Favorite Prue + Order

[Aaeiyn]

Disclaimer: This is a continuation from the Favorite Paige + Order thread.

Which Prue do you like? You're free to select ALL of them, some of them or none, at all! It's completely up to you!

Feel free to even comment below, your preferred order, since there's a lot of combinations, to put into a poll so just comment your "order", down below!

[Aaeiyn]

Sorry, originally, I had inserted the poll with only one vote, but I fixed it. We should have 3 votes, now.

[Aaeiyn]

Anyway, I really only like S1 Prue. I feel like every season changes her, so S1 is the one I feel like is "the most Prue" compared to the rest.

My order, however: 1, 3, 2

[lunchking]

Like Paige Voting for all her seasons but my order Is season 1 > Season 3 > Season 2

[Prue's Feather]

Similarly to Paige, I voted all seasons, because I like Prue in all her seasons and picking a favorite is hard 😆

My order, for now though, is:

S1 > S3 > S2

[Aaeiyn]

Surprised to see S3 Prue, in the lead.  I wasn't expecting that, from this board.

[Esmeralda]

This one is tough for me, because I don't like Prue in the first part of S1 and I don't like her at the end of S3. So I just voted for S2.

But if I had to rank, I'd use FH for First Half and LH for Last Half:

LH S1 > S2 > FH S1 > S3.

[Sandra]

Voted Season 1 and 2.

My order: S2> S1 > S3

[goldeneye049]

S2 : ❤️ Love her
S3 : ❤️ Thanks to Prue for focusing on magic while her sisters are focused by Leo and Cole.
S1 part 2 : ❤️
S1 part 1 : No

[Too Much Coffee]

I love Prue beginning the second half of S1. So I couldn't vote S1 unless it was S1 Second half.

S2 got my vote.

My order:
S2 > S1 (second half) > Season 3 > Season 1 (first half)

[Ruth Marie]

Jun 1, 2023 3:27:56 GMT -5 goldeneye049 said:

S2 : ❤️ Love her
S3 : ❤️ Thanks to Prue for focusing on magic while her sisters are focused by Leo and Cole.
S1 part 2 : ❤️
S1 part 1 : No

That's exactly how I feel.

Voted S2 and S3.

[Aaeiyn]

Based off of Statistics:

S1 > S3 > S2

There's never an episode in S1 where Prue is NOT TKing. Even if, Prue is NOT APing in S1, yet, Prue is using her abilities, in EVERY single episode.

S3 has Prue using her abilities in MOST of the episode even with AP.  With the exception of 2-3 episodes.

S2 is the WORST in showcasing Prue's abilities even with the introduction of AP. Even though, S2 probably showcases her abilities, the most, compared to other sisters, in other seasons, but we're not talking about that, we're ONLY talking about Prue.  There's like 4-5 episodes where Prue is NOT using her abilities.

[rebooted]

Jun 1, 2023 3:26:21 GMT -5 Sandra said:

Voted Season 1 and 2.

My order: S2> S1 > S3

hMe too. 

I like prue from the end of Season 1 to Ex Libris-ish in Season 2 the most. 

She is still career orientated but wants to persue more of her own passion of art through Photography. interesting. 

Season 1 is my 2nd because she plays the responsible older sibling you can relate to and have sympathy for. 

In Season 3 it feels we have a traumtised Prue by the end of the Season. Maybe seeing so much of Patty and feeling like not having a purpose other than to eliminate evil. For me, she became reckless. 

I wonder what her 3rd power would have been if she said alive or whether they would have stopped at 2 each. 

2-1-3. 
Her career change (although quite unrealistic) was the most interesting character development for me.

[Aaeiyn]

Due to my calculations, in the Create Your Own Perfect Charmed Character Season thread, I have to go with S1 & S2. Even though, I'm still not a huge fan of S2 Prue's personality, S2 is the best in balancing out her powers of TK & AP. While, S3 has TK & AP in it, I still went with S1 because in when those two seasons go head to head, S1 outshines S3 due to having more TKs in an episode in comparative to S3 despite S3 having more APs.

[prueislove]

S1 Prue hands down. I loved how protective she was of her sisters and her character development was at its peak. Her relationship with Andy was also very well-written. Not perfect by any means but I feel Andy might have come around to accepting Prue as a witch.