pscharm
Familiar
I Just Felt A Chill
Posts: 146
|
Post by pscharm on Dec 30, 2007 1:49:54 GMT -5
brand kern making a new charmed film called Charmed the new evil where as in this one prue was never truly led to heaven so in this one shes been training 5 years in the astro plan for her big comeback with the help and training of a demon who has brain washed her since she was so vunerable when she was killed but back to the story she's training to come back for revenge on pheobe piper paige and leo for not saving her from the tortures shes delt with in the ap but the question is will the sisters get prue back to the good side and probally make the power of 4
|
|
|
|
Post by pipercharmedphreak on Dec 30, 2007 2:45:03 GMT -5
honestly, i don't think that it would sit easy with me..
|
|
colehellsangel
Familiar
In Love and War; or in this case Love IS war.
Posts: 797
|
Post by colehellsangel on Dec 30, 2007 17:53:50 GMT -5
honestly, i don't think that it would sit easy with me.. Yeah very very creative idea but I agree with Pipercharmedphreak here. I would have liked to see her become a whitelighter though. She totally deserved it for all the good she did with her sisters and some by herself. |
|
pscharm
Familiar
I Just Felt A Chill
Posts: 146
|
Post by pscharm on Dec 30, 2007 18:02:44 GMT -5
now with that idea i strongly agree honestly, i don't think that it would sit easy with me.. Yeah very very creative idea but I agree with Pipercharmedphreak here. I would have liked to see her become a whitelighter though. She totally deserved it for all the good she did with her sisters and some by herself. |
|
|
|
Post by pipercharmedphreak on Dec 31, 2007 0:15:53 GMT -5
i think "whitelighter" was the way to go with Prue. She really deserved something good like that for all the wonderful things she did (as stated before). But i am not too keen on a Charmed movie in general.
|
|
colehellsangel
Familiar
In Love and War; or in this case Love IS war.
Posts: 797
|
Post by colehellsangel on Dec 31, 2007 15:34:01 GMT -5
Yeah its hard to welcome more onto whats already so great. But I would totally go for a Charmed movie especially if Prue at least makes an appearance.
|
|
|
|
Post by vandergraafk on Jan 1, 2008 1:50:26 GMT -5
Prue, a whitelighter? You've got to be kidding? Hey, why not make Grams a whitelighter so she can break all of the rules too. Prue would never ever aspire to be Nathalie like. Her response would be even more visceral than Sam's when he learned - to his chagrin - that the Elders made him a whitelighter again and presumably took him from Patty (again)!
|
|
ljones
Whitelighter
Posts: 4,123
|
Post by ljones on Jan 2, 2008 22:09:42 GMT -5
Prue, a whitelighter? You've got to be kidding? Hey, why not make Grams a whitelighter so she can break all of the rules too. Prue would never ever aspire to be Nathalie like. Her response would be even more visceral than Sam's when he learned - to his chagrin - that the Elders made him a whitelighter again and presumably took him from Patty (again)! I don't exactly find the idea of Prue being a whitelighter that thrilling, either. As for Grams . . . well, I must be honest that I don't really care about her fate. |
|
Esmeralda
Charmed
S2 "What If...?"
Fan Fic Winner
Twenty Years Gone....But Never Forgotten.
Posts: 21,920 
|
Post by Esmeralda on Jan 3, 2008 17:03:32 GMT -5
I agree with Prue being a whitelighter but not with Brad Kern producing it. He fired Shannen. I doubt Shannen would work with him. Now if you could get Connie Burge to produce it, I think it would be fantastic!
|
|
charmedfan4evr
Avatar
[glow=green,2,300]Prue Fan Club Member
Piper Fan Club Member
Phoebe Fan Club Member
Paige Fan Club Member[/glow]
Posts: 7,700
|
Post by charmedfan4evr on Jan 3, 2008 22:40:30 GMT -5
Creative...but I would NOT like to see that movie.  Prue come back as evil? No way. Her vulnerable? I don't see how. All of the Charmed ones, were vulnerable to evil as we saw, but completely brain-washed, I don't think so. I don't even think Phoebe would get that completely turned over. Phoebe still had that bit of Charmed inside of her, while being the Queen of the Underworld. And that small piece, was powerful enough to take control. She wasn't completely turned. As far as Prue coming back as a whitelighter..I also do not like that idea. Yes, she most certainly deserves it! But I don't quite see her as one. I don't know if you're still considered to be a witch or Charmed One after death, I would assume you are so I would only want Prue to remain known as a Charmed One, not a whitelighter. However, now that I think about it...if she could come back as a whitelighter with out letting the recognition of her being the eldest Charmed One lose it's status, that I may be fine with. It's hard to explain...but I just don't want the character of a whitelighter, to over run her character as a Charmed One. I want her to be known first as a Charmed One, then a whitelighter.... There that's it! |
|
Esmeralda
Charmed
S2 "What If...?"
Fan Fic Winner
Twenty Years Gone....But Never Forgotten.
Posts: 21,920
|
Post by Esmeralda on Jan 4, 2008 0:37:05 GMT -5
Creative...but I would NOT like to see that movie. Prue come back as evil? No way. Her vulnerable? I don't see how. All of the Charmed ones, were vulnerable to evil as we saw, but completely brain-washed, I don't think so. I don't even think Phoebe would get that completely turned over. Phoebe still had that bit of Charmed inside of her, while being the Queen of the Underworld. And that small piece, was powerful enough to take control. She wasn't completely turned. As far as Prue coming back as a whitelighter..I also do not like that idea. Yes, she most certainly deserves it! But I don't quite see her as one. I don't know if you're still considered to be a witch or Charmed One after death, I would assume you are so I would only want Prue to remain known as a Charmed One, not a whitelighter. However, now that I think about it...if she could come back as a whitelighter with out letting the recognition of her being the eldest Charmed One lose it's status, that I may be fine with. It's hard to explain...but I just don't want the character of a whitelighter, to over run her character as a Charmed One. I want her to be known first as a Charmed One, then a whitelighter.... There that's it! So you don't want what happened to Paige to happen to Prue--turning her from a Charmed One into *just* a whitelighter. I hated when they did that to Paige! I agree with you except the two situations are different. Obviously Prue being dead means she can no longer help harness the Power of Three. That's why Piper and Phoebe needed Paige. If Prue can no longer help harness the Power of Three, she's no longer a Charmed One. Known as an ex-Charmed One and remembered and revered for all the great things she did as a Charmed One, oh, yes, but if that's all she'd be, then it's better if she's just a ghost like Patty or Grams. I prefer thinking of her continuing to do good things--like being a whitelighter--or better, an Elder, maybe even the Chief Elder! Oh, could SHE straighten out those other Elders! Yes, Assassin Witch, you know *EXACTLY* which fic I'm thinking of! Grams Up There! And anyone who hasn't read this hilariously wonderful fic must! Here's a link: www.websitetoolbox.com/tool/post/thecharmedsons/vpost?id=1672424 |
|
charmedfan4evr
Avatar
[glow=green,2,300]Prue Fan Club Member
Piper Fan Club Member
Phoebe Fan Club Member
Paige Fan Club Member[/glow]
Posts: 7,700
|
Post by charmedfan4evr on Jan 4, 2008 1:00:44 GMT -5
So you don't want what happened to Paige to happen to Prue--turning her from a Charmed One into *just* a whitelighter. I hated when they did that to Paige! I agree with you except the two situations are different. Obviously Prue being dead means she can no longer help harness the Power of Three. Known as an ex-Charmed One and remembered and revered for all the great things she did as a Charmed One, oh, yes, but if that's all she'd be, then it's better if she's just a ghost like Patty or Grams. I prefer thinking of her continuing to do good things--like being a whitelighter--or better, an Elder, maybe even the Chief Elder! Oh, could SHE straighten out those other Elders! Right. I know that she can obviously not longer harness the Power of Three. But like you said, I want her to be remembered and revered to as I guess, an ex-Charmed One forever. And I would not want the title of a whitelighter, an Elder, or Elder "Chief" surpass her Charmed title, for that I believe defines her the best. That's who she is. When it comes to her continuing to do good things..she could very well do great things as a spirit like Grams and Patty. She can most definitely do great things as a whitelighter, but I still can't quite see her as one. I see her first as a spirit like Grams and Patty, and then I'll go from there. |
|
Esmeralda
Charmed
S2 "What If...?"
Fan Fic Winner
Twenty Years Gone....But Never Forgotten.
Posts: 21,920
|
Post by Esmeralda on Jan 4, 2008 1:20:18 GMT -5
*shrug* Different strokes for different folks, I guess.
I just can't see Prue agreeing to simply sit on her laurels as an ex-Charmed One any more than I can see Leo as truly happy as Piper's helpless errand boy or as a teacher of magical kids who can use their magical powers on him and he can't do anything about it because he no longer has his powers. (GRRRR at Kern!) I can see Piper happily sitting on her laurels. I can see Phoebe doing that. I can't see Paige doing that and I definitely can't see Prue doing that.
Prue would want to be able to continue to go out and do something, so some good, and I do believe that if she was offered a chance to be a whitelighter, she'd jump at it, especially one for her nephews, where she could to still use everything she learned as a Charmed One to continue to do good.
Yes, being an ex-Charmed One would always be what she would be known for best and honored for. But simply sitting on her laurels when she could still be doing some good? No, that's not Prue. And I think the fact that she's a whitelighter is the true reason why we never saw her on the show after her death, even tho Piper and Phoebe had definitely faced the fact that she was dead and should've been able to see her if she was still "just" a ghost.
|
|
ljones
Whitelighter
Posts: 4,123
|
Post by ljones on Jan 4, 2008 1:59:31 GMT -5
Why not? Prue didn't like being a Charmed One anymore than Piper did.
|
|
Esmeralda
Charmed
S2 "What If...?"
Fan Fic Winner
Twenty Years Gone....But Never Forgotten.
Posts: 21,920
|
Post by Esmeralda on Jan 4, 2008 10:02:43 GMT -5
Why not? Prue didn't like being a Charmed One anymore than Piper did. Liking it had nothing to do with it. She wanted to save innocents. That was her high priority. It's why she kept hunting for them, something Piper as leader of the Charmed Ones never did. And if Prue could keep doing that, I believe that she would. |
|
ljones
Whitelighter
Posts: 4,123
|
Post by ljones on Jan 4, 2008 12:38:44 GMT -5
Liking it had nothing to do with it. She wanted to save innocents.
No, she didn't. Not really. Like Piper, Prue felt that she had no choice in the matter.
|
|
|
|
Post by whitelightertony on Jan 4, 2008 16:06:00 GMT -5
Have any former witches ever been turned into whitelighters? It seems that all of the whitelighters whom we've learned about were non-magical mortals in their previous lives.
|
|
ljones
Whitelighter
Posts: 4,123
|
Post by ljones on Jan 4, 2008 20:55:50 GMT -5
I don't recall any former witches-turned-whitelighters in the series.
Frankly, I don't think I would want to see it. I have a rather low opinion of whitelighters.
|
|
pscharm
Familiar
I Just Felt A Chill
Posts: 146
|
Post by pscharm on Jan 5, 2008 22:17:56 GMT -5
yea but pheobe was evil for only 2 monts prue be 5 years Creative...but I would NOT like to see that movie. Prue come back as evil? No way. Her vulnerable? I don't see how. All of the Charmed ones, were vulnerable to evil as we saw, but completely brain-washed, I don't think so. I don't even think Phoebe would get that completely turned over. Phoebe still had that bit of Charmed inside of her, while being the Queen of the Underworld. And that small piece, was powerful enough to take control. She wasn't completely turned. As far as Prue coming back as a whitelighter..I also do not like that idea. Yes, she most certainly deserves it! But I don't quite see her as one. I don't know if you're still considered to be a witch or Charmed One after death, I would assume you are so I would only want Prue to remain known as a Charmed One, not a whitelighter. However, now that I think about it...if she could come back as a whitelighter with out letting the recognition of her being the eldest Charmed One lose it's status, that I may be fine with. It's hard to explain...but I just don't want the character of a whitelighter, to over run her character as a Charmed One. I want her to be known first as a Charmed One, then a whitelighter.... There that's it! |
|
charmedfan4evr
Avatar
[glow=green,2,300]Prue Fan Club Member
Piper Fan Club Member
Phoebe Fan Club Member
Paige Fan Club Member[/glow]
Posts: 7,700
|
Post by charmedfan4evr on Jan 5, 2008 23:50:59 GMT -5
yea but pheobe was evil for only 2 monts prue be 5 years Ok, so what's your point? I said Prue would not come back as an evil brain-washed being. She would never be so vulnerable to that, and she most certainly would not last as long as 5 years being evil. Her Charmed One inside of her would start kicking in immediately. And exactly my point...Phoebe who is probably the most vulnerable to evil, who became the Queen of the Underworld (how much more evil can ya get?), was able to overcome such an evil, in a very reasonable amount of time. |
|
