rebooted
Witch
Started watching at 12
Posts: 1,803 
|
Post by rebooted on May 20, 2019 5:01:17 GMT -5
Its also funny how TW King left because he wanted a staring role when really, Leo's character monopolised Season 6 and 7 If only Ted knew, he'd get a bigger role most likely eventually. I think he would have, especially when Andy knew the secret, he'd have more of a role in S2, or more screentime with the sisters. Too True. I would have liked for him to have be relocated to like Sacramento or something and catching up with Prue in the weekends or something like that. It would have allowed her to be more with Piper and Phoebe and persue her passions like she did in Season 2. Also I would have liked Leo to maybe leave by the end of Season 1 when Piper knew she couldn't be with him because their love was forbidden - and that he was a creep that had watched her since a baby. Yuk. I would have preferred her being with Dan. I do like the idea of Phoebe being with a Richard or someone who abuses power after Cole died in Sleuthing. Imagine Charmed Again with Andy grieving Prue like a sister, Piper with Dan (left a little to the side) and Richard helping Phoebe find out more information about Paige through his underground ties. |
|
|
|
Post by CharmedFaith on Mar 6, 2022 0:07:26 GMT -5
Oh My Goddess. If they had to write him out, he finally ascended to the highest power there was but that would involve making The Elders mysterious and having to stay in "heaven" full time again isntead of them just doing whatever they felt like.
|
|
Aaeiyn
Elder
✨The Amazing Phoebe✨
Posts: 5,554
|
Post by Aaeiyn on Mar 6, 2022 8:17:31 GMT -5
I picked two conflicting answers:
S1E10 Wicca Envy
S6E16 The Courtship of Wyatt's Father
S1E10 Wicca Envy would've been the earliest time to get rid of the mess that were whitelighters.
S6E16 The Courtship of Wyatt's Father is the latest one that makes sense, and we'll still have baby Wyatt & Chris. Along with if Whitelighters must stay.
|
|
rebooted
Witch
Started watching at 12
Posts: 1,803
|
Post by rebooted on Apr 8, 2022 1:44:58 GMT -5
I just said something in another thread about this, Maybe Murphy's Luck was the perfect spot to end Leo. Him getting his wings back because she chooses his job as a whitelighter to help people over Piper, and to have his wings back he has to give up Piper, or Leo realizes that his job as a whitelighter is more important than what he has with Piper. Piper and Leo got off way too easy. When the Elders gave him his wings back, they let him and Piper stay together, when they took Leo away, they let Leo come back straight away, when the sisters saved the Elders, they let them get married. I don't know, they really had it too easy. Leo was gifted the job as a whitelighter in the first place, because of his great service in his former life as a mortal. Yet, coming back as a whitelighter is such a gift in itself. Yet he's allowed a second chance at a family and love, and I feel somewhat Leo got it way too good. Really I can see why whitelighters just need to do the job, and not get muddled up with love and having children of their own. Because it gets in the way of the job, of course, they will put the family above the job when push comes to shove. Being a whitelighter stopped being a gift and an honor for what you did in your last life, and I feel Leo took advantage of it by being with Piper. I'm sure people will not feel this way as I do. Because when I look at the bigger picture, I just feel the two really had it too easy. I think Murphy's Luck would make a great send-off to Piper and Leo and Leo on the series. It would end their relationship on a much better note, and they part ways on good terms. You do make some good points Marlene. That whitelighters did not feel that special when they started having children, who then went on to have powers too. That just made the whole purpose and specialness of whitelighters not so special anymore. I agree Murphy's Luck would have been good for Leo to leave. I am trying to remember when Dan and Piper stop seeing each other because it would have been great if the triangle storyline ended up with neither Dan or Leo. |
|
Esmeralda
Charmed
S2 "What If...?"
Fan Fic Winner
Twenty Years Gone....But Never Forgotten.
Posts: 21,920 
|
Post by Esmeralda on Apr 9, 2022 11:44:47 GMT -5
I think Murphy's Luck would make a great send-off to Piper and Leo and Leo on the series. It would end their relationship on a much better note, and they part ways on good terms. You do make some good points Marlene. That whitelighters did not feel that special when they started having children, who then went on to have powers too. That just made the whole purpose and specialness of whitelighters not so special anymore. I agree Murphy's Luck would have been good for Leo to leave. I am trying to remember when Dan and Piper stop seeing each other because it would have been great if the triangle storyline ended up with neither Dan or Leo. Unfortunately we had to tolerate Dan until the end of S2. Personally I would've preferred if Leo had stayed away after 'Love Hurts' or if he had to come back, he stayed away until Dan was gone. S2 could've been such a perfect season if there were not triangles, since it includes both the innocents I still love to love and the baddies still I love to hate, which isn't really true for me in any other season. I'll always wonder whether or not if Leo had stayed in S1 and Andy had continued instead if we would've had an Andy-Prue-Dan triangle; if that was always their plan, especially if they had Prue and Andy as the divorced couple with a daughter in 'Morality Bites' rather than Piper and Leo. Had that been the case, I think I'd still find myself wishing that my favorite episode had never been aired because it would force Prue to want to stay with her first love when someone whose life wasn't as dangerous as a witch or a cop (or a whitelighter) would've been better for her. |
|
Aaeiyn
Elder
✨The Amazing Phoebe✨
Posts: 5,554
|
Post by Aaeiyn on Apr 9, 2022 13:58:24 GMT -5
I'll always wonder whether or not if Leo had stayed in S1 and Andy had continued instead if we would've had an Andy-Prue-Dan triangle; if that was always their plan, especially if they had Prue and Andy as the divorced couple with a daughter in 'Morality Bites' rather than Piper and Leo. Had that been the case, I think I'd still find myself wishing that my favorite episode had never been aired because it would force Prue to want to stay with her first love when someone whose life wasn't as dangerous as a witch or a cop (or a whitelighter) would've been better for her. I don't understand the appeal of love triangle storylines. I hated it in Charmed and hate it in other shows like Boy/Girl Meets World, Pretty Little Liars, etc. They just frustrate me. And, IDK how I feel about the concept of Prue being with someone who isn't magical/a cop (Andy)/a "bad boy" or criminal (via Bane, T.J., etc.)/one who "doesn't bring danger", but she's the one "bringing the danger". IDK, doesn't seem right, to me :/ |
|
