Saddest Scene/Dialogue

[cyma]

Nov 7, 2014 17:02:23 GMT -5 Esmeralda said:

3) Piper telling Paige she may not be able to have kids

It's funny - when I read that I translated it to "Piper telling Paige Paige may not be able to have kids" and I was trying to figure out which episode that was - then I realized it was "Piper telling Paige Piper may not be able to have kids" and my heart simply ached because I wish so much that she never had had them!

But you're right - even though she never should've became a mother (or at least not until the series was long over...), when she told Paige about that, it was extremely emotional.

Grammar and its rules....ugh! Headache.

Paige being told by Piper she may not be able to have kids?

Piper revealing to Paige she can't have kids?

Piper telling Paige about Melinda her future daughter and now she won't be able to have her because she can't have kids? 

[Esmeralda]

I think I like the last one best. The other two, I still might think it's Paige who can't have kids.

[sky1]

On a re-watch? S3 finale. Due to knowledge this the last time we see Prue. The way Shax left their house in. The way Prue got killed. It's giving me horror vibes.

[sonja]

All Hell Breaks Loose, Piper's death. Top tier acting and delivery, it always tears my heart apart and has me sobbing for hours. No other scene compares in my opinion, but another good one is Phoebe talking her sisters into letting her burn in Morality Bites. Such an impactful moment in the series.

[Elle Em]

I agree about the season 3 finale. It's one of the few times I get a true sinister vibe from the show. 

I think some of the saddest scenes have to do with their lack of parents and how it affects them. In That '70s Episode, under all of Phoebe's silliness and immaturity we see very real pain and even a bit of bitterness that she never knew her mom. And of course Prue crying over her at the end of Death Takes a Halliwell is just heartbreaking.