Elise (The Big Secret)

[foxfire]

Jason should have known earlier. She was really serious with him and the way he found out was just all wrong. I agree with Esmeralda that there's a large problem when one of the sisters tells the boyfriend in the wrong way.

Jason shouldn't have had to see her orb in. That was probably what made him freak-out. Although, he clearly couldn't handle it. Seeing as the two parted ways at the end of the episode. I am however peeved that Phoebe told Dex. Dex should have NEVER known about her being a witch. They dated for all of what... a month or two?! On top of that, she didn't even love him!! That Phoebe... girl never learns.

[vandergraafk]

Ljones, I guess that one consequence of the anarchy that currently rages in the Charmed Cafe. We've got multiple, overlapping threads. We've got new ones popping up all the time that duplicate existing ones. As a long-time poster, I am equally frustrated when an issue arises that has been discussed elsewhere. Worse: new participants seem disinclined to seek out the old ones to see what was already discussed. Hang in there. It could be worse. What if we forgot where we had already posted something? Oh wait! I've already done that. Now where did I write this already.

[colehellsangel]

foxfire said:

Jason should have known earlier. She was really serious with him and the way he found out was just all wrong. I agree with Esmeralda that there's a large problem when one of the sisters tells the boyfriend in the wrong way.

Jason shouldn't have had to see her orb in. That was probably what made him freak-out. Although, he clearly couldn't handle it. Seeing as the two parted ways at the end of the episode. I am however peeved that Phoebe told Dex. Dex should have NEVER known about her being a witch. They dated for all of what... a month or two?! On top of that, she didn't even love him!! That Phoebe... girl never learns.

Yes I agree Jason should have known the way Henry found out from Paige(Which I have not actually seen but people here seem to approve of it and I guess he did not take it badly). She even moved in with Jason for pity's sake. I think the person she lives with needs to know. I also agree with Esmeralda about the way the boyfriends are told just that its not an easy thing to tell someone so they can't be fully blamed is all.

[spiritsas]

Two things strike me about this thread. I hadn't read all the posts but the same thought dawned on me as did, ina, a newbie innocent to the site, who notes that Elise ran a newspaper and was a professional in her field. How could they tell such a person their secret and expect her to keep the biggest story of her life under wraps. Second thing that struck me was that it seems to have gone off on a tangent about the boy friends and who else should have been told. Dan is brought up. Actually, he was told, but the memory was removed by the Genie who caused the wish to turn on Dan and make him grow old, suddenly.

It's also worth noting, to add to this tangent, that not every male in a romantic relationship with one of the sisters was told. Obviously, anyone who was going to marry a CO would have to be told, but "what's his name" from the first couple of seasons (Prue partner at the auction house) was never told and he was unceremoniously dumped. Fireman Tom or whatever his name was, was never told by Piper. In fact, the only boyfriends, who then didn't marry a CO who were told, all belonged to Phoebe. Paige's friend (from her past) doesn't count here as they were not romantically involved during the show (well, there was a short encounter during his first visit, OK, but they were not dating or anything). Just thought I'd throw that one out there.

[ljones]

Piper was not seriously involved with Dan in my opinion. Even phoebe said aloud that Dan was lust.

Sounds like typical Phoebe trying to dismiss Dan so that Piper can have an easier choice. Like her idiotic reason for losing the child she was carrying in late S4.

Piper never struck me as the type who would date a guy for half a year merely because she felt lust for him. In fact, Dan's personality strongly reminds me of Leo. Which is why I'm not surprised that she became serious with him. Even though she loved Dan, she loved Leo more. That's it.

[Esmeralda]

ljones said:

Piper was not seriously involved with Dan in my opinion. Even phoebe said aloud that Dan was lust.

Sounds like typical Phoebe trying to dismiss Dan so that Piper can have an easier choice. Like her idiotic reason for losing the child she was carrying in late S4.

Piper never struck me as the type who would date a guy for half a year merely because she felt lust for him. In fact, Dan's personality strongly reminds me of Leo. Which is why I'm not surprised that she became serious with him. Even though she loved Dan, she loved Leo more. That's it.

I'll agree. The sisters were very good at rationalizing bad decisions.

I wish I could say that I thought that Piper loved Dan more than Leo. I don't think she ever loved Dan, period. She was in love with what he represented--the normal life that Leo couldn't give her--that's why she rebounded onto him--and the reason why she didn't tell him the secret--if he knew, then he'd be part of the life she didn't want to have--the life of a witch. But until when/if she truly wanted that enough to give up her powers, she *was* a witch and shouldn't have slept with him until she 1)accepted the fact that she was a witch and told him or 2)gave up her powers and wouldn't have to tell him. Since, thanks to her sisters, she couldn't/wouldn't do that, she truly should not have slept with Dan since she was truly simply using him, which was terribly unfair to him and explains why he acted like such a jerk in the latter part of S2. And Piper never learned her lesson, since she acted the same way with Greg the Fireman for a worse reason--pure lust.

Which brings us to Phoebe. Of all the sisters, she handled her relationships the worst, the reason so many fans call her a sl*t and her guys her slampieces. She was the ultimate user.

When it came to guys, she seemed to be in a fantasy world, not accepting reality, which is amazing after what she went through with Cole. She truly should've been given a very, VERY huge reality check--real life just doesn't work like that. It's why I wish *she* was the one who ended up with a true non-magical handyman.

For those who watched the show "Cheers!", Phoebe always reminded me a lot of Rebecca and I would've liked her ending to be more like Rebecca's--Rebecca always wanted to marry someone rich who could take care of her and ended up with a plumber, someone she truly loved and who truly loved her despite neither being rich. Rebecca had her realtiy check--Phoebe desperately needed one and Coop wasn't it, since he was the biggest fantasy of all--a *cupid* in love with her and married by the Angel of Destiny. I'm sure that couple didn't last far beyond her finally getting those three daughters--the reason why we never saw what happened after she had that third daughter, since having her daughters was the only thing she really wanted. If she continued her fantasy world, I'm sure she beat Grams for number of divorces and probably had a dozen kids, all of whom she ignored as she went on to her next fantasy guy.

Getting back to the original topic. Maybe that's why Phoebe was able to get away with not telling her secret to Elise and get away with such a flimsy excuse so often and still keep her job. Kern let Phoebe live in a fantasy world where you can get away with such stuff--Phoebe's entire life (like Charmed itself) was truly just someone's (probably Piper's) dream and she should wake up at any time and find out that none of it happened, ESPECIALLY the last three seasons, and ESPECIALLY ESPECIALLY the last season and ESPECIALLY ESPECIALLY ESPECIALLY Forever Charmed!

[spiritsas]

E: In a real world situation, I couldn't agree with you more about Phoebe. I'm not sure about the last part that she would dump Cupid and keep moving on from guy to guy. That's not the impression left by Forever Charmed, but it doesn't matte.

Of course, since it was a show and Alyssa M. is supposed to be the hot, shapely sex symbol (and I'm not that HMC or RM are not hot, but AM is the one who lists on Maxim and other similar mags as one of the top 100 hottest women). So, it's logical they kept her doing the more sexy relationships with a constant series of hunky guys, like Jason, Dex, Leslie, etc. Her character, in making fun of herself, even stated in one episode that she felt pathetic or sad that, up until that point, her best relationship had been with a demon (Cole, of course). My point is that you have to blame either Kern or the studio in that AM got tagged to be the more sexually active sister, always looking for love and not finding it. But having a good time trying.

[Esmeralda]

spiritkas said:

E: In a real world situation, I couldn't agree with you more about Phoebe. I'm not sure about the last part that she would dump Cupid and keep moving on from guy to guy. That's not the impression left by Forever Charmed, but it doesn't matte.

That's the impression left AT THE TIME THAT SHE WAS GOING INTO LABOR WITH HER THIRD CHILD! We never were told what happened after that and since we WERE shown what happened to Leo and Piper, I always took that to mean that the "problems and sorrows" that Piper mentions has to do with stuff happening to the other two couples--the only ones who were "Forever Charmed" were Leo & Piper--the reason I think the whole thing is Piper's fantasy after she and the other two were blown up at the end of Kill Billie, Vol 2, since there's no possible way that Piper could've survived that without a single injury when Paige (who should've panic-orbed) didn't.

Of course, since it was a show and Alyssa M. is supposed to be the hot, shapely sex symbol (and I'm not that HMC or RM are not hot, but AM is the one who lists on Maxim and other similar mags as one of the top 100 hottest women). So, it's logical they kept her doing the more sexy relationships with a constant series of hunky guys, like Jason, Dex, Leslie, etc. Her character, in making fun of herself, even stated in one episode that she felt pathetic or sad that, up until that point, her best relationship had been with a demon (Cole, of course). My point is that you have to blame either Kern or the studio in that AM got tagged to be the more sexually active sister, always looking for love and not finding it. But having a good time trying.

I'd agree with you IF at the end she was given a more realisitic husband or didn't have that "where I am, he is" crap to try to fill in a horrible plothole!

[charmedfan4evr]

esmeralda said:

spiritkas said:

E: In a real world situation, I couldn't agree with you more about Phoebe. I'm not sure about the last part that she would dump Cupid and keep moving on from guy to guy. That's not the impression left by Forever Charmed, but it doesn't matte.

That's the impression left AT THE TIME THAT SHE WAS GOING INTO LABOR WITH HER THIRD CHILD! We never were told what happened after that and since we WERE shown what happened to Leo and Piper, I always took that to mean that the "problems and sorrows" that Piper mentions has to do with stuff happening to the other two couples--the only ones who were "Forever Charmed" were Leo & Piper

See this is just one reason why I hated that the show ended in the future.

HOW DO YOU KNOW? How do you know that that will actually be their futures? In the world of Charmed, you have no idea! Their future's could most certainly be changed. Which has been clearly evident throughout the series!

It just left us to a more unanswered, and unsatisfying end.

[Esmeralda]

charmedfan4evr said:

esmeralda said:

That's the impression left AT THE TIME THAT SHE WAS GOING INTO LABOR WITH HER THIRD CHILD! We never were told what happened after that and since we WERE shown what happened to Leo and Piper, I always took that to mean that the "problems and sorrows" that Piper mentions has to do with stuff happening to the other two couples--the only ones who were "Forever Charmed" were Leo & Piper

HOW DO YOU KNOW? How do you know that that will actually be their futures? In the world of Charmed, you have no idea! Their future's could most certainly be changed. Which has been clearly evident throughout the series!

See this is just one reason why I hated that the show ended in the future.

It just left us to a more unanswered, and unsatisfying end.

Exactly. Something like three sisters standing in the doorway and the breeze would've made so much more sense!

Either that or show Phoebe and Coop telling the story to *their* grandkids, and then Paige and Henry telling *theirs* and finally Piper and Leo telling *theirs*, so we'd know that all three couples made it. Having the three of them write stuff down when they hadn't even lived it yet made no sense whatsoever!

I still like my ending from my own Charmed Forever best:

Fifty years later...

Three old couples, sitting around a Scrabble board, watched as the figures of Paige, Coop and Patty heart-orbed out before turning back to their game. While Leo decided what word he could make out of his letters, Piper got up and left the room. The others watched her, but also watched as Leo got his triple score anyway when he was able to spell out "Xanadu".

While everyone groaned at him for including a 1980 Olivia Newton-John movie and Phoebe decided on her next play, Piper returned, carrying the Book of Shadows. Immediately her sisters became concerned. “Is there a demon the kids need help fighting?” asked Paige.

Piper shook her head. “No, the kids are doing just fine, much better than we ever did, in fact. It’s just that after seeing young Paige and young Coop, even seeing Mom again, I think we should write down everything that has happened since you, Paige, and you, Coop, were the ones doing the visiting, along with everything else we want to pass down to future generations, so we can pass the Book of Shadows down to them, like it was passed down to us.”

Leo nodded. “You guys have told our kids and our grandkids the stories over and over again. They know them almost as well as you do. But it’s a good idea to have them written down for our grandkids' kids and their kids and so forth down the line.”

“Phoebe," Paige suggested. "Since you're the one who started this whole thing by finding the Book of Shadows in the first place, why don’t you go first?”

Phoebe nodded and began looking through the Book for a blank page, her hand caressing the Book when she found certain pages that meant a lot to her. When she finally found a blank page, Coop picked up the pen he’d been using to keep score and passed it to her.

“Why don’t you read out loud as you write?" Henry suggested. "That way we can all hear what you‘re writing and not duplicate,” and everyone thought that was a great idea.

So as Phoebe wrote, she also spoke: “So much happened after the Angel of Destiny rewarded us for a job well done. So much was gained, so much was lost, but it was all worth it,” and everyone nodded in agreement.

Taking the time to look up to smile at Coop, Phoebe returned to reading what she was writing: “After Coop gave up his powers as a cupid, I was finally able to have the big huge church wedding that I always wanted. I patterned my dress after the one I wore as the Goddess of Love and that’s what I felt like when the minister pronounced us husband and wife. I knew that I could finally stop looking for love,” and Coop reached out to squeeze her hand. She smiled at him, then continued. “Thanks to that love, I was finally able to have the special little girl who I thought I would never have. Patty is indeed the joy of my life, but then so are Prue and Penny, the other two little girls that Coop’s and my love created. They have grown to be beautiful, loving women with families of their own and powers of their own. Because they are three sisters descended from Melinda Warren, they can also harness The Power of Three. I never dreamed that I would be the mother of the next set of Charmed Ones, but I am. And because despite being mortal, Coop was able to pass his cupid powers to his daughters, Patricia, Prudence and Penelope care for innocents and take care of them much more than my sisters and I ever did, as will their children after them,” and the others all had to agree with that.

“Talk about our jobs,” Coop suggested.

Phoebe grinned and began to write again, still reading her words as she did: “I continued to work at the Bay Mirror, giving out advice, until it was time to retire, but I soon shared my office and my byline with a very special co-worker. Shortly after our marriage, the old banners that used to read ‘Ask Phoebe‘, instead read ‘Ladies, Ask Phoebe!--Guys, Ask Coop!’ All of Coop‘s experiences as a cupid helped me give even better advice on love, and even helped me write my best-seller ‘Finding Love’.” and everyone clapped as she signed “Phoebe Halliwell“ beneath her words.

Paige couldn’t help it. She grabbed the pen from her sister and began to write, also reading aloud: “Thanks to Coop’s love, Phoebe indeed became an expert on finding love, helping all of our children find their own true loves. That kept her busy during the demon truce, just as the Angel of Destiny knew it would. As for my family, Henry continued to look after his parolees, including one who ended up becoming our daughter-in-law! Henry eventually became a captain before retiring and still managed to make time to help me with Henry Jr. and our twins, Charlotte and Cassandra, named after Melinda Warren’s mother and granddaughter. Since I was made full-whitelighter by the Angel of Destiny, all three are all half-whitelighters with whitelighter powers similar to what I had before the Big Battle that Never Was, while Cass and Char also have Warren powers. They and Hank use them to do all they can to help their cousins, the next set of Charmed Ones, just like Piper‘s kids do. They all learned how to do that from me, because thanks to the demon truce and the special gifts the Angel of Destiny gave me, I was able to help the next generation of witches come into their own, something I enjoyed doing and found completely fulfilling,” and everyone clapped as she signed: “Paige Matthews-Mitchell.”

This time it was Piper who grabbed the pen from her sister and began to write, also reading aloud: “Paige was able to pass on all she learned as a whitelighter and as a Charmed One, not just to her children or mine or Phoebe’s, but also to other future witches and whitelighters. When the demon truce was finally over, the next generation of Halliwells didn’t have to fight them alone as we did, so they all have more than enough time for their own lives,” and everyone agreed with that, too.

Piper continued, still reading aloud: “While the truce was in place, I was finally able to go back to my roots and cook things other than potions, finally opening up ‘Piper’s’, the restaurant I always wanted to have, while continuing to run P3."

“Talk about Leo!” cried Paige.

“And Wyatt!” added Henry.

"And Chris and Bianca!" added Coop, smiling at Phoebe.

Piper nodded and continued to write, still reading aloud as she did: “Since the Angel of Destiny finally gave Leo an identity in this time period, he was able to go back to school and become a doctor, so he could continue to heal people as has always been his destiny. He continued this destiny until it was time for both of us to retire, but by that time we both had help. Melinda has taken over running Piper’s and Wyatt is now a doctor, using both his knowledge and his powers to continue his father’s destiny of healing, while Chris took over running P3. He was the first of the next generation that found love--he is very happily married to his one true love. Bianca is not a Phoenix as she was in Chris' original past, because when she came back to our time to try to bring Chris back to Wyatt, she scared her mother so much, that her mother ran away with Young Bianca, so Bianca was never initiated into the Phoenix cult and never received her powers. Instead she is a cop, playing the same role with the next generation that Darryl played with us, although much closer than Darryl ever was!”

“Amen!” agreed Phoebe as she and Coop remembered what it was like to help bring those two together.

Smiling, Piper finished the entry: “Although we’ve had our struggles and our heartaches, we are and always will be a family of survivors--charmed forever!”

“AMEN!” declared the others, as she happily signed “Piper Halliwell-Wyatt” with a flourish and then closed the Book of Shadows.

Suddenly the front door flew open and all nine of the next generation of Halliwells and their spouses, along with a whole crowd of grandkids ran into the room. The grandkids each ran to hug their own grandparents, while their parents stood in the doorway and proudly, lovingly watched.

One little granddaughter ran in last, one with shorter raven-black hair, electric-blue eyes and a large freckle in just the right spot, dressed in a bright red dress. Seeing her brother and sister and cousins hugging Piper and Leo, she hugged her dad instead.

Chris looked down and smiled at his youngest child before telling her, “You left the door open, Prue!” so the youngest Halliwell turned back towards the foyer and waved her arm.

The front door of the Manor magically closed.

That's how *I* would've liked to have seen it end. And for any part that doesn't make sense--you'll have to read my fic!

[colehellsangel]

I don't think she ever loved Dan, period. She was in love with what he represented--the normal life that Leo couldn't give her--that's why she rebounded onto him--and the reason why she didn't tell him the secret--if he knew, then he'd be part of the life she didn't want to have--the life of a witch.

All I have to say about this is that I could not agree more.

See this is just one reason why I hated that the show ended in the future.

HOW DO YOU KNOW? How do you know that that will actually be their futures? In the world of Charmed, you have no idea! Their future's could most certainly be changed. Which has been clearly evident throughout the series!

It just left us to a more unanswered, and unsatisfying end.

Umm but wasn't that the real future? Or was it a Morality Bites kind of thing? I am confused as I have only seen the end scene.

Like her idiotic reason for losing the child she was carrying in late S4.

Umm its was a demon child, it was turning her evil! and it was not even hers it was the seer's.

[ljones]

Umm its was a demon child, it was turning her evil! and it was not even hers it was the seer's.

How could that baby have been the Source's? Even though the Source had possession of Cole's body at the time of the baby's conception, it was Cole's sperm that helped conceived the child. Cole's body. All the Seer did was ensure that Phoebe would get pregnant . . . with the Source using Cole's body. But that baby was Phoebe and Cole's. To insinuate that the baby belonged to the Source only tells me that the writers knew crap about biology. How could it have biologically belonged to the Source's? Technically, he no longer had a sentient body. He was using Cole's. Which means that he was using Cole's seed to impregnate Phoebe:

Cole: We've been through this. Cole's love for Phoebe still exists within me, I can't overcome it. If I'm to regain what I've lost it has to be with Phoebe, marrying her.

Seer: Even if it means losing your son?

Cole: A son? You saw a son in my future?

Seer: More than a son. You and Phoebe Halliwell will produce the most powerful child the magical world has ever seen.

Cole: That's my boy.

Seer: No, he won't be your boy, he'll be theirs. On the side of good. Unless you marry the witch in a dark way.

The only way the Seer and the Source could ensure that the child would be his was for him to marry Phoebe in a dark ceremony and use a tonic that would allow the baby's darker nature to dominate.

If the sisters had been able to use a potion to counter that tonic, chances are that Phoebe and Cole's baby could have lived up to the Seer's original vision.

“After Coop gave up his powers as a cupid, I was finally able to have the big huge church wedding that I always wanted."

You know, that sounds like Phoebe and her fairy tale longings.

I don't think she ever loved Dan, period. She was in love with what he represented--the normal life that Leo couldn't give her--that's why she rebounded onto him--and the reason why she didn't tell him the secret--if he knew, then he'd be part of the life she didn't want to have--the life of a witch.

I believe that she did love Dan. But I don't think that she was in love with him in the way she was in love with Leo. Although if I had my way, she would have ended up with Mark Cho from "Dead Man Dating".

[charmedfan4evr]

colehellsangel said:

Umm but wasn't that the real future? Or was it a Morality Bites kind of thing? I am confused as I have only seen the end scene.

Who knows if it was. That's my whole point, we don't! No one can for sure. In the reality of Charmed, do I really think that's what their future holds in store, that exact? No, I don't think so.

[Assassin Witch]

colehellsangel said:

Umm but wasn't that the real future? Or was it a Morality Bites kind of thing? I am confused as I have only seen the end scene.

It's unknown. Because we've learned from Charmed that every decision/action we make changes the future. They wanted a "and they all lived happily ever after ending", but Charmed doesn't work like that. There are plenty of us who see passed it and are not afraid to call Kern out on his BS.

I for one totally erase the future scene from memory. Well, actually, I stop thinking about Charmed after Chris was born, but whatever.

[colehellsangel]

musicrpgoddess said:

colehellsangel said:

Umm but wasn't that the real future? Or was it a Morality Bites kind of thing? I am confused as I have only seen the end scene.

It's unknown. Because we've learned from Charmed that every decision/action we make changes the future. They wanted a "and they all lived happily ever after ending", but Charmed doesn't work like that. There are plenty of us who see passed it and are not afraid to call Kern out on his BS.

I for one totally erase the future scene from memory. Well, actually, I stop thinking about Charmed after Chris was born, but whatever.

Ok I see. It was nice to see Piper and Leo grow old together but I can see that being a very depressing ending in the sense that being old means the true end. That end may not come right away of course but you go to sleep every night wondering if you will wake up the next morning. And live only to wonder how long you have left(not in an obsessive way though as that only helps it come faster). So in that sense having in end with the charmed ones growing old is certainly a depressing ending. However it ended for me anyway when the Wyatt's Future and Avatar things came into play with a few episodes during those eras here and there that I enjoyed such as Witchstock. I never even bothered to see season eight at first it was no intentional as my mom had been taping them from TNT and it had went back to season one after season seven ended. But after reading things and seeing one or two episodes I really don't like the ideas of season eight. The Charmed ones hiding under fake identities because they are supposed to be dead and more the whole billie thing.

I think for a lot of us it was already long over before the finale as it really went downhill in some certain area. For me it was after Cole was permanently vanquished.

[charmedfan4evr]

musicrpgoddess said:

It's unknown. Because we've learned from Charmed that every decision/action we make changes the future. They wanted a "and they all lived happily ever after ending", but Charmed doesn't work like that. There are plenty of us who see passed it and are not afraid to call Kern out on his BS.

Exactly right.

musicrpgoddess said:

I for one totally erase the future scene from memory.

So do I, there's no point to it. It wasn't set in stone.

colehellsangel said:

with a few episodes during those eras here and there that I enjoyed such as Witchstock

I was never a fan of "Witchstock." I actually just watched it yesterday (it was up next on my DVD's), and noticed a blooper. When the warlock freezes the room for the second time, you can clearly see Piper blink.

[colehellsangel]

I was never a fan of "Witchstock." I actually just watched it yesterday (it was up next on my DVD's), and noticed a blooper. When the warlock freezes the room for the second time, you can clearly see Piper blink.

No kidding? I actually just finished watching it on Veohtv and I did not notice that. I will have to open my eyes more next time. I love it its one of my favorite eps. Any particular reasons you don't like it? Just curious not attacking here I am no demon despite my username lol.

[charmedfan4evr]

colehellsangel said:

I was never a fan of "Witchstock." I actually just watched it yesterday (it was up next on my DVD's), and noticed a blooper. When the warlock freezes the room for the second time, you can clearly see Piper blink.

No kidding? I actually just finished watching it on Veohtv and I did not notice that. I will have to open my eyes more next time. I love it its one of my favorite eps. Any particular reasons you don't like it? Just curious not attacking here I am no demon despite my username lol.

You should definitely check it out. I re-winded it twice to make sure, and you can clearly see her blink.

I thought the episode was just, I don't know a better way to put it but weird. It was another one of those "happy go lucky" episodes of S6,which I don't like. Plus..so did Grams and Leo always know about Paige? But certainly Grams because she saw all three CO's in the 60's, who admitted that they were her grand-daughters. It was strange.

[colehellsangel]

Plus..so did Grams and Leo always know about Paige? But certainly Grams because she saw all three CO's in the 60's, who admitted that they were her grand-daughters. It was strange.

Well Grams at the end when it was time for the girls traveled back to the future said that she wanted to brew a forgetting potion for herself. As for Leo I guess its hard to say although he did remember their meeting since Paige decided to play with him a little and call him 'sungod' as he introduced himself as in 1967. But I doubt any connection was made by the Charmed Again Leo. '67 Leo never saw any of the other sisters only her alone so it can be assumed that no he did not know about Paige being an extra Charmed One as '67 Leo never met the other sisters or was told that Paige was from the future. Charmed Again Leo probably dismissed her as a mere look-alike. Or perhaps he just kept having met her before to himself as he did his past self's romance with past Piper in Pardon my Past. Besides it is not of importance to mention and would probably just cause more confusion than there already was with all of the events of Charmed Again.

There seem to be quite a few possibilities but we know for sure that Grams does not know as she said aloud that she would brew herself a forgetting potion.

[ljones]

Or perhaps he just kept having met her before to himself as he did his past self's romance with past Piper in Pardon my Past.

I don't think that it was possible for Leo's past self to be having an affair with Piper's past self (and great-grandmother) in 1924. Leo should have been born before 1924. According to Season 1 of "Love Hurts", Leo had been in medical school when he joined the Army in 1942. I have grave doubts that Leo had already earned a Bachelor's degree in Medicine by the age of 17-18 in 1942.