Rating the Seasons

[rebooted]

Mar 7, 2010 17:31:44 GMT -5 SEERofCHAOS said:

I don't like the scale but I will try my best. I will give reasons too.

Season 1-B It's still finding it's way. Some plots are a little to Buffy-ish in my opinion.

Season 2-A as Idiviual episodes, C as a whole season Dan and Jenny are some of the most annoying plot devices ever.

Season 3-A Truly the best season out of the whole show. The girl's personalities and performances were perfected this season.

Season 4-B Although the Evil Phoebe and Cole as the Source plot is flawed, I still find it enjoyable and dark, and I like dark.

Season 5-C Although this was honestly the weirdest season, some of the indviual episodes were good. Also I don't have much of a problem with Wyatt as a lot of people seem to have.

Season 6-F It's like morality was thrown right out the window. I hate Chris. I just hope baby Chris doesn't grow up to be like him.

Season 7-D The Charmed Ones are still as annoying as in season 6, but I can't give a proper rating because I haven't actually seen all of this season. Avatars sucked. Charisma Carpenter and Zankou saved this from an F.

Season 8-D Atleast they saved innocents a couple of times this season...

I do agree with the season 2 statement that for individual episodes I could give Season 2 an A on par with Season 1 (as an entire season). As an overall Season I give it a B because of Dan, Jenny, the unnecessary love triangle.

[zack]

S1 - 9.5/10
S2 - 7.5/10
S3 - 8/10
S4 - 4/10
S5 - 3/10
S6 - 6/10
S7 - 5/10
S8 - 1.5/10