word.
Phoebe: Uh, it's a long story. Never mind.
(Phoebe and Prue walk away.)
Piper: Leo, you're leaving, aren't you?
Leo: Yeah, afraid so.
Piper: Do you really have to go?
Leo: Well, I've fixed everything I came here to fix. But I'll be back. Promise.
(Leo kisses Piper as Prue and Phoebe watch.) Nothing can keep me away from you too long.
(Leo grabs his toolbox and leaves.)
Piper: Well, at least he wasn't a warlock.
Phoebe: Hey, you don't suppose Leo was the, uh...(Prue rips the relinquishment spell out of the Book.) What are you doing?
Prue: Just getting rid the Relinquishment spell. Now we've got our powers back I certainly I don't want to risk losing them again.
Piper: I second that.
Phoebe: Third.
Prue: So, witches forever?
Phoebe: And damn proud of it.
(Piper lights a match and burns the page.)
Choice #8: 1x11: Feats of Clay
[Scene: Quake. Prue, Piper and Phoebe are sitting at the bar.]
Piper: Good thing we didn't have to end up using our powers to vanquish her. Otherwise Clay would've seen her.
Prue: They didn't work anyway.
Phoebe: Not something I hope ever happens again.
(Doug walks along holding a tray of glasses. Shelley walks near him.)
Piper: Ooh, ooh, forgot about Doug.
(Doug drops the tray and Piper freezes it in mid-air.)
Prue: This is getting ridiculous.
Piper: Oh, tell me about it. That engagement ring's probably stopped burning a hole in his apron. (Prue gets up and walks over to Doug.) Where are you going? What are you doing?
Prue: Saving your problem and keeping you employed.
(Prue takes a ring box out of Doug's pocket and puts it on the floor. She sits back down and they unfreeze. The tray falls on the floor.)
Doug: Sorry.
(Shelley notices the ring on the floor.)
Shelley: What's that? (She picks it up and opens it. She gasps.)
Doug: I was carrying that around for weeks, trying to find the right time to ask you.
Shelley: Ask me what?
Doug: To, um, marry me.
Shelley: But that's why I broke up with you. I gave up on waiting.
(They smile and hug.)
Piper: This would've happened sooner if I would've keep my little wicca nose out of their business.
Phoebe: You can't change people; they have to change themselves.
Prue: Speaking of that. Yum. (Clay walks towards them.) Go, baby.
Piper: Go, girl.
Phoebe: Alright.
Piper: You go. You can do it.
(They laugh. Phoebe walks up to Clay.)
Clay: Hey.
Phoebe: Hey. I'm glad you stopped by.
Clay: Any chance you're gonna come back with me?
Phoebe: No. This is my home now.
Clay: I know I lied to you about a lot of things. But one thing I never lied to you about was how much I care about you.
Phoebe: I know, Clay.
(They kiss.)
Clay: I guess I should be going.
Phoebe: Yeah.
Clay: Um, you know, I hope the next time we cross paths, I'll be the guy you always think you see.
Phoebe: Goodbye.
(He leaves. Prue and Piper walk up to her.)
Prue: Are you okay?
Phoebe: Oh, yeah, yeah, he was just stopping by on his way home, no big deal.
Piper: Heard that before.
(Prue and Piper hug her.)
Choice #9: 1x12: The Wendigo
[Scene: Quake. Phoebe and Prue are sitting at a table. Piper brings them some drinks.]
Piper: On the house for saving my hide.
Phoebe: Literally, you Wendigo you.
(Piper sits down.)
Prue: Are you okay to work?
Piper: Yeah, I'm fine. It's like nothing ever happened. Except for Billy.
Prue: No, well, there was no way that you could've known about Agent Fallon.
Piper: I know. It's just I'm not used to losing an innocent we're supposed to protect.
Phoebe: He wanted to help stop her so she couldn't hurt anybody else and that's exactly what he did.
Prue: I'm just grateful that you're safe.
Piper: And Andy. By the way, what did you tell him about why we were all there?
Prue: I told him the truth.
Phoebe: Get out.
Prue: I did. I said what he saw happened was true, that Agent Fallon really was the Wendigo and that had we not vanquished her, that both he and Piper would've been killed. I couldn't think of anything else to say.
Piper: Well, what did he say?
Prue: Not much. He was either too stunned to speak or he actually believed me on some level. This was as close that we've ever come to having an honest conversation.
Phoebe: So maybe Andy's more open to you being a witch than you think.
Prue: Hmm. Alright, back to work.
Phoebe: Actually, I need to talk to you about something and please don't be mad but I quit.
Prue: What?
Phoebe: It's not that I don't appreciate the opportunity because I do. It's just that every time touch something at Bucklands I risk having a premonition and it's just too emotional for me. Besides that's your world. I need to find one of my own.
Prue: You will.
Piper: Just stay out of my world or I'll kill you. (Prue and Phoebe look worried and confused. Piper gets up and starts to walk away. She turns around.) Kidding! It's just a joke (She walks away.)
Prue: Ooh!
1x13: From Fear to Eternity
[Cut to the attic. Prue's sitting in a chair holding the Book Of Shadows. You see words magically appear on a page and their mother's voice saying: "Thanks for letting them in your heart."]
Prue: I miss you, Mom.
Choice #10. 1x14: Secrets and Guys
[Scene: Manor. Attic. A toy train goes across the floor. Phoebe picks it up. Piper is carrying a box of toys behind her. They go to a little table where Prue is sitting. Phoebe sits down. Piper puts the box down.]
Prue: Can you believe that? Dad's old train.
Piper: I can't believe you. You get mad at me for chasing monsters on my own.
Prue: Well, I figured I could handle it when I realized they weren't demons, but I probably should have asked for help.
Phoebe: Even though that killed you, and it almost did.
Prue: Live and learn.
Piper: Yeah, you didn't even get to say good-bye to Leo.
Phoebe: What is that supposed to mean?
Piper: I don't know. It's just weird. I felt like he was holding something back from me.
Prue: Holding something back? What do you mean?
Piper: Who knows? It just seems like he wasn't telling me the whole story. Like he had some secret he was afraid I couldn't handle.
Phoebe: Well, that's his call.(Prue and Piper give her the "what" look.)Uh, assuming that he had a secret. Might not of.
Piper: What are you talking about?
Phoebe: OK. OK. You don't have to beat it out of me. Leo is a whitelighter. They're sort of guardian angels for witches. And they're not supposed to get involved with witches. But Leo couldn't help it. He fell in love with you and that broke all the rules and got him in all sorts of trouble. And even though he'll love you forever, you will probably never see him again.
(Prue and Piper begin laughing.)
Piper: What? Phoebe, that's that's the most ridiculous thing I've ever heard. Oh, God. Don't be so silly. (Piper tosses Phoebe a doll.)
Phoebe: That's me. Silly.
Piper: I gotta go get some more tea. (She leaves.)
Prue: Yeah. You know, Pheebs. With an imagination like that, you should be writing children's books or something.
Phoebe: No. But I didn't even think of that. That's a really good idea, Prue.
(Phoebe moves the toy train to the box of toys going.)
Prue: Oh. Oh. (Prue grabs the toy train.) That stays here.
Phoebe: Wait. I thought all of the toys were going to the Salvation Army.
Prue: Well, like you said. We should save some for our children.
Phoebe: Do I scene a hormonal shift here?
Prue: It's no big deal. I just had some time to think.
Phoebe: Yeah. In all that spare time of yours.
Prue: And I realize that I do want kids. I think that I'd make a great mom.
Phoebe: So, did you save Max or did Max save you?
(Prue doesn't answer. Phoebe picks up the box and leaves.)
[Note from Es: I battled over Phoebe leaving means this one shouldn’t count, but since it doesn’t go back to Prue and show her alone, I decided it still counts as a Prue and Phoebe scene.]
Choice #11: 1x15: Is There a Woogy in the House?
[Scene: Manor. Attic. Prue, Piper and Phoebe are cleaning up.]
Prue: So, Morris said that it was only a two week suspension.
Piper: It doesn't seem fair; it wasn't even Andy's fault.
Prue: Well, what were we gonna do? Plead Shadows?
Piper: Anyway, everyone seems to be back to normal but that doesn't erase their actions.
Prue: Yeah, well, I wish it did; it could get me off Claire's bad side, if she has a good one.
Phoebe: I'm beginning to wonder if I have a good one. (Prue and Piper stare at her.) Well, I am. I mean not any more so than anyone else.
Prue: Yeah, well the important thing is the good side won out.
Phoebe: Yeah, but I must have been more susceptible than either one of you, otherwise he wouldn't of chosen me, right? Right?
Piper: You were the only one that was born in the house - that makes you more connected to it. That spiritual nexus thing.
Phoebe: That's exactly my point. I could go either way. Good or evil. Kinda freaky. I do have to tell you I am gonna miss that cool power though.
Piper: Um, if Grams put away the shadow and it came back…
Prue: Means it can come back again. Okay, it's time. Every witch before us has added to the Book of Shadows. We need to warn who comes next. It's our turn.
Phoebe: Who should do it?
(Prue hands Phoebe a pen; they find a blank page in the Book and she starts writing.)
1x16: Which Prue is It, Anyway?
[Scene: Andy's office. He has a folder of Prue's confidential files. He's looking through newspaper clippings and finds one on witchcraft. He then picks up the Bay Area Music Awards tickets and her fingerprints chart. He puts it all back in his drawer and sits back in his chair.]
Choice #12: 1x17: That Seventies Episode
[Scene: Prue and Phoebe are looking at photos. Piper brings in the vase of flowers.]
Phoebe: I can't stop thinking about Mom. I lost her and then I found her again.
Prue: I'm just glad you finally have memories of her.
(Phoebe points to the flowers.)
Piper: What? I'm supposed to throw out perfectly good flowers 'cause they came from a creep? If that was the rule then we'd never have flowers in this house.
Prue: Well, they didn't just come from a creep - they came from a warlock who tried to kill us.
Phoebe: Still, if it weren't for him, I probably never would’ve gotten to know Mom.
Piper: We all wanted to save Mom, Pheebs, but both Mom and Grams said we can't change destiny.
Phoebe: But, um, I still wrote her a note anyway.
Prue: You did?
Phoebe: Yes. I wrote her a note telling her to stay away from water on the day that she died. And then I put it in the Book of Shadows.
Piper: I can't believe you did that.
Phoebe: You don't understand. Every time I've made a wish, I wished for time with Mom. And I believed in my heart that someday, somehow, that wish would come true and when it finally did, I didn't want to let her go. You know, but then I realized that I had to let her go, so I took the note out and put it in my pocket.
Prue: Maturity sucks, doesn't it?
Piper: So faith has its rewards. (She shows them the picture that Phoebe took in the attic.) It's a pretty good one of us, but once again, not a great one of you, Pheebs.
Phoebe: Are you kidding? That is the best picture of me I've ever taken.
Choice #13: 1x18: When Bad Warlocks Go Good
[Prue walks over to a table where Piper and Phoebe are sitting.)
Piper: Well, you're not handcuffed, that's a good sign.
Phoebe: Depends on who's cuffing you. I'm joking.
Prue: I wonder how he knew that I would be here?
Phoebe: Are you kidding? We're always at Quake after we vanquish warlocks. Either here or at home.
(Piper sees Josh.)
Piper: Oh, there's Josh.
Phoebe: Oh man, that guy cannot take a hint. Piper, this is my fault, I'm the one that pushed you on him. So I will handle this okay.
Piper: It's okay. I called him. I decided it's time to try and work through my fears and trust my instincts.
Prue: Always a good thing to do.
Phoebe: Especially when they're that cute.
Josh: Piper. I'm a little surprised you called, I thought you were mad at me or something.
Piper: No, I just had to go to church. Table for two. Yes, you.
(They sit at a different table.)
Phoebe: You know, maybe I didn't do such a bad thing after all.
Prue: I'd say helping her get over falling for the wrong guy is a good thing. Now maybe you can help me with it.
Phoebe: Yeah, that's not fair, losing such a catch like Brendan to the priesthood. God's got all the studs.
Prue: Well, at least he's not a warlock anymore.
Phoebe: And at least Piper's not a nun.
Prue: Oh.
Phoebe: Right?
Prue: Right.
Choice #14: 1x19: Blind Sided
[Scene: Manor, Living Room. Prue, Piper and Phoebe are talking.]
Phoebe: Have they said anything?
Prue: No, they just got back from the hospital but who knows what they'll say once the police start questioning them.
Phoebe: So much for our secret. (to Piper) Hey, you okay?
Piper: Yeah, I was just thinking when I was in the storm drain I was kinda out of it and I kept thinking about Leo. That's weird.
Phoebe: Maybe you miss him.
Piper: Maybe.
Prue: What are you gonna do about Josh?
Piper: I'm gonna call him and tell him I think he should take the job in Beverly Hills.
Phoebe: But, sweetie, you can't hold out for Leo. I mean, who knows of he's ever gonna come back.
Piper: I know. He may not. But if I'm thinking about Leo, than I'm definitely not thinking about Josh.
Phoebe: That's too bad, he had really nice glutes. There's Brent. Hey Brent! Ah, over here. (Brent walks over) Hi.
Brent: Hi.
Phoebe: Where's your dog?
Brent: (He takes off his sunglasses.) He's retired.
Phoebe: You can see? But how did that...?
Brent: I don't know. I mean, you tell me. I mean someone must’ve slayed those monsters. Do you know anything about it? (Phoebe pretends to zip her mouth closed.) That's alright. If anyone knows the danger of telling amazing stories, I sure do. I was right - you do have a beautiful smile. Are those the boys?
Phoebe: Yeah
Brent: Maybe I should have a little talk with them.
Phoebe: That would be so great. Thank you.
Brent: No. Thank you.
(Andy walks up to Prue.)
Prue: So, now you know.
Andy: Yeah. It's still sinking in.
Prue: Where do we go from here?
Andy: That's a good question.
(Lots of reporters come up to Andy with cameras wanting to ask him questions as the sisters watch.)
Choice #15: 1x20: The Power of Two
[Scene: Halliwell Manor. Phoebe and Prue are bringing the groceries in the kitchen.]
Phoebe: So did you burn Andy's file like he suggested?
Prue: Yeah, you should’ve seen it. It turns out he knew a lot more about us than he's letting on.
Phoebe: Still doesn't explain how he could hear a ghost.
Prue: What do you mean?
Phoebe: Well, when you were a spirit you said you yelled out to him and that's what made him turn around in time. How could he hear you?
Prue: I don't know.
(Piper enters the room.)
Piper: Hi.
Phoebe: Piper, yay, I thought you weren't coming back until tomorrow.
Piper: I took an earlier flight. I had this terrible feeling you guys were um...
Prue: What?
Piper: Oh, I don't know, at each other's throats maybe.
Prue: Us?
Phoebe: Are you kidding?
Piper: So, nothing happened while I was gone?
Phoebe: No, just the same old boring stuff. Hey, you need a hand?
Prue: Uh, yeah, that would be great. Thanks, Pheebs.
(They start putting the groceries away.)
Choice #16: 1x21: Love Hurts
[Cut to downstairs.]
Phoebe: Is it just me or can you draw a chalk outline around this place?
Prue: Well, I don't know what you could possibly mean, Phoebe. I mean the weekend's almost over; we never made it to Cabo; I'm never gonna see Andy again; and Piper just lost the love of her life.
Phoebe: The glass is way more than half way full here, Prue. Piper saved the love of her life; Alec is long gone, and Daisy's on her way back to her family. And we even managed to straighten out our powers, thank God. (She gets two pineapples with straws out of the fridge.)
Prue: Thank God? I thought that you always wanted an active power.
Phoebe: Maybe, but I never thought I'd actually miss my premonitions. Your power was like wearing a dress that was too tight. Not that that would ever happen.
Prue: Remember when I said you had no vision.
Phoebe: Which time?
Prue: Well, you would never hear it again. It takes a lot of strength to see what you see.
Phoebe: I'll drink to that. We can't go to Cabo, we might as well bring Cabo to us.
Prue: I don't know, Pheebs. We still have some serious problems. (She plays some reggae music on the CD player.)
Phoebe: Problems are for Monday mornings. What do you say?
Prue: It's gonna be a hell of a Monday morning but until then...
(They use their pineapples to toast.)
1x22: Déjà vu All Over Again
(Piper and Phoebe walk outside where Prue is sitting on the steps.)
Piper: Prue, are you alright?
Prue: Actually I am. Andy's been exonerated; they are now looking for Rodriguez.
Piper: Good luck.
Phoebe: Hey, are you sure you're alright?
Prue: Yeah. I was just thinking all that we've been through since we became witches.
Piper: Rodriguez give you a headache?
Prue: No actually, it gave me a good feeling. I mean, look, it's a hassle and can sometimes screw up our personal lives.
Piper: Amen to that.
Prue: And we do good things together. Helps offset the bad things.
Phoebe: I'm gonna really miss Andy.
Piper: It's gonna be very sad without him.
Prue: Something tells me that he'll always be with us. We better get ready for work.
Piper: I'll tell her later.
Prue: Tell me what?
Piper: Nothing. It's not important.
Phoebe: Nothing. Nothing.
(They walk inside and Prue points at the door and it swings shut.)
[Note from Es: Once more, the last scene is really Prue using her power to close the door, so this won’t be part of the poll.]
SEASON ONE SUMMARY, using my rules:
Endings with at least two sisters: 16
Endings with all three sisters: 11 (Half! Bet that never happens again!)
Endings with two sisters: 5
Endings with one sister: 5
Ending with no sister (just Andy): 1
Endings with just Prue and Piper: 0
Endings with just Prue and Phoebe: 4
Endings with just Piper and Phoebe: 1
Endings with just Prue and Andy: 2
Endings with just Prue: 3
Endings with just Piper: 0
Endings with just Phoebe: 0
No doubt that Power of Three was important, Prue and Andy were *the* couple, and Shannen Doherty was the star...
RULES:
1) Only the very last scene counts...for this poll, as soon as they change scenery, it’s a different scene.
2) There must be two sisters (Prue, Piper and/or Phoebe) as part of the final scene. There can be more than two sisters and there can be other characters as part of the scene, but if at the end, there’s just one sister or no sister, the scene won't be part of this poll.
3) If the last scene starts with all three sisters together, but more than one leave before the end, leaving only one sister with another character as the ending, the scene does not count.
4) If anyone wants to redo this poll with different rules, GO FOR IT!
5) Even if the scene isn’t part of this poll, enjoy all of these memories!
DISCLAIMER: In all situations, these fan-written transcripts come from transcripts.foreverdreaming.org/viewtopic.php?t=6051 I’m bolding the name each time one of the sisters first appears in the scene or each time a sister leaves the scene so I can see if the scene counts.
CHARMED: SEASON ONE FINAL SCENES
1x01: Something Wicca This Way Comes
[Scene: Halliwell manor. It's morning. Prue walks outside and grabs the paper.]
Andy: Good morning! (He's holding a paper and a cup of coffee.)
Prue: Hey, this is a surprise.
Andy: I've been feeling really guilty about that bad cup of coffee. I just want to make it up to you.
Prue: So, you brought me a good cup of coffee?
Andy: Oh this? No, this is mine. I, uh, just wanted to ask you out to dinner. Unless of course you're afraid.
Prue: Afraid of what?
Andy: Oh, you know, having too good of time, stirring up old memories, rekindling and old flame.
Prue: Hmm, good point, better not.
Andy: Okay. Friday night, eight o'clock? You're hesitating.
Prue: Yeah, but it's not what you think. It's just that my life has gotten a bit complicated. Can I call you?
(He gives her his card.)
Andy: Take care, Prue.
Prue: Bye, Andy.
(He walks to his car. Phoebe and Piper come outside. Phoebe's holding the cat.)
Phoebe: It's Andy. I told you I heard a man's voice.
Piper: What did he want?
Prue: He asked me out.
Piper: And you said...?
Prue: I started to say yes and then I stopped. I wondered if I could date. I mean, do witches date?
Piper: Not only do they date but they usually get the best guys.
Prue: You two will not be laughing when this happens to you. Believe me, everything will be different now.
Phoebe: Well, at least our lives won't be boring.
Prue: But they'll never be the same.
Phoebe: And this is a bad thing?
Prue: No. But it could be a big problem.
Piper: Prue's right. What are we gonna do?
Phoebe: What can't we do?
Prue: We are gonna be careful, we're gonna be wise and we're gonna stick together.
Piper: This should be interesting.
(Prue stands inside the house, looks at the door and shuts it with her power.)
[Note from Es: Since both Piper and Phoebe leave the scene and we only see Prue, so much as I personally love this whole scene, it won’t be part of this poll.]
Choice #1: 1x02: I’ve Got You Under My Skin
[Scene: Quake. Phoebe walks in.]
Phoebe: Whoops, excuse me. (She walks up to a woman.) Hey, how are you? (The woman looks at her strangely. She goes over to Prue and Piper.)
Piper: Do you know that girl?
Phoebe: I almost was that girl. She was one of Stefan's victims. Obviously doesn't remember.
Prue: Lucky her.
Phoebe: No, lucky me. I learned my lesson. I have got to be more careful.
Prue: Excuse me, did I just hear it? Did she actually admit to doing something wrong?
Piper: That's what I heard.
Phoebe: Frame it. It won't happen again.
Piper: At least we helped those people. I mean, it's nice we know our powers really are good.
Prue: Yeah, good for everything but love lives unfortunately. Although I must admit they do come in handy once in a while.
Phoebe: Uh huh. Hypocrite. (Phoebe sees the lottery numbers come up on the TV screen.) The winning numbers. I've won. (Prue gives her a look.) Well, I did.
(She gets the ticket out of her purse and the numbers disappear.)
Prue: See, I told you. You can't intentionally use your powers for your own personal gain, remember?
Phoebe: It's a good thing I didn't take the tags off that dress. Oh, well. At least those old couples didn't lose their house.
Piper: A toast to the Power of Three. Whether we like it or not.
Choice #2: 1x03: Thank You for Not Morphing
[Time lapse. Prue, Piper and Phoebe are watching the video. On the video it's Christmas. Prue, Piper and Phoebe are there as kids. They are opening their presents. Victor kisses Prue on the cheek and then grabs Piper and lifts her in the air. He then asks what Phoebe got and she holds up a Barbie.]
Choice #3: 1x04: Dead Man Dating
[Scene: Manor. Prue, Piper and Phoebe walk inside.]
Prue: You know what? I've changed my mind. Maybe I should have a party after all.
Phoebe: Are you serious?
Prue: Yeah, why not? I mean, Mark is right.
Piper: Well, Prue, I'm glad you said that 'cause...
(They walk in the living room and there stands a room full of people.)
Everyone: Surprise!
Piper: Did I getcha? I gotcha.
Prue: Yeah, you got me.
Piper: Yeah.
Phoebe: And an actual present too. It's paid for. (She hands Prue a present.) I hope you like it.
Prue: I'm speechless.
(They hug. Prue sees Andy standing across the room. They smile at each other.)
1x05: Dream Sorcerer
[Scene: Hospital. Piper and Phoebe are carrying bunches and bunches of flowers into Prue's room.] Phoebe: Knock, knock.
Prue: Please, tell me you guys are here to pick me up.
Piper: Hi. No, Dr. Black said one more day. Just to be sure.
Phoebe: Yeah, and you know, it wouldn't kill you to get some rest. (She realizes what she just said and covers her mouth.)
Prue: Phoebe, it's okay. Thanks for the flowers.
Piper: Yeah.
(Phoebe laughs.)
Prue: What's going on?
Phoebe: Oh, long story, not very interesting.
Prue: Does this have anything to do with your lust spell?
Phoebe: Mmm hmm. But don't worry. Piper: We reversed the spell last night.
Phoebe: Piper called Jack.
Prue: The guy that you had dinner with?
Piper: And he didn't remember anything. And Phoebe called Hans...
Phoebe: And he didn't remember anything.
Piper: So, don't worry. Everything is back to normal.
Prue: Good.
(Andy walks in carrying a red rose and some take-away.)
Andy: Afternoon, ladies. Surprise.
Prue: Yes. It is. (Prue looks at Phoebe.)
Phoebe: What are you looking at me for? I didn't tell him.
(Prue then looks at Piper.)
Piper: Guilty. Come on, let's go.
Phoebe: Okay, bye.
Piper: Um, we'll see you later tonight.
Phoebe: After we raid your closet. (They leave.)
Andy: Brought your favourite.
(He hands Prue the take-away bag and she looks in it.)
Prue: Oh, cheeseburgers and fries.
Andy: Glad to see every bone in your body's not broken.
Prue: What?
Andy: The car accident. Never mind.
(Andy gives Prue the rose.)
[Note from Es: Since Piper and Phoebe left, this one doesn’t count.]
Choice #4: 1x06: The Wedding from Hell
[Scene: Outside the Spencer's house. Elliot and Allison are together hugging and kissing. Prue, Piper and Phoebe are nearby.]
Prue: We did that.
Phoebe: And they'll live happily ever after.
Piper: I wonder if we will.
Prue: Of course, we will. Why shouldn't we?
Piper: That's easy for you to say. You'll never greet your husband at the door with: "Honey, I think I froze the kids."
Prue: No, I've just accidentally moved them to another zip code.
Phoebe: But I will see them, find them, and bring them back safely. If I can ever learn to control my powers.
Piper: If any of us can.
Phoebe: Just think of the obstacles that Allison and Elliot have overcome. If they can do it, so can we.
Prue: I guess true love does conquer all.
Phoebe: Especially if you have separate bathrooms.
(They see Andy walking towards them.)
Piper: Speaking of true love...
Phoebe: Ooh. Andy: Fancy seeing you here.
Prue: Yeah, isn't it? (She holds up the poingnard.) Uh, I wanted to give this back to you. I'm finished with it.
Andy: How'd you know I'd be here? (He takes it off of her.)
Prue: I didn't. I was gonna drop it off after the wedding.
Andy: Aha, shall we talk about this in private, Prue?
(Andy puts his arm around Prue and they walk away.)
Phoebe: Do you believe in destiny?
(They giggle.)
Piper: He believes in destiny. Shh.
1x07: The Fourth Sister
[Scene: Outside Andy's house. Prue is in her car waiting for Andy. He pulls up in his car. Prue gets out and so Andy.]
Prue: Hey.
Andy: Hey.
(He walks towards his door and so does Prue.)
Prue: Uh, can we talk?
Andy: Is there really anything to talk about?
Prue: Andy? (He stops and turns around.) I'm sorry.
Andy: So am I!
Prue: What do you mean by that?
Andy: I mean, come on, Prue. Who we kidding? I mean, let's face it. One of us is obviously more interested in this relationship than the other.
Prue: That's not true.
Andy: Isn't it? Then how come I'm always the one left standing there looking like a jerk?
Prue: I can explain.
Andy: No, you can't. Or you won't. (He goes up the stairs and stops at the top. He throws the jacket on the ground.) Damn it Prue. I still love you. I'm not saying you have to explain it all to me, Prue. (Prue walks up to him.) That’s your prerogative. All I'm saying is it hurts that you don't trust me enough.
Prue: I do trust you, Andy. It has nothing to do with you. It's just…it's just something that I don't know if I can ever share with anybody.
Andy: Well I hope that's not true for your sake. All I know is there's nothing I can say or do to reassure you that I'm there for you. (He grabs his coat and walks up the stairs.)
Prue: Andy? (He stops half-way and turns around.) Are you saying that you don't want to see me anymore?
Andy: I don't know what I want anymore.
Choice #5: 1x08: The Truth is Out There and It Hurts
[Cut to Phoebe. Prue walks up to the table.]
Prue: Hey.
Phoebe: Hey. How'd it go?
Prue: Not well.
Phoebe: Oh, Prue, I'm so sorry.
Prue: Yeah, me too, but I cast the spell for an answer and I got it. Even if it wasn't the one I wanted. (They hug.)
Choice #6: 1x09: The Witch is Back
(Piper goes back upstairs in the attic.)
Phoebe: Who was it?
Piper: It was Leo.
Prue: Is he gone?
Piper: We're perfectly safe.
Melinda: Then let's begin.
(Piper joins the others around the table. Melinda is dressed in her normal clothes. She hands Phoebe's dress back to her.)
Phoebe: Oh, we can't take those back.
Melinda: Why not?
Phoebe: Because that means you're leaving.
Melinda: Well, I have to go.
Phoebe: Why? Why can't you stay here and have the life that you should've had?
Melinda: Because this isn't my time. It's your time, and Prue's and Piper's.
Piper: We don't mind sharing.
Melinda: You three give me great joy. I've seen the Charmed Ones. Good witches. Women of strength and grace.
(Phoebe takes Melinda's hand and holds it up to her heart.)
Phoebe: Tell me what you see. Melinda: I see the future. Many more generations of my beautiful daughters. I see my dreams fulfilled. Oh, thank you for that. (She puts on the locket and they all join hands.)
Prue: "Melinda Warren, blood of our blood, we release you."
Melinda: Blessed be, my daughters. I love you.
(Stardust surrounds her and she disappears.)
Phoebe: I'm gonna miss her.
Piper: Me too.
Prue: We can always bring her back.
Choice #7: 1x10: Wicca Envy
[Scene: Manor. Attic. Prue, Piper and Phoebe are looking through the Book Of Shadows.]
Piper: Spells, incantations, demons stuff. It's all here. Everything just like before.
Phoebe: Thank God.
Prue: But how? I mean, we certainly didn't reverse the spell.
Phoebe: Maybe we screwed it up. (Prue and Piper look at her.) What? It's not like it would be the first time.
Prue: No, we didn't screw it up. Something or someone must have done it. It couldn't happened on its own.
Piper: Why not? It's magic.
(Leo enters the attic.)
Leo: Knock, knock.
Piper: Leo.
Leo: The front door was open. I hope it's all right. I left my tool box.
Piper: That's funny. I don't remember that being there last night.
Leo: Yeah, well, you know what Freud always said about leaving things.
Piper: That you secretly wanted to come back for it.
Leo: Guilty.
Prue: Oh, don't use that word.
Phoebe: Uh, it's a long story. Never mind.
(Phoebe and Prue walk away.)
Piper: Leo, you're leaving, aren't you?
Leo: Yeah, afraid so.
Piper: Do you really have to go?
Leo: Well, I've fixed everything I came here to fix. But I'll be back. Promise.
(Leo kisses Piper as Prue and Phoebe watch.) Nothing can keep me away from you too long.
(Leo grabs his toolbox and leaves.)
Piper: Well, at least he wasn't a warlock.
Phoebe: Hey, you don't suppose Leo was the, uh...(Prue rips the relinquishment spell out of the Book.) What are you doing?
Prue: Just getting rid the Relinquishment spell. Now we've got our powers back I certainly I don't want to risk losing them again.
Piper: I second that.
Phoebe: Third.
Prue: So, witches forever?
Phoebe: And damn proud of it.
(Piper lights a match and burns the page.)
Choice #8: 1x11: Feats of Clay
[Scene: Quake. Prue, Piper and Phoebe are sitting at the bar.]
Piper: Good thing we didn't have to end up using our powers to vanquish her. Otherwise Clay would've seen her.
Prue: They didn't work anyway.
Phoebe: Not something I hope ever happens again.
(Doug walks along holding a tray of glasses. Shelley walks near him.)
Piper: Ooh, ooh, forgot about Doug.
(Doug drops the tray and Piper freezes it in mid-air.)
Prue: This is getting ridiculous.
Piper: Oh, tell me about it. That engagement ring's probably stopped burning a hole in his apron. (Prue gets up and walks over to Doug.) Where are you going? What are you doing?
Prue: Saving your problem and keeping you employed.
(Prue takes a ring box out of Doug's pocket and puts it on the floor. She sits back down and they unfreeze. The tray falls on the floor.)
Doug: Sorry.
(Shelley notices the ring on the floor.)
Shelley: What's that? (She picks it up and opens it. She gasps.)
Doug: I was carrying that around for weeks, trying to find the right time to ask you.
Shelley: Ask me what?
Doug: To, um, marry me.
Shelley: But that's why I broke up with you. I gave up on waiting.
(They smile and hug.)
Piper: This would've happened sooner if I would've keep my little wicca nose out of their business.
Phoebe: You can't change people; they have to change themselves.
Prue: Speaking of that. Yum. (Clay walks towards them.) Go, baby.
Piper: Go, girl.
Phoebe: Alright.
Piper: You go. You can do it.
(They laugh. Phoebe walks up to Clay.)
Clay: Hey.
Phoebe: Hey. I'm glad you stopped by.
Clay: Any chance you're gonna come back with me?
Phoebe: No. This is my home now.
Clay: I know I lied to you about a lot of things. But one thing I never lied to you about was how much I care about you.
Phoebe: I know, Clay.
(They kiss.)
Clay: I guess I should be going.
Phoebe: Yeah.
Clay: Um, you know, I hope the next time we cross paths, I'll be the guy you always think you see.
Phoebe: Goodbye.
(He leaves. Prue and Piper walk up to her.)
Prue: Are you okay?
Phoebe: Oh, yeah, yeah, he was just stopping by on his way home, no big deal.
Piper: Heard that before.
(Prue and Piper hug her.)
Choice #9: 1x12: The Wendigo
[Scene: Quake. Phoebe and Prue are sitting at a table. Piper brings them some drinks.]
Piper: On the house for saving my hide.
Phoebe: Literally, you Wendigo you.
(Piper sits down.)
Prue: Are you okay to work?
Piper: Yeah, I'm fine. It's like nothing ever happened. Except for Billy.
Prue: No, well, there was no way that you could've known about Agent Fallon.
Piper: I know. It's just I'm not used to losing an innocent we're supposed to protect.
Phoebe: He wanted to help stop her so she couldn't hurt anybody else and that's exactly what he did.
Prue: I'm just grateful that you're safe.
Piper: And Andy. By the way, what did you tell him about why we were all there?
Prue: I told him the truth.
Phoebe: Get out.
Prue: I did. I said what he saw happened was true, that Agent Fallon really was the Wendigo and that had we not vanquished her, that both he and Piper would've been killed. I couldn't think of anything else to say.
Piper: Well, what did he say?
Prue: Not much. He was either too stunned to speak or he actually believed me on some level. This was as close that we've ever come to having an honest conversation.
Phoebe: So maybe Andy's more open to you being a witch than you think.
Prue: Hmm. Alright, back to work.
Phoebe: Actually, I need to talk to you about something and please don't be mad but I quit.
Prue: What?
Phoebe: It's not that I don't appreciate the opportunity because I do. It's just that every time touch something at Bucklands I risk having a premonition and it's just too emotional for me. Besides that's your world. I need to find one of my own.
Prue: You will.
Piper: Just stay out of my world or I'll kill you. (Prue and Phoebe look worried and confused. Piper gets up and starts to walk away. She turns around.) Kidding! It's just a joke (She walks away.)
Prue: Ooh!
1x13: From Fear to Eternity
[Cut to the attic. Prue's sitting in a chair holding the Book Of Shadows. You see words magically appear on a page and their mother's voice saying: "Thanks for letting them in your heart."]
Prue: I miss you, Mom.
Choice #10. 1x14: Secrets and Guys
[Scene: Manor. Attic. A toy train goes across the floor. Phoebe picks it up. Piper is carrying a box of toys behind her. They go to a little table where Prue is sitting. Phoebe sits down. Piper puts the box down.]
Prue: Can you believe that? Dad's old train.
Piper: I can't believe you. You get mad at me for chasing monsters on my own.
Prue: Well, I figured I could handle it when I realized they weren't demons, but I probably should have asked for help.
Phoebe: Even though that killed you, and it almost did.
Prue: Live and learn.
Piper: Yeah, you didn't even get to say good-bye to Leo.
Phoebe: What is that supposed to mean?
Piper: I don't know. It's just weird. I felt like he was holding something back from me.
Prue: Holding something back? What do you mean?
Piper: Who knows? It just seems like he wasn't telling me the whole story. Like he had some secret he was afraid I couldn't handle.
Phoebe: Well, that's his call.(Prue and Piper give her the "what" look.)Uh, assuming that he had a secret. Might not of.
Piper: What are you talking about?
Phoebe: OK. OK. You don't have to beat it out of me. Leo is a whitelighter. They're sort of guardian angels for witches. And they're not supposed to get involved with witches. But Leo couldn't help it. He fell in love with you and that broke all the rules and got him in all sorts of trouble. And even though he'll love you forever, you will probably never see him again.
(Prue and Piper begin laughing.)
Piper: What? Phoebe, that's that's the most ridiculous thing I've ever heard. Oh, God. Don't be so silly. (Piper tosses Phoebe a doll.)
Phoebe: That's me. Silly.
Piper: I gotta go get some more tea. (She leaves.)
Prue: Yeah. You know, Pheebs. With an imagination like that, you should be writing children's books or something.
Phoebe: No. But I didn't even think of that. That's a really good idea, Prue.
(Phoebe moves the toy train to the box of toys going.)
Prue: Oh. Oh. (Prue grabs the toy train.) That stays here.
Phoebe: Wait. I thought all of the toys were going to the Salvation Army.
Prue: Well, like you said. We should save some for our children.
Phoebe: Do I scene a hormonal shift here?
Prue: It's no big deal. I just had some time to think.
Phoebe: Yeah. In all that spare time of yours.
Prue: And I realize that I do want kids. I think that I'd make a great mom.
Phoebe: So, did you save Max or did Max save you?
(Prue doesn't answer. Phoebe picks up the box and leaves.)
[Note from Es: I battled over Phoebe leaving means this one shouldn’t count, but since it doesn’t go back to Prue and show her alone, I decided it still counts as a Prue and Phoebe scene.]
Choice #11: 1x15: Is There a Woogy in the House?
[Scene: Manor. Attic. Prue, Piper and Phoebe are cleaning up.]
Prue: So, Morris said that it was only a two week suspension.
Piper: It doesn't seem fair; it wasn't even Andy's fault.
Prue: Well, what were we gonna do? Plead Shadows?
Piper: Anyway, everyone seems to be back to normal but that doesn't erase their actions.
Prue: Yeah, well, I wish it did; it could get me off Claire's bad side, if she has a good one.
Phoebe: I'm beginning to wonder if I have a good one. (Prue and Piper stare at her.) Well, I am. I mean not any more so than anyone else.
Prue: Yeah, well the important thing is the good side won out.
Phoebe: Yeah, but I must have been more susceptible than either one of you, otherwise he wouldn't of chosen me, right? Right?
Piper: You were the only one that was born in the house - that makes you more connected to it. That spiritual nexus thing.
Phoebe: That's exactly my point. I could go either way. Good or evil. Kinda freaky. I do have to tell you I am gonna miss that cool power though.
Piper: Um, if Grams put away the shadow and it came back…
Prue: Means it can come back again. Okay, it's time. Every witch before us has added to the Book of Shadows. We need to warn who comes next. It's our turn.
Phoebe: Who should do it?
(Prue hands Phoebe a pen; they find a blank page in the Book and she starts writing.)
1x16: Which Prue is It, Anyway?
[Scene: Andy's office. He has a folder of Prue's confidential files. He's looking through newspaper clippings and finds one on witchcraft. He then picks up the Bay Area Music Awards tickets and her fingerprints chart. He puts it all back in his drawer and sits back in his chair.]
Choice #12: 1x17: That Seventies Episode
[Scene: Prue and Phoebe are looking at photos. Piper brings in the vase of flowers.]
Phoebe: I can't stop thinking about Mom. I lost her and then I found her again.
Prue: I'm just glad you finally have memories of her.
(Phoebe points to the flowers.)
Piper: What? I'm supposed to throw out perfectly good flowers 'cause they came from a creep? If that was the rule then we'd never have flowers in this house.
Prue: Well, they didn't just come from a creep - they came from a warlock who tried to kill us.
Phoebe: Still, if it weren't for him, I probably never would’ve gotten to know Mom.
Piper: We all wanted to save Mom, Pheebs, but both Mom and Grams said we can't change destiny.
Phoebe: But, um, I still wrote her a note anyway.
Prue: You did?
Phoebe: Yes. I wrote her a note telling her to stay away from water on the day that she died. And then I put it in the Book of Shadows.
Piper: I can't believe you did that.
Phoebe: You don't understand. Every time I've made a wish, I wished for time with Mom. And I believed in my heart that someday, somehow, that wish would come true and when it finally did, I didn't want to let her go. You know, but then I realized that I had to let her go, so I took the note out and put it in my pocket.
Prue: Maturity sucks, doesn't it?
Piper: So faith has its rewards. (She shows them the picture that Phoebe took in the attic.) It's a pretty good one of us, but once again, not a great one of you, Pheebs.
Phoebe: Are you kidding? That is the best picture of me I've ever taken.
Choice #13: 1x18: When Bad Warlocks Go Good
[Prue walks over to a table where Piper and Phoebe are sitting.)
Piper: Well, you're not handcuffed, that's a good sign.
Phoebe: Depends on who's cuffing you. I'm joking.
Prue: I wonder how he knew that I would be here?
Phoebe: Are you kidding? We're always at Quake after we vanquish warlocks. Either here or at home.
(Piper sees Josh.)
Piper: Oh, there's Josh.
Phoebe: Oh man, that guy cannot take a hint. Piper, this is my fault, I'm the one that pushed you on him. So I will handle this okay.
Piper: It's okay. I called him. I decided it's time to try and work through my fears and trust my instincts.
Prue: Always a good thing to do.
Phoebe: Especially when they're that cute.
Josh: Piper. I'm a little surprised you called, I thought you were mad at me or something.
Piper: No, I just had to go to church. Table for two. Yes, you.
(They sit at a different table.)
Phoebe: You know, maybe I didn't do such a bad thing after all.
Prue: I'd say helping her get over falling for the wrong guy is a good thing. Now maybe you can help me with it.
Phoebe: Yeah, that's not fair, losing such a catch like Brendan to the priesthood. God's got all the studs.
Prue: Well, at least he's not a warlock anymore.
Phoebe: And at least Piper's not a nun.
Prue: Oh.
Phoebe: Right?
Prue: Right.
Choice #14: 1x19: Blind Sided
[Scene: Manor, Living Room. Prue, Piper and Phoebe are talking.]
Phoebe: Have they said anything?
Prue: No, they just got back from the hospital but who knows what they'll say once the police start questioning them.
Phoebe: So much for our secret. (to Piper) Hey, you okay?
Piper: Yeah, I was just thinking when I was in the storm drain I was kinda out of it and I kept thinking about Leo. That's weird.
Phoebe: Maybe you miss him.
Piper: Maybe.
Prue: What are you gonna do about Josh?
Piper: I'm gonna call him and tell him I think he should take the job in Beverly Hills.
Phoebe: But, sweetie, you can't hold out for Leo. I mean, who knows of he's ever gonna come back.
Piper: I know. He may not. But if I'm thinking about Leo, than I'm definitely not thinking about Josh.
Phoebe: That's too bad, he had really nice glutes. There's Brent. Hey Brent! Ah, over here. (Brent walks over) Hi.
Brent: Hi.
Phoebe: Where's your dog?
Brent: (He takes off his sunglasses.) He's retired.
Phoebe: You can see? But how did that...?
Brent: I don't know. I mean, you tell me. I mean someone must’ve slayed those monsters. Do you know anything about it? (Phoebe pretends to zip her mouth closed.) That's alright. If anyone knows the danger of telling amazing stories, I sure do. I was right - you do have a beautiful smile. Are those the boys?
Phoebe: Yeah
Brent: Maybe I should have a little talk with them.
Phoebe: That would be so great. Thank you.
Brent: No. Thank you.
(Andy walks up to Prue.)
Prue: So, now you know.
Andy: Yeah. It's still sinking in.
Prue: Where do we go from here?
Andy: That's a good question.
(Lots of reporters come up to Andy with cameras wanting to ask him questions as the sisters watch.)
Choice #15: 1x20: The Power of Two
[Scene: Halliwell Manor. Phoebe and Prue are bringing the groceries in the kitchen.]
Phoebe: So did you burn Andy's file like he suggested?
Prue: Yeah, you should’ve seen it. It turns out he knew a lot more about us than he's letting on.
Phoebe: Still doesn't explain how he could hear a ghost.
Prue: What do you mean?
Phoebe: Well, when you were a spirit you said you yelled out to him and that's what made him turn around in time. How could he hear you?
Prue: I don't know.
(Piper enters the room.)
Piper: Hi.
Phoebe: Piper, yay, I thought you weren't coming back until tomorrow.
Piper: I took an earlier flight. I had this terrible feeling you guys were um...
Prue: What?
Piper: Oh, I don't know, at each other's throats maybe.
Prue: Us?
Phoebe: Are you kidding?
Piper: So, nothing happened while I was gone?
Phoebe: No, just the same old boring stuff. Hey, you need a hand?
Prue: Uh, yeah, that would be great. Thanks, Pheebs.
(They start putting the groceries away.)
Choice #16: 1x21: Love Hurts
[Cut to downstairs.]
Phoebe: Is it just me or can you draw a chalk outline around this place?
Prue: Well, I don't know what you could possibly mean, Phoebe. I mean the weekend's almost over; we never made it to Cabo; I'm never gonna see Andy again; and Piper just lost the love of her life.
Phoebe: The glass is way more than half way full here, Prue. Piper saved the love of her life; Alec is long gone, and Daisy's on her way back to her family. And we even managed to straighten out our powers, thank God. (She gets two pineapples with straws out of the fridge.)
Prue: Thank God? I thought that you always wanted an active power.
Phoebe: Maybe, but I never thought I'd actually miss my premonitions. Your power was like wearing a dress that was too tight. Not that that would ever happen.
Prue: Remember when I said you had no vision.
Phoebe: Which time?
Prue: Well, you would never hear it again. It takes a lot of strength to see what you see.
Phoebe: I'll drink to that. We can't go to Cabo, we might as well bring Cabo to us.
Prue: I don't know, Pheebs. We still have some serious problems. (She plays some reggae music on the CD player.)
Phoebe: Problems are for Monday mornings. What do you say?
Prue: It's gonna be a hell of a Monday morning but until then...
(They use their pineapples to toast.)
1x22: Déjà vu All Over Again
(Piper and Phoebe walk outside where Prue is sitting on the steps.)
Piper: Prue, are you alright?
Prue: Actually I am. Andy's been exonerated; they are now looking for Rodriguez.
Piper: Good luck.
Phoebe: Hey, are you sure you're alright?
Prue: Yeah. I was just thinking all that we've been through since we became witches.
Piper: Rodriguez give you a headache?
Prue: No actually, it gave me a good feeling. I mean, look, it's a hassle and can sometimes screw up our personal lives.
Piper: Amen to that.
Prue: And we do good things together. Helps offset the bad things.
Phoebe: I'm gonna really miss Andy.
Piper: It's gonna be very sad without him.
Prue: Something tells me that he'll always be with us. We better get ready for work.
Piper: I'll tell her later.
Prue: Tell me what?
Piper: Nothing. It's not important.
Phoebe: Nothing. Nothing.
(They walk inside and Prue points at the door and it swings shut.)
[Note from Es: Once more, the last scene is really Prue using her power to close the door, so this won’t be part of the poll.]
SEASON ONE SUMMARY, using my rules:
Endings with at least two sisters: 16
Endings with all three sisters: 11 (Half! Bet that never happens again!)
Endings with two sisters: 5
Endings with one sister: 5
Ending with no sister (just Andy): 1
Endings with just Prue and Piper: 0
Endings with just Prue and Phoebe: 4
Endings with just Piper and Phoebe: 1
Endings with just Prue and Andy: 2
Endings with just Prue: 3
Endings with just Piper: 0
Endings with just Phoebe: 0
No doubt that Power of Three was important, Prue and Andy were *the* couple, and Shannen Doherty was the star...
