|
Post by magena on Jul 18, 2017 11:32:20 GMT -5
I think there were different faction among the Elders
Gideon supported Leo's marriage against other Elders opinions and following he might have repented, noting Wyatt's power
The Elders were no stranger to working with evil, as in the Tribunal or in the control of the Hollow and they had the bad habit to play with the sisters life, as they were their little soldiers
Why they didn't help when magic was esposed? Or when the sisters were in danger with Zankou?
When Chris came back and alerted the sisters and Leo about Wyatt's future, the Elders'ld help with some advices or their tricks, instead they did nothing, maybe waiting that Gideon saved the day
|
|
|
Post by Melinda Halliwell on Jul 18, 2017 18:38:45 GMT -5
Bianca spoke of books of story, if the Charmed Ones were famous, their story'ld be well known Maybe like how the Winchester brothers have their books wherein God/Chuck's wrote about their adventures which could happen similarly or there about's in the future with the Charmed Ones if a relative, friend or innocent they'd previously saved done that perhaps.
|
|
|
Post by unakite on Jul 19, 2017 4:26:06 GMT -5
I agree that Bianca could be the mind of the plan She seems to be a determined, hasty woman capable of planning and acting
|
|
rebooted
Witch
Started watching at 12
Posts: 1,803
|
Post by rebooted on Jul 31, 2017 3:21:15 GMT -5
Random I know.
But it would have made way more sense if Phoebe's daughter came back from the future to save Wyatt. Not Chris.
And if they didn't want to show Alyssa Milano pregnant, they could have just skipped forward a couple of months or something. It would have made the Seasons 5 - 8 less Piper/Leo centric and it would have been... "How I met your father"... in Season 7... which again could have been a 50/50 storyline.
I loved the Mother-Daughter relationship in Charmed and it would have been nice seeing Phoebe bond with her daughter!
|
|
|
Post by charmedforlife28 on Aug 1, 2017 21:37:12 GMT -5
Random I know. But it would have made way more sense if Phoebe's daughter came back from the future to save Wyatt. Not Chris. And if they didn't want to show Alyssa Milano pregnant, they could have just skipped forward a couple of months or something. It would have made the Seasons 5 - 8 less Piper/Leo centric and it would have been... "How I met your father"... in Season 7... which again could have been a 50/50 storyline. I loved the Mother-Daughter relationship in Charmed and it would have been nice seeing Phoebe bond with her daughter! Wait why would it make more sense if Phoebe's daughter came back to save Wyatt instead of Chris. I understand that it would make it less piper-centric but I don't know if it would make more sense.
|
|
Esmeralda
Charmed
S2 "What If...?" Fan Fic Winner
Twenty Years Gone....But Never Forgotten.
Posts: 21,920
|
Post by Esmeralda on Aug 2, 2017 7:55:23 GMT -5
Random I know. But it would have made way more sense if Phoebe's daughter came back from the future to save Wyatt. Not Chris. And if they didn't want to show Alyssa Milano pregnant, they could have just skipped forward a couple of months or something. It would have made the Seasons 5 - 8 less Piper/Leo centric and it would have been... "How I met your father"... in Season 7... which again could have been a 50/50 storyline. I loved the Mother-Daughter relationship in Charmed and it would have been nice seeing Phoebe bond with her daughter! Wait why would it make more sense if Phoebe's daughter came back to save Wyatt instead of Chris. I understand that it would make it less piper-centric but I don't know if it would make more sense. If Chris never existed and the only kids in the future after the sisters died were Wyatt and Ladybug, it would've made plenty of sense and as we've said, made the show less Piper-centric, and also less male-centric rather than girl power as the show was supposed to be about. And just two kids would've been so much better than nine. Although Chris being Paige's daughter would've made even more sense since like Piper's son, she would've had whitelighter powers. Although I would prefer it being Phoebe's Ladybug who's dead in the future - killed by Wyatt - and the Elders turning her into a true whitelighter and send her back to the past to fix this. Especially if it was truly Gideon who had turned Wyatt and not Vicus, it could've made a great storyline that would've been a *CHARMED* one rather than a Poor, Poor Pitiful Piper one starring Holly Marie Combs, Brian Krause and Drew Fuller, and, oh, yes, also featuring Dorian Gregory, Alyssa Milano, and Rose McGowan.
|
|
rebooted
Witch
Started watching at 12
Posts: 1,803
|
Post by rebooted on Aug 2, 2017 20:56:46 GMT -5
Wait why would it make more sense if Phoebe's daughter came back to save Wyatt instead of Chris. I understand that it would make it less piper-centric but I don't know if it would make more sense. If Chris never existed and the only kids in the future after the sisters died were Wyatt and Ladybug, it would've made plenty of sense and as we've said, made the show less Piper-centric, and also less male-centric rather than girl power as the show was supposed to be about. And just two kids would've been so much better than nine. Although Chris being Paige's daughter would've made even more sense since like Piper's son, she would've had whitelighter powers. Although I would prefer it being Phoebe's Ladybug who's dead in the future - killed by Wyatt - and the Elders turning her into a true whitelighter and send her back to the past to fix this. Especially if it was truly Gideon who had turned Wyatt and not Vicus, it could've made a great storyline that would've been a *CHARMED* one rather than a Poor, Poor Pitiful Piper one starring Holly Marie Combs, Brian Krause and Drew Fuller, and, oh, yes, also featuring Dorian Gregory, Alyssa Milano, and Rose McGowan. I do like the idea of Chris/Christina being Paige's son from the future too.
But then again, Holly Marie Combs did get pregnant and Paige didn't have a partner at the time of Chris's birth so I guess this why it made sense
What I don't understand is that when Chris was exposed as a Witch in Chris Crossed, shouldn't they have calculated Chris's age and figured out that he was being born around the same time?...The girls were smarter than this.
|
|
Esmeralda
Charmed
S2 "What If...?" Fan Fic Winner
Twenty Years Gone....But Never Forgotten.
Posts: 21,920
|
Post by Esmeralda on Aug 3, 2017 1:29:03 GMT -5
If Chris never existed and the only kids in the future after the sisters died were Wyatt and Ladybug, it would've made plenty of sense and as we've said, made the show less Piper-centric, and also less male-centric rather than girl power as the show was supposed to be about. And just two kids would've been so much better than nine. Although Chris being Paige's daughter would've made even more sense since like Piper's son, she would've had whitelighter powers. Although I would prefer it being Phoebe's Ladybug who's dead in the future - killed by Wyatt - and the Elders turning her into a true whitelighter and send her back to the past to fix this. Especially if it was truly Gideon who had turned Wyatt and not Vicus, it could've made a great storyline that would've been a *CHARMED* one rather than a Poor, Poor Pitiful Piper one starring Holly Marie Combs, Brian Krause and Drew Fuller, and, oh, yes, also featuring Dorian Gregory, Alyssa Milano, and Rose McGowan. I do like the idea of Chris/Christina being Paige's son from the future too.
But then again, Holly Marie Combs did get pregnant and Paige didn't have a partner at the time of Chris's birth so I guess this why it made sense
What I don't understand is that when Chris was exposed as a Witch in Chris Crossed, shouldn't they have calculated Chris's age and figured out that he was being born around the same time?...The girls were smarter than this.
But "Chris" was introduced in Season Five and they didn't find out that Holly was pregnant until 'The Sword and the City' (she said at a convention that it was her favorite episode because she got to play with the sword and found out that she was pregnant), so Christina easily could've already been part of Charmed before Holly found out - Kern just wanted it to be all about brothers rather than sisters. Had that happened, then they would've had to do the same thing they did when she was pregnant in Season Eight - hide her pregnancy. And had they not found out, "Chris" would've only been part of the first eight episodes, as was previously planned (Drew Fuller has said that's how long he was originally signed) and probably not have changed his storyline as much, making him seem like such a liar. Him sticking around for an entire year screwing up the life of everyone he met never made a lot of sense to me. OR, for that matter, they could've still had Piper become pregnant - but perhaps having Melinda who could've been half-firefighter rather than half-whitelighter and perhaps a close friend of Paige's daughter Chris, who could've gone back into the past after Wyatt killed his sister... That's the storyline that could've become my favorite instead of one of my least-favorites.
|
|
|
Post by magena on Aug 29, 2017 12:25:48 GMT -5
I like Chris as Wyatt brother, I love the stories of brothers opposing each other, like the Atrids or the Plantagenet dynasty
The tie between cousins is weaker, a girl'ld be quickly identified as a daughter of one of the sisters, seeing the story of the Warren witches
Wyatt/Chris story was a very very good idea, I read it was wote before Holly' pregnancy
|
|
Esmeralda
Charmed
S2 "What If...?" Fan Fic Winner
Twenty Years Gone....But Never Forgotten.
Posts: 21,920
|
Post by Esmeralda on Aug 30, 2017 5:53:47 GMT -5
I'd agree - IF the brother vs. brother had been saved for a spin-off. Charmed was about women and Kern shanghaied it by making it about brothers. If they wanted to include a child from the future as part of Charmed and not the spin-off, she should've been female, and not Piper's, because that's part of what turned Charmed into "The Perils of Poor, Poor Pitiful Piper" STARRING HOLLY MARIE COMBS, BRIAN KRAUSE and DREW FULLER. Oh, yes, and also featuring Alyssa Milano and Rose McGowan. The show was about three sisters, not just one and her husband and her sons, and, oh, yes, also her two sisters.
|
|
|
Post by adzpower on Aug 30, 2017 11:36:29 GMT -5
This is definitely a problem with the later half of the show, instead of being a show about three sisters who happen to be witches protecting the innocent, it turned into a show about whitelighters who demon hunt.
I didn't want to see two brothers literally taking up an ENTIRE season of storylines, I wanted to see the sisters do what they do best, helping the innocent. If I wanted to see two brothers demon hunt, I'd watch Supernatural.
|
|
Esmeralda
Charmed
S2 "What If...?" Fan Fic Winner
Twenty Years Gone....But Never Forgotten.
Posts: 21,920
|
Post by Esmeralda on Aug 30, 2017 22:39:51 GMT -5
I agree, although I'd change it to "a show about witchlighters who demon hunt, along with a couple witches."
|
|
|
Post by sol on Aug 31, 2017 0:14:11 GMT -5
If the writers wished to introduce a future-kid plot, I'm happy about Chris ad Wyatt's baby brother, instead Chris as Paige's son - I agree with Magena, the link between cousins is different - or, worse, a Christine as Piper's daughter
Unfortunately, it is rare to see a good relationship between a brother and a sister in the TV series
|
|
rebooted
Witch
Started watching at 12
Posts: 1,803
|
Post by rebooted on Aug 31, 2017 3:46:10 GMT -5
If the writers wished to introduce a future-kid plot, I'm happy about Chris ad Wyatt's baby brother, instead Chris as Paige's son - I agree with Magena, the link between cousins is different - or, worse, a Christine as Piper's daughter Unfortunately, it is rare to see a good relationship between a brother and a sister in the TV series Monica and Ross !
|
|
cyma
Witch
Waiting
Posts: 1,447
|
Post by cyma on Aug 31, 2017 12:24:45 GMT -5
If the writers wished to introduce a future-kid plot, I'm happy about Chris ad Wyatt's baby brother, instead Chris as Paige's son - I agree with Magena, the link between cousins is different - or, worse, a Christine as Piper's daughter Unfortunately, it is rare to see a good relationship between a brother and a sister in the TV series Monica and Ross ! And there's Elena and Jeremy Gilbert from Vampire Diaries. Klaus and Rebekah Mikaelson from The Originals. Oliver and Thea Queen from Arrow: And lastly, the infamous twins Jaime and Cersei Lannister from the Game of Thrones: I was also pleasantly surprised that a horror movie like Occulus had this brother/sister duo with great chemistry, interactions and dialogues, trying to defeat an evil mirror responsible for many deaths over the centuries including their parents.
|
|
|
Post by gzv969 on Aug 31, 2017 15:58:46 GMT -5
For me I think Wyatt being the ultimate evil in the future was a bit too dark for him.
This is how I would have rewritten it.
It would have been better if Wyatt worked for a Source in the future more evil and powerful than him. Someone that corrupted him to evil and was using him to keep the charmed ones and his bothers/sisters and cousins in check.
The future Source would be phoebes Son that she thought had died but didn't. Not only does he have the sources powers from cole but also his mom/phoebes premonition making him virtually impossible to defeat in the future as he anticipates everything.
So Chris still comes back to the past to save Wyatt from corruption , but preferably with phoebes daughter ladybug. Both of them are the ones who have stood up the most to Wyatt and her brother the source in the future.
Wyatt in the future was turned by the source so easily because of an evil half created in him in his early childhood due to some trauma. And being blood relatives it made it so easy magically for the source to tap into that evil half and corrupt him. So that's what Chris and ladybug are trying to find out and eliminate in baby Wyatt. What created that trauma creating the power evil half. But ladybug also wants to ensure chris doesn't spill the beans to mom on her brother being the source and she also has a secret agenda to find out where her evil brother has been kept hidden all his childhood years in hopes to kill him and mom never finding out he still lived.
Chris poses as a whitelighter like before and ladybug as a young witch in college needing protection and guidance and she is able to get Leo to become her whitelighter. And she also convinces Leo to get the charmed ones to train her to be a witch so she can have access to the book and manor. Similar to Billie. But like how Billie was looking for her sister and getting into trouble, ladybug is looking for little evil brother and getting into all types of trouble and she won't tell her mom and aunts what she's looking for and who she really is.
Between her and chris and the fact that chris and ladybug seem to know so much about themselves, claiming they crossed paths in the past,and are best friends, will be so suspicious to the sisters. There is a weird close relationship between them going on. Also phoebe keeps seeing herself in ladybug but can't put her finger on it or get a premonition off her. Ladybug and Chris had used a future anti premonition spell that doesn't exist in the past. Something they had been using to prevent future Source from figuring out what they were planning.
And also ladybug has her dads heart throb orbing ability and the power of suggestion like cupids have but mixed with empathy. To suggest a thought and make you act on it. But she's still learning it. That's from her Cupid half and phoebes empathy side. Leo and the elders notice her Cupid like abilities and cannot figure out how she could have gotten those powers.
And by the way the charmed ones aren't really dead in the future in my story, like the tour guide in the future had told the people in the manor during the tour. The source just had them all put in a frozen state by a similar demon like the one we see in season 8 that froze Leo. Any relative that disobeys the source, he had that done to them. As a promise to future Wyatt that he wouldn't kill any of of their relatives.
|
|
Esmeralda
Charmed
S2 "What If...?" Fan Fic Winner
Twenty Years Gone....But Never Forgotten.
Posts: 21,920
|
Post by Esmeralda on Aug 31, 2017 21:43:23 GMT -5
For me I think Wyatt being the ultimate evil in the future was a bit too dark for him. This is how I would have rewritten it. It would have been better if Wyatt worked for a Source in the future more evil and powerful than him. Someone that corrupted him to evil and was using him to keep the charmed ones and his bothers/sisters and cousins in check. The future Source would be phoebes Son that she thought had died but didn't. Not only does he have the sources powers from cole but also his mom/phoebes premonition making him virtually impossible to defeat in the future as he anticipates everything. So Chris still comes back to the past to save Wyatt from corruption , but preferably with phoebes daughter ladybug. Both of them are the ones who have stood up the most to Wyatt and her brother the source in the future. Wyatt in the future was turned by the source so easily because of an evil half created in him in his early childhood due to some trauma. And being blood relatives it made it so easy magically for the source to tap into that evil half and corrupt him. So that's what Chris and ladybug are trying to find out and eliminate in baby Wyatt. What created that trauma creating the power evil half. But ladybug also wants to ensure chris doesn't spill the beans to mom on her brother being the source and she also has a secret agenda to find out where her evil brother has been kept hidden all his childhood years in hopes to kill him and mom never finding out he still lived. Chris poses as a whitelighter like before and ladybug as a young witch in college needing protection and guidance and she is able to get Leo to become her whitelighter. And she also convinces Leo to get the charmed ones to train her to be a witch so she can have access to the book and manor. Similar to Billie. But like how Billie was looking for her sister and getting into trouble, ladybug is looking for little evil brother and getting into all types of trouble and she won't tell her mom and aunts what she's looking for and who she really is. Between her and chris and the fact that chris and ladybug seem to know so much about themselves, claiming they crossed paths in the past,and are best friends, will be so suspicious to the sisters. There is a weird close relationship between them going on. Also phoebe keeps seeing herself in ladybug but can't put her finger on it or get a premonition off her. Ladybug and Chris had used a future anti premonition spell that doesn't exist in the past. Something they had been using to prevent future Source from figuring out what they were planning. And also ladybug has her dads heart throb orbing ability and the power of suggestion like cupids have but mixed with empathy. To suggest a thought and make you act on it. But she's still learning it. That's from her Cupid half and phoebes empathy side. Leo and the elders notice her Cupid like abilities and cannot figure out how she could have gotten those powers. And by the way the charmed ones aren't really dead in the future in my story, like the tour guide in the future had told the people in the manor during the tour. The source just had them all put in a frozen state by a similar demon like the one we see in season 8 that froze Leo. Any relative that disobeys the source, he had that done to them. As a promise to future Wyatt that he wouldn't kill any of of their relatives. WOW, GZV! You keep coming up with the *best* alternate scenarios! ANOTHER fanfic I would *love* to see written and that would *love* to read! By the way, even if Phoebe calls her Ladybug, I think her name *should be* Billie. I remember the first time I heard that name - especially when I thought she was a brunette - I thought she was another visitor from the future - Phoebe's daughter named after Billy Applegate from 'Chick Flick'! But I LOVE the idea of the Phoetus becoming the Source in the future and *him* being the one who turns Wyatt, with both Phoetus' half-sister and Wyatt's brother trying to save him. A *great* way to combine S6 and S8 and make *both* of them tolerable!
|
|
|
Post by sol on Sept 1, 2017 0:43:38 GMT -5
I don't watch so much series, never seen Arrow or Vampires Friends was a sit com, it's more easy to manage a relationship big brother- baby sister GOT has revolutionized any kind of relationship between characters, moreover, the bond between the two twins is incestuous At the times of Charmed it'ld win the clichè "older brother who protects, little sister who gets into trouble"
|
|
|
Post by charmedforlife28 on Sept 1, 2017 16:45:33 GMT -5
For me I think Wyatt being the ultimate evil in the future was a bit too dark for him. This is how I would have rewritten it. It would have been better if Wyatt worked for a Source in the future more evil and powerful than him. Someone that corrupted him to evil and was using him to keep the charmed ones and his bothers/sisters and cousins in check. The future Source would be phoebes Son that she thought had died but didn't. Not only does he have the sources powers from cole but also his mom/phoebes premonition making him virtually impossible to defeat in the future as he anticipates everything. So Chris still comes back to the past to save Wyatt from corruption , but preferably with phoebes daughter ladybug. Both of them are the ones who have stood up the most to Wyatt and her brother the source in the future. Wyatt in the future was turned by the source so easily because of an evil half created in him in his early childhood due to some trauma. And being blood relatives it made it so easy magically for the source to tap into that evil half and corrupt him. So that's what Chris and ladybug are trying to find out and eliminate in baby Wyatt. What created that trauma creating the power evil half. But ladybug also wants to ensure chris doesn't spill the beans to mom on her brother being the source and she also has a secret agenda to find out where her evil brother has been kept hidden all his childhood years in hopes to kill him and mom never finding out he still lived. Chris poses as a whitelighter like before and ladybug as a young witch in college needing protection and guidance and she is able to get Leo to become her whitelighter. And she also convinces Leo to get the charmed ones to train her to be a witch so she can have access to the book and manor. Similar to Billie. But like how Billie was looking for her sister and getting into trouble, ladybug is looking for little evil brother and getting into all types of trouble and she won't tell her mom and aunts what she's looking for and who she really is. Between her and chris and the fact that chris and ladybug seem to know so much about themselves, claiming they crossed paths in the past,and are best friends, will be so suspicious to the sisters. There is a weird close relationship between them going on. Also phoebe keeps seeing herself in ladybug but can't put her finger on it or get a premonition off her. Ladybug and Chris had used a future anti premonition spell that doesn't exist in the past. Something they had been using to prevent future Source from figuring out what they were planning. And also ladybug has her dads heart throb orbing ability and the power of suggestion like cupids have but mixed with empathy. To suggest a thought and make you act on it. But she's still learning it. That's from her Cupid half and phoebes empathy side. Leo and the elders notice her Cupid like abilities and cannot figure out how she could have gotten those powers. And by the way the charmed ones aren't really dead in the future in my story, like the tour guide in the future had told the people in the manor during the tour. The source just had them all put in a frozen state by a similar demon like the one we see in season 8 that froze Leo. Any relative that disobeys the source, he had that done to them. As a promise to future Wyatt that he wouldn't kill any of of their relatives. I love this idea so much!
|
|
|
Post by gzv969 on Sept 1, 2017 17:23:31 GMT -5
For me I think Wyatt being the ultimate evil in the future was a bit too dark for him. This is how I would have rewritten it. It would have been better if Wyatt worked for a Source in the future more evil and powerful than him. Someone that corrupted him to evil and was using him to keep the charmed ones and his bothers/sisters and cousins in check. The future Source would be phoebes Son that she thought had died but didn't. Not only does he have the sources powers from cole but also his mom/phoebes premonition making him virtually impossible to defeat in the future as he anticipates everything. So Chris still comes back to the past to save Wyatt from corruption , but preferably with phoebes daughter ladybug. Both of them are the ones who have stood up the most to Wyatt and her brother the source in the future. Wyatt in the future was turned by the source so easily because of an evil half created in him in his early childhood due to some trauma. And being blood relatives it made it so easy magically for the source to tap into that evil half and corrupt him. So that's what Chris and ladybug are trying to find out and eliminate in baby Wyatt. What created that trauma creating the power evil half. But ladybug also wants to ensure chris doesn't spill the beans to mom on her brother being the source and she also has a secret agenda to find out where her evil brother has been kept hidden all his childhood years in hopes to kill him and mom never finding out he still lived. Chris poses as a whitelighter like before and ladybug as a young witch in college needing protection and guidance and she is able to get Leo to become her whitelighter. And she also convinces Leo to get the charmed ones to train her to be a witch so she can have access to the book and manor. Similar to Billie. But like how Billie was looking for her sister and getting into trouble, ladybug is looking for little evil brother and getting into all types of trouble and she won't tell her mom and aunts what she's looking for and who she really is. Between her and chris and the fact that chris and ladybug seem to know so much about themselves, claiming they crossed paths in the past,and are best friends, will be so suspicious to the sisters. There is a weird close relationship between them going on. Also phoebe keeps seeing herself in ladybug but can't put her finger on it or get a premonition off her. Ladybug and Chris had used a future anti premonition spell that doesn't exist in the past. Something they had been using to prevent future Source from figuring out what they were planning. And also ladybug has her dads heart throb orbing ability and the power of suggestion like cupids have but mixed with empathy. To suggest a thought and make you act on it. But she's still learning it. That's from her Cupid half and phoebes empathy side. Leo and the elders notice her Cupid like abilities and cannot figure out how she could have gotten those powers. And by the way the charmed ones aren't really dead in the future in my story, like the tour guide in the future had told the people in the manor during the tour. The source just had them all put in a frozen state by a similar demon like the one we see in season 8 that froze Leo. Any relative that disobeys the source, he had that done to them. As a promise to future Wyatt that he wouldn't kill any of of their relatives. WOW, GZV! You keep coming up with the *best* alternate scenarios! ANOTHER fanfic I would *love* to see written and that would *love* to read! By the way, even if Phoebe calls her Ladybug, I think her name *should be* Billie. I remember the first time I heard that name - especially when I thought she was a brunette - I thought she was another visitor from the future - Phoebe's daughter named after Billy Applegate from 'Chick Flick'! But I LOVE the idea of the Phoetus becoming the Source in the future and *him* being the one who turns Wyatt, with both Phoetus' half-sister and Wyatt's brother trying to save him. A *great* way to combine S6 and S8 and make *both* of them tolerable! I called her ladybug because I couldn't think of a name for her 😊 But I love your idea to use Billie from "Kill it before it dies", though Billie was the guy😊
|
|