the next charmed ones????

[*~moonbaby~*]

So in the last Charmed episode Pheobe had three girls so would that make her three girls the Charmed ones???



Im new here so if there was a topic like this a while back im sorry.

[Esmeralda]

Yep, it sure would! Since she's the only one who had three daughters and only three sisters descended from Melinda Warren can access the Power of Three (and it's PHOEBE's daughters who Melinda saw when she touched Phoebe's heart), that would make them the next Charmed Ones. Combined, they'd be even more powerful than the Twice-Blessed Child!

And just think...Charmed Ones who are half-cupid! Now *there* would be a set who would think about innocents and not just themselves!

[spiritsas]

Now that could be a realistic and very good idea for a spin off or follow on show. It's accurate to the shows concepts and history, which is important, and it continues the Charmed story while allowing for any of the other characters to make guest or recurring appearances. I gather the twice blessed child is Wyatt.

[Cara Halliwell]

i think all nine kids are the power of three. like piper's kids are one power of three, phoebe's are one, and paige's are one. cuz in the end piper said when the kids were doing the fighting and it showed Wyatt and Chris.

[*~moonbaby~*]

I was wondering all that because technecaly they would because Piper Pheobe Paige and Prue were 4 sisters even though they didnt know of paige but they still were 4 sisters and the Charmed ones are suppost to be 3....if that make scince.

[foxfire]

I think technically speaking... once the Charmed Ones die they take the Power of Three with them. However, their offspring will be powerful but they'd be no Charmed Ones. I wouldn't see the need for a second set of Charmed Ones. I'd hope all the children would be equally as powerful and not just Wyatt being a God with the others suffering from Phoebe syndrome (AKA passive powers and pointless levitation).

[Astral Echo]

Not many people actually like the idea of a second set of Charmed Ones, I'm a little suprised that Es does and it took me a little while to become accustomed to the idea. But Phoebe's daughters are the only ones that could access the Power of Three. As Es said, three sisters decsending from Melinda Warren.

Paige's or Piper's aren't three sisters, both have at least one male. And like Es, I think it's interesting that they're half Cupids.

[Astral Chaos]

They do fit all of the category's to qualify for Power-of-Three status. And because their father is a Cupid, it automatically gives them a stronger bond which enhances their Charmed abilities, as it has been shown throughout the series the The Charmed One's strength derives from their sisterly bond not their individual powers.

But this does not mean that they will inherit The Book of Shadows that goes to Piper and Leo's children due to Piper being the eldest living sister. However, if either Wyatt, Chris and Melinda (or all three) reject The Book of Shadows and the responsibility's that come with it, then The BOS gets passed down to Phoebe's daughters, however if Phoebe's daughters also reject The Book of Shadows then Paige's kids will inherit it. Although I once heard an interesting theory which goes something along the lines of this: Piper's children get the manor, Phoebe's daughters get the Charmed prophecy and Paige's daughter's get The Book of Shadows, which (IMO) is a relatively fair distribution.

But as an interesting side note: Neither Wyatt, Chris or Henry Jr. can produce any offspring that will be the next Charmed Ones. Due to the fact that the are all males which means that the "Charmed" blood is 'tainted'. A female of Warren descent can only produce a set of Charmed Ones if her father or (any of her male ancestors) weren't Warren witches.

[Hansemand]

Who's to say, the reason for The Charmed Ones might not even be because of the Warren line of the family.

The history of the Halliwell line is rather unknown, perhaps in their past the reason for Charmed Ones should be found.
It was not until the Halliwell blood was mixed with the Warren blood that 3 daughters was born by the same mother and thereby opening the door for The Charmed Ones to be born.

Just saying, it might not even be because of Melinda Warren that The Charmed Ones showed up in the family hundreds of years later after she died, the Halliwells might also be a huge reason.

[foxfire]

I think the Book of Shadows would be shared. It stays in the house and whoever lives in the house gets to use it. Mind you, I think it'd still be the sisters' until they pass it on. I doubt that the Sisters would let their sons/daughters start fighting demons until they reach adulthood (strictly for safety reasons). They should grow up knowing about demons but they should also grow up having a childhood.

Think of the Charmed Ones kind of like Slayers. There's only one at a time and once one dies another one can come into the Power of Three. This means if Prue returned, Paige would either keep her Charmed Powers or lose them. Therefore, the Charmed Ones would remain with the Power of Three until their death. However, given that they have nine children between all of them... I think that the Power of Nine would probably be enough to fight evil so the world wouldn't need the Charmed Ones.

[Esmeralda]

I agree that the Book of Shadows would stay in the Manor, but that it would be shared by all. Once Piper died, the new set of Charmed Ones would move into the Manor and take care of the Book as would be their right. Piper being the oldest wouldn't automatically give her children that right, not when you have a second set of Charmed Ones.

Had Wyatt never been born then I would agree that there shouldn't be a second set of Charmed Ones. But if he's so dagnab powerful even more powerful than his mother and her sisters, then Melinda Warren's prophecy must continue, allowing the "daughters" she saw when she touched Phoebe's heart (and their daughters) to continue to be the most powerful force ever...the Power of Three...and adding Coop's cupid powers would make them even more powerful in a wonderful way--powers in their hearts.

Naturally, all this assumes that Forever Charmed really happened, since I don't think it did.

[ShantaD]

The prophecy clearly stated the Warren magic would culminate in one set of Charmed Ones, not multiple generations of Charmed Ones. It was a one-time deal. It was a big stretch that Paige could even step in for Prue (but the only way the show could continue so we had to buy into it). Just because Phoebe had three daughters doesn't mean they will have any Power of Three. The show was based around the idea that these were the one and only Charmed Ones and never suggested it was an inheritable title. It would cheapen the premise even more (already weakened by Super Wy, Billie and Christy) to have another set of Charmed Ones appear a generation later. So, no, Phoebe's daughters are not Charmed Ones following the mythology put down by the show.

[whitelightertony]

I agree with Shanta -- there will never be a second generation of Charmed Ones.

[~B@MeLiSsA30@B~]

I don't mind there being another generation. I agree no one can ever replace the charmed ones, and that the kids would be equal, and each has a special power that helps another with there power, and vice versa, etc. I think that would be cool.

[Astral Echo]

Where in the prophecy did it say, "one" set of Charmed Ones. It said the Warren line would grow until the culmination of three sisters. It never said that it stops.

[whitelightertony]

"Culmination" implies an end point. So we can deduce that the Charmed Ones will be the highest concentration of Warren magic possible.

[Astral Echo]

Again not meaning the only. And the very fact that Kern p****d up the wall and decided to make Superbrat, implies that Melinda Warren was wrong. And who's to say she saw Prue, Piper and Phoebe at all?? After all she never prophecized Paige!

[foxfire]

Prophecies are sometimes wrong... just take a look at Angel... can't tell you how many times prophecies on that show are twisted and misleading.

[whitelightertony]

By "Superbrat," I assume you mean Wyatt?

And again, some of you are taking The_Wall too literally. They could only afford to take pictures of the actors who were at their disposal.

[desi393]

I don't think that there can be (or should be) another power of three. But, when Melinda was brought from the past she had a premonition that went beyond the Charmed Ones (who she prophesied right before her execution) point being that just because she didn't see her future generations from any given point didn't mean they wouldn't exist. Continuity and the show didn't always go hand in hand. They gave us Wyatt who is absurdly powerful (makes you think the next gen is at least as powerful as their mom's) and Billie who was the Ultimate freakin power, no way. The Charmed progeny have got to top that! So long post short, no new PO3 but definite power to the coming generations.