Which was your favourite room in the Manor?

[forbuss]

What room did you enjoy the most? Which was your favourite and why? Which rooms would you have liked to see more or less of? Do you think I should have included the 'laundry room' and 'garage' on this list?

*NOTE

For the purposes of this poll the bedroom definitions are as follows:

Master Bedroom: The room Prue gave to Piper and Leo so they would have more Paige.
Paige's Bedroom: The bedroom Piper originally had and then was vacant until Paige moved into it.
Phoebe's Bedroom: This one is easy because she's the only sister not to have changed rooms! Unless you count moving out...

This is the best picture I could find of the main floor:

[BriannaWarren2.0]

I loved the attic however I do wished it was more organized. 

In my view, I would have loved to see these spaces in the attic: 

- Use the Victorian-esque lounges for a sitting area.
- Bookshelves for the magical supplies/books.
- A permanent alter set up, for spells.
- A desk for spell writing with a blessed pen. 

I just would have loved it if they set up these spaces properly. 

[CharmedHungary]

This is hard. I'd say probably the kitchen or the attic. The sunroom, dining area, TV room/Living room, sitting room & entrance seems like a whole.

[Too Much Coffee]

Oh man, this is so hard to pick just one, but going to go with the attic.

[Elle Em]

Sept 30, 2020 23:56:46 GMT -5 BriannaWarren2.0 said:

I loved the attic however I do wished it was more organized. 

In my view, I would have loved to see these spaces in the attic: 

- Use the Victorian-esque lounges for a sitting area.
- Bookshelves for the magical supplies/books.
- A permanent alter set up, for spells.
- A desk for spell writing with a blessed pen. 

I just would have loved it if they set up these spaces properly. 

This would be cool. It was mostly a place for storage and they didn't have any one specific space for anything except the book. It was definitely a large enough space to have the defined areas you mentioned. 

I also like the sitting room.

[BriannaWarren2.0]

Oct 1, 2020 8:35:55 GMT -5 Elle Em said:

Sept 30, 2020 23:56:46 GMT -5 BriannaWarren2.0 said:

I loved the attic however I do wished it was more organized. 

In my view, I would have loved to see these spaces in the attic: 

- Use the Victorian-esque lounges for a sitting area.
- Bookshelves for the magical supplies/books.
- A permanent alter set up, for spells.
- A desk for spell writing with a blessed pen. 

I just would have loved it if they set up these spaces properly. 

This would be cool. It was mostly a place for storage and they didn't have any one specific space for anything except the book. It was definitely a large enough space to have the defined areas you mentioned. 

I also like the sitting room.

I would have loved it if Phoebe organized the attic while she was unemployed. If I was Prue, I would have made it a rule that if you are unemployed you study the book, practice your power and make sure the attic is organized. 

So in the first season you see Phoebe getting everything done and studying the book, teaching her sisters about warlocks/demons overall being knowledgeable about magic. 

[Melinda Halliwell]

Ooh this is hard for me because I loved the manor as a house with the Victorian architecture, stain glassed windows, and furnishings.

I guess since the Sunroom was light and airy having plants in that and led to the garden that would be my first choice then.



And then my second choice would be either the Kitchen.




Or Prue then Piper and Leo's room because of how big it was with lots of storage, side closet room then used for Wyatt and Chris's nurseries, and a toilet also encase the bathroom one was been used already then.

[Sasha]

I really like the design of the sunroom, it always looked so pretty to me.

[Elle Em]

Oct 1, 2020 23:14:09 GMT -5 BriannaWarren2.0 said:

Oct 1, 2020 8:35:55 GMT -5 Elle Em said:

This would be cool. It was mostly a place for storage and they didn't have any one specific space for anything except the book. It was definitely a large enough space to have the defined areas you mentioned. 

I also like the sitting room.

I would have loved it if Phoebe organized the attic while she was unemployed. If I was Prue, I would have made it a rule that if you are unemployed you study the book, practice your power and make sure the attic is organized. 

So in the first season you see Phoebe getting everything done and studying the book, teaching her sisters about warlocks/demons overall being knowledgeable about magic. 

This makes sense. I never understood how it was okay for Phoebe to not work, but also not be their designated magic person or at the very least the person who takes care of the house. I'm thinking of the fit she threw about Prue giving her that to-do list in season 1 when Piper was out of town. If she were busy studying the book and making potions and spells and learning things about magic to then teach her sisters, I'd totally understand. But she didn't seem to do any of that.

I remember also when Piper was in the hospital in season 2 and told Prue to leave and go to work, and told Phoebe to go do "whatever it is you do," or something like that. Prue and Piper worked too hard for Phoebe to just do nothing. 

[forbuss]

The manor is probably the most beautiful home set I've saw in any TV show to date.

[BriannaWarren2.0]

Oct 2, 2020 8:11:53 GMT -5 Elle Em said:

Oct 1, 2020 23:14:09 GMT -5 BriannaWarren2.0 said:

I would have loved it if Phoebe organized the attic while she was unemployed. If I was Prue, I would have made it a rule that if you are unemployed you study the book, practice your power and make sure the attic is organized. 

So in the first season you see Phoebe getting everything done and studying the book, teaching her sisters about warlocks/demons overall being knowledgeable about magic. 

This makes sense. I never understood how it was okay for Phoebe to not work, but also not be their designated magic person or at the very least the person who takes care of the house. I'm thinking of the fit she threw about Prue giving her that to-do list in season 1 when Piper was out of town. If she were busy studying the book and making potions and spells and learning things about magic to then teach her sisters, I'd totally understand. But she didn't seem to do any of that.

I remember also when Piper was in the hospital in season 2 and told Prue to leave and go to work, and told Phoebe to go do "whatever it is you do," or something like that. Prue and Piper worked too hard for Phoebe to just do nothing. 

Another thing I don't understand, is why after eight years of being witches, why do you have to consult the book all the time? Shouldn't you know the majority of what's in the Book? 

I completely agree that Phoebe should have been their personal BOS Encyclopedia, even buying more books to study upon, the first season should have been her studying about witchcraft and demonology, to be honest, I would rather her open up an occult shop rather than her being an advice columnist, she was so memorized by magic that it seemed like the best path for her. 

[Elle Em]

Oct 2, 2020 17:40:28 GMT -5 BriannaWarren2.0 said:

Another thing I don't understand, is why after eight years of being witches, why do you have to consult the book all the time? Shouldn't you know the majority of what's in the Book? 

I completely agree that Phoebe should have been their personal BOS Encyclopedia, even buying more books to study upon, the first season should have been her studying about witchcraft and demonology, to be honest, I would rather her open up an occult shop rather than her being an advice columnist, she was so memorized by magic that it seemed like the best path for her. 

If I'm remembering correctly, didn't the book change from time to time? Maybe there was always just enough new information relating to their current situation to make sense for them to consult it. 

Phoebe opening an occult shop would have made so much sense for her. She loved magic early on, and I would have liked her passion for it to extend throughout the series. Plus it would help her blend in to the nonmagical world better. She could excuse any strange conversation or situation as relating to her store. 

[Esmeralda]

I'd say the sun room. I loved how bright it was and loved the furniture in it. So many happy moments When they were in there, they were usually more sisters than witches which is when I loved them best.

[BriannaWarren2.0]

Oct 3, 2020 7:09:43 GMT -5 Elle Em said:

Oct 2, 2020 17:40:28 GMT -5 BriannaWarren2.0 said:

Another thing I don't understand, is why after eight years of being witches, why do you have to consult the book all the time? Shouldn't you know the majority of what's in the Book? 

I completely agree that Phoebe should have been their personal BOS Encyclopedia, even buying more books to study upon, the first season should have been her studying about witchcraft and demonology, to be honest, I would rather her open up an occult shop rather than her being an advice columnist, she was so memorized by magic that it seemed like the best path for her. 

If I'm remembering correctly, didn't the book change from time to time? Maybe there was always just enough new information relating to their current situation to make sense for them to consult it. 

Phoebe opening an occult shop would have made so much sense for her. She loved magic early on, and I would have liked her passion for it to extend throughout the series. Plus it would help her blend in to the nonmagical world better. She could excuse any strange conversation or situation as relating to her store. 

Certain things did but not everything, the Book was pretty consistent, but even if the book did change, basic spells like "call the ancestors" didn't. 

I feel like she lost that something special, which in my opinion, was her passion for her craft and I believe that if she opened an occult shop she would have gained something back.

[rebooted]

I always loved the sitting room with the staircase as the backdrop.

Its also where Prue was thrown through the wall and I liked how it went on the Conservatory/sun room.

Guess I am the only one!

[xhalliwellx]

The Attic, of course! But also, I loved everything about the whole house. From the paint colours to all the sisters rooms. Still looking to make mine similar colours (one day).

[Aaeiyn]

Sept 30, 2020 23:38:00 GMT -5 forbuss said:

What room did you enjoy the most? Which was your favourite and why? Which rooms would you have liked to see more or less of? Do you think I should have included the 'laundry room' and 'garage' on this list?

*NOTE

For the purposes of this poll the bedroom definitions are as follows:

Master Bedroom: The room Prue gave to Piper and Leo so they would have more Paige.
Paige's Bedroom: The bedroom Piper originally had and then was vacant until Paige moved into it.
Phoebe's Bedroom: This one is easy because she's the only sister not to have changed rooms! Unless you count moving out...

This is the best picture I could find of the main floor:

In S5E15 "The Day That Magic Died" it's a closet (the part saying it's a bathroom) LOL

Oct 2, 2020 6:14:48 GMT -5 Sasha said:

I really like the design of the sunroom, it always looked so pretty to me.

I assumed "Sun Room" was the Conservatory, so I voted "Sun Room"

[Katie Warren]

Oct 2, 2020 6:14:48 GMT -5 Sasha said:

I really like the design of the sunroom, it always looked so pretty to me.

I didn't vote in this thread. But I voted the sun room. It looks so stunning, especially in HD when I re-watched 1-3. I really love the lightning. 

Thanks Sasha for sharing those pics.

[rebooted]

I always enjoyed the sitting soon.

a) becuase you could see through to the sun room
b) it would feel like thats where you'd watch movies or wait for dinner to come to the table and you'd be able to see who was coming in the entrance once the passed the foyer
c) I love the backdrop of the staircase behind the sitting room.

It was right in the middle of the house so feels like you are in almost every room

[rebooted]

I wonder if the Parlour has now or would have been made into another bedroom in the future.

I think I would have really liked the idea of Piper and Phoebe living together forever. Perhaps Phoebe being a solo Mum with Pipers 3rd girl child and Phoebe's girl child sharing a room like they did.