Official Christy Jenkins thread

[simplypoo83]

Discuss Chisty Jenkins from Charmed Season 8. As well as Marty Patterson and her future projects.

[leosgirl]

i don't want christy to die in the finale

[carlylenz]

Me neither! I want her and Billie to realize they are being tricked!

[leosgirl]

yes i think christy is just being convinced by that guy that there evil

[The Original P3]

Christy IS evil. Billie is the one that's being so easily persuaded. Nature vs. Nurture. Obviously nurture won out for Christy.

[carlylenz]

If any of the charmed ones were raised by demons their whole life they would be evil as well! Christy is evil not by choice but because the demons have swapped her morality. She thinks evil is good and good is evil.

[kirenkr]

xcharmed1x said:

Christy IS evil. Billie is the one that's being so easily persuaded. Nature vs. Nurture. Obviously nurture won out for Christy.

i agree

[acharmedone]

i agree with carly! i really don't want her to die!! though she kinda buggs the hell out of me the way she persuaded billie that the charmed ones were evil!

[The Original P3]

carlylenz said:

If any of the charmed ones were raised by demons their whole life they would be evil as well! Christy is evil not by choice but because the demons have swapped her morality. She thinks evil is good and good is evil.

Are we stating the obvious? If you're raised by evil you are evil. Doesn't matter what she thinks. If she thinks that evil is good..then well..she's evil. Someone who thinks that evil is good is even harder to convert.

[pip3rhalliw3ll]

Christy is evil but she is innocent because she was tricked by her so called 'imaginary friend' and he said that all the witches will die including Billie and Christy.

[prue]

I have to agree with Carly on this one. Christy truly believes that evil is good because she hadn't had any exposure to the real world for 15 years. She is determined to make Billie see the same thing, by whatever means possible. I think that they should be spared, made to realize that they both had been played. They are being used by the Triad to destroy the Charmed Ones and in the process, taking out the "ultimate power" so that they can take over the world. If evil wins, then evil will rule the world.

[glow=red,2,300]Blessed Be[/glow].

[charmedgoddess]

Personaly, I think Christy got the end she deserved. She was too warped to come back, I just feel sorry for Billie. I wished the sisters would have been more comforting!!

[rebeccamatthews]

I like Christie.

[Assassin Witch]

I was kind of shocked that Christy wouldn't go into the "light" with Billie. I guess I was excepting her to be saved, too. Of course, I'm personally happy that Christy is gone, but I didn't exactly expect that.

[charmedgoddess]

rebeccamatthews said:

I like Christie.

Rebecca, Wait! You like Christy, but are just ok with Billie? A little confused here.

~Of course we wish Christy could have been saved, but it wasn't meant to be.

[The Original P3]

charmedgoddess said:

Personaly, I think Christy got the end she deserved. She was too warped to come back, I just feel sorry for Billie. I wished the sisters would have been more comforting!!

You've gotta be kidding me. You expected Piper to comfort the person who was the reason her husband was taken away, the person who used her son to summon the Hollow and then take her sons powers to kill his mother?

Even if I didn't love Piper, I would say that's why too much to expect of her. Billie was lucky Grams was there at the manor, the "You used my son.." sounded like an explosion was coming up next.

[charmedgoddess]

xcharmed1x said:

charmedgoddess said:

Personaly, I think Christy got the end she deserved. She was too warped to come back, I just feel sorry for Billie. I wished the sisters would have been more comforting!!

You've gotta be kidding me. You expected Piper to comfort the person who was the reason her husband was taken away, the person who used her son to summon the Hollow and then take her sons powers to kill his mother?

Even if I didn't love Piper, I would say that's why too much to expect of her. Billie was lucky Grams was there at the manor, the "You used my son.." sounded like an explosion was coming up next.

*sighs* How many times do I have to say this "BILLIE IS NOT THE REASON LEO GOT TAKEN AWAY, IT WAS THE TRIAD,DUMAIN AND EVEN IN THE END CHRISTY WHO WERE THE THREAT!! OTHERWISE LEO WOULDN'T HAVE CAME BACK!

They are ones who plotted for 15 years a way to destroy the Charmed ones, not Billie! She was completely brainwashed by her new found sister, the only other family she had after her parents were murdered!! and Dumain; who cast the spells that made the charmed ones look extreemely selfish.

Actually, Billie helped save Leo in 8x10! If it wasn't for her quest, Leo never would have been able to be preserved frozen. She also helped end the final battle. Saving the charmed ones and Leo again by making the ultimate sacrifice.

And yes, they could have been a little comforting. Not necessarily all forgive and forget of course, but after all they lost a sister themselves and nearly had to kill phoebe after she turned evil. I would think they would understand what Billie was going through. And no one she have had to go through what Billie went through in the last few weeks, especially when your only 20 years old!!

Losing her parents, being bombared by lies, then Piper comming after her though she hadn't made a decision, and finally learning everything had been nothing but a horrible evil plan to trick her, and having to kill her own sister; the only blood relative she has left to save the greater good!

[The Original P3]

Touching. Still not convicing me though.

Actually I fully believe that either Christy or Billie had to be vanquished. It was the two of them together that was the force that the Charmed Ones had to defeat. The Triad didn't give them any powers, they just had to be taken out along the way. If it was the Triad all long, then Leo should have been returned when the sisters vanquished them with powers from the Hollow.

And, now that I've seen Forever Charmed, it begs the question as why Leo had to be frozen in the first place. The Angel of Destiny had no problem taking him as is, soo..I hereby claim the freezing scenario, unnecessary. New arguement please. And like I said, the Charmed Ones could have vanquished Christy. She didn't have to make that sacrifice so she has no one to blame but herself.

And no they didn't need to comfort their enemy. I think the Charmed Ones did way too much for her as it is during the whole season. Teaching her everything about magic only to be betrayed. Sorry..comfort food not involved.

Piper coming after her though she hadn't made a decision? What's that one about? Piper had every right in the world to be thoroughly pissed at Billie for what she did.

[charmedgoddess]

Yes you're mostly right about either Billie or Christy, but technically it would've had to be Christy or both Billie and Christy, Because Christly would have stopped at nothing to kill the charmed ones. Same with Dumain, he was the brains behind the operation, all to become a member of the triad. So all three Triad, Dumain and Christy needed to die in order to end the battle, save the future, and bring back Leo.

and yes while The Charmed ones could have killed Christly, they let Billie decide. To help her understand what had to be done!!

That was not the only reason I had for Billie helping end the battle. She warned the sisters and took them to the past. So again I ask: How could the charmed ones, Leo and the future have been saved without the help of Billie?

The whole decision thing was in earlier episodes, when Billie was still deciding fight with Christy, not confinced the Charmed ones were wrong. Piper went after them right away; which I don't blame her for but it made them seem wrong.

[The Original P3]

charmedgoddess said:

That was not the only reason I had for Billie helping end the battle. She warned the sisters and took them to the past. So again I ask: How could the charmed ones, Leo and the future have been saved without the help of Billie?

See Billie thread for explaination.