Rating the Seasons

[Esmeralda]

If you had to rate each of the seasons:

A = THE BEST
B = VERY GOOD
C = GOOD
D = BAD
F = WORST

how would you rate them?

Here's mine:

Season 1 - A
Season 2 - A
Season 3 - B
Season 4 - B
Season 5 - C
Season 6 - F
Season 7 - D
Season 8 - F

[Astral Echo]

Season One - B
Season Two - B
Season Three - A
Season Four - A
Season Five - F
Season Six - C
Season Seven - D
Season Eight - F

[~B@MeLiSsA30@B~]

Season 1 - A
Season 2 - A
Season 3 - A
Season 4 - B
Season 5 - C
Season 6 - C
Season 7 - D
Season 8 - C

I don't dislike any of the seasons to give any a F.

[The Original P3]

Season 1 - A-
Season 2 - A
Season 3 - A++
Season 4 - B-
Season 5 - C
Season 6 - B+
Season 7 - F-------
Season 8 - F-----------------

[Fourever Charmed]

Season 1 - B
Season 2 - B+
Season 3 - A+
Season 4 - A++
Season 5 - F----------------
Season 6 - D-
Season 7 - D
Season 8 - F-----------------

[Esmeralda]

Well, if you're going to do + and -'s:

Season 1 - A
Season 2 - A++++++++++++++++++++++++
Season 3 - B
Season 4 - B--
Season 5 - C
Season 6 - F---------------------------------------------
Season 7 - D
Season 8 - F -----------------------------------

[ljones]

Season 1 - B
Season 2 - C
Season 3 - A
Season 4 - B
Season 5 - D
Season 6 - C
Season 7 - D
Season 8 - F

[Astral Echo]

So far our ratings average out at about:

Season 1 - A/B
Season 2 - A
Season 3 - A
Season 4 - A/B
Season 5 - D
Season 6 - C
Season 7 - D
Season 8 - F

So Season Three is currently rating higher than any other season, if I did the above with +'s, its the only one that would recieve one working on the averages of results seen below but Season Two would be very closely behind. Odd that, I remember back along people hating S2, I agree that it's pretty awesome! Even with Dan and his annoying niece!

[Fourever Charmed]

I entered the grades into an online grading calculator (including plus or minuses, but not multiple [+++++++ or ----------], and because I didn't do multiple I changed my A++ and A+ for seasons four and three to A+ and A) and this is what it came out with:

Season 1 - B+
Season 2 - B+
Season 3 - A
Season 4 - B+
Season 5 - D+
Season 6 - C-
Season 7 - D
Season 8 - F

[**Teyla_Emmagan**]

Season 1 - B
Season 2 - B
Season 3 - A
Season 4 - A
Season 5 - B
Season 6 - C
Season 7 - B
Season 8 - D

[Fourever Charmed]

Calculating in Teyla's votes, the only season that changes its average is Season 7 from D to D+.

[Esmeralda]

If you're going to do averaging, let's try this, which I saw at a different site. Rate them this way:

A = THE BEST (Rate ONLY ONE, your very favorite season, as A)
B = GOOD
C = OKAY
D = BAD
F = THE WORST (Rate ONLY ONE, your least-favorite season, as F)

NO PLUSSES OR MINUSES ALLOWED!

If I use this system, mine becomes

Season 1 - B
Season 2 - A
Season 3 - B
Season 4 - B
Season 5 - C
Season 6 - F
Season 7 - D
Season 8 - D


ETA: In case you're curious, on that other site, Season 3 ended up with the highest score and Season 8 ended up with the lowest. Out of 12 people voting, Season 3 had 7 A's, while Season 8 had 10 F's.

[~B@MeLiSsA30@B~]

Alright, I'll redo it with F being the worst season, but I still like the season though.

Season 1 - B
Season 2 - B
Season 3 - A (My favorite season)
Season 4 - B
Season 5 - C
Season 6 - C
Season 7 - F (The worse season, but I still like season 7, but it is the worse though)
Season 8 - C

[Astral Echo]

Oo Es, that makes it really tough. Cause I love S3 cause of Shannen, her acting was flawless. And for episodes like Primrose Empath, All Hallows Eve and All Hell Breaks Loose. But I really love S4 cause pretty much every episode was good but no Shannen, so it evens out with S4.

Then I love S2 cause of PMP, MB, MH, & AN. But Dan and Jenny really lower my enjoyment of that season. That levels it out with S1 which I love cause of Andy, Bucklands and Quake - amongst a good tally of decent episodes.

SO my list becomes:

Season One - B
Season Two - B
Season Three - A
Season Four - B
Season Five - F
Season Six - C
Season Seven - D
Season Eight - D

But then I really want to give S4 an A too and I don't want S8 running away with a D. lol

[The Original P3]

I can truly never choose which I hate more. Seasons 7 or 8. So I can't rate with that scale. Just know my one A goes to season 3.

[Fourever Charmed]

Well my A is easiest. It hands down goes to season four. It's the F that's the kicker, because season five and season eight are both so disgusting. Season eight has Bimbo and Crazy and season five has Super Brat which was the beginning of the end of the series.

Season One - B
Season Two - B
Season Three - B
Season Four - A
Season Five - D
Season Six - D
Season Seven - D
Season Eight - F

[CharmedFaith]

Season 1- B
Season 2- B
Season 3- A
Season 4- B
Season 5- D
Season 6- D
Season 7- C
Season 8- D

To bad we cant count Season4 as to halves since the first part of the season was great until they vanquished the Source and cut Phoebes hair making her someone different and having Cole becoming the Source. While it had some good episodes during the 2nd half they werent as enjoyable as the first half of the season.

And Season 7 had Zankou which was enjoyable along with Kira.

[la]

1 = A
2= B
3= A
4 = C
5=A
6=B
7=D
8=B

[patmos]

Season 1 - A
Season 2 - A
Season 3 - A
Season 4 - C
Season 5 - D
Season 6 - F
Season 7 - D
Season 8 - F

[Quadquetra]

Season One -- A
Season Two -- B
Season Three -- A
Season Four -- A
Season Five -- B
Season Six -- C-/D+
Season Seven -- C
Season Eight -- C-/D+