The Ultimate Fave Charmed Episode Poll

[rebooted]

LOGIN and VOTE!
For your TOP 12 Charmed Episodes Ever!

west73 did such a great job with putting together the polls for Favorite Episodes per each season. 

It's been at least a year since this poll to choose up to 12 of your top episodes was created. 

The options in this poll is a consolidation of all episodes from each of west73's polls which had 13 votes or more as at 24 April 2017.

These top 50 episodes include:

Season 1 (9 Episodes)
Something Wicca This Way Comes (22 Votes)
Dead Man Dating (15 Votes)
The Witch is Back (18 Votes)
Wicca Envy (13 Votes)
From Fear to Eternity (13 Votes)
That 70's Episode (21 Votes)
Is There A Woogy in the House? (20 Votes)
The Power of Two (15 Votes)
DeJa Vu All Over Again (21 Votes)

Season 2 (7 Episodes)
Morality Bites (22 Votes)
P3H20 (13 Votes)
Awakened (19 Votes)
Pardon My Past (Added)
Chick Flick (19 Votes)
Astral Monkey (19 Votes)
Apocalypse Now (19 Votes)

Season 3 (10 Episodes)
All Halliwell’s Eve (21 Votes)
Sight Unseen (15 Votes)
Primrose Empath (15 Votes)
Power Outage (17 Votes)
Sleuthing with the Enemy (19 Votes)
The Good the Bad and the Cursed (17 Votes)
Just Harried (Added)
Pre-Witched (19 Votes)
Sin Francisco (17 Votes)
All Hell Breaks Loose (15 Votes)

Season 4 (7 Episodes)
Charmed Again Part One (23 Votes)
Hell Hath No Fury (16 Votes)
Brain Drain (25 Votes)
A Paige from the Past (20 Votes)
Charmed And Dangerous (17 Votes)
Long Live the Queen (17 Votes)
Womb Raidar (18 Votes)

Season 5 (6 Episodes)
Sympathy for the Demon (17 Votes)
A Witch in Time (18 Votes)
Centennial Charmed (15 Votes)
The Day the Magic Dead (14 Votes)
Cat House (15 Votes)
Sense and Sense Ability (19 Votes)

Season 6 (4 Episodes)
The Power of Three Blondes (13 Votes)
Little Monsters (14 Votes)
Chris Crossed (13 Votes)
I Dream of Phoebe (16 Votes)

Season 7 (3 Episodes)
Cheaper by the Coven (14 Votes)
Witchness Protection (14 Votes)
Death Becomes Them (13 Votes) and/or Something Wicca This Way Goes …? (15 Votes)

Season 8 (4 Episodes)
Vaya Cons Leos (14 Votes)
Paybacks a Witch (13 Votes)
Engaged and Confused (15 Votes)
Kill Billie Vol. 2 (15 Votes)

It's going to be hard, but from these choices try and pick your top 12 episodes. 

The number of allowable poll answers ran out so I had to make some changes:

(a) I combined Death Becomes Them and Something Wicca This Way Goes...? to make space for an 'Other' category and also because they are the only 2 episodes on this list that are 2 parters. Option for and/or.

(b) Adjustments based on comments from posters.
Siren Song (15 Votes) and The Eyes Have It (13 Votes) were replaced with Pardon My Past and Just Harried. You can still vote for these in 'Other'

Some episodes that I was surprised didn't make the cut in the individual polls:

Season One:
Secrets and Guys
Out of Sight
Love Hurts

Season Two:
Ms. Hellfire
Ex Libris
Be Careful What You Witch For

Season Three:
Magic Hour
One Upon A Time
Blinded by the Whitelighter
Death Takes A Halliwell
Exit Strategy

Season Four:
A Knight to Remember
Muse to My Ears
Saving Private Leo

Season Five:
Sam I Am
Baby's First Demon
Oh My Goddess P1 or 2

Season Six:
Witchstock
Courtship
It's a Bad Bad P1 or 2

Season Seven:
Carpe Demon
Show Ghouls
7 Year Witch

Season Eight
Forever Charmed

Which is why I made room for the 'Other' option.

[rebooted]

Mine - I don't think these are the BEST, but they are my favourites.

Something Wicca This Way Comes
Deja Vu All Over Again
Morality Bites
Pardon My Past
Chick Flick
All Halliwell's Eve
Pre-Witched
All Hell Breaks Loose
Charmed Again P1
Hell Hath No Fury
Charmed and Dangerous
Long Live the Queen

If I could pick an 13th - Just Harried

[Esmeralda]

Since I have 50 favorites and most of them were on this list, this was really *really* hard. But after deciding to just choose Charmed episodes (S1-3), [Keep in mind that I count S4-8 as the alternate-universe spin-off and not due to Prue vs Paige - except for making Paige a whitelighter more than a witch - but due to the changes in Piper, Phoebe, Cole and Leo which I don't think could just be explained by Prue's death) it was easier, although I could've easily chosen twice that many even with just those three seasons. For now these are the ones I chose - I may change my mind and do one of the others instead (well, except for 'Morality Bites').

Like you, Reboot, these aren't necessarily the ones I think are the best, but they are my favorites, ones I watch over and over and over while skipping others - mainly because some of the best ones scared me too much and gave me nightmares. I like suspense, not horror.

And I could've easily chosen "Other" for my favorites that didn't make the cut, but then I'd have to zilch out one of these, and I had a hard enough time coming up with this list.

1. Dead Man Dating
2. The Witch is Back
3. Wicca Envy
4. That 70's Episode
5. Deja vu All Over Again
6. Morality Bites (My favorite Episode)
7. P3 H20
8. Chick Flick
9. Apocalypse Not (Not 'Apocalypse Now' - that was the name of the movie the title was based on)
10. All Halliwell's Eve
11. The Good, The Bad and the Cursed
12. Sin Francisco

Season One = 5 episodes
Season Two = 4 episodes
Season Three = 3 episodes

[craig]

Another tricky poll. So I am going to just base my 12 on episodes that are re-watchable for me over what I consider the best.

Some episodes I love didn't make the list like Love Hurts and Secrets and Guys. But even then, I am unable to actually vote for both of these episodes.

1. Dead Man Dating
2. The Witch is Back
3. Wicca Envy
4. Is There a Woggy in the House?
5. That 70's Episode
6. Deja vu All Over Again
7. Morality Bites
8. P3 H20
9. Chick Flick
10. Apocalypse Not
11. All Halliwell's Eve
12. Primrose Empath

[Chrisaholic]

I don't have that many favorite episodes. Only five so far and these are:
- Dead Man Dating
- That 70's episode
- Astral Monkey
- A Paige From the Past and
- Chris Crossed (all time favorite!!)

[rebooted]

Im interested to see what the fave episode is for Season 4 to 8.

Right now it looks like Charmed Again, Chris Crossed, Centennial and Kill Bill Vol 2 are going to fight it out for a while.

Not surprised by Seasons 1 - 3 with the classics already leading.

Happy voting people! - I know its really hard. I think I'm going to have to reconsider my choices again.

[West]

Apr 25, 2017 3:04:37 GMT -5 rebooted said:

LOGIN and VOTE!
For your TOP 12 Charmed Episodes Ever!

west73 did such a great job with putting together the polls for Favorite Episodes per each season. 

It's been at least a year since this poll to choose up to 12 of your top episodes was created. 

It has been so long since I have been on this site. But I am smiling that I have inspired others to come up with some amazing polls in my absence. I appreciate you enjoyed my polls, and found a way to use the results for this one.

You have done a great job rebooted with this. 

[West]

The Witch is Back
Wicca Envy
That 70s Episode
Is There a Woggy in the House
Deja Vu All Over Again
Morality Bites
Apocalypse Not
All Halliwell's Eve
Primrose Empath
Sin Francisco
Charmed Again Part 1
Womb Raider

[rebooted]

Season One:
-Something Wicca This Way Comes
-That 70's Episode
-Deja Vu All Over Again

Season Two
-Pardon My Past

Season Three
-All Halliwell's Eve
-Pre-Witched
-All Hell Breaks Loose

Season Four
-Charmed Again
-Hell Hath No Fury
-Charmed and Dangerous
-Love Live the Queen
-Womb Raidar

none from Seasons 5 - 8.

Morality Bites, Chick Flick and Just Harried would be my top 15.

The least fave on this list of me is Engaged and Confused.

[Granny Charmed]

1. Something Wicca This Way Comes
2. Dead Man Dating
3. The Witch is Back
4. Wicca Envy
5. That 70's Episode (My favorite episode)
6. Deja vu All Over Again
7. Morality Bites (My second favorite episode)
8. P3 H20
9. Apocalypse Not
10. All Halliwell's Eve
11. Primrose Empath
12. Sin Francisco

[Granny Charmed]

Current Tally (top 10 with 7 or more votes)

That 70s Episode
Deja Vu All Over Again
All Halliwell's Eve
Apocalypse Now
Womb Raidar
Wicca Envy
Awakened
All Hell Breaks Loose
Sight Unseen / Primrose Empath
From Fear to Eternity

Surprised dears Morality Bites and P3H20 and Charmed Again Part 1 are not higher. Womb Raidar being so high I am surprised, but The Seer dears is popular that might be why it is so loved.

[erikamarie]

Jun 13, 2017 7:40:28 GMT -5 Granny Charmed said:

Current Tally (top 10 with 7 or more votes)

That 70s Episode
Deja Vu All Over Again
All Halliwell's Eve
Apocalypse Now
Womb Raidar
Wicca Envy
Awakened
All Hell Breaks Loose
Sight Unseen / Primrose Empath
From Fear to Eternity

Surprised dears Morality Bites and P3H20 and Charmed Again Part 1 are not higher. Womb Raidar being so high I am surprised, but The Seer dears is popular that might be why it is so loved.

Personal taste
For example, I don't like P3H20, I don't like how is described Sam's character and I think the story is prosaic, with a prosiac monster
Instead I love Charmed again part 1, it's not easy to make people smile after a funeral, but Piper was able to do it
I found very captivating the plot and Leo and Cole couldn't be better

[sol]

As I love The Day the Magic Dead, a true Charmed story, magic, humor, suspance..but many didn't like Wyatt so they can't respect sufficiently the episode

[Granny Charmed]

Jun 13, 2017 8:57:24 GMT -5 erikamarie said:

Jun 13, 2017 7:40:28 GMT -5 Granny Charmed said:

Current Tally (top 10 with 7 or more votes)

That 70s Episode
Deja Vu All Over Again
All Halliwell's Eve
Apocalypse Now
Womb Raidar
Wicca Envy
Awakened
All Hell Breaks Loose
Sight Unseen / Primrose Empath
From Fear to Eternity

Surprised dears Morality Bites and P3H20 and Charmed Again Part 1 are not higher. Womb Raidar being so high I am surprised, but The Seer dears is popular that might be why it is so loved.

Personal taste
For example, I don't like P3H20, I don't like how is described Sam's character and I think the story is prosaic, with a prosiac monster
Instead I love Charmed again part 1, it's not easy to make people smile after a funeral, but Piper was able to do it
I found very captivating the plot and Leo and Cole couldn't be better

Everyone has their favorites and least favourites dear. I did love Charmed Again Part 1, it was just part 2 I hated. If *only* the full 2 part episode was devoted to the material used in part 1. But still parts of Charmed Again bugged me, except the acting was great. 

Jun 14, 2017 0:55:31 GMT -5 sol said:

As I love The Day the Magic Dead, a true Charmed story, magic, humor, suspance..but many didn't like Wyatt so they can't respect sufficiently the episode

Oh yes dear, I think had it been Melinda who was born and we didn't have a twice blessed child. Fans would love this episode more. 

[Esmeralda]

Jun 14, 2017 0:55:31 GMT -5 sol said:

As I love The Day the Magic Dead, a true Charmed story, magic, humor, suspance..but many didn't like Wyatt so they can't respect sufficiently the episode

Had I included episodes from the spin-off (S4-8), this one definitely would've been on my list, just like Charmed Again, Part 1, but not Part 2. Although I didn't think it was a true Charmed story, since it's when the show permanently jumped the shark, when protecting Wyatt became more important than protecting innocents.

[rebooted]

Jun 13, 2017 7:40:28 GMT -5 Granny Charmed said:

Current Tally (top 10 with 7 or more votes)

That 70s Episode
Deja Vu All Over Again
All Halliwell's Eve
Apocalypse Now
Womb Raidar
Wicca Envy
Awakened
All Hell Breaks Loose
Sight Unseen / Primrose Empath
From Fear to Eternity

Surprised dears Morality Bites and P3H20 and Charmed Again Part 1 are not higher. Womb Raidar being so high I am surprised, but The Seer dears is popular that might be why it is so loved.

Hey GC!

With your magic words - the rankings have changed with Morality Bites getting 7 votes.

Which means the top 10/11 (votes with 7 or more):

13 votes
That 70s Ep

11 votes
De Ja Vu
All Halliwells Eve

8 votes
Apocalypse Not
Wicca Envy
Womb Raider

7 votes
From Fear to Eternity
Morality
Awakened 
Sight Unseen / Primrose Empath
AHBL

I'm also surprised that Charmed Again P1 and SWTWComes aren't higher up the list with only 5 and 6 votes respectively. Also, some other landmark episodes like Charmed and Dangerous and Centennial didn't make the cut.

I'm surprised that Kill Billie Vol 2 and I Dream of Phoebe are in fans' top 12' eps and higher rated than the one's I've just mentioned.

Not surprised that Chris Crossed is popular given that there is a huge fan base out there for Chris and Wyatt.

Like you, I am surprised that Womb Raider is so popular. It's the last one I voted for chronologically. I would have bene happy if Charmed finished here with Piper knowing that she's pregnant at the end of this episode.

Interesting that Season 7 on the whole is generally more well received that 5, 6 and 8 on this board but no episodes even get a vote. Makes me think that Season 7 was an average season across the board but 5, 6 and 8 had some very horrible but some stand out episodes. 

SWTWGoes is arguably the best episode of Season 7 and 8 combined and is a preferred series finale over Forever Charmed yet, not one vote. 

Interesting results !

[sol]

I'm also surprised that Charmed Again P1 and SWTWComes aren't higher up the list with only 5 and 6 votes respectively. Also, some other landmark episodes like Charmed and Dangerous and Centennial didn't make the cut.



I'm surprised that Kill Billie Vol 2 and I Dream of Phoebe are in fans' top 12' eps and higher rated than the one's I've just mentioned.



Not surprised that Chris Crossed is popular given that there is a huge fan base out there for Chris and Wyatt.

You mentioned all my favorite episodes, Chris Crossed and Kill Billie v 2 above all
Even if I wasn't a Chris and Wyatt fan I'll judge Chris Crossed one of Charmed best episode, full of patos, action, family drama 

[Granny Charmed]

Jun 15, 2017 22:49:24 GMT -5 rebooted said:

Jun 13, 2017 7:40:28 GMT -5 Granny Charmed said:

Current Tally (top 10 with 7 or more votes)

That 70s Episode
Deja Vu All Over Again
All Halliwell's Eve
Apocalypse Now
Womb Raidar
Wicca Envy
Awakened
All Hell Breaks Loose
Sight Unseen / Primrose Empath
From Fear to Eternity

Surprised dears Morality Bites and P3H20 and Charmed Again Part 1 are not higher. Womb Raidar being so high I am surprised, but The Seer dears is popular that might be why it is so loved.

Hey GC!

With your magic words - the rankings have changed with Morality Bites getting 7 votes.

Which means the top 10/11 (votes with 7 or more):

13 votes
That 70s Ep

11 votes
De Ja Vu
All Halliwells Eve

8 votes
Apocalypse Not
Wicca Envy
Womb Raider

7 votes
From Fear to Eternity
Morality
Awakened 
Sight Unseen / Primrose Empath
AHBL

I'm also surprised that Charmed Again P1 and SWTWComes aren't higher up the list with only 5 and 6 votes respectively. Also, some other landmark episodes like Charmed and Dangerous and Centennial didn't make the cut.

I'm surprised that Kill Billie Vol 2 and I Dream of Phoebe are in fans' top 12' eps and higher rated than the one's I've just mentioned.

Not surprised that Chris Crossed is popular given that there is a huge fan base out there for Chris and Wyatt.

Like you, I am surprised that Womb Raider is so popular. It's the last one I voted for chronologically. I would have bene happy if Charmed finished here with Piper knowing that she's pregnant at the end of this episode.

Interesting that Season 7 on the whole is generally more well received that 5, 6 and 8 on this board but no episodes even get a vote. Makes me think that Season 7 was an average season across the board but 5, 6 and 8 had some very horrible but some stand out episodes. 

SWTWGoes is arguably the best episode of Season 7 and 8 combined and is a preferred series finale over Forever Charmed yet, not one vote. 

Interesting results !

Hello dear. I have really enjoyed this thread and watching the results grow, a fantastic update to West's separate threads. 

Hehe yes, I had to vote Morality Bites up, it wouldn't *feel* right if it wasn't among the top 10 or 13. 

Charmed Again P1 and SWTWComes I am surprised dear. Even Charmed and Dangerous and Long Live the Queen, since I know some fans adored those. But again, when you have to pick just 12 dear. I suppose, some episodes just don't make the cut. 

Womb Raider could of been an ending with Piper learning she is pregnant. If only Cole stays away and Phoebe does just receive a note without his voice in the wind.

I am curious dear, slightly off-topic had the episode Witch Way Now not existed at the end of season 4, and they saved that story for the end of season 8. Would they have accepted the offer. Maybe here, they are given more time, and offered it after Leo was frozen and the decision must be made *once* the final battle was over. Might make a great new thread idea. 

I have to agree that season 7 was *much* better than the other later seasons dear, especially the second half. 5, 6 and 8 seem to be regarded as those seasons that are hated, but 6 especially do have fans of Wyatt and Chris. 

[Esmeralda]

Not sure if this really belongs here, but since others wondered about latter season favorites and I only did my S1-3 favorites, I decided to add it anyway. Since Rebooted started with the 50 top episodes from the previous polls, I decided to re-list from another thread my 50 favorite episodes. Like before, these aren't ones I consider the best episodes, just ones that are my favorites and that if they're on TNT, I'll sit down and watch.

If anyone else wants to do the same, go for it. I'm just curious as to which episodes current members like as compared to when West did his polls.

1. Something Wicca This Way Comes
2. Dead Man Dating
3. The Fourth Sister
4. The Truth is Out There...And it Hurts
5. The Witch is Back
6. Wicca Envy
7. From Fear to Eternity
8. Secrets and Guys
9. That 70's Episode
10. When Bad Warlocks Turn Good
11. The Power of Two
12. Out of Sight
13. Love Hurts
14. Deja vu All Over Again

15. Morality Bites (My favorite Episode)
16. They're Everywhere
17. P3 H20
18. Heartbreak City
19. Reckless Abandon
20. Show Me a Sign
21. Murphy's Luck
22. Chick Flick
23. Ex Libris
24. Apocalypse Not

25. Once Upon a Time
26. All Halliwell's Eve
27. The Good, The Bad and the Cursed
28. Pre-Witched
29. Sin Francisco

30. Charmed Again, Part One
31. A Knight to Remember
32. Brain Drain
33. A Paige From the Past
34. Lost and Bound
35. Saving Private Leo

36. The Eyes Have It
37. The Day the Magic Died
38. Baby's First Demon
39. Cat House
40. Sense and Sense Ability

41. Little Monster
42. I Dream of Phoebe

43. Styx Feet Under
44. Carpe Demon
45. Show Ghouls
46. Scry Hard
47. Little Box of Horrors
48. Something Wicca This Way Goes

49. Payback's a Witch
50. The Jung and the Restless

Season One = 14 episodes
Season Two = 10 episodes
Season Three = 5 episodes
Season Four = 6 episodes
Season Five = 5 episodes
Season Six = 2 episodes
Season Seven = 6 episodes
Season Eight = 2 episodes

[rebooted]

Jun 17, 2017 6:48:23 GMT -5 Esmeralda said:

Not sure if this really belongs here, but since others wondered about latter season favorites and I only did my S1-3 favorites, I decided to add it anyway. Since Rebooted started with the 50 top episodes from the previous polls, I decided to re-list from another thread my 50 favorite episodes. Like before, these aren't ones I consider the best episodes, just ones that are my favorites and that if they're on TNT, I'll sit down and watch.

If anyone else wants to do the same, go for it. I'm just curious as to which episodes current members like as compared to when West did his polls.

1. Something Wicca This Way Comes
2. Dead Man Dating
3. The Fourth Sister
4. The Truth is Out There...And it Hurts
5. The Witch is Back
6. Wicca Envy
7. From Fear to Eternity
8. Secrets and Guys
9. That 70's Episode
10. When Bad Warlocks Turn Good
11. The Power of Two
12. Out of Sight
13. Love Hurts
14. Deja vu All Over Again

15. Morality Bites (My favorite Episode)
16. They're Everywhere
17. P3 H20
18. Heartbreak City
19. Reckless Abandon
20. Show Me a Sign
21. Murphy's Luck
22. Chick Flick
23. Ex Libris
24. Apocalypse Not

25. Once Upon a Time
26. All Halliwell's Eve
27. The Good, The Bad and the Cursed
28. Pre-Witched
29. Sin Francisco

30. Charmed Again, Part One
31. A Knight to Remember
32. Brain Drain
33. A Paige From the Past
34. Lost and Bound
35. Saving Private Leo

36. The Eyes Have It
37. The Day the Magic Died
38. Baby's First Demon
39. Cat House
40. Sense and Sense Ability

41. Little Monster
42. I Dream of Phoebe

43. Styx Feet Under
44. Carpe Demon
45. Show Ghouls
46. Scry Hard
47. Little Box of Horrors
48. Something Wicca This Way Goes

49. Payback's a Witch
50. The Jung and the Restless

Season One = 14 episodes
Season Two = 10 episodes
Season Three = 5 episodes
Season Four = 6 episodes
Season Five = 5 episodes
Season Six = 2 episodes
Season Seven = 6 episodes
Season Eight = 2 episodes

NICELY DONE! 

My top 50 comprise of only 50 episodes from Season 1-4

SWTWComes
The Witch is Back
Wicca Envy
From Fear to Eternity
Woogy
That 70's
Love Hurts
De Ja Vu
=8 Season 1

Morality Bites
Reckless Abandon
Pardon My Past
Chick Flick
Astral Monkey
Apocalypse Not
=6 Season 2

All of Season 3 except
Once Upon a Time
We All Scream
Wrestling
The Demon that Came in from the Cold
= 18 Season 3

All of Season 4 except
Enter the Demon
The Three Faces of Phoebe
Marry-Go Round
Witch Way Now?
=18 Season 4 --> Charmed Again P1 my most favourite


My top 25 and only faves from Season 5 - 8 are:
Sirens Song
Witches in Tights
The Eyes That Have It
Sympathy for the Demon
A Witch in Time
Sam I Am
Mummy
Centennial --> Fave Season 5 - 8 episode
Cat House
Sense and Sensibility
= 10 from Season 5

The PO3 Blondes
Loves A Witch
Little Monsters
Chris Crossed
= 4 from Season 6

Styx Feet Under
Someone To Witch Over Me
Witchness Protection
Ordinary Witches
Imaginary Fiends
Death Becomes Them
Something Wicca This Way Goes
= 7 from Season 7

Vaya Cons Leos
Paybacks A Witch
Kill Billie Vol 2
Forever Charmed
= 4 from Season 8



This was actually pretty fun!