When was the Prue and Phoebe dynamic the best?

[rebooted]

Two poll answers allowed. 

But any specific episodes you thought were amazing between Shannen & Alyssa and Prue and Phoebe? 

Season 2 is where I feel they become equals with respect for each others perspectives. 

Alyssa and Shannen in Pardon My Past are great and in Season 3's Once Upon A Time. 

They have great chemistry in the first episodes of Season 3 as well. 

What are your standouts?

[Aaeiyn]

I have a little bit of time before needing to rest to do more things for the rest of the Thanksgiving weekend.

Anyway, interesting that this thread popped after I had made some Phoebe & Prue GIFs, but I had a lot of S1 and not a whole lot from S2 nor S3.

So, I went with S1 Mid & S1 End. Even if I did had some more GIFs to show their S2 counterparts, I probably still wouldn't vote for it simply because I don't accept S2 Prue as the Prue IK and love from S1.

That being said, here are some of those S1 Mid & S1 End moments of them, that I just absolutely love and adore <3

S1E12 "The Wendigo"


S1E13 "From Fear to Eternity"


S1E16 "Which Prue is it, Anyway?"


S1E21 "Love Hurts"

---

That being said, if there are more S2 or S3 moments of Phoebe & Prue, I'd love to make more GIFs of them! And, perhaps, in the future, there'd be a poll about the Phoebe & Paige Sisterhood, as well. As I do have GIFs of that, too LOL

Happy Thanksgiving everyone!

[rebooted]

Love hurts does seem like a good one

[Elle Em]

I think season 2. Like Rebooted said, they were more equals here. Phoebe was becoming more responsible and Prue was loosening up, and it put them each in good places in relation to each other. It was really nice to see them getting along better and Prue seeing Phoebe as more of a peer than a baby sister while Phoebe was growing up and treating Prue less like a mom.

[Aaeiyn]

I still disagree that Prue is supposed to be some sort of "loosened up" character. That's what Phoebe is supposed to be. While, Prue is the more "uptight" one. Which is why their dynamic in S1 works the best compared to S2.

S2 Prue just feels like she's trying to mimic Phoebe's mold, when that's not exactly what her character is supposed to be.

Their dynamic seen in BOTH S1E12 "The Wendigo" and S1E13 "From Fear to Eternity" definitely showed their strengths in their respective personalities. Prue being too scared to say "I love you", while Phoebe is free to give out the love. Which is why Phoebe's fear is "losing a sister" 'cause of that love, but I digress.

[West]

They had a great storyline in S1 with the rebuilding of the relationship in S1. Mid to late S1 especially. Even into S2. S3 is where things went downhill for them although they had a few good moments when Piper got married.

[greta]

Prue and Phoebe had so many great moments. But when the dynamic was the best depends on how you define it by chemistry, and good storylines despite them having conflict.

S1 when they're bonding always stands out to me.

[Sandra]

Late S1 was really good. I really do like seeing them grow closer in S1. I ended up voting for S1 mid and end.