Favorite S4 Writer(s)

[Aaeiyn]

Disclaimer: For the purpose of this/these thread(s), when it pertains to the word "writer", the writer(s) listed [within this/these poll(s)] will only be writers that were actually credited, within the episode upon watching them. If a name is missing [within this/these poll(s)], that means they were not credited, during the episode and will not be listed [within this/these poll(s)] as such. Thank you.

This is a continuation from the Favorite S3 Writer thread. Who is your favorite S4 writer(s)? Careful! You only get 2 votes!

Written by Daniel Cerone
S4E4 Enter the Demon
S4E10 A Paige from the Past
S4E15 Marry-Go-Round
(Teleplay) S4E17 Saving Private Leo
S4E21 Womb Raider

Written by Krista Vernoff
S4E3 Hell Hath No Fury
S4E9 Muse to My Ears
S4E16 The Fifth Halliwheel
S4E20 Long Live the Queen

Written by Brad Kern
S4E1 Charmed Again, Pt 1
S4E2 Charmed Again, Pt 2
(Teleplay) S4E8 Black as Cole
S4E22 Witch Way, Now?

Written by Monica Breen & Alison Schapker
S4E6 A Knight to Remember
S4E13 Charmed & Dangerous
S4E19 We're Off to See the Wizard

Written by Curtis Kheel
S4E7 Brain Drain
S4E14 The Three Faces of Phoebe
S4E18 Bite me

Written by Nell Scovell
S4E5 Size Matters
(Teleplay) S4E8 Black as Cole
S4E12 Lost & Bound

Written by Michael Gleason
S4E11 Trial by Magic

Written by Doug E. Jones
(Story) S4E17 Saving Private Leo

Written by Abbey Campbell
(Story) S4E8 Black as Cole

[Aaeiyn]

You know? I'm surprised I'm saying Brad Kern, again. I thought I only like his S1 episodes, but he didn't too bad in S4, I guess LOL I think S4 is where Krista Vernoff really shines with Hell Hath No Fury, Fifth Halliwheel & Long Live the Queen.

I'll go back to taking a break from doing this, again, since our re-watches stopped here, at S4. I'll create the S5 one, when we get done with it. Have fun!

EDIT: Though, I'm still upset with him, in bringing Cole back, in S4E22.  Other than that, the rest of S4E22 isn't too bad.

[Sandra]

As I did with the overall favorite writers.

I'll be bolding my favorites I loved and italic the ones I liked

Whatever two writers has 2 or more episodes wins.

Written by Daniel Cerone
S4E4 Enter the Demon
S4E10 A Paige from the Past
S4E15 Marry-Go-Round
(Teleplay) S4E17 Saving Private Leo
S4E21 Womb Raider

Written by Krista Vernoff
S4E3 Hell Hath No Fury
S4E9 Muse to My Ears
S4E16 The Fifth Halliwheel
S4E20 Long Live the Queen (just for her writing of the ending, and only way I broke my tie to get a second pick)

Written by Brad Kern
S4E1 Charmed Again, Pt 1
S4E2 Charmed Again, Pt 2
(Teleplay) S4E8 Black as Cole
S4E22 Witch Way, Now?

Written by Monica Breen & Alison Schapker
S4E6 A Knight to Remember
S4E13 Charmed & Dangerous
S4E19 We're Off to See the Wizard

Written by Curtis Kheel
S4E7 Brain Drain
S4E14 The Three Faces of Phoebe
S4E18 Bite me

Written by Nell Scovell
S4E5 Size Matters
(Teleplay) S4E8 Black as Cole
S4E12 Lost & Bound

Written by Michael Gleason
S4E11 Trial by Magic

Written by Doug E. Jones
(Story) S4E17 Saving Private Leo

Written by Abbey Campbell
(Story) S4E8 Black as Cole

Daniel Cerone gets my first vote.

It's a tie between everybody else. I decided to give Krista some love. I'm not as crazy about Long Live the Queen like others are. But, since this is about favorite writers not favorite episodes, I'm giving her love for writing my favorite sisterly ending from Long Live the Queen in S4.

[ryanhalliwell]

Krista Vernoff & Daniel Cerone

[Aaeiyn]

Changed my mind to Krista Vernoff and Michael Gleason. I couldnn't throw away my love for S4E11 "Trial by Magic" for a couple of "meh" Kern episodes.

[lunchking]

Krista Vernoff and Michael Gleason.

[Aaeiyn]

Mar 12, 2023 1:38:37 GMT -5 Aaeiyn said:

Changed my mind to Krista Vernoff and Michael Gleason. I couldnn't throw away my love for S4E11 "Trial by Magic" for a couple of "meh" Kern episodes.

I removed my vote away from Michael Gleason and onto Daniel Cerone.

[Aaeiyn]

Changing my mind to Michael Gleason and Nell Scovell. I've always kept my vote on Michael Gleason. My second vote seems to change a lot, but I like Nell Scovell's focus on "Protecting/Saving the Innocent(s)". Even if S4E12 "Lost & Bound" doesn't quite the hit spot for me, the other two vis S4E5 "Size Matters" & S4E8 "Black as Cole" do.