Official Christy Jenkins thread

[Reality Bites]

I'm kind of confused. I haven't seen "Forever Charmed" in a long while, but if I'm not mistaken shouldn't a version of Christy still be alive?

When Christy dies, it is the time traveling Christy that is killed. Not the Christy that existed in the time frame that was travelled to... if that makes sense.

In the scene there were:

Pre-Hollow Triad
Pre-Hollow Dumain
Present-Day Dumain
Present-Day Christy
Present-Day Billie
Present-Day Charmed Ones.

Present-Day Charmed Ones kill Pre-Hollow Triad, Pre-Hollow Dumain, and Present-Day Dumain. Present-Day Billie then kills Present-Day Christy.

So... where were Pre-Hollow Billie and Pre-Hollow Christy? I get with both versions of Dumain gone, there is no one to convince Pre-Hollow Billie and Christy to summon The Hollow. So, shouldn't both sets of sisters (Billie/Christy and Piper/Phoebe/Paige) still be alive and kicking?

Am I missing something? lol

[cyma]

All I can think of is Prue, Piper and Phoebe going to the past to stop Nicholas, but suppose one of them dies there, then when the living two sisters return to their present, the deceased sister, let’s suppose Phoebe, won’t be there because she died in the past. Umm….if that makes sense

But if the past Grams and Mom besides binding the little COs powers, decide to do something more in hopes to change Phoebe’s fate, the two sisters might be retuning to a present where Phoebe could be alive.

So the question is, what do the Past COs and Past Billie and Christy do after their future versions vanquish the Triad for them? I guess something unknowingly which ultimately results in the present where Wyatt didn't lose his powers, Phoebe and Paige are alive, Leo is back, but Christy is dead.

And now I’m getting a headache…

[Chrisaholic]

Getting a headache by just reading it. But there might be a sparkle of truth in there somewhere. ;D

[cyma]

Be glad it’s Christy and not Chris. His situation will give one the mother of all headaches