Prue's worst season

[shay321]

So I was messing around and watched all those beautiful questions and polls and i got motivated to add one more to the fandom about Prue. In which one do you think she had the worst appearance overall (for example: from sistersly aspect towards her sisters, from witchy aspect which powers were clumsy written to appeal the character even more, from character aspect about her pride,stubbornness and overshadowing others, clothing aspect and the almost every episode forced romance). Keep in mind those are just some criteria to vote for 

Have fun!!

[BriannaWarren2.0]

I loved Prue in the seasons one through three however, I felt like at the ending of Prue's time on the show, she became ALMOST unwatchable: 

• She was doing martial arts (episodes for reference: Wrestling With Demons | Primrose Empath) the thing that made Phoebe special and unique, that didn't help the rumours that Shannen and Alyssa were feuding behind the scenes. 

• She became prideful: we all know that is Prue's downfall, she was almost able to save every innocent, including Tom Peters, which I would have loved if she had lost. 
• Being hypocritical (episodes for reference: Wrestling With Demons | The Good, The Bad, and the Cursed) she was willing to save Tom Peters a man that we haven't heard from prior or succeeding the episode he was in (WWD) however she was pissed off that Phoebe wanted to save Cole, a demon that she fell in love with, the demon willing to help you, someone who doesn't like him to save her sister. 

I am pretty sure I can name a few others, I just have to rewatch the series again, I do love Prue however during season three she really annoyed me and as someone who is the eldest in their trio, I hated it. 

[Elle Em]

I voted for season 3. She was obnoxious at times and didn't really seem like herself. 

I thought her best season was 2, which was a nice balance of her as the typical oldest child that also showed her relaxing a bit more about life. I also liked her in season 1 though, even when she was too uptight and bossy.

[Esmeralda]

Season Three makes me glad Prue died when she did. You can see Kern's influence during S3 and seeing what he turned Piper into and thinking that's what he thinks the Oldest should be like, I would've hated watch him ruin Prue's character even more than I hated watching him ruin Piper and Phoebe.

[shay321]

Jun 30, 2021 3:24:09 GMT -5 BriannaWarren2.0 said:

I loved Prue in the seasons one through three however, I felt like at the ending of Prue's time on the show, she became ALMOST unwatchable: 

• She was doing martial arts (episodes for reference: Wrestling With Demons | Primrose Empath) the thing that made Phoebe special and unique, that didn't help the rumours that Shannen and Alyssa were feuding behind the scenes. 

• She became prideful: we all know that is Prue's downfall, she was almost able to save every innocent, including Tom Peters, which I would have loved if she had lost. 
• Being hypocritical (episodes for reference: Wrestling With Demons | The Good, The Bad, and the Cursed) she was willing to save Tom Peters a man that we haven't heard from prior or succeeding the episode he was in (WWD) however she was pissed off that Phoebe wanted to save Cole, a demon that she fell in love with, the demon willing to help you, someone who doesn't like him to save her sister. 

I am pretty sure I can name a few others, I just have to rewatch the series again, I do love Prue however during season three she really annoyed me and as someone who is the eldest in their trio, I hated it. 

Girl I hated her in ‘’Wrestling with demons” during the ending with phoebe by the fireplace. I mean first in ‘Coyote Piper’’ she says to Phoebs: ‘’You have to know that you can talk to me and I’m not gonna judge you’’ and two episodes later Prue does exactly the same thing as phoebs, motivated by emotions as Halliwells always do, yet she proceeds giving hard time to phoebs for saving her epic love. Phoebs was trying to convince Prue and herself that she did the right thing by not killing Cole, she did actually at least the first time around, by explaining her actions and prue not handling it well she responds dismissively ‘’ His good side and bad side are  both dead’’ as if cole is season 3, at least, didn’t deserve to be saved. That felt like crocodile tears to me…. Not only that but her wardrobe was all over the map she went from slutty to granny outfits which some were epic fails, nothing like the good old classy Prue.



The cherry on top was her dating timeline she went from Dick in ‘’be careful what you witch for’’ to Micah to Shaw to Justin (the last two were  very poorly treated) to Tj (we never found out what happened to him, after Prue exposed magic in this episode) and lastly the two romances in ‘’Look who’s barking’’ episode from the guy she was smouching of the porch as phoebs said to this journalist whom ran her over, with the speed of light. I mean she was even worst compared to Phoebs when dealing with men, its justified for the youngest sisters to be the most naïve, guiltless or’’ low moral value’’ at times but Prue was supposed to be the role model for her sisters yet she failed big time acting like a Freebie. No wonder why Phoebs whom looked up to Prue ended up dating uncontrollably after Jason.

[goldeneye049]

For me it's season 1. The first part. For example, she yells at Phoebe for having a premonition but uses her power to not wake Andy. She was a hypocrite and then became gentle. I don't hate her in season 3 I understand her point of view because Tom had not yet killed and it was still possible to save him. While Cole has killed several innocent people in the past and will eventually become a demon again, I think he has no soul and tried to be kind for Phoebe, to no avail. She was getting far too strict and cold. Piper and Phoebe only thought about Leo and Cole. In truth it's Phoebe who annoys me the most in season 3.

[Esmeralda]

Yup, I'm with you. I don't like Prue before 'Secrets and Guys' but I do like her during that episode and after it (if you put "Power of Two" earlier in the season - she and Phoebs seem too much like the earlier versions of them (naturally, Kern wrote the episode and I HATE how he writes the sisters unless it's an episode he wrote with someone else), while I only like her in S3 during 'All Halliwell's Eve', not enough to take away from it being my least-favorite Prue-season.

Phoebs is definitely my favorite during S1 and S2 and least-favorite in S3 once she meets Cole, the way I don't like Piper once she finds out that Leo is a whitelighter while loving her before that.

My favorite "season" is from 'Secrets and Guys' to 'Murphy's Luck'. With a few exceptions of bummer episodes or great ones, this is the only time I love all three sisters. I don't like Prue before it and I don't like Piper after it.

[BriannaWarren2.0]

Jul 1, 2021 8:38:39 GMT -5 shay321 said:

Jun 30, 2021 3:24:09 GMT -5 BriannaWarren2.0 said:

I loved Prue in the seasons one through three however, I felt like at the ending of Prue's time on the show, she became ALMOST unwatchable: 

• She was doing martial arts (episodes for reference: Wrestling With Demons | Primrose Empath) the thing that made Phoebe special and unique, that didn't help the rumours that Shannen and Alyssa were feuding behind the scenes. 

• She became prideful: we all know that is Prue's downfall, she was almost able to save every innocent, including Tom Peters, which I would have loved if she had lost. 
• Being hypocritical (episodes for reference: Wrestling With Demons | The Good, The Bad, and the Cursed) she was willing to save Tom Peters a man that we haven't heard from prior or succeeding the episode he was in (WWD) however she was pissed off that Phoebe wanted to save Cole, a demon that she fell in love with, the demon willing to help you, someone who doesn't like him to save her sister. 

I am pretty sure I can name a few others, I just have to rewatch the series again, I do love Prue however during season three she really annoyed me and as someone who is the eldest in their trio, I hated it. 

Girl I hated her in ‘’Wrestling with demons” during the ending with phoebe by the fireplace. I mean first in ‘Coyote Piper’’ she says to Phoebs: ‘’You have to know that you can talk to me and I’m not gonna judge you’’ and two episodes later Prue does exactly the same thing as phoebs, motivated by emotions as Halliwells always do, yet she proceeds giving hard time to phoebs for saving her epic love. Phoebs was trying to convince Prue and herself that she did the right thing by not killing Cole, she did actually at least the first time around, by explaining her actions and prue not handling it well she responds dismissively ‘’ His good side and bad side are  both dead’’ as if cole is season 3, at least, didn’t deserve to be saved. That felt like crocodile tears to me…. Not only that but her wardrobe was all over the map she went from slutty to granny outfits which some were epic fails, nothing like the good old classy Prue.



The cherry on top was her dating timeline she went from Dick in ‘’be careful what you witch for’’ to Micah to Shaw to Justin (the last two were  very poorly treated) to Tj (we never found out what happened to him, after Prue exposed magic in this episode) and lastly the two romances in ‘’Look who’s barking’’ episode from the guy she was smouching of the porch as phoebs said to this journalist whom ran her over, with the speed of light. I mean she was even worst compared to Phoebs when dealing with men, its justified for the youngest sisters to be the most naïve, guiltless or’’ low moral value’’ at times but Prue was supposed to be the role model for her sisters yet she failed big time acting like a Freebie. No wonder why Phoebs whom looked up to Prue ended up dating uncontrollably after Jason.

The issue with the whole motivated by emotions is that throughout the series they should have had a better understanding on how to control them especially Prue since her trigger is anger, so they made that her first response to any disagreements, I would have expected her to know that she can't automatically react with that emotion. 

I did feel like those tears were crocodile tears. It's a manipulative tactic. 

Her wardrobe could have been amazing, I would have kept her at Bucklands, working her way up the business with her eventually purchasing the Auction House renaming it to 'Halliwell Auction House' since Bucklands took quite a hit after Rex and Hannah. I would have dressed her into business pant and skirt suits while at the office. [Reference: i.pinimg.com/originals/95/31/73/953173f831691b8943ed7d94d81fe114.jpg | I could totally see Prue wearing this while at the office]. I like a few of her casual outfits, I wouldn't have messed around with them too much, however I do wished they found a style for her. (I do believed she rocked Ms Hellfire's looks the best and would have made that her style)

I do think her dating timeline was all over the place, I would have wanted her to be with Bane, so she would be working and being a witch other than dating, waiting for him to be released from prison, writing letters to each other and actively seeing him trying to do better whilst behind bars. With Prue seeing this first hand she changes her view point on Cole and the whole "people can't change" mentality giving her something to relate to with Phoebe. 

[shay321]

Jul 2, 2021 1:01:15 GMT -5 BriannaWarren2.0 said:

Jul 1, 2021 8:38:39 GMT -5 shay321 said:

Girl I hated her in ‘’Wrestling with demons” during the ending with phoebe by the fireplace. I mean first in ‘Coyote Piper’’ she says to Phoebs: ‘’You have to know that you can talk to me and I’m not gonna judge you’’ and two episodes later Prue does exactly the same thing as phoebs, motivated by emotions as Halliwells always do, yet she proceeds giving hard time to phoebs for saving her epic love. Phoebs was trying to convince Prue and herself that she did the right thing by not killing Cole, she did actually at least the first time around, by explaining her actions and prue not handling it well she responds dismissively ‘’ His good side and bad side are  both dead’’ as if cole is season 3, at least, didn’t deserve to be saved. That felt like crocodile tears to me…. Not only that but her wardrobe was all over the map she went from slutty to granny outfits which some were epic fails, nothing like the good old classy Prue.



The cherry on top was her dating timeline she went from Dick in ‘’be careful what you witch for’’ to Micah to Shaw to Justin (the last two were  very poorly treated) to Tj (we never found out what happened to him, after Prue exposed magic in this episode) and lastly the two romances in ‘’Look who’s barking’’ episode from the guy she was smouching of the porch as phoebs said to this journalist whom ran her over, with the speed of light. I mean she was even worst compared to Phoebs when dealing with men, its justified for the youngest sisters to be the most naïve, guiltless or’’ low moral value’’ at times but Prue was supposed to be the role model for her sisters yet she failed big time acting like a Freebie. No wonder why Phoebs whom looked up to Prue ended up dating uncontrollably after Jason.

The issue with the whole motivated by emotions is that throughout the series they should have had a better understanding on how to control them especially Prue since her trigger is anger, so they made that her first response to any disagreements, I would have expected her to know that she can't automatically react with that emotion. 

I did feel like those tears were crocodile tears. It's a manipulative tactic. 

Her wardrobe could have been amazing, I would have kept her at Bucklands, working her way up the business with her eventually purchasing the Auction House renaming it to 'Halliwell Auction House' since Bucklands took quite a hit after Rex and Hannah. I would have dressed her into business pant and skirt suits while at the office. [Reference: i.pinimg.com/originals/95/31/73/953173f831691b8943ed7d94d81fe114.jpg | I could totally see Prue wearing this while at the office]. I like a few of her casual outfits, I wouldn't have messed around with them too much, however I do wished they found a style for her. (I do believed she rocked Ms Hellfire's looks the best and would have made that her style)

I do think her dating timeline was all over the place, I would have wanted her to be with Bane, so she would be working and being a witch other than dating, waiting for him to be released from prison, writing letters to each other and actively seeing him trying to do better whilst behind bars. With Prue seeing this first hand she changes her view point on Cole and the whole "people can't change" mentality giving her something to relate to with Phoebe. 

your ideas are quite great and have this season 1 vibe i like the continuing and most stable relationship with bane, and the halliwell aution house suits her more compare to the occasional photographer job 

[BriannaWarren2.0]

Jul 2, 2021 13:24:25 GMT -5 shay321 said:

Jul 2, 2021 1:01:15 GMT -5 BriannaWarren2.0 said:

The issue with the whole motivated by emotions is that throughout the series they should have had a better understanding on how to control them especially Prue since her trigger is anger, so they made that her first response to any disagreements, I would have expected her to know that she can't automatically react with that emotion. 

I did feel like those tears were crocodile tears. It's a manipulative tactic. 

Her wardrobe could have been amazing, I would have kept her at Bucklands, working her way up the business with her eventually purchasing the Auction House renaming it to 'Halliwell Auction House' since Bucklands took quite a hit after Rex and Hannah. I would have dressed her into business pant and skirt suits while at the office. [Reference: i.pinimg.com/originals/95/31/73/953173f831691b8943ed7d94d81fe114.jpg | I could totally see Prue wearing this while at the office]. I like a few of her casual outfits, I wouldn't have messed around with them too much, however I do wished they found a style for her. (I do believed she rocked Ms Hellfire's looks the best and would have made that her style)

I do think her dating timeline was all over the place, I would have wanted her to be with Bane, so she would be working and being a witch other than dating, waiting for him to be released from prison, writing letters to each other and actively seeing him trying to do better whilst behind bars. With Prue seeing this first hand she changes her view point on Cole and the whole "people can't change" mentality giving her something to relate to with Phoebe. 

your ideas are quite great and have this season 1 vibe i like the continuing and most stable relationship with bane, and the halliwell aution house suits her more compare to the occasional photographer job 

I am glad you like my opinions, Prue having a stable relationship and job just made sense, I could never see her as the type to have freelance work and date casually. 

[Elle Em]

Jul 2, 2021 18:36:39 GMT -5 BriannaWarren2.0 said:

Jul 2, 2021 13:24:25 GMT -5 shay321 said:

your ideas are quite great and have this season 1 vibe i like the continuing and most stable relationship with bane, and the halliwell aution house suits her more compare to the occasional photographer job 

I am glad you like my opinions, Prue having a stable relationship and job just made sense, I could never see her as the type to have freelance work and date casually. 

And on the other side of that, I could totally see Phoebe as a freelancer. Maybe they could give the photographer story to her instead of Prue, and Phoebe could be the one going all over the city to take photos for various clients. It would give her a job as well as something she's good at, since Phoebe seems more like the artsy one over Prue, who always seemed more intellectual even when she was working with artifacts and had knowledge of things like art history. 

[BriannaWarren2.0]

Jul 3, 2021 7:20:54 GMT -5 Elle Em said:

Jul 2, 2021 18:36:39 GMT -5 BriannaWarren2.0 said:

I am glad you like my opinions, Prue having a stable relationship and job just made sense, I could never see her as the type to have freelance work and date casually. 

And on the other side of that, I could totally see Phoebe as a freelancer. Maybe they could give the photographer story to her instead of Prue, and Phoebe could be the one going all over the city to take photos for various clients. It would give her a job as well as something she's good at, since Phoebe seems more like the artsy one over Prue, who always seemed more intellectual even when she was working with artifacts and had knowledge of things like art history. 

I can see her being a freelancer too. With Phoebe's psychology degree she could have seriously helped Maggie Murphy out.

Exactly, Prue didn't even want to be a photographer until she found out that's what she did in her past life. Prue being the more intellectual and responsible sister, she should have a job reflecting that, her being the owner of Bucklands would have been perfect for her since I could totally see her working her up through the chain of command finally being at the top.  

[Esmeralda]

Does anyone else wish that Piper never found out she had a daughter in the future or Prue find out that she was a photographer in a previous life? Both characters would've been more consistent if they never found out. I'd also prefer Phoebe as the photographer (or Paige as the photographer and Phoebe as the social worker) and Piper owning a bunch of P3s all over the country and never having a child.

[Elle Em]

Jul 4, 2021 7:01:51 GMT -5 Esmeralda said:

Does anyone else wish that Piper never found out she had a daughter in the future or Prue find out that she was a photographer in a previous life? Both characters would've been more consistent if they never found out. I'd also prefer Phoebe as the photographer (or Paige as the photographer and Phoebe as the social worker) and Piper owning a bunch of P3s all over the country and never having a child.

I wish this so much. Once Piper saw her daughter, or even knew of her existence, there was no way she would go back to her own time and not try to have her. But I think that once she started to try, that girl no longer existed as a possibility. 

As far as Prue, when I think back about the time I liked her the most, it was in season 2 when she was still at Bucklands but had more of a relaxed personality. Photography changed her too much and didn't fit who she really was, a professional with a full-time job.

I could also see Phoebe as a social worker and Paige as a photographer. I think photography best fits Paige over any of the sisters, actually. Imagine how irritated Piper would be when she meets Paige in season 4 and instead of having a sister with a full-time job, she now has a sister with a freelance photography gig. 

And I think I've been seeing Morality Bites in the wrong way. Prue took away from the experience to not become a workaholic and to live her life for things other than money and the corporate life. That was her lesson, to not drown in her work at the expense of all else. 

Then Phoebe obviously learned (and promptly forgot) a lesson about the wrongs things done for the right reason. The trip to the future taught her a lesson as well as Prue.

But what if it was teaching Piper a lesson as well? It's a much harder thing to uncover. Prue and Phoebe's lessons are very obvious: don't use your powers for evil, and don't become lost in your work. But what if Piper's lesson was to not marry Leo? It's so much harder to see it as a warning, especially because of Melinda's presence, because what kind of person would see their future child and not decide to have them? But the more I think about it, none of them should have ended up with the future they briefly lived in for themselves. 

[Esmeralda]

Jul 4, 2021 7:19:29 GMT -5 Elle Em said:

Jul 4, 2021 7:01:51 GMT -5 Esmeralda said:

Does anyone else wish that Piper never found out she had a daughter in the future or Prue find out that she was a photographer in a previous life? Both characters would've been more consistent if they never found out. I'd also prefer Phoebe as the photographer (or Paige as the photographer and Phoebe as the social worker) and Piper owning a bunch of P3s all over the country and never having a child.

I wish this so much. Once Piper saw her daughter, or even knew of her existence, there was no way she would go back to her own time and not try to have her. But I think that once she started to try, that girl no longer existed as a possibility. 

As far as Prue, when I think back about the time I liked her the most, it was in season 2 when she was still at Bucklands but had more of a relaxed personality. Photography changed her too much and didn't fit who she really was, a professional with a full-time job.

I could also see Phoebe as a social worker and Paige as a photographer. I think photography best fits Paige over any of the sisters, actually. Imagine how irritated Piper would be when she meets Paige in season 4 and instead of having a sister with a full-time job, she now has a sister with a freelance photography gig. 

And I think I've been seeing Morality Bites in the wrong way. Prue took away from the experience to not become a workaholic and to live her life for things other than money and the corporate life. That was her lesson, to not drown in her work at the expense of all else. 

Then Phoebe obviously learned (and promptly forgot) a lesson about the wrongs things done for the right reason. The trip to the future taught her a lesson as well as Prue.

But what if it was teaching Piper a lesson as well? It's a much harder thing to uncover. Prue and Phoebe's lessons are very obvious: don't use your powers for evil, and don't become lost in your work. But what if Piper's lesson was to not marry Leo? It's so much harder to see it as a warning, especially because of Melinda's presence, because what kind of person would see their future child and not decide to have them? But the more I think about it, none of them should have ended up with the future they briefly lived in for themselves. 

Agreed; completely totally. It's why I'd still love to see a retcon where we see what their lives would've been like had they learned all of those lessons...starting with 'Morality Bites'. Then I'd still love my favorite episode and not wish it had ever been aired, since I feel it screwed up Piper.

[BriannaWarren2.0]

Jul 4, 2021 7:01:51 GMT -5 Esmeralda said:

Does anyone else wish that Piper never found out she had a daughter in the future or Prue find out that she was a photographer in a previous life? Both characters would've been more consistent if they never found out. I'd also prefer Phoebe as the photographer (or Paige as the photographer and Phoebe as the social worker) and Piper owning a bunch of P3s all over the country and never having a child.

Not really but I wished they had wrote her to be more determined in her witchcraft, since she would want to be prepared for anything that went down, I know that if I was shown my future that I would be determined to get certain things established, like my knowledge about my family heritage and with my job before that child arrives. 

I could never see the Prue of this life working as a freelancer, which is why I would have kept her working at Bucklands, she would learn from her future self that she needs to have fun sometimes but she would also understand the importance of establishing herself financially and making sure that her money situation never dwells.

I would have written from day one that Phoebe is the one at home studying the Book Of Shadows, basically making her to be the encyclopaedia of magic. 

But, going back to the past life aspect, I wished that Prue and Phoebe would have researched their former selves and have an understanding to why their souls evolved in this way, since Piper's former self is their great-grandmother, they could have asked Grams about her, I wished they did though. 

But since it was written this way, I agree that they should have never shown them their past or future selves, especially because nothing was ever learnt from it nor did they take an interest in what they had experienced.

[Aaeiyn]

As the sole vote for S2, I guess I can explain this further, S2 Prue doesn't feel like Prue, to me. What happened to my very uptight and workaholic Prue, that was established in S1? At least S3 remembered to make her somewhat uptight and bossy, just like she was back in S1.

S2 Prue is completely unrecognizable, to me, from what was established, back in S1.

[wiccawonder]

Mar 28, 2023 8:49:37 GMT -5 Aaeiyn said:

As the sole vote for S2, I guess I can explain this further, S2 Prue doesn't feel like Prue, to me. What happened to my very uptight and workaholic Prue, that was established in S1? At least S3 remembered to make her somewhat uptight and bossy, just like she was back in S1.

S2 Prue is completely unrecognizable, to me, from what was established, back in S1.

I think Mortality Bites has a huge impact on Prue, and while a lot of people think it was negative, I actually think it was positive. Prue could see how she became a workaholic who woke up at her office, no husband, no children and had become someone who just fire people at the flick of her pen. While she probably enjoyed aspects of being able to travel, be in control of Bucklands and of course the money aspect of things, she saw her life as negative and didn’t want a future like that. I think her quitting and having more freedom to explore who she is outside of being a big sister and bread winner, was fantastic for her development! That is just me though.

[Aaeiyn]

Dec 15, 2023 4:27:18 GMT -5 wiccawonder said:

I think Mortality Bites has a huge impact on Prue, and while a lot of people think it was negative, I actually think it was positive. Prue could see how she became a workaholic who woke up at her office, no husband, no children and had become someone who just fire people at the flick of her pen. While she probably enjoyed aspects of being able to travel, be in control of Bucklands and of course the money aspect of things, she saw her life as negative and didn’t want a future like that. I think her quitting and having more freedom to explore who she is outside of being a big sister and bread winner, was fantastic for her development! That is just me though.

That's a good explanation, but I still don't like it, and IK I'm in the minority on that. I'm gonna double down that S2 Prue is NOTHING like S1 Prue, at all, and how Connie established her, to begin with.

She can still "find herself" without being a completely different character which is why I like how S3 handled her growth. It remembered her bossiness, unlike her S2 counterpart.

[wiccawonder]

Dec 15, 2023 19:14:40 GMT -5 Aaeiyn said:

Dec 15, 2023 4:27:18 GMT -5 wiccawonder said:

I think Mortality Bites has a huge impact on Prue, and while a lot of people think it was negative, I actually think it was positive. Prue could see how she became a workaholic who woke up at her office, no husband, no children and had become someone who just fire people at the flick of her pen. While she probably enjoyed aspects of being able to travel, be in control of Bucklands and of course the money aspect of things, she saw her life as negative and didn’t want a future like that. I think her quitting and having more freedom to explore who she is outside of being a big sister and bread winner, was fantastic for her development! That is just me though.

That's a good explanation, but I still don't like it, and IK I'm in the minority on that. I'm gonna double down that S2 Prue is NOTHING like S1 Prue, at all, and how Connie established her, to begin with.

She can still "find herself" without being a completely different character which is why I like how S3 handled her growth. It remembered her bossiness, unlike her S2 counterpart.

I think S2 Prue is just trying to find herself, she had Mortality Bites happen, explores her love without Andy, learns about her mother’s death and Sam, just so much going on for her here, I think naturally she’d seem off and is just figuring things out. I’m actually rewatching S2 at the moment and I personally don’t see how she is drastically different? I think she is probably less rigid and focused more on magic but doesn’t seem to be overly that different but maybe I’m just not seeing it? I don’t know?