Favorite S4 Sister(s)

[Aaeiyn]

This is a continuation from the Favorite S3 Sister(s) thread.

Max of up to TWO votes!

Don't forget to vote in other threads!

• Season One
• Season Two
• Season Three

[Aaeiyn]

This is REALLY tough for me. As I like ALL three sisters in this season. But, I decided to vote for Piper & Paige merely because I do find some (not all) of S4B Phoebe a little annoying but not as bad as S5A Phoebe, when we get to that season LOL

Still though, I don't hate S4 Phoebe.

[greta]

Just Paige for me.

[lunchking]

Piper and Paige this season.

[Esmeralda]

Just Paige for me. Don't like PhoeME or Poor, Poor Pitiful PIper.

[Aaeiyn]

Sept 12, 2023 7:58:32 GMT -5 Esmeralda said:

Don't like PhoeME or Poor, Poor Pitiful PIper.

I understand the case against Phoebe. Once upon a time, I didn't like her from S4E14 "The Three Faces of Phoebe" and beyond.

However, besides S4E3 "Hell Hath No Fury", what other episodes is Piper displaying her "Poor, Poor Pitiful Piper" persona?  And, does not liking Piper in S4E3 "Hell Hath No Fury" warrant not voting for her?

Seems to me, Piper was the only one to care that Prue was gone.

[Keeper Of Melinda's Locket]

I like Paige's introduction in S4. She's a fun character (on my first re-watch I HATED her, but it was more my mourning of Prue so I took it out on her). I really don't like Phoebe through the Cole arc in the second half and I don't enjoy Piper and how she treats Paige in Size Matters, A Knight to Remember, and Trial By Magic. Piper and Phoebe get on my nerves in A Knight to Remember with how they treat Paige and the reasons for having her move in with them.

So I only voted for Paige this season.

[Aaeiyn]

Sept 12, 2023 17:36:04 GMT -5 Keeper Of Melinda's Locket said:

I like Paige's introduction in S4. She's a fun character (on my first re-watch I HATED her, but it was more my mourning of Prue so I took it out on her). I really don't like Phoebe through the Cole arc in the second half and I don't enjoy Piper and how she treats Paige in Size Matters, A Knight to Remember, and Trial By Magic. Piper and Phoebe get on my nerves in A Knight to Remember with how they treat Paige and the reasons for having her move in with them.

So I only voted for Paige this season.

I get they have their terrible moments. At the same time, I certainly like one more than the other.

In my case, Piper's...behavior is understandable.

[wiccawonder]

For me, it is Piper and Paige for this season!

Piper mourning Prue, learning of a new sister, teaching Paige the craft and becoming the eldest sister is great! Even though, I prefer Prue as the eldest but I digress.

I adore Paige, her introduction, her passion in her work, learning where she came from and her solo episodes were fabulous! Once Prue was killed off, Paige filled her void in my heart somewhat and she became my favourite of the later three.

[chromaticanmomdasia]

Phoebe her and Coles story arc was top tier elevated everything

Love her journey this season would've loved more episodes of her as queen of evil

Though Paige is iconic too Phoebe and Paige for me ...this was pipers best season though

[latincoffee]

I have grown to love Paige. Originally, I was not feeling her character back when Season (4) aired and stopped watching altogether. But rewatching now in 2024.

[prueislove]

Piper and Paige. Phoebe's a bit untolerable after becoming Cole's wife.

[angelap]

I don't mind all three (I get Piper's grief). I voted Phoebe (even if she can have moments I detest) & Paige though.