PO3 vs Non-PO3

[Aaeiyn]

Nov 19, 2024 22:10:45 GMT -5 prueislove said:

Thank you for showing some love to s8. I feel its so hated on.

I do like S8 but my love for S8 isn't the reason for showcasing ALL THREE being present at the final fight/vanquish AND ACTUALLY CONTRIBUTING something. It's just objectively true.

Like, I like S7, but I need to be honest and show that it didn't too well with having ALL THREE present at the final fight/vanquish AND ACTUALLY CONTRIBUTING to the final fight/vanquish. It may suck, for me, but I need to be honest, in my findings.

Statistics don't lie. But, then again, some (not all) may not care about these LOL

[Aaeiyn]

If we're going to be honest about the season order in best representing all three sisters being present and contributing to the final fight/vanquish, the order will be like so:

S2 > S4 > S1 > S3 > S6 > S8 > S5 > S7

I compared every season with each other and selected the best episode that wasn't always repetitive with spellchanting, potion vanquishing, Piper blowing things up, etc. I tried to find the most unique final fight/vanquishes, as much as possible, between all 8 seasons & 22/23 episodes.

[Aaeiyn]

I'll be going over episodes that had ALL THREE sisters PRESENT, at the final fight/vanquish but 1, 2 or ALL 3 didn't really help, and I question why they were present, to begin with, but I digress.

S1E4 "Dead Man Dating" - Phoebe isn't really contributing to the final fight/vanquish. She's present but isn't contributing anything. Unless, we count her standing in front of Yama's lance (which I don't), that's about it.  Prue & Piper did most of the work with Prue TKing Wong's men & Piper freezing a gun bullet, to save Prue from being shot at.

S1E6 "The Wedding from Hell" - NONE of the sisters contributed to the final fight/vanquish. They (at least, Prue) delivered the knife to Elliot. I MIGHT consider the after thought editing of Prue TKing Hecate & the bride's maids into the knife, but I'm not convinced that scene intended that, but I digress. Yeah, the sisters were practically worthless, here.

S1E9 "The Witch is Back" - Only Prue & Piper contributed to this final fight/vanquish. Phoebe wasn't really involved and just stood there...

S1E10 "Wicca Envy" - Same as S1E9 "The Witch is Back", only Prue & Piper did anything, Phoebe did absolutely nothing, in this final fight/vanquish despite being present.

S1E11 "Feats of Clay" - NONE of the sisters did anything, in this final fight/vanquish despite ALL THREE being present. I guess Phoebe's presence was needed for Clay to perform his "selfless act" but even that's stretching it. IDK what more they could've done, perhaps Prue could've TK'd the Guardian of the Urn some more, IDK. They just seemed useless, here.

S1E22 "Deja Vu, all Over, Again" - Prue's the only one to really do anything, here, maybe Piper. Which is surprising because they specifically put Phoebe to answer the door to perform her martial arts, yet Phoebe performed NO martial arts, in this episode, whatsoever, but I digress. Prue said the spell to get rid of Tempus and even TK'd the energy ball back at Rodriguez. Both Phoebe & Piper seemed rather useless despite being present. I MIGHT give Piper credit for freezing Rodriguez but even then, not ALL THREE sisters contributed to the final fight/vanquish, of this episode.

---

This concludes S1 of ALL THREE sisters present, at the final fight/vanquish, but 1, 2 or ALL 3 didn't really help, and I question why they were present, to begin with, but I digress.