Granny Charmed
Whitelighter
S1 "What If...?" Fan Fic Winner
Posts: 3,225
|
Post by Granny Charmed on Aug 22, 2018 22:50:12 GMT -5
SR? Pheebs? The rest of Team Charmed Cafe? What do you think? As long as I'm on this track of discussing possible changes, something else to consider. A lot of our episodes so far have centered around Prudence, Patience and/or Phoebe while I think The CW would want ALL of the episodes to center around Piper and/or Phoebe, especially Phoebe, who would play to their core audience, like the ripoff does or even Classic Charmed did. I wonder if OUR reboot doesn't really belong on The CW (since most of us are older, so we'd be more interested in the older members of the family) and maybe for the second season, it could be "moved" to TNT or Lifetime or even CBS - reverse what happened to Supergirl when her show went from CBS to The CW. What do you guys think about that? I think that sounds pretty much right. Most of us (me included) dears are much older than The CW audience. I'm basically just about the same age you made Prudence. Might be wise to have our reboot move after season one. I recall Ghost Whisperer aired Friday nights on CBS. If I'm right - maybe CBS picks up *our* reboot and airs it in that timeslot hoping to capture that old friday night audience. Maybe on CBS airing sunday, same timeslot, different network as another option? What do you all think of this idea Team Charmed Cafe?
|
|
pheebs
Whitelighter
Posts: 3,828
|
Post by pheebs on Aug 22, 2018 23:53:06 GMT -5
Good suggestion, Granny Charmed. I checked online, and CBS airs on Friday Nights, MacGyver reboot at 8 pm, Hawaii Five-O reboot at 9 pm and Blue Bloods at 10 pm. On Sunday Nights, they are airing a new series called God Friended Me at 8 pm and NCIS: Los Angeles at 9 pm. Maybe after the first season, our show 'Elemental Charmed' is picked up by CBS, like Supergirl shifted from CBS to The CW and winds up on Friday or Sunday' schedulele. I couldn't help but do a press release for it. What do you all think?
|
|
Esmeralda
Charmed
S2 "What If...?" Fan Fic Winner
Twenty Years Gone....But Never Forgotten.
Posts: 21,920
|
Post by Esmeralda on Aug 23, 2018 6:52:26 GMT -5
Good suggestion, Granny Charmed. I checked online, and CBS airs on Friday Nights, MacGyver reboot at 8 pm, Hawaii Five-O reboot at 9 pm and Blue Bloods at 10 pm. On Sunday Nights, they are airing a new series called God Friended Me at 8 pm and NCIS: Los Angeles at 9 pm. Maybe after the first season, our show 'Elemental Charmed' is picked up by CBS, like Supergirl shifted from CBS to The CW and winds up on Friday or Sunday' schedulele. I couldn't help but do a press release for it. What do you all think? Even though I want to go back and reply to the other posts I haven't commented on yet, i HAD to pop back and comment on this right away! Absolutely totally LOVE it, Pheebs! I'm glad you liked my idea of moving our show from broadcast TV to network TV as compared to Supergirl which did it in reverse and I *so* love how you find real press releases and adapt them for out show! You calling it a "fantasy drama" really made me smile - that's truly what we'd want our show to be, one that takes itself seriously, the way early Classic Charmed did. My only problem with this is that the way I have it set up, Shannen wouldn't appear in the Season One finale. However, I think that can be fixed by showing flashbacks of the Salem Witch Trials that include both sisters (I'll add here that I absolutely love your idea of having one sister the start of a line of witches and the other the start of a line of warlocks, but I still don't think they have to - or should be - non-identical twins. But as always in this project, I'll bow to the majority's opinion. Here's my edits: Due to loving this, I've changed my version of the Season One finale and Season Two Premiere: How's that?
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Aug 23, 2018 10:08:07 GMT -5
Oh man! Why can't this be real? Great job, guys.
I don't know if I'm too late to add this but I've been mulling over ideas for the Earth power and thought that wouldn't it be cool if Patience could grant and remove "Lifeforce" from animate beings.
She could do all the stereotypical Earthy things, such as making flowers bloom, but she'd also have a limited form of healing. My hypothesis for the mechanics of this ability would be that physical injuries "kill" skin and healthy bodily function, in a sense, so Patty could grant "life" back into the person and heal their wounds. Similarly, if an Innocent was suffering a heart attack, she could regulate their blood flow and restore the heart's normal function.
On the opposite end of the scale, she could induce harm to a demon/enemy but restricting "Lifeforce" to them; the warlock, Nicholas', "blood-boiling" power comes to mind here.
What do you think?
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Aug 23, 2018 10:26:34 GMT -5
Oh, I'm a "Witch" now, I see. 1,000 posts! 🎉
|
|
Esmeralda
Charmed
S2 "What If...?" Fan Fic Winner
Twenty Years Gone....But Never Forgotten.
Posts: 21,920
|
Post by Esmeralda on Aug 24, 2018 0:35:21 GMT -5
Oh man! Why can't this be real? Great job, guys. I don't know if I'm too late to add this but I've been mulling over ideas for the Earth power and thought that wouldn't it be cool if Patience could grant and remove "Lifeforce" from animate beings. She could do all the stereotypical Earthy things, such as making flowers bloom, but she'd also have a limited form of healing. My hypothesis for the mechanics of this ability would be that physical injuries "kill" skin and healthy bodily function, in a sense, so Patty could grant "life" back into the person and heal their wounds. Similarly, if an Innocent was suffering a heart attack, she could regulate their blood flow and restore the heart's normal function. On the opposite end of the scale, she could induce harm to a demon/enemy but restricting "Lifeforce" to them; the warlock, Nicholas', "blood-boiling" power comes to mind here. What do you think? Can't say I like this idea - I hate non-whitelighters (including witchlighters) being able to heal - it made injuries and death mean nothing, so even limited, no, just not happy with that. I find myself preferring what Paul Rudiitis did in his book, having the one with the Element of Earth be the Earth Mover - moving Earth to move people and objects - her form of TK. I like the calmest person of the group have that power while letting Paige, the Wind Walker, being able to transport people. This way you have Melinda Warren's three original powers - move items with your mind (Patience), freeze molecules (Phoebe) hand see the future (Prudence) but in different forms, along with the other two elements, throwing fireballs (Phoebe) and transporting people (Paige) to make them the Elemental witches. But if any one else likes your idea (especially SR and Pheebs, since they've been doing such a great job with the press releases), go for it! Or, for that matter, if you want to keep Patience's Earth power of forming items from earth, go for it! As I said before, part of the fun of our series is so far the only powers that have really been used is Prudence's premonitions and - once - Paige's transporting, so we can still do whatever we want with the other powers, including Earth.
|
|
Granny Charmed
Whitelighter
S1 "What If...?" Fan Fic Winner
Posts: 3,225
|
Post by Granny Charmed on Aug 24, 2018 1:24:33 GMT -5
Oh, I'm a "Witch" now, I see. 1,000 posts! 🎉 Congratulations dear. Well done. I hit the same last month completely unnoticed. Such an effort to get that far. Your in wonderful company.
|
|
Granny Charmed
Whitelighter
S1 "What If...?" Fan Fic Winner
Posts: 3,225
|
Post by Granny Charmed on Aug 24, 2018 1:26:09 GMT -5
Great job Team Charmed Cafe! I absolutely love the press releases.
I honestly think Alyssa and Shannen would react exactly as you have them in these press release interviews.
|
|
Esmeralda
Charmed
S2 "What If...?" Fan Fic Winner
Twenty Years Gone....But Never Forgotten.
Posts: 21,920
|
Post by Esmeralda on Aug 24, 2018 1:47:31 GMT -5
Going to try and catch up and reply to as best I can and what I missed in the other thread. I haven't got any new press releases to share, but we've got enough here to keep us going. Es you deserve a big pat on the back for all the hard work you put in getting this new thread set-up. Reward yourself! Thank you! It wasn't that big of a deal since I just had to copy and paste - just wish I'd done it better, especially when I see that I'm going to end up with a similar problem with your thread that Colton had with mine. But since I'm very curious to see what you thought, I'll do my best, copying and pasting again if I have to, doing it slightly differently by using blockquotes rather than quotes in hopes that it won't go away if someone quotes me. However if someone *does* quote me, BE SURE to delete the [*quote source=""*] quote at the beginning or if anyone quotes YOU, all of the press releases will go away! I’ve learned the hard way – preview before you hit the “Post” button! For that reason, when I talk about me replying, I’m going to say “Es replied” rather than “I replied” so it will make sense if someone quotes this. Just in case these get lost in another page, I decided to cut and paste all of SummerReading's (SR) and what Es, Deono, and everyone came up with before. So it would be easier for people to quote and comment on them directly. As was mentioned, if anyone wants to edit or change something, feel free. Thank you, Pheebs. This is truly something we should do each time we hit a new page so any members new to this thread will know what we're doing and have a chance to add their own ideas. Since it's been copied a couple of times, I'm going to skip the earlier parts and just comment on the new parts, but have to start by saying you also did a fantastic job with these! Pheebs wrote: And here are my additions.
Again I cut and pasted how SR laid it out and just made my additions. But what I worked on, might not fit with having a spirit ot ghost of some kind haunting in the previous episode.
Summer Reading or anyone else, if you wish to change mine, go ahead, if you wish to add your own episode 6, go ahead, and if you wish to move this around to another episode in the season, go ahead. Es replied: And that's the fun of this being a Team Charmed Cafe project. Everything in this thread is just a rough draft - anyone else want to do it their way, they're more than welcomed to do it - especially because then Editor Es can later have fun combining all of the ideas into one cohesive whole! Since I'm not good at coming up with original stuff, this is what I love doing most!
So, as always, Pheebs, I hope you don't mind if I edit yours. As always, feel free to change anything I edit back if you don't like what I do - you guys are the ones with the original ideas, so it's totally up to you to decide if what I change should stay changed or not. SummerReading (SR) replied: Great thinking to have our breakdown of press releases, stories and backstories once we hit a new page. LOL with the amount of material this thread now has and what we will keep on having, we may need additional threads eventually. LOL Es’ reply to her: Oh! I *really* hope that someday either Assassin Witch or our Café Librarian, StoryGirl83, gives us a sub-sub-subboard for just “Elemental Charmed”. ES' NOTE TO SR: Because I ended up doing quite a bit of editing as I was copying these press releases, I decided not to reply to your comments on these and wait to see what you and others think of these. Pheebs added: I went and look at her myth online: I saw the Ghost Whisperer episode of Bloody Mary before, never seen the Supernatural one, might be way scarier than the GW one.
If this can play into Paige and her daughter Peyton maybe? But I'm not so sure, might be worth saving a story like this for later in the season or beyond. If someone has other idea's, go ahead? Es replied: Wasn't Bloody Mary one of the scary creatures in 'Chick Flick', even if it didn't include a mirror - although, of course, a mirror *was* used in 'The Fourth Sister'? This episode would be a great nod to those great episodes, even if, typical Classic Charmed, they twisted the mythology to fit their episode.
Although you might be right that it would fit later in the season or even in a different season, depending upon what SC and others had in mind - but it is definitely something I'd want as part of "Elemental Charmed" - great job!
And the idea of connecting Bloody Mary to Peyton is fantastic! Pheebs added: And here's my press release following Es' lead:
I went and looked at the CW press release for their reboot, and made changes to it to fit *our* reboot. Es replied: Oh, what great fun! Although as I said in an earlier post, the more I think about it, the more I don't think including our stars as Prudence, Patience and Paige is a good idea - it was just Es having fun dreaming of what could be, maybe not what should be. But if/when we decide to "cast" this, this is a great way of doing it. NOTE FROM ES: In reformatting this, since Pheebs later approved my edits, I took out my own comments and just put in my edit: NOTE FROM ES: Because I think most of us agree that my idea of using Holly, Shannen and Alyssa to play Prudence, Patience and Paige doesn’t really work, I’ve edited the following press release. Also, just for the fun of it, I edited the powers a little. Remember that these can be changed. I'd love to know what you guys think of these ideas. NOTE FROM ES: I had fun casting Piper and Phoebe. Again, if anyone wants someone else in those roles – I don’t watch enough broadcast TV or The CW to know who would fit - feel free to change it. Es added: Even if we recast "Elemental Charmed", we SO have to include this! So? What do you guys think of those? Remember - this is all still just rough draft, part of brainstorming, so if you don't like anything I did, don't be afraid to say so!
|
|
Esmeralda
Charmed
S2 "What If...?" Fan Fic Winner
Twenty Years Gone....But Never Forgotten.
Posts: 21,920
|
Post by Esmeralda on Aug 24, 2018 1:48:20 GMT -5
Oh, I'm a "Witch" now, I see. 1,000 posts! 🎉 Congratulations, Deano!
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Aug 24, 2018 4:42:33 GMT -5
Can't say I like this idea - I hate non-whitelighters (including witchlighters) being able to heal - it made injuries and death mean nothing, so even limited, no, just not happy with that. I find myself preferring what Paul Rudiitis did in his book, having the one with the Element of Earth be the Earth Mover - moving Earth to move people and objects - her form of TK. I like the calmest person of the group have that power while letting Paige, the Wind Walker, being able to transport people. This way you have Melinda Warren's three original powers - move items with your mind (Patience), freeze molecules (Phoebe) hand see the future (Prudence) but in different forms, along with the other two elements, throwing fireballs (Phoebe) and transporting people (Paige) to make them the Elemental witches. But if any one else likes your idea (especially SR and Pheebs, since they've been doing such a great job with the press releases), go for it! Or, for that matter, if you want to keep Patience's Earth power of forming items from earth, go for it! As I said before, part of the fun of our series is so far the only powers that have really been used is Prudence's premonitions and - once - Paige's transporting, so we can still do whatever we want with the other powers, including Earth. TK probably does fit the EarthMover better, actually. Congratulations dear. Well done. I hit the same last month completely unnoticed. Such an effort to get that far. Your in wonderful company. Thanks guys! You're right, Granny. They seemed to take forever to reach! Belated congrats to you too.
|
|
|
Post by summerreading on Aug 24, 2018 5:06:10 GMT -5
Good suggestion, Granny Charmed. I checked online, and CBS airs on Friday Nights, MacGyver reboot at 8 pm, Hawaii Five-O reboot at 9 pm and Blue Bloods at 10 pm. On Sunday Nights, they are airing a new series called God Friended Me at 8 pm and NCIS: Los Angeles at 9 pm. Maybe after the first season, our show 'Elemental Charmed' is picked up by CBS, like Supergirl shifted from CBS to The CW and winds up on Friday or Sunday' schedulele. I couldn't help but do a press release for it. What do you all think? Even though I want to go back and reply to the other posts I haven't commented on yet, i HAD to pop back and comment on this right away! Absolutely totally LOVE it, Pheebs! I'm glad you liked my idea of moving our show from broadcast TV to network TV as compared to Supergirl which did it in reverse and I *so* love how you find real press releases and adapt them for out show! You calling it a "fantasy drama" really made me smile - that's truly what we'd want our show to be, one that takes itself seriously, the way early Classic Charmed did. My only problem with this is that the way I have it set up, Shannen wouldn't appear in the Season One finale. However, I think that can be fixed by showing flashbacks of the Salem Witch Trials that include both sisters (I'll add here that I absolutely love your idea of having one sister the start of a line of witches and the other the start of a line of warlocks, but I still don't think they have to - or should be - non-identical twins. But as always in this project, I'll bow to the majority's opinion. Here's my edits: Due to loving this, I've changed my version of the Season One finale and Season Two Premiere: How's that?[/quote]I think this is perfect! Pheebs yet again you're killing the press releases. Can't wait to do some more on the weekend. I can't wait for when we are able to put these in chronlogical order when we have our first season in order. Es and Pheebs you have the thumbs up from me, that I don't think anything above needs changing unless of course we end up adding more to the plots or rework the stories for another episode or season. As of now, I really am impressed. Oh man! Why can't this be real? Great job, guys. I don't know if I'm too late to add this but I've been mulling over ideas for the Earth power and thought that wouldn't it be cool if Patience could grant and remove "Lifeforce" from animate beings. She could do all the stereotypical Earthy things, such as making flowers bloom, but she'd also have a limited form of healing. My hypothesis for the mechanics of this ability would be that physical injuries "kill" skin and healthy bodily function, in a sense, so Patty could grant "life" back into the person and heal their wounds. Similarly, if an Innocent was suffering a heart attack, she could regulate their blood flow and restore the heart's normal function. On the opposite end of the scale, she could induce harm to a demon/enemy but restricting "Lifeforce" to them; the warlock, Nicholas', "blood-boiling" power comes to mind here. What do you think? Can't say I like this idea - I hate non-whitelighters (including witchlighters) being able to heal - it made injuries and death mean nothing, so even limited, no, just not happy with that. I find myself preferring what Paul Rudiitis did in his book, having the one with the Element of Earth be the Earth Mover - moving Earth to move people and objects - her form of TK. I like the calmest person of the group have that power while letting Paige, the Wind Walker, being able to transport people. This way you have Melinda Warren's three original powers - move items with your mind (Patience), freeze molecules (Phoebe) hand see the future (Prudence) but in different forms, along with the other two elements, throwing fireballs (Phoebe) and transporting people (Paige) to make them the Elemental witches. But if any one else likes your idea (especially SR and Pheebs, since they've been doing such a great job with the press releases), go for it! Or, for that matter, if you want to keep Patience's Earth power of forming items from earth, go for it! As I said before, part of the fun of our series is so far the only powers that have really been used is Prudence's premonitions and - once - Paige's transporting, so we can still do whatever we want with the other powers, including Earth. I have been really concentrating on other parts of our reboot including plots and getting the character stories sorted and figuring out the living situations and backstory properly, that I admit that all the powers have really not been on my mind at all. But, I do really think sorting out the powers is the next thing, I hope we can address. But like Es said, if anyone else here likes those ideas, go for it! We can have several different directions or alternate powers. That when we get much further into the project, at a later point, we can have a master 'Elemental Charmed' where we figure out truly which one works, and agree as a team. But on that note, Prudence and Paige's powers do seem pretty settled. Deano, I do like your suggestion of inducing harm like the warlock Nicholas, with "blood-boiling" powers. But we might end up wanting to have Peyton have that power further down the line. All part of the fun in coming up with ideas. But in regards to healing, I wonder if we might actually have fun with maybe making Prudence being an ex nurse, that way she can use actual medical knowledge to heal injuries the human way, or the use of potions to heal injuries. But not having whitelighters or healing abilities. Again, if others want healing, and enough agree. I'll go with the majority. Going to try and catch up and reply to as best I can and what I missed in the other thread. I haven't got any new press releases to share, but we've got enough here to keep us going. Es you deserve a big pat on the back for all the hard work you put in getting this new thread set-up. Reward yourself! Thank you! It wasn't that big of a deal since I just had to copy and paste - just wish I'd done it better, especially when I see that I'm going to end up with a similar problem with your thread that Colton had with mine. But since I'm very curious to see what you thought, I'll do my best, copying and pasting again if I have to, doing it slightly differently by using blockquotes rather than quotes in hopes that it won't go away if someone quotes me. However if someone *does* quote me, BE SURE to delete the [*quote source=""*] quote at the beginning or if anyone quotes YOU, all of the press releases will go away! I’ve learned the hard way – preview before you hit the “Post” button! For that reason, when I talk about me replying, I’m going to say “Es replied” rather than “I replied” so it will make sense if someone quotes this. I'm going to have to keep an eye out myself when I reply - make sure I don't have a similar problem that Colton had. Thank you very much, this has helped. Now I'll do my best to catch up on everything now. Since we don't have any like button, I don't want to clog up this thread with posts of me just thanking someone for liking the reboot press releases or ideas, so to anyone I haven't already thanked. Thank you for liking what everyone here has been producing. That sounds like a very wise idea Es with how you lay out the replies below. Just in case these get lost in another page, I decided to cut and paste all of SummerReading's (SR) and what Es, Deono, and everyone came up with before. So it would be easier for people to quote and comment on them directly. As was mentioned, if anyone wants to edit or change something, feel free. Thank you, Pheebs. This is truly something we should do each time we hit a new page so any members new to this thread will know what we're doing and have a chance to add their own ideas. Since it's been copied a couple of times, I'm going to skip the earlier parts and just comment on the new parts, but have to start by saying you also did a fantastic job with these! Pheebs wrote: And here are my additions.
Again I cut and pasted how SR laid it out and just made my additions. But what I worked on, might not fit with having a spirit ot ghost of some kind haunting in the previous episode.
Summer Reading or anyone else, if you wish to change mine, go ahead, if you wish to add your own episode 6, go ahead, and if you wish to move this around to another episode in the season, go ahead. Es replied: And that's the fun of this being a Team Charmed Cafe project. Everything in this thread is just a rough draft - anyone else want to do it their way, they're more than welcomed to do it - especially because then Editor Es can later have fun combining all of the ideas into one cohesive whole! Since I'm not good at coming up with original stuff, this is what I love doing most!
So, as always, Pheebs, I hope you don't mind if I edit yours. As always, feel free to change anything I edit back if you don't like what I do - you guys are the ones with the original ideas, so it's totally up to you to decide if what I change should stay changed or not. SummerReading (SR) replied: Great thinking to have our breakdown of press releases, stories and backstories once we hit a new page. LOL with the amount of material this thread now has and what we will keep on having, we may need additional threads eventually. LOL Es’ reply to her: Oh! I *really* hope that someday either Assassin Witch or our Café Librarian, StoryGirl83, gives us a sub-sub-subboard for just “Elemental Charmed”. SummerReading (SR) replied: (I bolded my reply to let you know where I made a comment reply to you, maybe we could all do the same, just so we know where to reply underneath)
That's the best idea I've heard. If we had a sub-sub-subboard someday, then would we really be able to have everything all neatly in separate threads. I hope that can happen someday.
ES' NOTE TO SR: Because I ended up doing quite a bit of editing as I was copying these press releases, I decided not to reply to your comments on these and wait to see what you and others think of these. SR' reply: That is a great idea! Pheebs added: I went and look at her myth online: I saw the Ghost Whisperer episode of Bloody Mary before, never seen the Supernatural one, might be way scarier than the GW one.
If this can play into Paige and her daughter Peyton maybe? But I'm not so sure, might be worth saving a story like this for later in the season or beyond. If someone has other idea's, go ahead? Es replied: Wasn't Bloody Mary one of the scary creatures in 'Chick Flick', even if it didn't include a mirror - although, of course, a mirror *was* used in 'The Fourth Sister'? This episode would be a great nod to those great episodes, even if, typical Classic Charmed, they twisted the mythology to fit their episode.
Although you might be right that it would fit later in the season or even in a different season, depending upon what SC and others had in mind - but it is definitely something I'd want as part of "Elemental Charmed" - great job!
And the idea of connecting Bloody Mary to Peyton is fantastic! Pheebs added: And here's my press release following Es' lead:
I went and looked at the CW press release for their reboot, and made changes to it to fit *our* reboot. Es replied: Oh, what great fun! Although as I said in an earlier post, the more I think about it, the more I don't think including our stars as Prudence, Patience and Paige is a good idea - it was just Es having fun dreaming of what could be, maybe not what should be. But if/when we decide to "cast" this, this is a great way of doing it. SummerReading (SR) replied:I really strongly agree with this. Even though your fun dreaming I really loved. Especially because the way we have already cast Shannen and Alyssa, I honestly think is such a really outstanding way to bring them in.
NOTE FROM ES: In reformatting this, since Pheebs later approved my edits, I took out my own comments and just put in my edit: NOTE FROM ES: Because I think most of us agree that my idea of using Holly, Shannen and Alyssa to play Prudence, Patience and Paige doesn’t really work, I’ve edited the following press release. Also, just for the fun of it, I edited the powers a little. Remember that these can be changed. I'd love to know what you guys think of these ideas. SummerReading (SR) replied: Wonderful Es. NOTE FROM ES: I had fun casting Piper and Phoebe. Again, if anyone wants someone else in those roles – I don’t watch enough broadcast TV or The CW to know who would fit - feel free to change it. SummerReading (SR) replied: You did a great job. I really haven't thought about casting, I haven't seen too many The CW shows. So I might leave it in the hands of those that do. I know that television series Holly was a regular on Pretty Little Liars has a number of options for Piper and Phoebe, but I don't know much about those stars. But if someone can convince me why they should be cast, I'll listen. Es added: Even if we recast "Elemental Charmed", we SO have to include this! So? What do you guys think of those? Remember - this is all still just rough draft, part of brainstorming, so if you don't like anything I did, don't be afraid to say so! SummerReading (SR) replied: That press release is very good. Don't change a thing with the '20 Years of Magic'.Oh, I'm a "Witch" now, I see. 1,000 posts! 🎉 Congratulations, Deano! Congrats, Deano!
|
|
Ruth Marie
Whitelighter
Prue Seasons "What If...?" Fan Fic Winner
Posts: 4,353
|
Post by Ruth Marie on Aug 24, 2018 5:43:32 GMT -5
I really like you have done with these new press releases. Great job, Team Charmed Cafe. The backstory of Mary Ann and Jenna Warren is great. Especially the idea of having one sister the start of a line of witches and the other the start of a line of warlocks. Another suggestion is having our very own That 70s Episode' with renaming it That 90s Episode' the title a nod to the Classic original episode. But coming up with our own fun time travel episode or one that would explore the past, show exactly what happened to Peyton, how the sisters got sent away in more detail, and such. What does everyone think of that idea? EDIT: Forgot to mention. Congratulations, Deano on becoming a Witch.
|
|
Esmeralda
Charmed
S2 "What If...?" Fan Fic Winner
Twenty Years Gone....But Never Forgotten.
Posts: 21,920
|
Post by Esmeralda on Aug 24, 2018 7:13:34 GMT -5
Can't say I like this idea - I hate non-whitelighters (including witchlighters) being able to heal - it made injuries and death mean nothing, so even limited, no, just not happy with that. I find myself preferring what Paul Rudiitis did in his book, having the one with the Element of Earth be the Earth Mover - moving Earth to move people and objects - her form of TK. I like the calmest person of the group have that power while letting Paige, the Wind Walker, being able to transport people. This way you have Melinda Warren's three original powers - move items with your mind (Patience), freeze molecules (Phoebe) and see the future (Prudence) but in different forms, along with the other two elements, throwing fireballs (Phoebe) and transporting people (Paige) to make them the Elemental witches. But if any one else likes your idea (especially SR and Pheebs, since they've been doing such a great job with the press releases), go for it! Or, for that matter, if you want to keep Patience's Earth power of forming items from earth, go for it! As I said before, part of the fun of our series is so far the only powers that have really been used is Prudence's premonitions and - once - Paige's transporting, so we can still do whatever we want with the other powers, including Earth. TK probably does fit the EarthMover better, actually. Yay! Glad you agree! [/quote]I'm proud that like me, you guys got your points by replying to posts and starting new threads, not playing games. Of course, if you like playing games - go for it!
|
|
Esmeralda
Charmed
S2 "What If...?" Fan Fic Winner
Twenty Years Gone....But Never Forgotten.
Posts: 21,920
|
Post by Esmeralda on Aug 24, 2018 7:32:20 GMT -5
Even though I want to go back and reply to the other posts I haven't commented on yet, i HAD to pop back and comment on this right away! Absolutely totally LOVE it, Pheebs! I'm glad you liked my idea of moving our show from broadcast TV to network TV as compared to Supergirl which did it in reverse and I *so* love how you find real press releases and adapt them for out show! You calling it a "fantasy drama" really made me smile - that's truly what we'd want our show to be, one that takes itself seriously, the way early Classic Charmed did. My only problem with this is that the way I have it set up, Shannen wouldn't appear in the Season One finale. However, I think that can be fixed by showing flashbacks of the Salem Witch Trials that include both sisters (I'll add here that I absolutely love your idea of having one sister the start of a line of witches and the other the start of a line of warlocks, but I still don't think they have to - or should be - non-identical twins. But as always in this project, I'll bow to the majority's opinion. Here's my edits: Due to loving this, I've changed my version of the Season One finale and Season Two Premiere: How's that? I think this is perfect! Pheebs yet again you're killing the press releases. Can't wait to do some more on the weekend. I can't wait for when we are able to put these in chronlogical order when we have our first season in order. Es and Pheebs you have the thumbs up from me, that I don't think anything above needs changing unless of course we end up adding more to the plots or rework the stories for another episode or season. As of now, I really am impressed. Can't say I like this idea - I hate non-whitelighters (including witchlighters) being able to heal - it made injuries and death mean nothing, so even limited, no, just not happy with that. I find myself preferring what Paul Rudiitis did in his book, having the one with the Element of Earth be the Earth Mover - moving Earth to move people and objects - her form of TK. I like the calmest person of the group have that power while letting Paige, the Wind Walker, being able to transport people. This way you have Melinda Warren's three original powers - move items with your mind (Patience), freeze molecules (Phoebe) hand see the future (Prudence) but in different forms, along with the other two elements, throwing fireballs (Phoebe) and transporting people (Paige) to make them the Elemental witches. But if any one else likes your idea (especially SR and Pheebs, since they've been doing such a great job with the press releases), go for it! Or, for that matter, if you want to keep Patience's Earth power of forming items from earth, go for it! As I said before, part of the fun of our series is so far the only powers that have really been used is Prudence's premonitions and - once - Paige's transporting, so we can still do whatever we want with the other powers, including Earth. I have been really concentrating on other parts of our reboot including plots and getting the character stories sorted and figuring out the living situations and backstory properly, that I admit that all the powers have really not been on my mind at all. But, I do really think sorting out the powers is the next thing, I hope we can address. But like Es said, if anyone else here likes those ideas, go for it! We can have several different directions or alternate powers. That when we get much further into the project, at a later point, we can have a master 'Elemental Charmed' where we figure out truly which one works, and agree as a team. But on that note, Prudence and Paige's powers do seem pretty settled. Deano, I do like your suggestion of inducing harm like the warlock Nicholas, with "blood-boiling" powers. But we might end up wanting to have Peyton have that power further down the line. All part of the fun in coming up with ideas. But in regards to healing, I wonder if we might actually have fun with maybe making Prudence being an ex nurse, that way she can use actual medical knowledge to heal injuries the human way, or the use of potions to heal injuries. But not having whitelighters or healing abilities. Again, if others want healing, and enough agree. I'll go with the majority. Thank you! It wasn't that big of a deal since I just had to copy and paste - just wish I'd done it better, especially when I see that I'm going to end up with a similar problem with your thread that Colton had with mine. But since I'm very curious to see what you thought, I'll do my best, copying and pasting again if I have to, doing it slightly differently by using blockquotes rather than quotes in hopes that it won't go away if someone quotes me. However if someone *does* quote me, BE SURE to delete the [*quote source=""*] quote at the beginning or if anyone quotes YOU, all of the press releases will go away! I’ve learned the hard way – preview before you hit the “Post” button! For that reason, when I talk about me replying, I’m going to say “Es replied” rather than “I replied” so it will make sense if someone quotes this. I'm going to have to keep an eye out myself when I reply - make sure I don't have a similar problem that Colton had. Thank you very much, this has helped. Now I'll do my best to catch up on everything now. Since we don't have any like button, I don't want to clog up this thread with posts of me just thanking someone for liking the reboot press releases or ideas, so to anyone I haven't already thanked. Thank you for liking what everyone here has been producing. That sounds like a very wise idea Es with how you lay out the replies below. Just in case these get lost in another page, I decided to cut and paste all of SummerReading's (SR) and what Es, Deono, and everyone came up with before. So it would be easier for people to quote and comment on them directly. As was mentioned, if anyone wants to edit or change something, feel free. Thank you, Pheebs. This is truly something we should do each time we hit a new page so any members new to this thread will know what we're doing and have a chance to add their own ideas. Since it's been copied a couple of times, I'm going to skip the earlier parts and just comment on the new parts, but have to start by saying you also did a fantastic job with these! Pheebs wrote: And here are my additions.
Again I cut and pasted how SR laid it out and just made my additions. But what I worked on, might not fit with having a spirit ot ghost of some kind haunting in the previous episode.
Summer Reading or anyone else, if you wish to change mine, go ahead, if you wish to add your own episode 6, go ahead, and if you wish to move this around to another episode in the season, go ahead. Es replied: And that's the fun of this being a Team Charmed Cafe project. Everything in this thread is just a rough draft - anyone else want to do it their way, they're more than welcomed to do it - especially because then Editor Es can later have fun combining all of the ideas into one cohesive whole! Since I'm not good at coming up with original stuff, this is what I love doing most!
So, as always, Pheebs, I hope you don't mind if I edit yours. As always, feel free to change anything I edit back if you don't like what I do - you guys are the ones with the original ideas, so it's totally up to you to decide if what I change should stay changed or not. SummerReading (SR) replied: Great thinking to have our breakdown of press releases, stories and backstories once we hit a new page. LOL with the amount of material this thread now has and what we will keep on having, we may need additional threads eventually. LOL Es’ reply to her: Oh! I *really* hope that someday either Assassin Witch or our Café Librarian, StoryGirl83, gives us a sub-sub-subboard for just “Elemental Charmed”. SummerReading (SR) replied: (I bolded my reply to let you know where I made a comment reply to you, maybe we could all do the same, just so we know where to reply underneath)
That's the best idea I've heard. If we had a sub-sub-subboard someday, then would we really be able to have everything all neatly in separate threads. I hope that can happen someday.
ES' NOTE TO SR: Because I ended up doing quite a bit of editing as I was copying these press releases, I decided not to reply to your comments on these and wait to see what you and others think of these. SR' reply: That is a great idea! Pheebs added: I went and look at her myth online: I saw the Ghost Whisperer episode of Bloody Mary before, never seen the Supernatural one, might be way scarier than the GW one.
If this can play into Paige and her daughter Peyton maybe? But I'm not so sure, might be worth saving a story like this for later in the season or beyond. If someone has other idea's, go ahead? Es replied: Wasn't Bloody Mary one of the scary creatures in 'Chick Flick', even if it didn't include a mirror - although, of course, a mirror *was* used in 'The Fourth Sister'? This episode would be a great nod to those great episodes, even if, typical Classic Charmed, they twisted the mythology to fit their episode.
Although you might be right that it would fit later in the season or even in a different season, depending upon what SC and others had in mind - but it is definitely something I'd want as part of "Elemental Charmed" - great job!
And the idea of connecting Bloody Mary to Peyton is fantastic! Pheebs added: And here's my press release following Es' lead:
I went and looked at the CW press release for their reboot, and made changes to it to fit *our* reboot. Es replied: Oh, what great fun! Although as I said in an earlier post, the more I think about it, the more I don't think including our stars as Prudence, Patience and Paige is a good idea - it was just Es having fun dreaming of what could be, maybe not what should be. But if/when we decide to "cast" this, this is a great way of doing it. SummerReading (SR) replied:I really strongly agree with this. Even though your fun dreaming I really loved. Especially because the way we have already cast Shannen and Alyssa, I honestly think is such a really outstanding way to bring them in.
NOTE FROM ES: In reformatting this, since Pheebs later approved my edits, I took out my own comments and just put in my edit: NOTE FROM ES: Because I think most of us agree that my idea of using Holly, Shannen and Alyssa to play Prudence, Patience and Paige doesn’t really work, I’ve edited the following press release. Also, just for the fun of it, I edited the powers a little. Remember that these can be changed. I'd love to know what you guys think of these ideas. SummerReading (SR) replied: Wonderful Es. NOTE FROM ES: I had fun casting Piper and Phoebe. Again, if anyone wants someone else in those roles – I don’t watch enough broadcast TV or The CW to know who would fit - feel free to change it. SummerReading (SR) replied: You did a great job. I really haven't thought about casting, I haven't seen too many The CW shows. So I might leave it in the hands of those that do. I know that television series Holly was a regular on Pretty Little Liars has a number of options for Piper and Phoebe, but I don't know much about those stars. But if someone can convince me why they should be cast, I'll listen. Es added: Even if we recast "Elemental Charmed", we SO have to include this! So? What do you guys think of those? Remember - this is all still just rough draft, part of brainstorming, so if you don't like anything I did, don't be afraid to say so! SummerReading (SR) replied: That press release is very good. Don't change a thing with the '20 Years of Magic'.Congrats, Deano! [/quote]SR, I just had time to read your reactions and not reply and reformat this whole thing, but I *had* to reply to your reply to this:
|
|
Esmeralda
Charmed
S2 "What If...?" Fan Fic Winner
Twenty Years Gone....But Never Forgotten.
Posts: 21,920
|
Post by Esmeralda on Aug 24, 2018 7:42:09 GMT -5
I really like you have done with these new press releases. Great job, Team Charmed Cafe. The backstory of Mary Ann and Jenna Warren is great. Especially the idea of having one sister the start of a line of witches and the other the start of a line of warlocks. Another suggestion is having our very own That 70s Episode' with renaming it That 90s Episode' the title a nod to the Classic original episode. But coming up with our own fun time travel episode or one that would explore the past, show exactly what happened to Peyton, how the sisters got sent away in more detail, and such. What does everyone think of that idea? Oh, *definitely* like that idea, Ruth! And because ours is a true reboot of the show, unlike the ripoff, I think we can get away with doing this - doing our versions of favorite Charmed episodes. In something like 'The 90's Episode', would it be *just* Piper and Phoebe who would go time-traveling with the other actresses playing younger versions of themselves? If so, it's why having the actresses being younger than their characters (since it's easier to make younger actors look older than making older actors look younger...hehehehehe, yeah, I still like my idea of the originals playing the older Warrens, even if I've agreed not to do that, since I admit I can't see Holly agreeing to look that much older than Shannen and Alyssa in every episode!
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Aug 24, 2018 9:50:31 GMT -5
Perhaps you’re right about the women using spells and potions to heal, summerreading - like the witch, Janna, did in ‘Exit Strategy’ with her healing paste - as this would require more time and effort (I.e, needing the right herbs, perhaps it only works at midnight) than simply sticking out your hand and ‘hey presto!’
Actually, in the book I’m currently reading, Labyrinth Lost, one of the witches can heal but she has to “absorb” the injury herself so maybe that’s another route because then, obviously, this form of healing can’t be used for every little cut or scrape.
But these are only suggestions if you do wantbuo include a healing power further down the line.
I love the idea of Prudence being a nurse or doctor.
|
|
|
Post by prudencehalliwell on Aug 24, 2018 16:39:00 GMT -5
Prudence being a Nurse or Doctor is a really good idea. Regardless if she's retired or not.
Deano. That's an interesting twist to healing. Maybe even everytime she heals it weakens her or takes a day of her own life away. So they'd have to only use it in rare cases. Can't heal the dead. But maybe
But maybe going the way of having Prudence being a nurse or Doctor and potions and herbs is enough.
|
|
|
Post by summerreading on Aug 24, 2018 21:01:25 GMT -5
I think the idea of Peyton having that power (although right now her power is Water, not Fire or Earth - BUT as a warlock, she could steal these powers, but by killing other witches, not her family) having that power is a fantastic idea. So is making Prudence an ex-nurse (or even a full doctor...) who can help heal injuries, but not people who are dead. We've yet to come up with an occupation for Prudence and that would be a great one! Come along next page, I get the feeling I'm going to have to redo our whole thing, including these and other additions/subtractions/changes. That is correct, she can steal these powers and killing other witches, not her family. I'm glad you liked that power idea Es, what do others think? I just thought of the idea that our Nexus or Hollow, might need the five elements to unlock or get access to it. That Peyton might want to get their powers for her own gains to get inside. Not sure where we would have our Nexus or Hollow located, maybe the Salem Witches burial site or just go Classic Charmed and near the Manor. We didn't come up with an occupation for Prudence yet, If others agree, I'd love for that to be hers. I have a feeling we're only a few replies off from being on a new page.
|
|
|
Post by summerreading on Aug 24, 2018 21:11:18 GMT -5
I really like you have done with these new press releases. Great job, Team Charmed Cafe. The backstory of Mary Ann and Jenna Warren is great. Especially the idea of having one sister the start of a line of witches and the other the start of a line of warlocks. Another suggestion is having our very own That 70s Episode' with renaming it That 90s Episode' the title a nod to the Classic original episode. But coming up with our own fun time travel episode or one that would explore the past, show exactly what happened to Peyton, how the sisters got sent away in more detail, and such. What does everyone think of that idea? Oh, *definitely* like that idea, Ruth! And because ours is a true reboot of the show, unlike the ripoff, I think we can get away with doing this - doing our versions of favorite Charmed episodes. In something like 'The 90's Episode', would it be *just* Piper and Phoebe who would go time-traveling with the other actresses playing younger versions of themselves? If so, it's why having the actresses being younger than their characters (since it's easier to make younger actors look older than making older actors look younger...hehehehehe, yeah, I still like my idea of the originals playing the older Warrens, even if I've agreed not to do that, since I admit I can't see Holly agreeing to look that much older than Shannen and Alyssa in every episode! What a wonderful idea, Ruth! Maybe Piper and Phoebe would just travel, I don't think to have the others travel would work. But maybe, like Phoebe going back to the 20's to find the pendant from 'Pardon My Past'. The reason they go back in time is to find something important or another reason they end up in the 90's. I guess the older Warren's could be dealing with their own crisis in the present. That's a good point, we might have to cast actresses younger for the parts. It isn't uncommon that shows do this Es. You find that actresses who play the mothers to their kids are sometimes only a decade older than the actors or actresses playing their kids. I don't think Holly would agree either. Perhaps you’re right about the women using spells and potions to heal, summerreading - like the witch, Janna, did in ‘Exit Strategy’ with her healing paste - as this would require more time and effort (I.e, needing the right herbs, perhaps it only works at midnight) than simply sticking out your hand and ‘hey presto!’ Actually, in the book I’m currently reading, Labyrinth Lost, one of the witches can heal but she has to “absorb” the injury herself so maybe that’s another route because then, obviously, this form of healing can’t be used for every little cut or scrape. But these are only suggestions if you do wantbuo include a healing power further down the line. I love the idea of Prudence being a nurse or doctor. Prudence being a Nurse or Doctor is a really good idea. Regardless if she's retired or not. Deano. That's an interesting twist to healing. Maybe even everytime she heals it weakens her or takes a day of her own life away. So they'd have to only use it in rare cases. Can't heal the dead. But maybe But maybe going the way of having Prudence being a nurse or Doctor and potions and herbs is enough. Those are good suggestions. But I wouldn't want any healing powers to heal the dead. Plus if we're going to have Prudence being a doctor, maybe we wouldn't need a healing power. Maybe the Warren's come across someone who has a healing power but this Witch doesn't survive long enough. But play with all the idea's you suggested above. Maybe this Witch keeps healing, and the more she heals, the more she absorbs, the more it drains her to the point that she dies.
|
|