|
|
Post by Miranda Turner on Nov 9, 2016 0:51:20 GMT -5
Well since Phoebe had three daughters, it can work with sisters yet again as the Charmed Ones. I cannot see it working with Wyatt and Chris, because the actors would be a recast and most fans may not approve.
But the canon we got never told us if Piper's daughter was Melinda? Right?
|
|
|
|
Post by Assassin Witch on Nov 9, 2016 23:35:51 GMT -5
It was never stated within canon that the little girl with Wyatt and Chris was Piper's daughter.
Plus, she looked a little to old to be a third child. But just right "Ladybug."
|
|
Esmeralda
Charmed
S2 "What If...?"
Fan Fic Winner
Twenty Years Gone....But Never Forgotten.
Posts: 21,920 
|
Post by Esmeralda on Nov 10, 2016 2:37:12 GMT -5
It was never stated within canon that the little girl with Wyatt and Chris was Piper's daughter. Plus, she looked a little to old to be a third child. But just right "Ladybug." No, but in a finale where each scenario is showing a sister with her family, it makes sense to assume that she is indeed the daughter Piper always wanted, although I'll never assume that she's the same Melinda as the one they saw in 'Morality Bites' - definitely too young for that - she's that alternate universe's version of Wyatt, not their sister, no matter her name. And if Piper is pregnant in S8 like Holly was (and she looks it), then it makes plenty of sense for fans to think that that is indeed Prudence Melinda (the name is what's not canon since Piper never mentions it, the way *all* of the girls' names aren't canon while the boys - Wyatt, Chris and Henry Jr - as if Paige would *really* name her son that - to me, it's *HE* who is Matthew, not the boy at the end), then there's the right amount of time between Wyatt, Chris and Prudence, besides that meaning that like her brothers, she might have whitelighter powers if she was conceived before Leo became mortal but Piper just didn't know it yet. And I know that idea is simply horrifying to Charmed Sons fans who would never want a sister to take away attention from their beloved Wyatt and Chris. But if Charmed Sons fans want to think that that *isn't* their sister, they're just as right in assuming that as non-Charmed Sons fans are in thinking that she is - remember that the comics are *not* canon, but official fanon. In that case, I like to assume that the "sorrow" that Piper talks about the family includes either a miscarraige or that little girl dying shortly after we see that picture - or that it's the little girl, not Matthew Henry, who was adopted, since most CHarmed Sons fans want only Wyatt and Chris to be males with powers. Any of those are also perfectly right in assuming. It's all part of the fun of the series being very inconsistent and not telling us everything during the flash-forward in that every fan can come up with his/her own head canon and be just as right in thinking that as any other fan is in thinking anything else that doesn't counter "canon". (Charmed was never consistent enough to truly have canon - if Kern could change canon whenever he wanted to in order to fit the episode rather than fitting the episode to S1-2 canon, so can fans.) The fact that Piper doesn't name her daughter or thinks that Matthew would automatically be part of her family and not Paige's is all part of why I just assume that it's her delusion as she dies after the explosion in 'Kill Billie, Part 2' - and I'm just as right in assuming that and making it part of my head canon (I love the idea of Piper, Phoebe and Paige dying during that explosion, leaving Victor and Leo left to raise the boys with no other kids so there is no new Charmed Ones in the next generation - a MUCH better spin-off) as any other fan is in making theirs. In fact, in my head canon, Piper FINALLY wakes up to find out that she's been in a coma since 'All Hell Breaks Loose' and the alternate-universe spin-off, "The Perils of Poor, Poor Pitiful Piper" was nothing but her delusion while she was in that coma. Prue is still alive, Phoebe and Cole are happily married with a daughter, Nicole Phoebe, the Source has left them alone since they weren't Charmed, and now it's time to start working on vanquishing him, while Paige, Wyatt, Chris, Billie, Christy, Henry, Coop, and all the others never existed. Oh, yes, that's *my* head-canon that makes so much more sense to me than anything else, and the spin-off I hope the next set of comics show. |
|
|
|
Post by BriannaWarren on Nov 10, 2016 4:29:59 GMT -5
Well since Phoebe had three daughters, it can work with sisters yet again as the Charmed Ones. I cannot see it working with Wyatt and Chris, because the actors would be a recast and most fans may not approve. But the canon we got never told us if Piper's daughter was Melinda? Right? I completely agree with you, having Phoebe's daughters as the next Charmed Ones can work. I believe that if Wyatt and Chris was the focus of the Next Generation of Charmed that will end up being a pathetic version of Supernatural (though I would love to see a Winchester boys vs Halliwell sons or maybe a crossover featuring all of four of them, because that would be awesome, in my eyes) I don't believe that is what the fans would want, because I wouldn't. Maybe the girls could have a veneration of the Charmed Ones powers or a different evolution, for example (please keep in mind that these are my ideas and not to be taken to heart) If you want me to show the evolution of these powers let me know: Prudence (Oldest): Would have a mental ability: so I would give her Telekinesis which would advance, she wouldn't have a secondary Witch power. Phoenix (Middle): Would have a time altering power: I would give her Time Manipulation, which wouldn't change, but their would be stronger variations of this power and she wouldn't have a secondary Witch power. Paris (Youngest): Would have a psychic power: I would give her Clairvoyance which would end up as a human lie detector, and she wouldn't have a secondary Witch power. All three of them would have Telepathy and Beaming due to their Cupid abilities but that's all the powers they will receive from their Cupid side. The sisters would have live a normal life, including: -Going out with friends. -Having relationships. -Having jobs. -Going to school. But they will be hundred percent committed to their witch-cupid obligations making that their number one priority but also knowing when to go out and have some fun. What do you guys think? |
|
|
|
Post by Miranda Turner on Nov 10, 2016 5:48:03 GMT -5
It was never stated within canon that the little girl with Wyatt and Chris was Piper's daughter. Plus, she looked a little to old to be a third child. But just right "Ladybug." It was never stated within canon that the little girl with Wyatt and Chris was Piper's daughter. Plus, she looked a little to old to be a third child. But just right "Ladybug." No, but in a finale where each scenario is showing a sister with her family, it makes sense to assume that she is indeed the daughter Piper always wanted, although I'll never assume that she's the same Melinda as the one they saw in 'Morality Bites' - definitely too young for that - she's that alternate universe's version of Wyatt, not their sister, no matter her name. And if Piper is pregnant in S8 like Holly was (and she looks it), then it makes plenty of sense for fans to think that that is indeed Prudence Melinda (the name is what's not canon since Piper never mentions it, the way *all* of the girls' names aren't canon while the boys - Wyatt, Chris and Henry Jr - as if Paige would *really* name her son that - to me, it's *HE* who is Matthew, not the boy at the end), then there's the right amount of time between Wyatt, Chris and Prudence, besides that meaning that like her brothers, she might have whitelighter powers if she was conceived before Leo became mortal but Piper just didn't know it yet. And I know that idea is simply horrifying to Charmed Sons fans who would never want a sister to take away attention from their beloved Wyatt and Chris. But if Charmed Sons fans want to think that that *isn't* their sister, they're just as right in assuming that as non-Charmed Sons fans are in thinking that she is - remember that the comics are *not* canon, but official fanon. In that case, I like to assume that the "sorrow" that Piper talks about the family includes either a miscarraige or that little girl dying shortly after we see that picture - or that it's the little girl, not Matthew Henry, who was adopted, since most CHarmed Sons fans want only Wyatt and Chris to be males with powers. Any of those are also perfectly right in assuming. It's all part of the fun of the series being very inconsistent and not telling us everything during the flash-forward in that every fan can come up with his/her own head canon and be just as right in thinking that as any other fan is in thinking anything else that doesn't counter "canon". (Charmed was never consistent enough to truly have canon - if Kern could change canon whenever he wanted to in order to fit the episode rather than fitting the episode to S1-2 canon, so can fans.) The fact that Piper doesn't name her daughter or thinks that Matthew would automatically be part of her family and not Paige's is all part of why I just assume that it's her delusion as she dies after the explosion in 'Kill Billie, Part 2' - and I'm just as right in assuming that and making it part of my head canon (I love the idea of Piper, Phoebe and Paige dying during that explosion, leaving Victor and Leo left to raise the boys with no other kids so there is no new Charmed Ones in the next generation - a MUCH better spin-off) as any other fan is in making theirs. In fact, in my head canon, Piper FINALLY wakes up to find out that she's been in a coma since 'All Hell Breaks Loose' and the alternate-universe spin-off, "The Perils of Poor, Poor Pitiful Piper" was nothing but her delusion while she was in that coma. Prue is still alive, Phoebe and Cole are happily married with a daughter, Nicole Phoebe, the Source has left them alone since they weren't Charmed, and now it's time to start working on vanquishing him, while Paige, Wyatt, Chris, Billie, Christy, Henry, Coop, and all the others never existed. Oh, yes, that's *my* head-canon that makes so much more sense to me than anything else, and the spin-off I hope the next set of comics show. Thanks guys for this. I wasn't sure. I like your head canon - and at the end of the day, we all are allowed to make our own judgements and choose what we want to believe. I would of been happy if they didn't do the flashforwards but ended the series with the sisters writing in the book of shadows and instead reflecting on the past 8 years - that I did like!. I actually liked that moment even if most fans didn't. Well since Phoebe had three daughters, it can work with sisters yet again as the Charmed Ones. I cannot see it working with Wyatt and Chris, because the actors would be a recast and most fans may not approve. But the canon we got never told us if Piper's daughter was Melinda? Right? I completely agree with you, having Phoebe's daughters as the next Charmed Ones can work. I believe that if Wyatt and Chris was the focus of the Next Generation of Charmed that will end up being a pathetic version of Supernatural (though I would love to see a Winchester boys vs Halliwell sons or maybe a crossover featuring all of four of them, because that would be awesome, in my eyes) I don't believe that is what the fans would want, because I wouldn't. Maybe the girls could have a veneration of the Charmed Ones powers or a different evolution, for example (please keep in mind that these are my ideas and not to be taken to heart) If you want me to show the evolution of these powers let me know: Prudence (Oldest): Would have a mental ability: so I would give her Telekinesis which would advance, she wouldn't have a secondary Witch power. Phoenix (Middle): Would have a time altering power: I would give her Time Manipulation, which wouldn't change, but their would be stronger variations of this power and she wouldn't have a secondary Witch power. Paris (Youngest): Would have a psychic power: I would give her Clairvoyance which would end up as a human lie detector, and she wouldn't have a secondary Witch power. All three of them would have Telepathy and Beaming due to their Cupid abilities but that's all the powers they will receive from their Cupid side. The sisters would have live a normal life, including: -Going out with friends. -Having relationships. -Having jobs. -Going to school. But they will be hundred percent committed to their witch-cupid obligations making that their number one priority but also knowing when to go out and have some fun. What do you guys think? I LOVE THIS!!! Exactly. We will never see a spin-off of Wyatt and Chris and with the Supernatural series going on for 12 years. It will never sit well with many people. Also let's not forget guys that Supernatural started when Charmed was in its final season. So we never would of gotten a spin-off even after it ended. I hate to say it, but it will forever do much better in fanfictions and comics than on the big screen. I would also think having her daughters being well into their 20's is the way to go. Because I feel having them under the same roof as their mother Phoebe, would mean she would be bailing them out of all the demons they face. I say all the family members should be only guest stars and showing up for special occasions. It would make more sense to have some of them killed off, or even Phoebe or Coop dying in the first episode which sets the girls on their destiny. Do you guys agree with me or have I upset people in feeling less use of the original cast and some dying is wrong? |
|
Esmeralda
Charmed
S2 "What If...?"
Fan Fic Winner
Twenty Years Gone....But Never Forgotten.
Posts: 21,920
|
Post by Esmeralda on Nov 10, 2016 7:18:33 GMT -5
This is why I would prefer Phoebe and Paige both being dead at this point (since if you're sticking with the flash-forward as canon, that means that Piper is still alive but the other two not necessarily) so for sure there is no Charmed Ones and as you said, they couldn't go running to their mother whenever they got in trouble.
But I would prefer them *not* being Charmed at all and not having those three powers, but different ones, or again it would be too much like the original. And I can't see selfish Phoebe or even selfish Coop teaching their daughters to be hundred percent committed to their obligations when Phoebe and Coop never were - in S9, yes, but not S8 or S10. In S8 they were only committed to each other, which is what they'd expect their daughters to do as soon as they fell in love.
I still like the idea of just following Prudence, Phoebe's oldest daughter and the oldest girl of the next generation - like Prue, forced into being like the caretake, but Prudence, being Phoebe's daughter, doesn't want to be and instead leaves the family and goes somewhere totally different, finds friends who are also magical but totally different and has a totally different life than the sisters, with her having fun with her magic rather than battling demons or saving innocents. Of all the next-generation spin-off ideas (and my all-time favorite spin-off idea is still Kyra living and learning how to be a mortal with and her lover Phoebe Halliwell being the focus of the spin-off), that's the one I think would have the best chance to succeed.
The WB knew that neither Drew Fuller or Wes Ramsey could've carried an entire show (besides Drew Fuller not interested in the idea since he wanted to play a man and not a boy), so that's why they created Supernatural.
|
|
|
|
Post by BriannaWarren on Nov 10, 2016 7:57:06 GMT -5
It was never stated within canon that the little girl with Wyatt and Chris was Piper's daughter. Plus, she looked a little to old to be a third child. But just right "Ladybug." No, but in a finale where each scenario is showing a sister with her family, it makes sense to assume that she is indeed the daughter Piper always wanted, although I'll never assume that she's the same Melinda as the one they saw in 'Morality Bites' - definitely too young for that - she's that alternate universe's version of Wyatt, not their sister, no matter her name. And if Piper is pregnant in S8 like Holly was (and she looks it), then it makes plenty of sense for fans to think that that is indeed Prudence Melinda (the name is what's not canon since Piper never mentions it, the way *all* of the girls' names aren't canon while the boys - Wyatt, Chris and Henry Jr - as if Paige would *really* name her son that - to me, it's *HE* who is Matthew, not the boy at the end), then there's the right amount of time between Wyatt, Chris and Prudence, besides that meaning that like her brothers, she might have whitelighter powers if she was conceived before Leo became mortal but Piper just didn't know it yet. And I know that idea is simply horrifying to Charmed Sons fans who would never want a sister to take away attention from their beloved Wyatt and Chris. But if Charmed Sons fans want to think that that *isn't* their sister, they're just as right in assuming that as non-Charmed Sons fans are in thinking that she is - remember that the comics are *not* canon, but official fanon. In that case, I like to assume that the "sorrow" that Piper talks about the family includes either a miscarraige or that little girl dying shortly after we see that picture - or that it's the little girl, not Matthew Henry, who was adopted, since most CHarmed Sons fans want only Wyatt and Chris to be males with powers. Any of those are also perfectly right in assuming. It's all part of the fun of the series being very inconsistent and not telling us everything during the flash-forward in that every fan can come up with his/her own head canon and be just as right in thinking that as any other fan is in thinking anything else that doesn't counter "canon". (Charmed was never consistent enough to truly have canon - if Kern could change canon whenever he wanted to in order to fit the episode rather than fitting the episode to S1-2 canon, so can fans.) The fact that Piper doesn't name her daughter or thinks that Matthew would automatically be part of her family and not Paige's is all part of why I just assume that it's her delusion as she dies after the explosion in 'Kill Billie, Part 2' - and I'm just as right in assuming that and making it part of my head canon (I love the idea of Piper, Phoebe and Paige dying during that explosion, leaving Victor and Leo left to raise the boys with no other kids so there is no new Charmed Ones in the next generation - a MUCH better spin-off) as any other fan is in making theirs. In fact, in my head canon, Piper FINALLY wakes up to find out that she's been in a coma since 'All Hell Breaks Loose' and the alternate-universe spin-off, "The Perils of Poor, Poor Pitiful Piper" was nothing but her delusion while she was in that coma. Prue is still alive, Phoebe and Cole are happily married with a daughter, Nicole Phoebe, the Source has left them alone since they weren't Charmed, and now it's time to start working on vanquishing him, while Paige, Wyatt, Chris, Billie, Christy, Henry, Coop, and all the others never existed. Oh, yes, that's *my* head-canon that makes so much more sense to me than anything else, and the spin-off I hope the next set of comics show. Thanks guys for this. I wasn't sure. I like your head canon - and at the end of the day, we all are allowed to make our own judgements and choose what we want to believe. I would of been happy if they didn't do the flashforwards but ended the series with the sisters writing in the book of shadows and instead reflecting on the past 8 years - that I did like!. I actually liked that moment even if most fans didn't. I completely agree with you, having Phoebe's daughters as the next Charmed Ones can work. I believe that if Wyatt and Chris was the focus of the Next Generation of Charmed that will end up being a pathetic version of Supernatural (though I would love to see a Winchester boys vs Halliwell sons or maybe a crossover featuring all of four of them, because that would be awesome, in my eyes) I don't believe that is what the fans would want, because I wouldn't. Maybe the girls could have a veneration of the Charmed Ones powers or a different evolution, for example (please keep in mind that these are my ideas and not to be taken to heart) If you want me to show the evolution of these powers let me know: Prudence (Oldest): Would have a mental ability: so I would give her Telekinesis which would advance, she wouldn't have a secondary Witch power. Phoenix (Middle): Would have a time altering power: I would give her Time Manipulation, which wouldn't change, but their would be stronger variations of this power and she wouldn't have a secondary Witch power. Paris (Youngest): Would have a psychic power: I would give her Clairvoyance which would end up as a human lie detector, and she wouldn't have a secondary Witch power. All three of them would have Telepathy and Beaming due to their Cupid abilities but that's all the powers they will receive from their Cupid side. The sisters would have live a normal life, including: -Going out with friends. -Having relationships. -Having jobs. -Going to school. But they will be hundred percent committed to their witch-cupid obligations making that their number one priority but also knowing when to go out and have some fun. What do you guys think? I LOVE THIS!!! Exactly. We will never see a spin-off of Wyatt and Chris and with the Supernatural series going on for 12 years. It will never sit well with many people. Also let's not forget guys that Supernatural started when Charmed was in its final season. So we never would of gotten a spin-off even after it ended. I hate to say it, but it will forever do much better in fanfictions and comics than on the big screen. I would also think having her daughters being well into their 20's is the way to go. Because I feel having them under the same roof as their mother Phoebe, would mean she would be bailing them out of all the demons they face. I say all the family members should be only guest stars and showing up for special occasions. It would make more sense to have some of them killed off, or even Phoebe or Coop dying in the first episode which sets the girls on their destiny. Do you guys agree with me or have I upset people in feeling less use of the original cast and some dying is wrong? (DISCLAIMER: I am only replying to their reply on my reply. And I don't know how to erase the other points in this thread, so I am sorry) I don't have a problem with the original cast dying off at some point but that leaves the question of if they are going to return as Whitelighters and I think that that is what we will be expecting at some point in time if the next generations starts off like this, that is why I would base them in another city, maybe New York after hearing about their mothers adventures in NY and deciding as a collective (Next Charmed Ones) that they will move to the big apple. I agree that they should be in the Mid-Late 20s but what I meant by them going to school is getting a higher education and after realising that they 'ate the worm' (as their mother called it after moving back) finds a place in San Fransisco and moves their, all three agree that if they have a problem being a Innocent or Demon that they will try and deal with it without consulting their mother or aunts. I would really like if Billie was still a character but she was the one to help them with their magical problems and teaching them about their powers. I would love this because it will give Billie's character some love. Even if Billie is married with her own children and then Prudence helps them out, then the Jenkins and Halliwell family forms a magical alliance. |
|
|
|
Post by BriannaWarren on Nov 10, 2016 8:23:34 GMT -5
This is why I would prefer Phoebe and Paige both being dead at this point (since if you're sticking with the flash-forward as canon, that means that Piper is still alive but the other two not necessarily) so for sure there is no Charmed Ones and as you said, they couldn't go running to their mother whenever they got in trouble. But I would prefer them *not* being Charmed at all and not having those three powers, but different ones, or again it would be too much like the original. And I can't see selfish Phoebe or even selfish Coop teaching their daughters to be hundred percent committed to their obligations when Phoebe and Coop never were - in S9, yes, but not S8 or S10. In S8 they were only committed to each other, which is what they'd expect their daughters to do as soon as they fell in love. I still like the idea of just following Prudence, Phoebe's oldest daughter and the oldest girl of the next generation - like Prue, forced into being like the caretake, but Prudence, being Phoebe's daughter, doesn't want to be and instead leaves the family and goes somewhere totally different, finds friends who are also magical but totally different and has a totally different life than the sisters, with her having fun with her magic rather than battling demons or saving innocents. Of all the next-generation spin-off ideas (and my all-time favorite spin-off idea is still Kyra living and learning how to be a mortal with and her lover Phoebe Halliwell being the focus of the spin-off), that's the one I think would have the best chance to succeed. The WB knew that neither Drew Fuller or Wes Ramsey could've carried an entire show (besides Drew Fuller not interested in the idea since he wanted to play a man and not a boy), so that's why they created Supernatural. I love this idea. What I would change is: -Prue and her sisters have a falling out, and she decides to move to NY, following in her mothers footsteps. -Phoenix (who is the middle child in my fanfic) has to become the eldest and the strongest to look after Paris(the youngest in my fanfic) who is still in high school. -Both Phoenix and Paris become the new Ultimate Power, with their new destiny they have to become more closer. I would then have them receive new powers that represents their new status as the Ultimate Power, so I would give Phoenix the ability to flame (teleportation), healing tears, resurrection, also the ability of psychokinesis (her mother's past life power). Paris I would give her smoke (teleportation), projection, premonitions, and telekinesis. -Prudence learning about this, then decides to come back with the Angel of Destiny saying 'You have a chance to create a legacy like your mother and your aunts, so with your sisters being the Ultimate Power and you wanting to come back, we can give you a status of just being either a cupid or a witch' this decision she talks with her mother and father and they suggest she goes with her heart rather then her head. -Prudence then picking being a witch, has beaming striped away from her, leaving her with the basic witch powers such as: telekinesis, premonitions, and telepathy, which these powers evolve due her understanding and control of these abilities. -Prudence then decides to move into her mothers old condo. -Phoenix and Paris move into a Victorian house together so they could become stronger and better at their new abilities and more powerful as sisters. -I would then have Kyra be a witch, after the Elders thinking she could be an asset to the side of good rather then allowing her to be dead. -Kyra teaches Phoenix and Paris their new abilities and how to control them. -Kyra and Phoenix become really good friends while Paris is friends with another magical witch. How are you liking these ideas? |
|
|
|
Post by Miranda Turner on Nov 10, 2016 20:05:55 GMT -5
Really great ideas everyone. WOW!!!
Isn't this the beauty of doing it through fanfictions - nobody has to worry about a network screwing it up.
Best of all, we can have fun with coming up with names for Phoebe's daughters. Peyton would be a name I would use and Panya (because it is the name of one of my very close friends).
|
|
|
|
Post by sol on Nov 11, 2016 1:54:03 GMT -5
I'ld like Prudence for the elder -because I don't think that Piper had a daughter - than Charlotte in honor of the Halloween night in the past and Kyra, in honor of her friend
But I'ld prefer if they were normal witches, not Charmed
|
|
Esmeralda
Charmed
S2 "What If...?"
Fan Fic Winner
Twenty Years Gone....But Never Forgotten.
Posts: 21,920
|
Post by Esmeralda on Nov 11, 2016 6:13:50 GMT -5
Really great ideas everyone. WOW!!! Isn't this the beauty of doing it through fanfictions - nobody has to worry about a network screwing it up. Best of all, we can have fun with coming up with names for Phoebe's daughters. Peyton would be a name I would use and Panya (because it is the name of one of my very close friends). Don't really like Peyton - to me, it's a boy's name and should've been Wyatt's - Peyton Matthew Wyatt, the way Piper should've been Piper Halliwell-Wyatt, since not even Penny Johnson Halliwell kept *her* maiden name. I've never heard the name Panya before...but I like it! I do see Phoebe as the one who would continue the P tradition - but Prudence, Charlotte and Kyra - yes, I can see that, too. Except since I see Prudence Melinda as Piper's, I'd see Phoebe's Prudence as Phoebs - it would be typical Phoebe to name Ladybug after herself - and if Henry Jr can be named after Henry - why not? |
|
|
|
Post by BriannaWarren on Nov 11, 2016 17:41:20 GMT -5
Really great ideas everyone. WOW!!! Isn't this the beauty of doing it through fanfictions - nobody has to worry about a network screwing it up. Best of all, we can have fun with coming up with names for Phoebe's daughters. Peyton would be a name I would use and Panya (because it is the name of one of my very close friends). Don't really like Peyton - to me, it's a boy's name and should've been Wyatt's - Peyton Matthew Wyatt, the way Piper should've been Piper Halliwell-Wyatt, since not even Penny Johnson Halliwell kept *her* maiden name. I've never heard the name Panya before...but I like it! I do see Phoebe as the one who would continue the P tradition - but Prudence, Charlotte and Kyra - yes, I can see that, too. Except since I see Prudence Melinda as Piper's, I'd see Phoebe's Prudence as Phoebs - it would be typical Phoebe to name Ladybug after herself - and if Henry Jr can be named after Henry - why not? I agree Peyton sounds more like a boys name rather then a girls name, I would love it if Wyatt was named Peyton Matthew Wyatt, makes more sense. In my fan-fiction, Phoebe's children's full names are: With Cole: 1) Benjamin Coleridge Turner. With Coop: 1) Prudence Brianna Halliwell. 2) Phoenix Patricia Halliwell. 3) Paris Kyra Halliwell. |
|
|
|
Post by Miranda Turner on Nov 11, 2016 18:06:25 GMT -5
Really great ideas everyone. WOW!!! Isn't this the beauty of doing it through fanfictions - nobody has to worry about a network screwing it up. Best of all, we can have fun with coming up with names for Phoebe's daughters. Peyton would be a name I would use and Panya (because it is the name of one of my very close friends). Don't really like Peyton - to me, it's a boy's name and should've been Wyatt's - Peyton Matthew Wyatt, the way Piper should've been Piper Halliwell-Wyatt, since not even Penny Johnson Halliwell kept *her* maiden name. I've never heard the name Panya before...but I like it! I do see Phoebe as the one who would continue the P tradition - but Prudence, Charlotte and Kyra - yes, I can see that, too. Except since I see Prudence Melinda as Piper's, I'd see Phoebe's Prudence as Phoebs - it would be typical Phoebe to name Ladybug after herself - and if Henry Jr can be named after Henry - why not? Don't really like Peyton - to me, it's a boy's name and should've been Wyatt's - Peyton Matthew Wyatt, the way Piper should've been Piper Halliwell-Wyatt, since not even Penny Johnson Halliwell kept *her* maiden name. I've never heard the name Panya before...but I like it! I do see Phoebe as the one who would continue the P tradition - but Prudence, Charlotte and Kyra - yes, I can see that, too. Except since I see Prudence Melinda as Piper's, I'd see Phoebe's Prudence as Phoebs - it would be typical Phoebe to name Ladybug after herself - and if Henry Jr can be named after Henry - why not? I agree Peyton sounds more like a boys name rather then a girls name, I would love it if Wyatt was named Peyton Matthew Wyatt, makes more sense. In my fan-fiction, Phoebe's children's full names are: With Cole: 1) Benjamin Coleridge Turner. With Coop: 1) Prudence Brianna Halliwell. 2) Phoenix Patricia Halliwell. 3) Paris Kyra Halliwell. I see where you two are coming from guy's - like I find the name Taylor a boys name. The funny thing is I have never meet a Peyton who was a boy, but just a girl - and a show I watched had a Peyton who was a girl. The name Paris, I cannot help guys but keep being reminded of Paris Hilton and that is a bad thing. Yes Panya I find a very unique name - and it is interesting because Prue, Piper and Phoebe I find are names I have rarely ran into in my life. Piper I think is just so rare, that is why I like Panya. Another name I thought about guys was Priscilla. |
|
Granny Charmed
Whitelighter
S1 "What If...?"
Fan Fic Winner
Posts: 3,225
|
Post by Granny Charmed on Nov 11, 2016 18:20:52 GMT -5
I find the names Phoenix and Panya to be very good dears. Very different.
As for Peyton well dears just like I find Taylor more a boys name than a girls name, I find Peyton more a boys name. Perhaps spelling it Payton with an "a: instead of an "e". The "a" in Payton makes it seem more girly to me dears.
|
|
Esmeralda
Charmed
S2 "What If...?"
Fan Fic Winner
Twenty Years Gone....But Never Forgotten.
Posts: 21,920
|
Post by Esmeralda on Nov 11, 2016 18:27:03 GMT -5
Yup, in her "Charmed: Heritage" series, StoryGirl83 uses Prudence (Ladybug), Priscilla and Hope (her middle name - I don't remember what her first name is) for Phoebe's daughters.
In a lot of ways I'm glad that Charmed didn't tell us the girls' names - it's a lot more fun to come up with our own.
My favorites are:
-the ones I chose for my 'Charmed Forever' story: Patricia (who has the power to freeze), Prudence (Who has the power to move things with her mind) and Penelope (who has the power to see the future) and who *are* the next Charmed Ones and who *are* the reincarnation of Patty, Prue and Penny (Grams is the baby and gets premonitions because she abused her power to move things with her mind as Grams and didn't do a good job training the future Charmed Ones - she never should've spoiled Phoebe),
-the ones 4Ever Charmed used in her story "Fourever Charmed" where she let Phoebe choose a different letter: C for both Cole and Coop for her daughters: Colleen, Cassandra and Charlotte (she never says what their powers, if any, are),
-LexiCharmed's "Progeny: Angels and Demons" where the daughters are Patricia (Patti) (who can slow molecules until they freeze), Patience (Pay) (who has dream premonitions) and Poppy (whose TK is just like Prue's).
|
|
|
|
Post by BriannaWarren on Nov 12, 2016 1:09:58 GMT -5
Don't really like Peyton - to me, it's a boy's name and should've been Wyatt's - Peyton Matthew Wyatt, the way Piper should've been Piper Halliwell-Wyatt, since not even Penny Johnson Halliwell kept *her* maiden name. I've never heard the name Panya before...but I like it! I do see Phoebe as the one who would continue the P tradition - but Prudence, Charlotte and Kyra - yes, I can see that, too. Except since I see Prudence Melinda as Piper's, I'd see Phoebe's Prudence as Phoebs - it would be typical Phoebe to name Ladybug after herself - and if Henry Jr can be named after Henry - why not? I agree Peyton sounds more like a boys name rather then a girls name, I would love it if Wyatt was named Peyton Matthew Wyatt, makes more sense. In my fan-fiction, Phoebe's children's full names are: With Cole: 1) Benjamin Coleridge Turner. With Coop: 1) Prudence Brianna Halliwell. 2) Phoenix Patricia Halliwell. 3) Paris Kyra Halliwell. I see where you two are coming from guy's - like I find the name Taylor a boys name. The funny thing is I have never meet a Peyton who was a boy, but just a girl - and a show I watched had a Peyton who was a girl. The name Paris, I cannot help guys but keep being reminded of Paris Hilton and that is a bad thing. Yes Panya I find a very unique name - and it is interesting because Prue, Piper and Phoebe I find are names I have rarely ran into in my life. Piper I think is just so rare, that is why I like Panya. Another name I thought about guys was Priscilla. Paris being the city of lights and love. That's I chose it, I never thought about the Paris Hilton being an issue with that name choice, maybe I should think a little bit harder next time, and rename her. Thank you for bring that aspect up and maybe next time I will think about it more in depth. *Back to the drawing board* I guess. |
|
|
|
Post by Miranda Turner on Nov 12, 2016 1:35:12 GMT -5
I see where you two are coming from guy's - like I find the name Taylor a boys name. The funny thing is I have never meet a Peyton who was a boy, but just a girl - and a show I watched had a Peyton who was a girl. The name Paris, I cannot help guys but keep being reminded of Paris Hilton and that is a bad thing. Yes Panya I find a very unique name - and it is interesting because Prue, Piper and Phoebe I find are names I have rarely ran into in my life. Piper I think is just so rare, that is why I like Panya. Another name I thought about guys was Priscilla. Paris being the city of lights and love. That's I chose it, I never thought about the Paris Hilton being an issue with that name choice, maybe I should think a little bit harder next time, and rename her. Thank you for bring that aspect up and maybe next time I will think about it more in depth. *Back to the drawing board* I guess. I see. That's alright. But if you really love that name and wish to use it, by all means go for it. Also thank you got bringing the name Peyton to my attention. We both have offered each other some feedback. |
|
|
|
Post by BriannaWarren on Nov 12, 2016 5:34:37 GMT -5
Paris being the city of lights and love. That's I chose it, I never thought about the Paris Hilton being an issue with that name choice, maybe I should think a little bit harder next time, and rename her. Thank you for bring that aspect up and maybe next time I will think about it more in depth. *Back to the drawing board* I guess. I see. That's alright. But if you really love that name and wish to use it, by all means go for it. Also thank you got bringing the name Peyton to my attention. We both have offered each other some feedback. Thank you for your imput, with different names, I can picture the girls having a Familiar called Psyche. |
|
|
|
Post by Melinda Halliwell on Nov 12, 2016 10:10:08 GMT -5
Well Psyche did have a relationship with Cupid in Greek mythology so if one of Phoebe's kids were named that it would be apt then.
|
|
Esmeralda
Charmed
S2 "What If...?"
Fan Fic Winner
Twenty Years Gone....But Never Forgotten.
Posts: 21,920
|
Post by Esmeralda on Nov 12, 2016 11:57:58 GMT -5
I see. That's alright. But if you really love that name and wish to use it, by all means go for it. Also thank you got bringing the name Peyton to my attention. We both have offered each other some feedback. Thank you for your imput, with different names, I can picture the girls having a Familiar called Psyche. OOOOO!!! Especially with them being half-cupid I totally ADORE the idea of them having a familiar called Psyche! |
|
